Canadian Tire Q3 2023 Earnings Call Transcript

Quartr
Provided by Quartr
November 9, 2023

There are 11 speakers on the call.

Operator

Thank you for standing by. My name is Paul, and I will be your conference operator today. Welcome to Canentar Corporation Earnings Call. All lines have been placed on mute to prevent any background noise. Now I will pass along to Karen Keyes, Head of Investor Relations for Canadian Tire Corporation.

Operator

Karen?

Speaker 1

Thank you, Paul, and good morning, everyone. Welcome to Canadian Tire Corporation's Q3 2023 results conference call. With me today are Greg Hicks, President and CEO Gregory Craig, Executive Vice President and CFO and T. J. Flood, President of Canadian Tire Retail.

Speaker 1

Before we begin, I wanted to draw your attention to the earnings disclosure, which is available on our website. It includes cautionary language about forward looking statements, risks And uncertainties, which also apply to the additional material included this quarter to help you better understand the results discussion during today's conference call. After our remarks today, the team will be happy to take your questions. We will try and get in as many questions as possible, but we ask And we welcome you to contact Investor Relations if we don't get through all the questions today. I'll now turn the call over to Greg.

Speaker 1

Greg?

Speaker 2

Thank you, Karen. Good morning and welcome everyone. Our results this quarter reflect the relevance and trust Canadians have in our brand to create value and be there for communities in uncertain times. Despite undeniable Challenges, we more than held our own in the market this quarter as our multi category business model proved its metal. Although Triangle Credit Card spend declined across almost all categories in Q3, our credit card data shows our sales performance outpaced that of the market In the categories in which we compete.

Speaker 2

Despite the favorable share of spend, however, it is evident that customers are stretched And spending less overall. Consolidated comparable sales were down 1.6% As a result of softening customer demand, especially in Ontario and BC, and we saw a continued performance bifurcation between essential and discretionary categories. Essential categories at CTR were up around 4% led by strength in automotive, While discretionary categories were down to a similar extent. Last quarter, I mentioned that when combining our Triangle membership data with External household data from our real estate modeling, we saw that the discretionary softness is coming from more indebted households, Most notably in Ontario and BC. In Q3, we observed similar trends, including at Sport Chek, a banner that has higher reach In Ontario, debt burden customers decreased spend drove almost 70% of the sales decline in the quarter, especially in the discretionary categories at CTR.

Speaker 2

Mark's, however, was a different story. Sales at Mark's increased among debt burden customers suggesting that Mark's attractive price to value proposition may be appealing to customers with high debt burdens, especially in the current high interest rate environment. Although retail revenue was down slightly, our retail gross margin was positive. This drove retail segment appreciation with the rate up 77 basis points excluding the MSA benefit. The team managed our margins well at CTR where gross margins excluding the MSA benefit As we stayed competitive and experienced lower freight costs compared to last year.

Speaker 2

We did, however, see margin rate down in our other banners, Driven in part by competitive intensity in D2C channels. From an inventory management standpoint, we remain focused These highlights are all evidence of our company's resilience. But I want to be clear, this resilience we so often speak of is neither luck No accident. We are resilient because we control what we can, take action and make the tough decisions about our business. A few weeks back, we listened intently to the Bank of Canada's announcement.

Speaker 2

Suffice it to say, the future is We are now increasingly murky given the Bank of Canada's pause was couched in a hawkish tone around risks of further inflation And the potential of more policy rate moves down the road. The amount of time the Central Bank will need to be in a holding pattern before decreasing rates will be a key determinant of the impact on consumer spending and the economy. We are operating against a structurally uncertain macro backdrop, which has us laser focused on controlling what we can control. We are operating with the assumption that there will be continued pressure on discretionary retail and credit metrics going forward. That said, the remainder of my prepared remarks will focus on 3 key areas.

Speaker 2

First, our resilience and focus on value in the short term. 2nd, how we intend to operate and prioritize as we head toward 2024 and third, our progress and plans for our long term better connected strategy. Starting with the short term, we remain confident in our ability to provide our customers with value when they need it most. In the quarter, comp traffic at CTR was down by only 0.5 percentage point and basket size remained relatively steady. The average e commerce order value across the Retail segment is also relatively flat.

Speaker 2

Across the consolidated retail business, There are fewer units per basket given the push to essential shopping. We believe these trends are a clear sign of the underlying health of our business and the role we play in the lives of Canadians. Our Triangle program and the first party data it generates continue to provide insights In Q3, we had an almost 100 basis point increase in the percentage of our loyalty sales Generated by returning members with over 90% of total loyalty sales attributable to these members. In previous quarters, I've talked about the importance of promotable members, those who have given us permission to communicate with them directly. And in Q3, traffic increased for this critical segment and their sales were up over 4%.

Speaker 2

Total Triangle member spend associated with our 1 on 1 offers nearly doubled in the quarter and our member cross banner shop rate is accelerating, Demonstrating that our 1 on 1 offers are achieving their objective. We also continue to focus on our highly And differentiated owned brands portfolio, which blend our product margins up, while offering customers value in all ladders of the quality architecture. Across all our banners, our own brands continue to deliver real value for Canadians. In addition to penetration rate growing by 42 basis points, we had almost 50,000 own brand product reviews in the quarter with an average star rating of 4.2. From a sales perspective, we had strong performance in 2 of our most profitable owned brands, MOTOMASTER and PROSERIES with sales up 10% and 26% respectively in the quarter.

Speaker 2

Overall, we have highly differentiated programs Focused on creating value in the short term and we continue to work hard with our vendors to engineer price crashing and provide promotions across our portfolio of Retail Banners. Moving to my second area of focus, as we look ahead to 2024, We are taking action to drive structural efficiencies to support our strategy of creating long term value. I will speak to running our business more efficiently in 3 ways: supply chain, margin management and our SG and A. Starting with our supply chain, where significant deleverage has occurred relative to pre pandemic trends. Following a tough operating environment for our supply chain, we We feel like we are now in a position to focus on the efficiency of the operation to drive operating leverage.

Speaker 2

Our team's work on inventory management has enabled us to focus on reducing our reliance on third party logistics DCs. We started the year with 15 3PLs and have managed down to 3 by the end of this quarter, And we expect to be out of all 3PL sites by the end of the year. Our new GTA DC is officially up and running smoothly, We will be focused on capacity utilization in the state of the art facility. We will be moving our Sports Explorer banner into this facility In addition to putting the inefficiencies created by the DC fire behind us, These actions provide OpEx leverage opportunity heading into the New Year. Moving to margin management.

Speaker 2

We remain very focused on holding the margin accretion we have created in the business and see product cost opportunities across the retail segment given commodity pricing and freight rates. We have set up a new nerve center looking at COGS negotiations through to consumer pricing to strike a balance between customer value and margin management. The 3rd way we'll run our business more efficiently is through our SG and A. As mentioned, our SG and A rate was on Favorable in Q3 as SG and A grew, while revenue remained relatively flat. We are accelerating efficiency initiatives, Prioritizing investments within our better connected strategy and actively managing our resource allocation.

Speaker 2

With that in mind, it's with a heavy heart that I say this includes a 3% reduction in our full time employee base. In addition, the closure of current vacancies will result in a further full time employee reduction of 3%. This was a tough decision that we did not take lightly. There is no question that the most difficult business decisions are the ones that impact At the same time, we know this is what's required to continue to execute our strategy and ensure we are equipped To deliver on our commitments to our customers, employees and shareholders. As a result of this tough decision, our annualized run rate savings are expected to be $50,000,000 As we focus on our highest returning investments, We expect our operating capital investments and the related OpEx to support projects in large functions like IT to come down.

Speaker 2

We expect operating capital in 2024 to be approximately $100,000,000 below 2023 levels. By reducing expenses and prudently managing cash flow, we intend to create the capacity to continue investing in our As you would have seen in our release today, we announced our 14th consecutive year of dividend increases With the annual dividend increasing to $7 for March 2024, we intend to repurchase up to an additional $200,000,000 Class A non voting shares in 2024, which Gregory will speak to in more detail. My third and final focus area today is our long term better connected strategy. We see opportunities to slow the pace of some investments and we'll prioritize our highest returning capital investments to position ourselves for strength When the market returns to stability. Priority investments include continuing to refresh our CTR store network, And we expect to have refreshed a total of 45 stores by the end of this year and we anticipate the pace of our store investments in 2024 We continue to leverage the investments made in our 1 digital platform by continually honing the site For example, this quarter, we launched a new gift registry, improved our site speed by over 35% and made functionality improvements to our product recommendations engine.

Speaker 2

We also continue to be very focused on leveraging multi channel capabilities. This quarter, we added 25 new stores to our Express delivery pilot and further extended digital experiences Like automated lockers, mobile app functionality, digital debit payments for the bank and electronic shelf labels. Our IT modernization also remains a priority and we're making good progress through our Microsoft partnership, targeting cloud cost savings and co innovation efforts, including those focused on efficiency and AI enabled shopping experiences. I spoke earlier about the role personalization is playing and creating value for our membership and we have an ongoing investment roadmap to build 1st class As we made clear earlier this month, we are leaning into loyalty With the repurchase of Scotiabank's 20% stake in our Financial Services business, a strategic transaction It gives us greater control and flexibility in accelerating the growth of Triangle Rewards. The feedback we've received since the announcement has been centered around the price paid and the timing, Given what is happening in both the credit and consumer markets, so why don't I hit those two questions head on.

Speaker 2

First on the price. For us in the agreement and BNS did not want to exercise the right to put their equity to us. The price Paid is a reflection of our view on value and embeds a premium to clean up the structure. With complete control of CTFS, We now have the flexibility to pursue a structure that can maximize value creation in our Triangle Rewards program, A critical driver of value for both CTFS and our Retail segment. On the issue of the appropriateness of the timing, As we said in the release, while we have appreciated partnering with Scotiabank over the past decade, with both Scotiabank and CTC having received significant strategic and financial benefits.

Speaker 2

In recent years, BNS and CTC have invested in and Our respective loyalty programs are now competing for the same customer in both credit cards And in a large percentage of our retail categories. The consumer loyalty landscape in Canada is moving extremely quickly With partnerships being formed at pace, we have worked really hard to build a compelling and leading loyalty program in Triangle Rewards, And our intention is to remain a leader. That's why the timing is now. We also announced our intention to evaluate strategic alternatives for our bank. Let me be clear, The optimal structure for us has us owning Triangle Rewards, our first party data and ultimately the relationship That we have with our customers.

Speaker 2

We understand that the merits of this transaction will be clear upon the conclusion of our strategic review. We believe that this was the appropriate decision and we will keep you updated as we move forward on the next steps. Overall, our strategic priorities are focused on improving our customer experience, leveraging on prioritization across the business and we are actively managing for disciplined expense management, while

Speaker 3

Thanks, Greg, and good morning, everyone. There's a lot to unpack this quarter. But before I jump in, I just Want to take a moment to acknowledge how hard our teams continue to work through the current macroeconomic challenges and thank them for their continued efforts. Now let's get into the quarterly results, starting with the 2 large items that flowed through Q3 diluted EPS. Recorded in the Retail segment and represented a contribution of $1.73 at the EPS line.

Speaker 3

That was offset by the second item, A $328,000,000 change in the fair value related to Scotiabank's put option, which as we disclosed last week represented a charge of 5 point The combination of these two items took diluted EPS to a loss of $1.19 for the quarter. Normalizing for these two items, EPS was $2.96 Down $0.38 compared to last year, driven by lower retail and financial services earnings. When we look at retail, Revenue was broadly in line with last year and the favorable impact of gross margin was offset by higher SG and A and net finance costs. While at Financial Services, revenue was strong, but gross margin was unfavorable as net write off rates continued to return to more historic levels. Now I'll take you through the detailed results by segment.

Speaker 3

Retail sales were $4,600,000,000 in the quarter With comparable sales down 1.6% compared to a slight increase of 0.7% last year. This decline was due to the continued softening of consumer demand, particularly in Ontario and BC and in the discretionary categories, Which is consistent with what we saw last quarter. At CTR, comparable sales were down 0.6% and we were pleased to see that traffic was Down only modestly compared with last year. However, we have continued to see a shift in what consumers are buying. Customers are shifting away from higher ticket discretionary items and also reducing the number of items in their basket with an increase in single unit baskets

Speaker 2

When we take a

Speaker 3

look at sales on a divisional basis in our larger divisions, automotive continued its positive Straight up 5% as essential automotive categories such as maintenance and auto parts grew across all regions driven by demand for oil and batteries. Softness in home projects drove a decline in fixing, while higher sales of pet and household cleaning were the drivers behind a modest increase in living. Despite benefiting from earlier fall winter shipments than last year, revenue in the quarter ended flat after adjusting for the MSA benefit. Softer demand as dealer focused on sell through of their existing inventory offset the advance of Q4 shipments into Q3. Now moving on to Sport Chek.

Speaker 3

Comparable sales were down 7.4% as we saw declines in higher ticket and discretionary categories Such as cycling, which had strong growth last year as well as key back to school categories like athletic footwear and clothing. As we mentioned last quarter, a key focus area for Sport Chek is building out team sports and we delivered strong growth In all sports across regions this quarter, our team's sports assortment is an important component of store refreshes We currently have underway in a number of markets. To drive store traffic, the team is also leveraging exclusive in store events, Including Triangle member shopping events and product launches such as the recent Air Jordan shoe drop. Additionally, given the mild temperatures in September, we delayed a major marketing event to early October. This impacted Q3 performance, but has contributed to improved sales performance over the 1st few weeks of Q4.

Speaker 3

Mark's once again delivered comparable sales slightly ahead of last year, up 2.6 up 0.2% against a 3.6% comp. Women's casual wear and casual footwear sales were up, offsetting the decline in industrial wear and men's casual wear compared to last year. Growth was strong in the Atlantic provinces and Alberta, where Mark's has had a longstanding presence, and that offset softness in Ontario and the other Western provinces. Turning now to Helly Hansen, where Q3 revenue was up 28%, driven by strong sports wholesale shipments Due to early deliveries of fallwinter product in Q3 versus Q4 last year, we continue to strengthen our D2C offering And delivered double digit growth in e commerce across a number of markets with the majority of growth in the U. S.

Speaker 3

Our retail stores also delivered double digit growth. And in August, we opened our new Helly Hansen outlet store just outside of Toronto and Halton Hills, which contribute to an increase in Canadian retail sales. Once again, we were really pleased with the retail gross margin rate we achieved this quarter. Excluding MSA, Retail gross margin rate was up 77 basis points, driven by CTR product margin, up more than 200 basis points. This was offset by lower margin at Marks and Check due to increased promotional activity.

Speaker 3

The CTR team continued to demonstrate an ability to manage the levers within our control And banked the significant tailwind from freight savings. Margin was also helped by $33,000,000 of benefit from our margin sharing arrangement with our dealers, Representing 66 basis points of margin uplift compared to last year, taking the total increase in retail gross margin rate, excluding petroleum, Up 143 basis points compared to last year. There were two factors that drove our normalized retail SG and A growth of 9% in the quarter. The first was our ongoing investment in our better connected strategy as we transition to cloud based infrastructure and invest in the retail store network, while the second was higher share based variable compensation. Variable compensation increased partly due to the decline in the share price in Q2, which resulted in a $20,000,000 year over year unfavorable variance In the mark to market adjustment of our equity hedges and related share based compensation awards, which drove higher expense than we had expected.

Speaker 3

Excluding the unfavorable impact of the equity hedges, Q3 SG and A was up 6%. Operational discipline remains a key focus for us And we will continue to take action to implement efficiencies that will help protect profitability while minimizing the long term impact on our business. Now let's move on to inventory, where we made great progress managing down inventory levels without eroding product margin. Compared to a 6% increase in Q2, inventory was down 2% in Q3. Lower CTR inventory Was somewhat offset by inventory build ahead of the important selling season in Q4 at other banners.

Speaker 3

On the dealer side, Inventory units are down and dealers feel well positioned with all things Christmas as we enter the holiday season. I'll now move on to Financial Services, where portfolio performance metrics have trended back to the bottom end of in line with our expectations. Card spend was down 2% in the quarter, marking a second consecutive decline. Average account balances were up by approximately 4%, While active account growth was below 3%, on the back of proactive measures we implemented to manage acquisition strategies. Despite the slowing in key account metrics, GAAR was up 6.4% and ending receivables finished the quarter unchanged on Q2 at 7,200,000,000 The ECL allowance was flat to last quarter at $912,000,000 which left the allowance rate at 12.6% within our target range of 11.5% To 13.5 percent.

Speaker 3

Revenue continued to be strong, up 9% over last year, while gross margin was down 3%, reflecting higher write offs Higher funding costs given the interest rate environment. Our higher SG and A contributed to a $13,900,000 decline in IBT. Given the current environment, we are watching unemployment rates and payment behavior metrics carefully. To manage potential exposure, we are taking proactive measures to reduce lending for higher risk segments. Risk metrics, although up compared to last year, We're in line with our expectations.

Speaker 3

The PD2 plus rate and the write off rate were both up 30 basis points compared to last quarter And the TDP2 plus rate at 3.3 percent and the write off rate at 5.9%. We expect the write off rate to continue to increase as newer accounts Before I finish on capital allocation, I wanted to touch base on our plans and expectations for Q4. As we sit here in early November, the retail trends we are seeing are Consistent with Q3, but there remains a lot of game left to be played in the quarter. And as you know, weather can be an important driver of seasonal performance in Q4 And in Q1, in fallwinter categories, the combination of higher inventory from last year and the majority Product shipping in Q3 this year compared to Q4 last year means our CTR dealers are very well stocked heading into our biggest selling season And we expect to ship little fall winter product in Q4 unless consumer demand proves stronger than expected. Not surprisingly, the incentive for dealers to hold extra inventory in other categories is also being dampened by higher interest rates.

Speaker 3

These factors will make for a tough revenue comp going into Q4 compared to a year ago, when retail revenue excluding petroleum was up 2% As dealers were still building Christmas and winter inventory, Q4 last year also included the benefit of a full year of MSA. I thought it would be helpful to also touch base on the retail gross margin rate and OpEx. In Q3, the MSA boosted margin by $33,000,000 Contributing to 143 basis point uplift in reported retail gross margin rate. The MSA recorded in Q3 Was significantly below our 4 year historical average of $80,000,000 based on the softening consumer demand we saw impacting dealers results in Q2 And based on the expected impact on Q3, which lowered our accrual for revenue and for margin. Our aim is to continue to manage margin levers The hold margins over the longer term and there will always be quarter to quarter variances driven by business performance.

Speaker 3

Importantly, as we look at 2023 on a full year basis, we currently expect our retail gross margin rate to come in Slightly below last year, mostly driven by a lower MSA. As Greg has mentioned, we have taken action on OpEx since the end of Q3 Through targeted headcount reductions that will reduce headcount by 3%. The elimination of open vacancies in the business is also expected to take our headcount down by a further 3% compared to last year. As a result of these actions, We will take a charge of between $20,000,000 $25,000,000 in Q4, which we expect to normalize for and will generate full rate run rate savings of approximately $50,000,000 These reductions will also provide some Q4 benefit along with slower supply chain costs as we exit 3PLs, We expect this to lead to a deceleration in SG and A growth in Q4. Before I wrap up, I want to touch on capital allocation.

Speaker 3

Since announcing our better connected strategy in Q1 of 2022, we have invested $1,100,000,000 in the business, paid close to $600,000,000 in dividends to shareholders And return close to $800,000,000 to shareholders by way of buybacks. We have also taken the short term step of investing to repurchase Scotiabank's 20% stake in our CTVS business with a view to evaluating strategic alternatives for that business. As you know, we continue to believe that balanced and consistent capital allocation anchored on investing in our business for the longer term is the best approach And that will continue to be our guiding principle in 2024. We will continue to make room for operating capital investment While balancing the higher short term leverage we have taken on in conjunction with the CTVS repurchase and protecting our investment grade rating, We expect to continue to spend above our long term historical run rate with operating capital expenditures expected to be in a range of $550,000,000 to $600,000,000 in 2024. Additionally, we are pleased to be announcing our 14th consecutive year of dividend increases With the annual dividend to increase $2.7 per share with our March dividend as well as our intention to repurchase Up to an additional 200,000,000 in shares during 2024, adding to the 470,000,000 of share repurchases over the last year.

Speaker 3

I want to thank our teams and our dealer network for continuing to focus on our customer needs, while in addition holding sales and protecting gross margin. We are pleased with the returns we've delivered to shareholders and the strategic investments we've made for the future of the business and for when the economy ultimately improves. We look forward to updating you on where we are with our CTVEST process and the value we can build in our Triangle Rewards program as well as how we performed in our biggest selling season when we come back in February. With that, I'll hand over to Greg for his closing remarks.

Speaker 2

I'll end my prepared remarks today by reiterating that as we navigate these ongoing challenges and continued uncertainty, we are focused On controlling what we can control and that includes taking decisive action to reinforce our resilience. In Q3, our teams continued to demonstrate their conviction for our better connected strategy, which will unlock our ability to deliver accelerated growth when the market stabilizes. I too want to thank all our team members who remain dedicated to making life in Canada better for our customers, communities and shareholders in the face of what feels With that, I'll pass it over to the operator for questions.

Operator

We ask that you limit yourself to 1 question plus one follow-up question before cycling back into the queue. We'll pause for just a moment to compile the Q and A roster. The first question is from Brian Morrison from TD Securities. Please go ahead. Your line is open.

Speaker 4

Thanks very much. Good morning. I have one question on retail, one question on financial services, please. So gross margin, maybe the first question The gross margin, very strong Q3 performance. I'm not sure I got all the details, but it looks like you're trying to sustain that maybe Slightly lower ex the MSA in Q4.

Speaker 4

Can you maybe just address the ability to do that when it's clear that the holiday season is going to be later than typical with promotions starting earlier in the year.

Speaker 5

Hey, Brian, it's TJ. Thanks for the question. As you know, at CTR, we've Growing our margin rate since the beginning of the pandemic and our intent is to hold those margin rates At these elevated levels as we go forward. So that's clearly our intent and we feel very good about how we've managed our margin rates in the quarter with rates Tracking up versus well above Q3 last year. And there were a lot of moving parts in there.

Speaker 5

We benefited from increases in our own brand Penetration rates, we had a significant amount of freight savings year over year, which contributed greatly to our improvement versus last year. Ken, we had some tailwind in category mix with higher shipments in automotive. And I think if you aggregate those three things, they helped offset Some headwind that we had in FX in the quarter. As you know and we've talked about it a few times on call We feel like we have strong capabilities such as elasticity modeling and obviously our own brands capabilities and offering and as well as Our Triangle Rewards program, which really helps us manage that balance of driving demand and managing our margins. But what I do want to articulate and you're kind of touching on it here is margin can be very choppy quarter to quarter.

Speaker 5

So it's really important to look at our margin performance over a longer term view, particularly over a full year. And as Gregory mentioned, we are Expecting full year margin rates at CTC to be slightly lower than a year ago, but I can tell you that within that we are expecting full year margin rates at CTR to be slightly ahead of last year. And this is despite and I think you mentioned that what is going to be a tougher Q4 for us in CTR given the margin dynamics associated with MSA that Gregory touched on in his opening remarks. But our goal is always to make sure as I Said that we run the right balance between demand creation and margin management. And as you articulated there, we do expect it to be a competitively intense market, But we also feel very good about our capabilities in terms of how we manage that balance between demand creation and margin

Speaker 4

Okay. Thank you for that color. Maybe turning to Gregory, CTFS, You talked about the stretched consumer, the weakening economic outlook. Those are 2 allowance drivers and yet your allowance provision is maintained. So maybe reconcile those comments and then I realize it's early in the process, but is there a scenario with the portfolio where you own the data but not have majority ownership Or should we expect a similar deal to the CTFS with another partner?

Speaker 3

I'll start with the first one and Maybe take the second one as well or if Greg wants to jump in, I'm sure he will. So in terms of I think your first question around kind of As we look at the allowance rates and thinking about kind of softening conditions, etcetera, etcetera, I mean, I think part of this is a consideration of your booking life I'm losses as you think about the allowance, Brian. So I think that's kind of still what I'd start with 1st and foremost. And then you have to look at the individual trends. So even though I acknowledge the Unemployment rate crept up a little bit to 5.7% in the most recent data available.

Speaker 3

That's still pretty much in line with kind of historical trends on what the unemployment rate would be. Go back to 2,009 and look at what happened to kind of unemployment rates kind of in those early months, and I think you see a bit of a different picture. I think the allowance is doing what it should do, which is it's taking the risk factors in new cases, taking payment rates into effect, it's Take into account things like economic conditions and at this point it's saying we think the lifetime loss That $912,000,000 that I referred to. So I think that's how you square it off is, I think You have to keep a look at the current data and take into account, what that is doing. So our payment rates still remain quite strong is what I would tell you.

Speaker 3

So that's kind of the first piece. Maybe I'll keep going on the second piece, which is, look, I think we've been very open in this. We are looking to a second step of the transaction and that's probably the best I can tell you at this time. Like we are going to be engaging with a number of different partners on this and would like to explore whether other options might be available. So really too early at this point to Commit to anything other than we're open to kind of having dialogues and discussions to see what different structures and arrangements may be available that can help us.

Speaker 3

I circle back to remember what Greg just talked about. How do we move our loyalty agenda, I think is the first and foremost on this. And then as part and parcel of that, we'll Consider kind of the banking side of things as well. That's all I would say.

Speaker 4

Okay. Thank you very much. Good luck going to the holiday season.

Speaker 3

You too. Thanks.

Operator

Thank you. The next question is from Irene Nattel from RBC Capital Markets. Please go ahead. Your line is open.

Speaker 1

Thanks and

Speaker 6

good morning everyone. Thank you for that sort of for the detail that you provided in your prepared remarks. As we look ahead to 2024 and if we think about where the Bank of Canada sits right now and where the economic forecast sits right now, If we do not see any relief on rates before the back half of twenty twenty four, How do you see yourself as positioned in terms of your committed offering for spring 2024 For your inventory levels and for, I guess, the mix in store.

Speaker 2

Good morning, Irene. It's Greg. Maybe I'll take that. I mean, I would as we said in our We're expecting continued softness going forward. It's tough to interpret the signals Right now in terms of what monetary policy could look like in the future, and we're taking that hawkish tone Into decisive action, like I suggested throughout my prepared remarks.

Speaker 2

And What we have behind us now is a quarter and a bit of Continued softening demand where we can really see what's important to the customer. And as we've talked about many times, we've got tremendous Operating cadence and discipline in terms of how we plan seasons, we've talked about a 7 season calendar Being kind of our operating rhythm, so we've been able to incorporate the last quarter in a bit here in terms of how we posture ourselves For 2024, and so you can expect us, as I said, to be extremely focused on value, Value through triangle, value through promotions, value through our own brands portfolio, and very focused I'm getting every single dollar that we can out of essential categories that continue to be really important to Canadians. And so, We feel really good about the fact that we've gotten a little bit more visibility here as we move towards 2024 to plan For this continued softening environment, maybe, not maybe to a larger much larger degree than we had with the Precipitous demand fall off starting in June this year. So we feel much better heading into 2024 than we did In terms of how the business came to us here in the back half of twenty twenty three.

Speaker 6

That's very helpful. Thank you. So presumably, in terms of good, better, best or sort of repair and maintenance versus new, We should be thinking about mix that is more toward value offering or Are you still keeping the same basic offering, just thinking about offering the value component of it through Triangle or promotion?

Speaker 3

Yes. It's

Speaker 2

more Irene how we kind of lean into components of the accordion. It's really about those essential Categories as I mentioned essential businesses up 4%, traveling through automotive. So we're leaning heavy into all sorts of tactics in our automotive business be that inventory, be that price, be that merchandising in store, on the site, How we're thinking about digital capability deployment around our service business, which continues to be really, really strong. And what we are still seeing the opportunity to drive demand in discretionary categories. It's just To T.

Speaker 2

J. Point, it's being disciplined around that investment in price To incremental sales equation and so again I just I keep coming back to we've got more planning lead time here For the machine to kick in around creating value and operating in the short term with all the arrows that we have in our quiver. And so it's that's why we feel much better heading into 2024 in terms of really How to deal with what we're seeing from a consumer demand standpoint. It will all be about delivering on that resiliency.

Speaker 6

That's great. Thank you. And just one housekeeping question. You noted in the prepared remarks, somebody noted in the prepared remarks There was a shipment in timing sorry, there was a shift in timing on some of the shipments from Q4 into Q3 at both Mark's and CTR. Is there a way for you to quantify that for us?

Speaker 3

Yes, it's Gregory here. I think on the CTR side, we were just trying to give as you're thinking about kind of your own models, we're trying to lay out The components of revenue to consider. So, I think there was 3 things we've said and you give me a chance, Irene, so I'm going to take them anyway. Just remember that last year we had the full year for the MSA versus this year we've got 1 quarter of the MSA. So we're looking at kind of Revenue and margin numbers, let's just make sure we capture that.

Speaker 3

The other two points we tried to raise kind of around revenue and shipments at CTR specifically There was some shift into Q3 around product, but the dealers also as we talked about in Q1 and Q2 We're a bit heavy kind of ending the season on kind of Christmas. So we don't see as much opportunity in Q4 to ship that product going forward, Because it's already either in the store from Q3 or from frankly end of season. And as I said in my prepared remarks, Unless consumer demand picks up, that's kind of the current kind of outlook or picture we would say at this point. And I said on Sport Chek, not really on Mark's, There was a timing shift of a fairly significant marketing campaign that moved sales kind of come from October sorry from September into October. And I tried because the 7.4% is not I think a fair way to think of an exit comp rate.

Speaker 3

So anyway, just wanted to clarify that.

Speaker 7

Thank you.

Operator

Thank you. The next question is from George Doumet from Scotiabank. Please go ahead. Your line is open.

Speaker 8

Yes. Hi. Good morning, everybody. It looks like the comp performance at CTR improved intra quarter, I guess, given the outlook That you guys provided last quarter. Is that the case?

Speaker 8

And just to clarify, Gregory's comments, I guess, Q4 being consistent with Q3. Should we read that that the comps are currently running in kind of the flattish range? Thanks.

Speaker 5

Yes, I mean, when you unpack CTR sorry, George, it's TJ here. When you unpack the quarter for Q3, We are actually relative to what was going on in the marketplace, we're actually quite pleased with the performance. And we did to your point start to outpace what was a pretty soft June. So from a Q3 perspective, I think we felt pretty good with how we landed there. If you look at a couple of metrics, the fact that we only modestly declined in traffic and modestly declined in basket size, Good size.

Speaker 5

That really speaks to kind of the resilience of our business given the economic backdrop. So that's how I would characterize Q3, I think what Gregory's comments and I'll let him jump in here about Q4 is we are starting to see early days similar performance in Q4 as what we saw in Q3, but I can't stress enough and Gregory said it in his opening remarks, we have a lot of game to play. November December are huge. So you can't call the ballgame after October, but that's how we're seeing it right now.

Speaker 8

Okay. It's helpful. And just one last one for me. Looking at the 20 purchase of financial services, you mentioned that it expediate the key elements of our Triangle Rewards Strategy. I was wondering if you could talk a little bit more to that and maybe give us some examples.

Speaker 8

Thanks.

Speaker 2

Yes, it's Greg here, George. Look, I talked about value and timing in my prepared remarks. I talked about what's critical for us. Our ownership of Triangle Rewards is non negotiable. The Triangle Rewards loyalty program is now at the core of our business model.

Speaker 2

So when you think about that, we and just step back contextually, we have a network of retail banners. Triangle connects them all with very privileged first party data and we use that data to create value for the customer and drive spend across those businesses. So it's a flywheel where our Retail segment is a system that works together. The bank is an accelerator of the flywheel because it issues the vast majority of Canadian Tire Money, The currency that drives that retail spend and engagement with our members. And so when you think again Contextually, about when we signed the deal with Scotiabank in 2014, Triangle Rewards wasn't even in existence.

Speaker 2

So the marketing rights within the deal for B and S were fairly restrictive in terms of where we now want to go with Triangle. So I'll probably stop short of giving you an idea Of the things that we're really looking for in a partner, but suffice it to say, it is all about that acceleration of the flywheel. It's more credit cards, it's more valued partnerships, it's new financial products, it's potentially helping us scale Accelerator products like Triangle Select, it's an active partner really helping to drive our core Business strategy. So why don't I stop there, George?

Operator

That's great.

Speaker 8

Thanks for the comments.

Operator

Yes. Thank you. The next question is from Mark Petrie from CIBC. Please go ahead. Your line is open.

Speaker 9

Yes, thanks. Good morning. CapEx is expected to be lower for 20 23% than you had previously messaged and 2024 lower again. I know it's sort of above, I think, what you were Calling out is the long term runway, but below what you had forecast previously. So obviously, you remain committed to better connected, but can you just talk about the type of spend that has been Trend and how that will affect the rollout of Better Connected if

Speaker 8

at all?

Speaker 3

Yes, it's Gregory here. I think we've tried to be as careful as possible to have this minimal impact on Better Connected. But I mean, I think what I would say is It has caused some lags in some place. So fully committed to the strategy. I think we've tried as much as possible to kind of protect the continued investment in real estate.

Speaker 3

I think Greg in his prepared remarks gave you a sense of where we were in 'twenty three and where we're going to be in 'twenty four. And I really think this year is about taking advantage of frankly A lot of the capabilities we've been building for the last year and a half are better connected. So this is just a slight slowdown In the delivery of all that, we're still fully committed and still are frankly excited about the capabilities we're building. We just think It's a more appropriate response given kind of the economic conditions to slow this down just a little bit as we enter 2024.

Speaker 9

Okay. Thanks for that. And then I also wanted to ask just at CTR specifically about Promotional penetration, if that shifted at all, you talked about it a little bit, but any further color would be helpful. And then also if you've seen behavior shift by the flyer or through other vehicles like the app? Thanks.

Speaker 9

Yes.

Speaker 5

Hey, Mark, it's TJ. Maybe I'll take that one. Look, our goal is always to make sure we have the right balance, as I said earlier, Demand creation being price competitive and managing our margins and we have seen The competitive landscape kind of dial up a little bit in the intensity here, but we really believe in our strong elasticity modeling and couple of examples As we used in Q3, we leaned heavily into improved discount or increased discounts in areas like home organization and And really we're able to move the needle from a sales perspective. And then other categories in Q3, we tried and just didn't get the sales response, things like kayaks And things like that, we kind of course corrected halfway through the quarter and kind of started to veer towards other things. So We're always kind of running that balance of demand creation and our flyer activity or promotional activity was relatively flat in Q3.

Speaker 5

3. As we go into Q4, we do expect some more intensity here. I'm not going to tip my hand too much to the competition on this call, but what We're going to do what we're going to do, but I feel very confident that we have a lot of tricks up our sleeve in terms of providing value to customers as We go forward here, and when you think about all of the weapons in our arsenal now with the Triangle Rewards program, our own brands portfolio, our good, better, best Range architecture, we provide a lot of choice for consumers and we're going to continue to try to expose them

Speaker 9

Okay. That's very helpful and all the best for your holiday.

Speaker 3

Thanks, Mark. Thanks, Mark.

Operator

Thank you. The next question is from Tami Chen from BMO Capital Markets. Please go ahead. Your line is open.

Speaker 7

Good morning. Thanks for the questions. I have 2 on the Financial Services segment. First is, I'm just wondering if you have this Even ballpark, I figure. In terms of your in store sales, would you know how much of that is on credit card?

Speaker 3

Yes, it's Gregory here. It we look at, we call it, share of tender. It varies by banner, from marks and check And petroleum, I mean, I've always used kind of as a rough rule for, I mean, that was probably about 12% or so would be what I would say. On the overall Average and then it does vary a little bit by petroleum is a higher share of tender and I think Sport Chek might be on the bit on the lower side, but that's what I would that's

Speaker 7

And my second question is, You talked about how the risk metrics for the Financial Services segment are coming back to historical Levels, I think your net write off is now within the historical range, and you talked about that. But just wanted to ask, As you look at the pool and behavior within it, is there anything that you would flag that you're watching closely that maybe you're a bit concerned about that You're keeping an eye on? Thanks.

Speaker 3

I don't think there's anything look, we keep a close eye on this portfolio Month to month, week to week, day to day. I don't think I think the team has taken some more action over the past 6 months. As I mentioned in some of my remarks around Higher risk segments, it's we're being a little bit more careful around adding additional exposure, credit exposure to those groups. But Again, the group looks at payment behaviors. They're looking at unemployment, look at it on a regional basis, look at it on time on books.

Speaker 3

And it really kind of continues to be the addition of the new accounts the team's brought on the last little while that's put more upward pressure on this. But we are given what the current outlooks are, we are being a bit more cautious around lending. And If we feel the need to act further, I. E. Credit limit reductions, that's a step the team will absolutely take.

Speaker 3

But I think we're pretty comfortable with where the portfolio is right now. And I as in team are kind of all over, making sure that it kind of fits within kind of our long term risk acceptance levels.

Speaker 7

Okay. Thank you.

Operator

Thank you. The next question is from Vishal Shreedhar from National Bank. Please go ahead. Your line is open.

Speaker 10

Hi, thanks for taking my questions. Just on the MSA and the delta versus the figure that Suggested earlier using the averages,

Speaker 6

is it correct

Speaker 10

to say that that suggested the dealers are less profitable? And Should we think of that MSA being a continued headwind on a year over year basis into 2024?

Speaker 3

It's Greg here. Let me start with that. Vishal, I think I've said this a number of times and I know TJ has as well. There are a number of mechanisms where we share revenues, we share We share capital expenditures with our dealer network. This is one of them.

Speaker 3

So, and in terms of As we talked about just this one measure in isolation, not the kind of combined sharing of our kind of 1,000,000,000 of dollars of margin and revenues and costs, This one element was impacted relative to what we saw in the Q2, right, around kind of consumer demand softening. So I think that's what I would And you want to look at it overall, take a look at CTR overall and as CTR overall does, there's going to be a relationship obviously for the dealers as well. So I wouldn't Try to be that specific to point to one element as a reason for up, down, left or right. I mean, it's part of an overall contractual relationship, but I think it's fair to say as CTR goes, so will the dealer network. So that's probably the best way I can frankly answer that question.

Speaker 10

Okay. Maybe my other question is on just given the slowing that you've noted, How do we how do you feel about the health of your dealer network? I'm talking about the financial health. And are there any metrics that you can Point 2 would provide to us that help us better understand their ability to withstand any sort of slowdown.

Speaker 5

Hey, Vishal, it's TJ. Maybe I'll take that one and I wanted to start a little bit with some context. So I've been at Canadian Tire for almost 20 years and I've never seen the strategic intent and aspirations of the corporation and dealers more congruent Then they are right now. So we'll start there that our relationship with the dealers is transparent, collaborative and really, really strong. And they take a long term view to the business and are all in on our better connected retail strategy.

Speaker 5

And as we look ahead and you pointed out a couple of things here, but I think it's important to note that dealers are coming into this period of economic uncertainty from a position of strength given the extraordinary performance that we've seen over the past couple of years and they really support and embrace Our investments, they understand the value of the Triangle ecosystem, which Greg just talked about and our credit card as well. And they believe in the power of customer data to help drive our growth. They're big believers in our own brands and are Committed to work with us to nurture and grow them and they're committed to improving our omni channel experience and are strong supporters of our investments in our digital assets. And as you can imagine, They're thrilled with the investments in our enhanced Concept Connect stores. So, they continue to invest in their own business by co investing with us in store projects and Through new technology like Tetris that helps them with assortment planning, electronic shelf labels and customer enhancements like pickup lockers, It's true what you say that we'll be facing a bit of uncertainty here in the short term.

Speaker 5

And some of the new dealers might be facing more interest Pressures when they think about buying inventory and things like that and some of them across the country in pockets maybe dealing with some store labor kind Of issues, but I truly believe the health of the dealer network is very, very strong And their performance as we go forward is going to mirror the performance of Canadian Tire Retail. And they take a long term view. They're in it for the long haul. They are very, very passionate entrepreneurs that run their businesses very, very tightly, and they're going to be a big driver and So I think that's how I would characterize how we're feeling with the dealer network right now.

Speaker 10

Thank you for that color.

Operator

Thank you. That's all the time we had today. I'll now Turn the call back to Greg Hicks. Greg?

Speaker 2

Well, thank you, operator, and thanks everybody for joining us and for your questions today. We look forward to speaking with you when we announce our Q4 and 2023 full year results on February 15. Bye for now.

Operator

Thank you. This will conclude today's call. You may now disconnect.

Powered by Quartr

Key Takeaways

  • Consolidated Q3 comparable sales declined by 1.6% as essential categories (notably automotive, up ~4%) offset steeper drops in discretionary categories, reflecting consumers “stretched and spending less overall.”
  • Retail gross margin rate rose 77 basis points (ex-MSA) driven by a 200 bps jump at Canadian Tire Retail on freight savings, higher own-brand penetration and disciplined price-to-demand management.
  • Supply chain and cost-efficiency actions include reducing 3PL partners from 15 to 3 distribution centres, commissioning the new GTA DC, and cutting full-time headcount by 6% for an expected $50 million in annualized run-rate savings.
  • Canadian Tire repurchased Scotiabank’s 20% stake in CT Financial Services to gain full control of Triangle Rewards, accelerate loyalty and first-party data initiatives, and is evaluating strategic alternatives for the banking business.
  • Capital allocation remains balanced: the 14th consecutive dividend increase raises the annual payout to $7, up to $200 million in share repurchases is planned for 2024, and operating capital expenditures will be managed at $550–$600 million.
AI Generated. May Contain Errors.
Earnings Conference Call
Canadian Tire Q3 2023
00:00 / 00:00