Tesla Recalls Chinese Vehicles, Is Trust Intact?

Tesla stock price forecast, Tesla car

Key Points

  • Shares of Tesla slid on Friday following a recall statement in China, which effectively applies to nearly every vehicle manufactured nationwide. 
  • Through collected data, previous accidents have shed some light on the root cause of each mishap. Management has responded with swift solutions, working with regulators to implement the needed changes. 
  • Analysts still see a double-digit upside in the stock, as faith has not been lost in Tesla remaining within the nation that delivers more than $18 billion in revenues. These event-driven sell-offs may allow investors to gain exposure at these technical levels. 
  • 5 stocks we like better than NIO

Shares of the beloved American electric car company Tesla Motors NASDAQ: TSLA declined during Friday's trading session by as much as 2.5%; some negative sentiment is attributed to an active announcement regarding vehicle recalls earlier that day. CEO Elon Musk has openly stated a recall of more than one million one hundred thousand vehicles made in China, including models made from January 2019 up until April of this year. 

This recall decision affects mostly vehicles manufactured in Tesla's Shanghai factory, with only a select few shipped from U.S. factories. The defects pertaining to the root cause of the recall come from the vehicle's regenerative brake system, which has reportedly failed to work on various occasions. China's regulator stated that these defects don't allow users to set a proper intensity on their braking and not alert drivers when they've applied the accelerator for a more extended period. 

The Grand Picture

According to Tesla's investor relations site, the company has sold about one million and thirteen thousand vehicles in China since 2014. The volume of recalls would effectively render nearly every car sold defective, severely tarnishing the company's reputation in a country already facing geopolitical pressures with the United States. The company was given a reasonable grace period since its incident on April 2021, when a disgraceful malfunction occurred during the Shanghai auto show.

According to news media, a Tesla Model three lost control of its breaks and acceleration, causing it to end on top of another display vehicle within the show. Tesla publicized the data about the faulty vehicle, revealing that the car traveled at dangerously high speeds of seventy-four miles per hour. Analytics would speculate whether this event was an accident since the car had been tested before this 'malfunction' by driving at speeds of sixty-two miles per hour and successfully applying the breaks more than forty times.

Given that the data stored by each vehicle is encrypted, it could not have been deleted or manipulated before publication, rendering the suggestion that the incident may have been an honest accident blamed on a malfunctioning system.


Another incident reported on November 2022 shows a Tesla Model Y telling a similar story. In this scenario, both video and data collected will show that the breaks were not applied during and leading up to the incident, a horrible mishap that took two lives. The evidence dictates that the accelerator was hard-pressed moments before the incident, raising whether accelerator awareness is the root cause of these accidents.

As electric vehicles have no engine noise, nor a 'revving' sensation, it is sometimes harder for users to realize they are stepping on the accelerator rather than the brake pedal. Considering the instant torque that these motors generate, it would be prudent to implement some updates to avoid similar accidents in the future.

Timely Response

Tesla analyst ratings suggest that the stock still has room to move upward by as much as 21%, considering today's prices and news-driven decline. Moreover, Tesla's financials would show investors how important China is to the company's overall growth trajectory. The nation is the root of more than $18 billion of revenues as of 2022. As a result of these heating allegations and rising relationship risks, Tesla is now deploying an over-the-air software update. The Chinese State Administration for Market Regulation issued a statement, calling upon all Tesla owners falling into the recall scope to bring in their vehicles for a software update. The vehicle remote upgrade technology will allow Tesla to push newly developed functions for these affected units, successfully alerting users of accelerator pedal functions and regenerative breaking intensity.

These non-recurring and event-driven sell-offs typically act as a 'dip' opportunity for investors to take advantage of, Tesla's chart seems to agree with these opportunistic times. On a one-hour chart basis, it seems that the stock price is hovering around a robust support level of $166.50 per share, where the stock price has bounced on the back of strong volume three times now.

What Tesla management decides to do following these updates is crucial; now that NIO NYSE: NIO is set to report its first quarter 2023 earnings results in early June, the American counterpart cannot afford to lose sales territory to local operators in the Asian nation. 

Should you invest $1,000 in NIO right now?

Before you consider NIO, you'll want to hear this.

MarketBeat keeps track of Wall Street's top-rated and best performing research analysts and the stocks they recommend to their clients on a daily basis. MarketBeat has identified the five stocks that top analysts are quietly whispering to their clients to buy now before the broader market catches on... and NIO wasn't on the list.

While NIO currently has a "Reduce" rating among analysts, top-rated analysts believe these five stocks are better buys.

View The Five Stocks Here

20 Stocks to Sell Now Cover

MarketBeat has just released its list of 20 stocks that Wall Street analysts hate. These companies may appear to have good fundamentals, but top analysts smell something seriously rotten. Are any of these companies lurking around your portfolio? Find out by clicking the link below.

Get This Free Report

Companies Mentioned in This Article

CompanyMarketRank™Current PricePrice ChangeDividend YieldP/E RatioConsensus RatingConsensus Price Target
Tesla (TSLA)
4.8621 of 5 stars
$144.68+1.9%N/A33.57Hold$194.33
NIO (NIO)
1.7138 of 5 stars
$4.02+0.5%N/A-2.30Reduce$8.43
Compare These Stocks  Add These Stocks to My Watchlist 

Gabriel Osorio-Mazilli

About Gabriel Osorio-Mazilli

  • gosoriomazzilli@gmail.com

Contributing Author

Value Stocks, Asian Markets, Macro Economics

Experience

Gabriel Osorio-Mazilli has been a contributing writer for MarketBeat since 2023.

Areas of Expertise

Value investing, long/short trading, options, emerging markets

Education

CFA Level I candidate; Goldman Sachs corporate training; independent courses

Past Experience

Analyst at Goldman Sachs, associate at Citigroup, senior financial analyst in real estate


Featured Articles and Offers

Easy Growth Over for Tesla, Stock Driving Lower

Easy Growth Over for Tesla, Stock Driving Lower

As Tesla approaches its Q1 earnings amid a turbulent period, we dive deep into what investors can expect.

Search Headlines: