Old Republic International Q3 2024 Earnings Call Transcript

Quartr
Provided by Quartr
October 24, 2024

Key Takeaways

  • Negative Sentiment: Consolidated pre-tax operating income fell to $229 M in Q3 from $251 M last year, and the combined ratio worsened to 95 from 92.
  • Positive Sentiment: Net investment income rose 17% in the quarter, boosting the total bond portfolio yield to 4.3% from 3.75% a year ago.
  • Positive Sentiment: Non-admitted surplus lines (E&S) premiums grew 21%, reaching a $585 M trailing-12-month run rate, driven by new specialty underwriting subsidiaries.
  • Positive Sentiment: Title insurance revenue climbed 4% to $709 M with Q3 pre-tax income of $40 M, and direct residential title orders jumped 26% year-over-year.
  • Positive Sentiment: Capital returns included $67 M in dividends and $165 M in share buybacks during Q3, with $385 M still available under the current repurchase authorization.
AI Generated. May Contain Errors.
Earnings Conference Call
Old Republic International Q3 2024
00:00 / 00:00

There are 7 speakers on the call.

Operator

Good afternoon. My name is Audra, and I will be your conference operator today. I'd like to welcome everyone to the Old Republic International Third Quarter 2024 Earnings Conference Call. Today's conference is being recorded. All lines have been placed on mute to prevent any background noise.

Operator

After the speakers' remarks, there will be a question and answer session. At this time, I would like to turn the conference over to Joe Calabrese with FRB. Please go ahead.

Speaker 1

Thank you. Good afternoon, everyone, and thank you for joining us for the Old Republic conference call to discuss Q3 2024 results. This morning, we distributed a copy of the press release and posted a separate financial supplement. Both of the documents are available on Old Republic's website at www.oldrepublic.com. Please be advised that this call may involve forward looking statements as discussed in the press release and financial supplement dated October 24, 2024.

Speaker 1

Risk associated with these statements can be found in the company's latest SEC filings. This afternoon's conference call will be led by Craig Schmidy, President and CEO of Old Republic International Corporation and several other senior executive members as planned for this meeting. At this time, I'd like to turn the call over to Craig Schmitt. Please go ahead, sir.

Speaker 2

All right. Thanks, Joe. Well, good afternoon, everyone, and welcome again to Old Republic's Q3 2024 Earnings Call. With me today are Frank Sodaro, CFO of ORI and Carolyn Monroe, President and CEO of our Title Insurance Group. So during the Q3, we produced $229,000,000 of consolidated pre tax operating income, which is down from $251,000,000 in 2023.

Speaker 2

And our consolidated combined ratio was 95 compared to 92 last year. General Insurance had strong underwriting results, which continued through the Q3 producing $197,000,000 of pretax operating income and that was down from $216,000,000 last year. The general insurance combined ratio was at 94 in the quarter compared to 89 last year. And this mostly reflects the anticipated lower level of favorable prior year loss reserve development when compared to the historically high level of favorable development we experienced in 2023. High mortgage interest rates and a continuing tight real estate market continue to constrict our title insurance business.

Speaker 2

Although, it does feel like we're at the beginning of a transition in the real estate market, which we'll talk about in a little bit more detail. And despite the headwinds, title insurance produced $40,000,000 of pre tax operating income in the quarter and almost $90,000,000 so far this year. The title insurance combined ratio was 96.7 in the quarter and that's unchanged from the quarter in 2023. So our conservative reserving practices continue to produce favorable prior year loss reserve development in both general insurance and title insurance. Though as expected, not to the same historically high level we saw in general insurance the last couple of years.

Speaker 2

In 2024, we remain on track to produce our 10th consecutive year of favorable loss reserve development. Our balance sheet remains strong as we returned capital to shareholders through both dividends and share repurchases during the quarter. We continue to manage for the long run investing in our new general insurance specialty underwriting subsidiaries as well as investing in technology in both general insurance and title insurance. So with those opening remarks, I will now turn it over to Frank and then Frank will turn things back to me to cover general insurance and that will be followed by Carolyn who will discuss title insurance and then we'll open up to the usual Q and A discussion. So Frank?

Speaker 3

Thank you, Craig, and good afternoon, everyone. This morning, we reported net operating income of $183,000,000 for the Q3 compared to $200,000,000 last year. On a per share basis, net operating income was relatively flat at $0.71 compared to $0.72 last year. Net investment income increased 17% in the quarter, driven by the impact of higher yields on the bond portfolio. Our average reinvestment rate on corporate bonds was 4.5%, while the comparable book yield on corporate bonds disposed of was 3.1%.

Speaker 3

The total bond portfolio book yield now stands at 4.3% compared to 3.75% at the end of the Q3 last year and 4% at the end of last year. Our investment portfolio composition and mix remained largely unchanged from last quarter. Turning to loss reserves, both the general and title insurance groups recognized favorable development in the quarter, leading to a benefit of 1.3 percentage points to the consolidated loss ratio, which is slightly lower than the 2% we strive for. I'll now give you some line of business color about the reserve development coming from the General Insurance Group in the quarter. Commercial auto continued to have strong favorable development coming predominantly from our trucking coverages.

Speaker 3

Workers' comp also had a high level of favorable development, although significantly lower by comparison to the same quarter last year. General liability had pluses and minuses across the system and ended with some unfavorable development, but at a lower level than last year. Additionally, we recorded unfavorable development of around $25,000,000 within financial indemnity, most of which relates to our transactional risks line of coverage. We saw development across several claims in this coverage, which represents a small portion of the total financial indemnity book. And finally, we had a larger amount of favorable development than usual in our property lines.

Speaker 3

We ended the quarter with book value per share of $25.71 which inclusive of dividends equates to an increase of 13.7% since year end and that resulted primarily from our strong operating earnings and increased investment valuations. In the quarter, we paid about $67,000,000 of dividends and repurchased $165,000,000 worth of our shares. Since the end of the quarter, we repurchased another $23,000,000 worth of our shares, leaving us with about $385,000,000 remaining in our current repurchase program. I'll now turn the call back over to Craig for a discussion of General Insurance.

Speaker 2

All right, Frank. Thanks. So General Insurance net written premiums were up 16% in the quarter with strong renewal retentions, rate increases on most lines of coverage, new business growth and increasing premium production in our new specialty underwriting subsidiaries. Whereas a reminder most of that business is written on E and S paper. Our E and S premiums were up 21% in the quarter and are running at $585,000,000 on a trailing 12 month basis.

Speaker 2

As I mentioned in my opening remarks in the Q3, general insurance pretax operating income was $197,000,000 and the combined ratio was 94, dollars While on a year to date basis, pre tax operating income is at $620,000,000 and the combined ratio is at $92,300,000 which is exactly in the middle of the target range we give between $90,000,000 $95,000,000 So this demonstrates that we continue to grow at a strong clip at a very profitable level. The loss ratio for the quarter was 65.2%, which includes 1.7 points of favorable prior year loss reserve development and that compares to 60.4% last year, which included 6.1 points of favorable development. Absent the impact of favorable reserve development, the accident year loss ratio was relatively stable as compared to last year on both the quarterly and year to date basis. The expense ratio held relatively steady at 28.8 compared to 28.6 last year and is running at 28.2 for the year, which again is right in line with our expectations. Now turning to property catastrophic losses that impacted the industry in the 3rd and 4th quarters.

Speaker 2

But first, let me express that our thoughts still remain with those that are recovering in the disaster areas, which includes about 1,000 of our associates. As most of you on the call know, we write less catastrophic exposed business than most of our peers. So with that said, we expect ultimate losses for Helene to be between $8,000,000 $10,000,000 and ultimate losses for Milton to be between $18,000,000 $23,000,000 As Frank mentioned, we experienced unfavorable prior year loss reserve development in the financial indemnity line of coverage, stemming primarily from transactional risks written in our professional liability unit, which writes mostly D and O and E and O and other management liability covers. The unfavorable development drove the high 83% loss ratio that you can all see in the financial supplement for the financial indemnity line of coverage. Now providing you with some more details on commercial auto and workers' compensation, 2 of our largest lines.

Speaker 2

Commercial auto net premiums written grew 14% in the quarter, while the loss ratio came in at 67.1% compared to 66.3% last year due to slightly lower levels of favorable prior year loss reserve development, although as Frank said, still strong. And rate increases were approximately 10% and that remains commensurate with the loss trends that we observe in that line. Workers' compensation net premiums written held relatively steady quarter to quarter, while the loss ratio came in at 58.8 compared to 33.2 last year due to much lower levels of favorable prior year loss reserve development this year when compared to the historically high levels of favorable development we experienced this quarter in 2023. So loss frequency trend continues to decline and loss severity trend remains relatively stable. So given higher wage trend within the payroll, which is our rating base, the declining loss frequency trend, the stable severity trend and our rate decreases of approximately 4% on this line, We continue to remain of the belief that our rate levels remain adequate for workers' compensation.

Speaker 2

We expect solid growth and profitability in General Insurance to continue for the remainder of 2024, reflecting the success of our specialty strategy, our operational excellence initiatives and our new specialty underwriting subsidiaries. So with that said for General Insurance, I will now turn the discussion over to Carolyn to report on title insurance. Carolyn?

Operator

And it does look like Carolyn has disconnected. If we could just wait one moment while we reconnect.

Speaker 2

Okay. I know Carolyn is in one of those areas impacted by the recent catastrophes. So hopefully, we'll be able to get her back on. That we don't have downtime for all of those listening in perhaps I can kind of wrap

Speaker 4

Craig, I got reconnected.

Speaker 2

Okay, great. I

Speaker 4

was I'm sorry.

Speaker 2

No problem. I was ready to pivot and call an audible here, but we'll hand it to you.

Speaker 4

All right. Thank you. Sorry about that. The title group reported premium and fee revenue for the quarter of $709,000,000 This represents an increase of nearly 4% from Q3 last year. Our directly produced premium and fees represented 22% of revenue versus 21% in the Q3 of 2023 and our fees were up 9% from prior year, while agency produced premiums were up 2%.

Speaker 4

Our commercial premiums decreased 6% and represent approximately 20% of our net premiums for the quarter. While commercial premiums decreased slightly, we are seeing some positive signs in our direct operations. Commercial direct new title orders were up 11% compared to Q3 2023. Our pre tax operating income of $40,000,000 was an increase of 7% over prior year Q3 and our expense ratio of 94% and our combined ratio of 96.7% are consistent with Q3 2023. Since the end of 2022, interest rates have been the headline story in our market.

Speaker 4

While many homeowners have already have low interest rates, homebuyers that purchased during recent years' rate increases are now seeing an opportunity to lower their rates. We are also seeing homeowners taking advantage of the equity in their homes to remodel or for other cash needs. These two activities are pushing up refinance activity. The recent Fed rate increase is significant because it signals a long awaited shift in monetary policy to spur economic growth. While housing affordability and lack of residential housing inventory still represent headwinds for our industry, The shift in Fed policy is a sign a very positive sign for our industry.

Speaker 4

In our direct operations, we have seen an increase in our open orders each quarter this year. Overall, our Q3 new open residential title orders in our direct locations were up 26% compared to the Q3 of 2023. As we start the final quarter of this year, we continue to focus on modernization efforts in our direct operations and bringing value and servicing our agents as they prepare for an increase in business as the markets recover. We'll continue to emphasize that investing in technology is a critical priority. While we are pleased with our Q3 results and activities, we remain mindful that the market is still recovering from the downturn and we will remain focused on managing for the long run.

Speaker 4

Thank you, Craig.

Speaker 2

And it feels like we're at the beginning of a transition in the real estate market. Overall, our year to date results are driving positive performance in our earnings per share growth, our operating return on equity and our book value growth. And these results have enabled us to return a record amount of capital to shareholders this year. So that concludes our prepared remarks and we'll now open up the discussion to Q and A where either I'll answer your question, I'll ask Frank or Carolyn to help me out and respond. So we'll open it up to Q and A.

Operator

Thank you. We will now begin the question and answer session. We'll take our first question from Gregory Peters at Raymond James.

Speaker 5

Good afternoon, everyone. So the last couple of comments I missed, I must have also a poor connection here. And you did mention, you got back in where you're talking about share repurchase activities. So can we go back to the capital management initiatives? What the expectations are for share repurchase for the balance of the year?

Speaker 5

And how you think about it for 2025?

Speaker 2

Sure. So maybe I'll Greg, since I don't know exactly what you might have missed, I know you're down in that same area as Carolyn. But perhaps Frank could just recap on where we were at the during the quarter and since the end of the quarter with our share repurchases.

Speaker 3

Yes. So share repurchases in the quarter was about $165,000,000 Since the end of the quarter, we did about another $23,000,000 That's taking the full year up to $768,000,000 of repurchases puts us right at about $1,000,000,000 return when you include since the end of the quarter and our dividends. The other thing I'd add is we have $385,000,000 remaining on our current authorization.

Speaker 2

Yes. And Greg, I would just speak to that and say that we have always been mindful of valuation when we're repurchasing and our pace of repurchases does depend somewhat on that. And it looks like we could continue to repurchase through the end of the year and that could possibly exhaust the remaining amount of $380,000,000 $385,000,000 that Brent spoke to or that might go into the Q1 of next year as we continue down the repurchase

Speaker 5

path. Thank you for clarifying that. The second question, in your comments, Craig, you spoke about, I think you said E and S was up 21%. Is that the 4 businesses, the new ventures you've been talking about where the premium is up? And I think you said the run rate is around $385,000,000 is that right or am I or $5.88,000 maybe, excuse me, I got 2 different numbers on here.

Speaker 6

Yes, that's right.

Speaker 5

And can you just give us an update on how you're looking at those businesses, Because I think that's a growth engine as we think out over a multiyear period.

Speaker 2

Sure. Yes, I'd be happy to. So just to level set, again Old Republic Union is our non admitted surplus line company. And all of our 17 subsidiaries within the General Insurance Group have access to that paper. So there are several of our subsidiary companies that do use that paper on some of their business.

Speaker 2

However, a good amount of that growth that we're seeing is coming from a couple of our newer subsidiaries, primarily our Old Republic E and S operation. And I know as we spoke about when we set that up a few years ago, we expected that to grow and it's growing in line with our expectations. And we think that it will continue at a pretty good clip for the next couple of years at least. And then we also have Old Republic Inland Marine that we also set up just prior to that. And that's helping to produce premium as well.

Speaker 2

And then to a lesser extent our new over public Lawyers Professional and our new Old Republic ANH. But again, those are to a lesser extent. So it is as I say primarily our over public E and S operation that's driving a lot of that growth within the E and S space.

Speaker 5

Fair enough. I guess the final question just on the reserve development. I don't recall Frank ever hearing a 2% favorable reserve development target for the company. So that was a new piece of information. The other thing is, I think you mentioned it twice in the call, which is this charge of the prior development of $25,000,000 in financial lines.

Speaker 5

Is this was this a one time situation? Or is there some potential some erosion of this as we think about looking into the quarters ahead?

Speaker 2

Yes. So Greg, let me first talk about that 2%. I know in the past I've said that we hope to on the side of producing favorable development as opposed to going between favorable and unfavorable developments. And as such, we hope for two points of favorable development over time. So that remains our target.

Speaker 2

It might be too strong of a word, but we are conservative reserving practices. We hope will result in favorable development of about that 2% level on average over time. So that on your the first part of your question. With respect to the transactional risk business, as Frank said, it's a small part of our professional business and it is currently running just to give you some relativity. We've been reducing our writings in that area this year.

Speaker 2

So year to date, we're about $14,000,000 of premium in that area. And it's a professional line that is primarily is in our professional liability unit. And as I stated in my comments that unit really is more of our D and O and E and O Management Liability Group. So it's a very small piece of our overall financial indemnity line. And as I know in other quarters where a certain line of coverage where we either adjust the accident year loss ratio up or we put up some additional reserve.

Speaker 2

When we see something come through, we in the way of claims and in this case very small number of claims, but they have some severity. And when we see something like that, we take a conservative view and put up reserves. So that's what we did this quarter. And we'll have to see where things go. But that's our best view of things right now on that business.

Speaker 2

And again, we've taken a conservative approach as we always do when we see something coming through. We rarely will take things down if it's favorable. But if it's unfavorable, we immediately react and try to react in a conservative way.

Speaker 5

Thank you very much for the answers.

Speaker 2

Thanks, Greg.

Operator

We'll move next to Carol Shneil at Citizens JMP.

Speaker 5

Yes. Hi, Carole. Hi, Carole.

Speaker 6

Hi, hi. I'm calling in for Matt. He's unavailable right now. But my main question is regarding commercial auto. And Craig, you had mentioned earlier that commercial auto, you're going to get the 10% rate, which is in line with the loss cost trend.

Speaker 6

But my question is really, are you seeing any of this frequency and severity that is being seen in the industry? And if not, is your book any different from your peers?

Speaker 2

Sure. Our we believe our book is different from our peers in at least how we approach the business. I think in prior quarters, I spoke about how our reserving practices are different, our claims practices are different and very specialized and our distribution model again is very different. However, with respect to frequency and severity, no, our it's very hard to isolate yourself from what the industry sees, whether that's workers' compensation or whether it's auto. Yesterday, our executives just had a meeting with the folks from NCCI, for instance, on workers' comp.

Speaker 2

And what they're observing in the way of frequency and severity is pretty much lines up with what we're seeing in the way of frequency and severity. So I would say the same goes for auto. It's very difficult to immune yourself from factors of frequency and severity that are driven by how many miles are being driven, traffic congestion on the roads when it comes to frequency and on severity. As we've talked about social inflation, jury verdict and the like are going to drive severity on that. And therefore, we're I think what we're seeing on frequency and severity on auto is probably very consistent with what the industry is seeing.

Speaker 2

I think the difference there too of us from industry and why we have the favorable loss reserve development that we have on commercial auto is again because of our reserving practices both on a case reserving basis, on an IBNR reserving basis are much more conservative. And when we saw back in 2019 2018 when we saw the changes come through on severity, we immediately reacted. We improved our pricing analytics and we refined our rate filings and also started implementing rate increases to get us back to where we need. And if you look back over the last 5 years, we have on average obtained a 10% rate increase. Back in 2019, it was actually about a 17% rate increase when we initially started to observe things.

Speaker 2

So you compound that all the way through and it helps explain why we've been able to maintain the results we have. And we were I think it's safe to say much sooner to react and perfect our pricing and our case reserving much sooner than many in the industry that are putting up unfavorable development.

Speaker 6

Great. Thank you. That's very helpful. And then just a short follow-up regarding the buyback and the overall capital management. You guys said earlier that you're open to maybe using all of your buyback for this year or maybe into next year?

Speaker 6

Is there something that you're looking at? I mean, are you looking to use the capital more for premium growth?

Speaker 2

Well, let me just step back and give you perhaps a broader response than that. And that is as I've indicated in several quarters when the issue of capital management comes up, I remind everyone that every quarter we review our capital management position with our board and we make a recommendation on ways to return excess capital if we deem there to be excess capital. The first preference for capital is to grow the business. But we have been so fortunate to produce the results we have that our retained earnings have as much capital as we've returned over the last several years. Our retained earnings keep filling that bucket back up and that keeps happening.

Speaker 2

So, as we get into next year, I would suspect that we will again be in that position where retained earnings keeps filling up that capital bucket. And unless there's an opportunity for an M and A transaction or an opportunity to continue to make stronger investments in new businesses, then we will deem that capital to be in excess And we'll again have a conversation with our board and talk about the best ways to return that whether that be through a share repurchase or through a special dividend.

Speaker 6

Great. Understood. Thank you very much.

Speaker 2

Thank you.

Operator

And we'll take a follow-up from Gregory Peters at Raymond James.

Speaker 6

Hey. So in your press release,

Speaker 5

you called out warranty, home warranty as being where pricing is being competitive and pulling back. Yet if I look at that segment's results, net written premium was up substantially in the quarter and up for the year. So maybe you can help walk us through the moving pieces inside that segment?

Speaker 2

Yes. So I'll talk to it a little bit, Greg. I can tell you that we did write a new program within our home and auto warranty segment that was auto warranty. That business has been very profitable for us and has ran at decent loss ratios. So we expect to continue to grow at a pretty decent clip of premium on our auto warranty.

Speaker 2

What and as respect I thought you said something in your question about something in the release that indicated perhaps something different than that. If you could just clarify.

Speaker 5

If I look at the press release, it said largely reflecting market conditions or declines in public D and O transactional risk and coverages and to a lesser extent home warranty.

Speaker 2

Okay. Yes. So thank you for that clarification. Yes. So the auto warranty is driving that line of coverage category of home and auto warranty as I just explained.

Speaker 2

And on home warranty, we're producing that business mostly through real estate agents and it's very dependent as our title insurance business is on sales transactions in the real estate market for homes. So in the home warranty segment, we've actually seen some declines there because of just where we're at in the real estate cycle. And again, we just as in title, we're hopefully feeling the real estate market starting to turn. But those are the 2 moving pieces, 1 up, 1 down. Thank you.

Speaker 2

Auto warranty up, home warranty down a bit.

Speaker 5

Fair enough. I feel like I should filibuster till I get the fire department running by you. I just wanted to pivot, Carolyn. I know you guys here we are at the end of October, you're starting to prepare budgets for next year. I'm not sure what of the outlook for both new and refinancing activities?

Speaker 5

Maybe you could provide us a snapshot of how you're thinking about it through your crystal ball?

Operator

Sure,

Speaker 4

Greg. This year every quarter, we've seen a slight increase in our orders that we track through our direct operations. It's a positive sign, but I also think just based on what we read, we listen to economists quite a bit, it's just still so hard to predict what could happen. I don't we would be happy if we continue to see the positive increases that we've seen quarter over quarter this year. A lot of people believe that we'll start seeing some recovery later in 2025.

Speaker 4

And then 2026 should be when it really starts having a larger effect on us. But we're just it's just so hard to predict anymore. I wouldn't have thought that when this first started, I would have thought we'd be way ahead of where we are now, but it's just something that's been so unpredictable almost month to month in the real estate cycle right now.

Speaker 5

So I guess as a related question, if there's a lot of that uncertainty, I look at the expense ratio. Let's just look at the 9 month expense ratio, 95.4%. I remember several quarters, maybe a year ago, your actual target in this period was a little bit lower. Should I just use that sort of as a bogey for the foreseeable future what you're currently reporting until conditions improve or do you have another recommendation?

Speaker 4

I would say it's hard to predict. A lot of what goes into our expense ratio has to do with fees and services that we pay for in producing all these orders. And those are expenses that are kind of upfront. And it takes a while for those to recover. We need the revenue for these orders to offset our expenses on these.

Speaker 4

And also we've continued while it's been slow to work through our technology and modernization. And so that does bring some pressure on our expense ratio.

Speaker 1

Okay. Thank you for the follow-up.

Speaker 2

Thanks, Mike.

Operator

And that concludes our Q and A session. I will now turn the conference back over to management for closing remarks.

Speaker 2

Okay. Well, thank you everyone for your interest and your time and participating with us. And we wish you all the best this fall and look forward to getting back together with you when we can report on our Q4 and the final 2024 figures. So again, thank you very much and have a great day.

Operator

And this concludes today's conference call. Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.

Powered by Quartr