MutualFirst Financial Company Profile (NASDAQ:MFSF)

About MutualFirst Financial (NASDAQ:MFSF)

MutualFirst Financial logoMutualFirst Financial, Inc. (MutualFirst) is the bank holding company of MutualBank (MutualBank or the Bank). The Bank offers financial services through approximately 30 full service retail financial center offices in Allen, Delaware, Elkhart, Grant, Kosciusko, Randolph, Saint Joseph and Wabash counties in Indiana. MutualBank also has trust offices in Carmel and Crawfordsville, Indiana and a loan origination office in New Buffalo, Michigan. The Bank has a subsidiary, Summit Mortgage, Inc., that operates a mortgage banking firm in Fort Wayne, Indiana. In addition, it originates residential mortgage and commercial loans. MutualWealth and MutualFinancial Advisors are the wealth management and brokerage divisions of the Bank that provide a range of fee-based financial services, including trust, investment, insurance, broker advisory, retirement plan and private banking services, in its market areas.

Industry, Sector and Symbol:
  • Sector: Finance
  • Industry: Regional - Midwest Banks
  • Sub-Industry: N/A
  • Symbol: NASDAQ:MFSF
  • CUSIP: N/A
  • Web:
  • Market Cap: $244.56 million
  • Outstanding Shares: 7,344,000
Average Prices:
  • 50 Day Moving Avg: $32.71
  • 200 Day Moving Avg: $31.40
  • 52 Week Range: $24.56 - $36.75
  • Trailing P/E Ratio: 17.69
  • Foreward P/E Ratio: 17.62
  • P/E Growth: 3.73
Sales & Book Value:
  • Annual Revenue: $64.21 million
  • Price / Sales: 3.81
  • Book Value: $19.42 per share
  • Price / Book: 1.71
  • Annual Dividend: $0.64
  • Dividend Yield: 2.0%
  • Net Margins: 18.08%
  • Return on Equity: 9.33%
  • Return on Assets: 0.87%
  • Debt-to-Equity Ratio: 1.73%
  • Current Ratio: 1.03%
  • Quick Ratio: 1.02%
  • Average Volume: 5,731 shs.
  • Beta: 0.34
  • Short Ratio: 3.52

Frequently Asked Questions for MutualFirst Financial (NASDAQ:MFSF)

What is MutualFirst Financial's stock symbol?

MutualFirst Financial trades on the NASDAQ under the ticker symbol "MFSF."

How often does MutualFirst Financial pay dividends? What is the dividend yield for MutualFirst Financial?

MutualFirst Financial declared a quarterly dividend on Monday, May 8th. Shareholders of record on Friday, June 9th will be given a dividend of $0.16 per share on Friday, June 23rd. This represents a $0.64 annualized dividend and a yield of 1.92%. The ex-dividend date is Wednesday, June 7th. View MutualFirst Financial's Dividend History.

How were MutualFirst Financial's earnings last quarter?

MutualFirst Financial, Inc. (NASDAQ:MFSF) posted its quarterly earnings results on Tuesday, April, 25th. The company reported $0.43 EPS for the quarter, beating analysts' consensus estimates of $0.40 by $0.03. The firm had revenue of $15.84 million for the quarter, compared to analysts' expectations of $15.70 million. MutualFirst Financial had a return on equity of 9.33% and a net margin of 18.08%. View MutualFirst Financial's Earnings History.

Where is MutualFirst Financial's stock going? Where will MutualFirst Financial's stock price be in 2017?

2 equities research analysts have issued 12-month target prices for MutualFirst Financial's shares. Their forecasts range from $24.00 to $27.00. On average, they expect MutualFirst Financial's share price to reach $25.50 in the next year. View Analyst Ratings for MutualFirst Financial.

What are analysts saying about MutualFirst Financial stock?

Here are some recent quotes from research analysts about MutualFirst Financial stock:

  • 1. According to Zacks Investment Research, "MutualFirst Financial, Inc. is the holding company of Mutual Federal Savings Bank. " (4/28/2017)
  • 2. DA Davidson analysts commented, "We expect the bulk of these benefits to come into play during the second half of 2017." (11/25/2016)

Who are some of MutualFirst Financial's key competitors?

Who owns MutualFirst Financial stock?

MutualFirst Financial's stock is owned by a variety of of institutional and retail investors. Top institutional shareholders include PL CAPITAL, LLC (9.80%), Dimensional Fund Advisors LP (5.28%), Vanguard Group Inc. (2.61%), Renaissance Technologies LLC (2.27%), Geode Capital Management LLC (0.66%) and James Investment Research Inc. (0.48%). Company insiders that own MutualFirst Financial stock include Charles J Viater, Jonathan E Kintner, Michael J Marien, Richard J Lashley and William V Hughes. View Institutional Ownership Trends for MutualFirst Financial.

Who sold MutualFirst Financial stock? Who is selling MutualFirst Financial stock?

MutualFirst Financial's stock was sold by a variety of institutional investors in the last quarter, including Thomson Horstmann & Bryant Inc., Morgan Stanley, JPMorgan Chase & Co., James Investment Research Inc., Goldman Sachs Group Inc., Martingale Asset Management L P and TIAA CREF Investment Management LLC. Company insiders that have sold MutualFirst Financial stock in the last year include Charles J Viater and Michael J Marien. View Insider Buying and Selling for MutualFirst Financial.

Who bought MutualFirst Financial stock? Who is buying MutualFirst Financial stock?

MutualFirst Financial's stock was bought by a variety of institutional investors in the last quarter, including Bowling Portfolio Management LLC, Renaissance Technologies LLC, Dimensional Fund Advisors LP, SG Americas Securities LLC, Bank of America Corp DE, Vanguard Group Inc., Bank of New York Mellon Corp and Geode Capital Management LLC. View Insider Buying and Selling for MutualFirst Financial.

How do I buy MutualFirst Financial stock?

Shares of MutualFirst Financial can be purchased through any online brokerage account. Popular online brokerages include Vanguard Brokerage Services, TD Ameritrade, E*TRADE, Scottrade, Fidelity and Charles Schwab.

How much does a share of MutualFirst Financial stock cost?

One share of MutualFirst Financial stock can currently be purchased for approximately $33.30.

Analyst Ratings

Consensus Ratings for MutualFirst Financial (NASDAQ:MFSF) (?)
Ratings Breakdown: 1 Sell Rating, 1 Hold Rating
Consensus Rating:Hold (Score: 1.50)
Consensus Price Target: $25.50 (23.42% downside)

Analysts' Ratings History for MutualFirst Financial (NASDAQ:MFSF)
DateFirmActionRatingPrice TargetImpact on Share PriceDetails
11/25/2016DA DavidsonReiterated RatingSell$24.00N/AView Rating Details
7/27/2016Keefe, Bruyette & WoodsBoost Price TargetNeutral -> Market Perform$26.00 -> $27.00N/AView Rating Details
10/2/2015StephensInitiated CoverageEqual WeightN/AView Rating Details
(Data available from 5/25/2015 forward)


Earnings History for MutualFirst Financial (NASDAQ:MFSF)
Earnings by Quarter for MutualFirst Financial (NASDAQ:MFSF)
Earnings History by Quarter for MutualFirst Financial (NASDAQ:MFSF)
DateQuarterConsensus EstimateActual EPSRevenue EstimateActual RevenueRelease LinkConference CallDetails
4/25/2017Q1 2017$0.40$0.43$15.70 million$15.84 millionViewN/AView Earnings Details
2/1/2017Q4 2016$0.40$0.43$15.85 million$16.04 millionViewN/AView Earnings Details
10/25/2016Q3$0.41$0.47$15.60 million$16.30 millionViewN/AView Earnings Details
7/25/2016Q2$0.37$0.55$15.15 million$16.88 millionViewN/AView Earnings Details
4/21/2016Q1$0.38$0.31$14.60 million$14.76 millionViewN/AView Earnings Details
2/3/2016Q4$0.41$0.44$15.20 million$15.46 millionViewN/AView Earnings Details
10/26/2015Q3$0.40$0.43$15.00 million$15.21 millionViewN/AView Earnings Details
7/23/2015Q2$0.37$0.43$14.70 million$14.91 millionViewN/AView Earnings Details
4/24/2015Q1 2015$0.35$0.33$14.20 million$14.54 millionViewN/AView Earnings Details
1/30/2015Q4 2014$0.35$0.48$14.30 million$15.15 millionViewN/AView Earnings Details
10/27/2014Q3$0.35$0.36$14.13 million$14.21 millionViewN/AView Earnings Details
7/21/2014Q2 2014$0.29$0.35$13.40 million$13.97 millionViewN/AView Earnings Details
4/22/2014Q1 14$0.29$0.27$13.34 million$13.29 millionViewN/AView Earnings Details
2/7/2014Q4 13$0.27$0.31ViewN/AView Earnings Details
(Data available from 1/1/2011 forward)


Earnings Estimates for MutualFirst Financial (NASDAQ:MFSF)
2017 EPS Consensus Estimate: $1.77
QuarterNumber of EstimatesLow EstimateHigh EstimateAverage Estimate
Q1 20172$0.38$0.41$0.40
Q2 20172$0.39$0.46$0.43
Q3 20172$0.42$0.50$0.46
Q4 20172$0.48$0.49$0.49
(Data provided by Zacks Investment Research)


Current Dividend Information for MutualFirst Financial (NASDAQ:MFSF)
Next Dividend:6/23/2017
Annual Dividend:$0.64
Dividend Yield:1.92%
Payout Ratio:36.36% (Trailing 12 Months of Earnings)
35.56% (Based on This Year's Estimates)
33.86% (Based on Next Year's Estimates)
Dividend Payments by Quarter for MutualFirst Financial (NASDAQ:MFSF)

Dividend History by Quarter for MutualFirst Financial (NASDAQ:MFSF)
AnnouncedPeriodAmountYieldEx-Dividend DateRecord DatePayable Date
(Data available from 1/1/2013 forward)

Insider Trades

Insider Trading and Institutional Ownership History for MutualFirst Financial (NASDAQ:MFSF)
Insider Ownership Percentage: 22.70%
Institutional Ownership Percentage: 45.99%
Insider Trades by Quarter for MutualFirst Financial (NASDAQ:MFSF)
Institutional Ownership by Quarter for MutualFirst Financial (NASDAQ:MFSF)
Insider Trades by Quarter for MutualFirst Financial (NASDAQ:MFSF)
Transaction DateInsider NameTitleBuy/SellNumber of SharesAverage Share PriceTotal TransactionDetails
2/27/2017Michael J MarienDirectorSell8,263$31.84$263,093.92View SEC Filing  
2/24/2017Michael J MarienDirectorSell141$31.85$4,490.85View SEC Filing  
2/23/2017Michael J MarienDirectorSell922$31.86$29,374.92View SEC Filing  
2/22/2017Michael J MarienDirectorSell714$31.86$22,748.04View SEC Filing  
2/17/2017Michael J MarienDirectorSell4,455$31.08$138,461.40View SEC Filing  
2/16/2017Michael J MarienDirectorSell222$31.14$6,913.08View SEC Filing  
2/13/2017Michael J MarienDirectorSell323$32.01$10,339.23View SEC Filing  
2/10/2017Michael J MarienDirectorSell300$31.90$9,570.00View SEC Filing  
2/7/2017Michael J MarienDirectorSell1,234$32.53$40,142.02View SEC Filing  
2/6/2017Michael J MarienDirectorSell3,466$32.50$112,645.00View SEC Filing  
11/16/2016Charles J ViaterInsiderSell2,000$28.05$56,100.00View SEC Filing  
9/22/2016Charles J ViaterInsiderSell2,777$27.80$77,200.60View SEC Filing  
9/19/2016Charles J ViaterInsiderSell300$27.75$8,325.00View SEC Filing  
9/16/2016Charles J ViaterInsiderSell423$27.75$11,738.25View SEC Filing  
9/7/2016Charles J ViaterInsiderSell1,000$27.80$27,800.00View SEC Filing  
5/10/2016Jonathan E KintnerDirectorSell717$28.20$20,219.40View SEC Filing  
4/25/2016Jonathan E KintnerDirectorSell5,000$26.08$130,400.00View SEC Filing  
11/6/2015Richard J LashleyDirectorBuy18,750$23.25$435,937.50View SEC Filing  
6/15/2015William V HughesDirectorSell1,963$21.52$42,243.76View SEC Filing  
6/9/2015William V HughesDirectorSell1,304$21.60$28,166.40View SEC Filing  
5/22/2015Jonathan E KintnerDirectorSell3,200$21.40$68,480.00View SEC Filing  
12/5/2014Charles J ViaterSVPSell1,800$21.26$38,268.00View SEC Filing  
11/24/2014Charles J ViaterSVPSell6,069$21.45$130,180.05View SEC Filing  
11/21/2014Charles J ViaterSVPSell1,100$21.40$23,540.00View SEC Filing  
11/20/2014Charles J ViaterSVPSell2,900$21.42$62,118.00View SEC Filing  
11/13/2014Charles J ViaterSVPSell1,750$21.50$37,625.00View SEC Filing  
11/12/2014Charles J ViaterSVPSell4,350$21.50$93,525.00View SEC Filing  
11/12/2014William V HughesDirectorSell4,011$21.50$86,236.50View SEC Filing  
11/3/2014William V HughesDirectorSell1,100$21.57$23,727.00View SEC Filing  
9/17/2014Wilbur R DavisDirectorSell5,700$20.82$118,674.00View SEC Filing  
9/15/2014Wilbur R DavisDirectorSell12,000$20.75$249,000.00View SEC Filing  
9/12/2014Wilbur R DavisDirectorSell3,800$20.70$78,660.00View SEC Filing  
9/11/2014Linn A CrullDirectorSell2,520$20.65$52,038.00View SEC Filing  
9/9/2014Linn A CrullDirectorSell4,000$20.55$82,200.00View SEC Filing  
9/4/2014Linn A CrullDirectorSell4,500$20.41$91,845.00View SEC Filing  
9/3/2014Linn A CrullDirectorSell1,000$20.20$20,200.00View SEC Filing  
8/27/2014James David RosemaDirectorSell15,900$19.84$315,456.00View SEC Filing  
8/26/2014James David RosemaDirectorSell4,100$20.13$82,533.00View SEC Filing  
8/14/2014Charles J ViaterSVPSell1,000$19.67$19,670.00View SEC Filing  
8/11/2014Charles J ViaterSVPSell2,500$19.50$48,750.00View SEC Filing  
8/8/2014Charles J ViaterSVPSell8,000$19.41$155,280.00View SEC Filing  
8/5/2014Charles J ViaterSVPSell2,000$19.38$38,760.00View SEC Filing  
8/4/2014Charles J ViaterSVPSell4,200$19.39$81,438.00View SEC Filing  
7/31/2014Charles J ViaterSVPSell3,000$19.23$57,690.00View SEC Filing  
7/28/2014Charles J ViaterSVPSell2,615$19.41$50,757.15View SEC Filing  
3/24/2014Michael MarienDirectorSell8,000$19.00$152,000.00View SEC Filing  
10/28/2013William V HughesDirectorSell5,000$16.52$82,600.00View SEC Filing  
(Data available from 1/1/2013 forward)


Headline Trends for MutualFirst Financial (NASDAQ:MFSF)
Latest Headlines for MutualFirst Financial (NASDAQ:MFSF)
DateHeadline logoMutualFirst Financial, Inc. :MFSF-US: Earnings Analysis: Q1, 2017 By the Numbers : May 18, 2017 - May 19 at 11:02 AM logoMutualFirst Financial, Inc. (MFSF) Expected to Post Quarterly Sales of $16.4 Million - May 12 at 11:45 AM logoMutualFirst Financial, Inc. (MFSF) Expected to Announce Earnings of $0.42 Per Share - May 11 at 12:28 AM logoMutualFirst Financial (MFSF) Earning Positive Media Coverage, Report Finds - May 9 at 12:30 AM logoMutualFirst Financial, Inc. (MFSF) to Issue $0.16 Quarterly Dividend - May 8 at 6:16 PM logoMutualFirst Financial, Inc. to Post FY2017 Earnings of $1.85 Per Share, FIG Partners Forecasts (MFSF) - May 1 at 9:48 AM logoQ2 2017 Earnings Estimate for MutualFirst Financial, Inc. (MFSF) Issued By DA Davidson - May 1 at 7:55 AM logoMutualFirst Financial (MFSF) Getting Somewhat Positive News Coverage, Study Finds - April 29 at 11:09 PM logoMutualFirst Financial, Inc. (MFSF) Raised to Buy at Zacks Investment Research - April 29 at 8:58 AM logoMutualfirst Financial (MFSF) Announces Re-Appointment of Richard Lashley to the Board of Directors - April 29 at 8:41 AM logoMutualFirst Financial, Inc. Announces Re-Appointment of Richard J. Lashley to the Board of Directors - April 28 at 7:24 PM logoFY2017 EPS Estimates for MutualFirst Financial, Inc. Boosted by Analyst (MFSF) - April 28 at 4:14 PM logoMutualFirst Financial, Inc. (MFSF) to Post Q2 2017 Earnings of $0.46 Per Share, FIG Partners Forecasts - April 28 at 9:40 AM logoMutualFirst Financial (MFSF) Receives Daily News Sentiment Score of -0.12 - April 26 at 1:24 PM logoMutualFirst Financial, Inc. (MFSF) Announces Quarterly Earnings Results - April 26 at 1:02 PM logo$15.7 Million in Sales Expected for MutualFirst Financial, Inc. (MFSF) This Quarter - April 22 at 9:55 AM logoMutualFirst Financial (MFSF) Getting Somewhat Positive Media Coverage, Analysis Shows - April 22 at 12:38 AM logoMutualFirst Financial, Inc. (MFSF) Expected to Post Earnings of $0.40 Per Share - April 20 at 8:03 AM logoMutualFirst Financial (MFSF) Given Media Impact Score of 0.20 - April 18 at 7:33 PM logoMutualFirst Financial, Inc. (MFSF) Set to Announce Earnings on Wednesday - April 17 at 9:24 AM logoMutualFirst Financial, Inc. (MFSF) Downgraded by Zacks Investment Research to Hold - April 14 at 12:54 PM logoMutualFirst Financial (MFSF) Receives Daily News Impact Score of 0.04 - April 13 at 6:15 PM logoMutualFirst Financial, Inc. (MFSF) Short Interest Update - April 7 at 6:06 PM logoZacks: MutualFirst Financial, Inc. (MFSF) Given Consensus Recommendation of "Sell" by Brokerages - April 5 at 1:12 PM logoMutualFirst Financial, Inc. (MFSF) Upgraded at Zacks Investment Research - April 2 at 9:14 AM logoMUTUALFIRST FINANCIAL INC Financials - March 22 at 6:38 PM logoMutualFirst Financial, Inc. DECLARES CASH DIVIDEND - February 24 at 9:31 AM logoMUTUALFIRST FINANCIAL INC Files SEC form 8-K, Other Events - February 24 at 9:31 AM logoMUTUALFIRST FINANCIAL INC Files SEC form 8-K, Change in Directors or Principal Officers, Financial Statements and Exh - February 17 at 2:52 PM logoMutualFirst Financial Announces Record Earnings in 2016 - February 1 at 7:22 PM logoWill Mutualfirst (MFSF) Continue to Surge Higher? - December 20 at 12:17 PM logoWhy Mutualfirst Financial (MFSF) Stock Might be a Great Pick - November 18 at 8:55 AM logoMUTUALFIRST FINANCIAL INC Files SEC form 8-K, Regulation FD Disclosure, Financial Statements and Exhibits - August 5 at 6:19 PM logoMUTUALFIRST FINANCIAL INC Files SEC form 8-K, Regulation FD Disclosure - July 22 at 1:15 PM logoMutualFirst Financial Shares Overvalued, Says D.A. Davidson - July 21 at 1:25 PM logoMUTUALFIRST FINANCIAL INC Files SEC form 8-K, Submission of Matters to a Vote of Security Holders, Regulation FD Disc - May 6 at 2:50 PM logoQ1 2016 MutualFirst Financial Inc Earnings Release-Tentative - Time Not Supplied - April 21 at 7:07 AM logoMUTUALFIRST FINANCIAL INC Files SEC form 10-K, Annual Report - March 15 at 3:08 PM logo1:52 pm MFS Financial increases quarterly dividend to $0.14/share from $0.12/share; authorizes 375,000 share repurchase program - February 19 at 1:52 PM logoMutualFirst Financial, Inc. Announces Increased Cash Dividend And Stock Repurchase Program - February 19 at 1:50 PM logoMutualFirst Financial Announces Record Earnings in 2015 - February 3 at 9:58 AM logoMutualfirst Financial Inc. (MFSF) - January 30 at 11:43 AM logoMUTUALFIRST FINANCIAL INC Files SEC form 8-K, Results of Operations and Financial Condition - October 26 at 9:02 AM



MutualFirst Financial (MFSF) Chart for Thursday, May, 25, 2017

This page was last updated on 5/25/2017 by Staff