NASDAQ:CRGO Freightos Q3 2024 Earnings Report $2.01 -0.20 (-9.00%) As of 04:00 PM Eastern This is a fair market value price provided by Polygon.io. Learn more. Earnings HistoryForecast Freightos EPS ResultsActual EPS-$0.06Consensus EPS -$0.22Beat/MissBeat by +$0.16One Year Ago EPSN/AFreightos Revenue ResultsActual RevenueN/AExpected RevenueN/ABeat/MissN/AYoY Revenue GrowthN/AFreightos Announcement DetailsQuarterQ3 2024Date11/25/2024TimeBefore Market OpensConference Call DateMonday, November 25, 2024Conference Call Time8:30AM ETUpcoming EarningsFreightos' Q1 2025 earnings is scheduled for Monday, May 19, 2025, with a conference call scheduled on Tuesday, May 20, 2025 at 8:30 AM ET. Check back for transcripts, audio, and key financial metrics as they become available.Conference Call ResourcesConference Call AudioConference Call TranscriptSlide DeckPress Release (8-K)Earnings HistoryCompany ProfileSlide DeckFull Screen Slide DeckPowered by Freightos Q3 2024 Earnings Call TranscriptProvided by QuartrNovember 25, 2024 ShareLink copied to clipboard.There are 5 speakers on the call. Operator00:00:00Hello, and welcome to Freitas Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call. A press release with detailed financial results was released earlier today and is available on the Investor Relations section of our website, frettus.com/investors. My name is Anati Ron Heilborn, and I'm joined today by Doctor. Zvi Schreiber, the CEO of Freitas and Ranjalev, CFO. Following the prepared remarks, we will open the call for questions. Operator00:00:27We are sharing slides during the call, so we recommend using Zoom on a computer rather than dialing in by phone. The slides, as well as a recording of this earnings call, will be available on our website shortly after the call. Please be aware that today's discussion contains forward looking statements, which are subject to a number of risks and uncertainties. Actual results may differ materially due to various risk factors. Please refer to today's press release and our SEC filings for more information on risk factors and other factors which could impact forward looking statements. Operator00:01:02Copies of these reports are available online. In discussing the results of our operations, we'll be providing and referring to certain non IFRS financial measures. You can find reconciliations to the most directly comparable IFRS financial measures along with additional information regarding those non IFRS financial measures in the press release on our website atfreitas.com/investors. The company undertakes no obligation to update any information discussed in this call at any time. Please note that in December, management will participate in AGP's Transportation and Electric Vehicles Virtual Conference and in January, in the Needham Growth Conference, also virtually. Operator00:01:44Participation in investor conferences and events may be updated from time to time, and upcoming events are listed on Freda's investor website. Today's earnings call will begin with an overview of Q3 performance by Zvi. Next, Ran will present the financial results and the guidance for Q4. We will conclude with Q and A. Questions can be submitted in writing during the call by using the Q and A feature in Zoom. Operator00:02:13Sveep, please go ahead. Speaker 100:02:17Good morning, and thanks for joining us to discuss Ruetas' Q3 2024 results. Before we start discussing the quarter, I wanted to mention that we just announced that Ran will be leaving Freitas at the end of this year to pursue another job opportunity. An active search is underway for a new CFO. Ran will remain engaged throughout Q1 to ensure a smooth handover. Ran has built a strong finance team that will keep everything working smoothly during the transition. Speaker 100:02:43We all thank Ran for his incredible contributions to the company over 8 years. This quarter reflects another step forward in Freitas' mission to drive digital transformation in global freight with record transaction volumes, growth in unique buyer users and the successful integration of our recent acquisition of the Shipstead tender procurement solution, strengthening our position in the market. Our performance this quarter highlights the industry's growing reliance on digital solutions to bring transparency, efficiency and resilience to global freight and Freitas remains at the forefront of the shift. Before diving into the results, let's briefly discuss how market conditions have influenced our performance this quarter. Air Cargo Rates and volumes in Q3 remained at similar levels to Q2 and elevated compared to Q3 last year. Speaker 100:03:29Global air cargo volumes increased 11% year on year and rates were 30% higher on China US routes and 17% higher on China EU routes, in part due to an accelerated international direct to consumer e commerce trend. Meanwhile, ocean rates remained elevated given the ongoing Red Sea crisis, although they have recently began to ease as the peak season of shipping for the holidays comes to an end. Against this backdrop, let's turn to see how Freitas has performed this quarter. In my comments this quarter, we'll focus on our progress across 3 areas: 1 is Platform 2, Solutions and 3, Network. Platform and Solutions are, of course, the two main ways we deliver our valuable products to our customers and these are also the segments in which we report revenue. Speaker 100:04:13Network effects are how we ensure continued long term capital efficient growth. Let's start by discussing our platform growth. Our most important platform KPI remains the number of transactions. This quarter, we achieved 339,000 transactions, a 26% increase compared to the same period last year and marking at least our 19th consecutive quarter of record transactions. As a reminder, transactions are digital bookings placed between a buyer of freight services and a logistics service provider, a carrier or freight forwarder on our platform. Speaker 100:04:45This consistent growth reflects the increasing adoption of Freightor's digital platform as an essential tool for global freight operations. We're a leader in digital, but digital is still only a small percentage of the total addressable market, so we expect to keep this consistent growth momentum going for many years to come. On the sell side of the Platform, in Q3 we reached 55 carriers. Among new airlines are Qantas, which adds transpacific capacity with both passenger planes and freighter services across key U. S. Speaker 100:05:14And Australian hubs. We also added Air India via their General Sales Agent or GSA Euro Cargo Aviation. Progress is ongoing with a couple of big carriers whose integration timelines were delayed earlier this year due to IT challenges on their side, as we discussed on our last call. Those carriers remain on track to contribute to transaction volumes in 2025. And despite those delays, the transaction volume exceeded guidance in Q3. Speaker 100:05:41On the buy side of the platform, we increased unique buyer users to 19,700 in Q3, an increase of 14% year over year. This increase in both sellers and buyers contributed to a 35% year over year growth in the gross booking value or GBV, which reached $217,500,000 for the quarter. Higher freight prices, driven by the ongoing Red Sea crisis and international e commerce, also supported the strong GBV performance. Freitas has continued to focus on expanding the scope of transactions by integrating additional services such as trucking to provide a seamless door to door freight experience. In Q3, our less than truckload or LTL offerings performed well enhancing 1st mile and last mile solutions and highlighting the value of our multimodal capabilities. Speaker 100:06:30We continue to expand our integration to 3rd party solution providers as well. Last week, we announced an integration with E2 Open. E2 Open, ticker symbol ETWO, is a large provider of supply chain software. This partnership embeds our air cargo pricing and booking directly into E2 Open's own transportation management system, or TMS, offering Freight Forwarders instant access to dynamic air freight rates and real time booking capabilities. This drives real customer value, as you can see from this quote from Megan Kelly, VP of Enterprise Solutions at a large freight forwarder customer, Crane Worldwide Logistics. Speaker 100:07:07Platform transactional revenue experienced strong growth in Q3, reflecting growth in each part of our platform: Webcargo, freighters.com and Clearit. Webcargo continued its rapid expansion with high transaction volumes of freight forwarders booking with airlines. Freighters.com is where importers and exporters book with service providers. And although we're not investing and growing it this year, it still had its best quarter in some time, contributing a higher take rate per transaction by serving small importers and exporters seeking efficient freight solutions. Clearit, our digital customs broker, also had a good quarter. Speaker 100:07:39Together, these platforms highlight Freitas' ability to capture value from digital bookings across diverse segments of the Freight ecosystem. The second pillar of Freitas' strategy is solutions. Here we focus on growing recurring subscription revenue through SaaS and Data Products. Our subscription based solutions empower freight forwarders and importers and exporters to improve operational efficiency and make data driven decisions through cutting edge digital tools. Solutions revenue in Q3 continued to grow steadily, supported by the integration of Shipstar, a leading procurement and tenant management platform, which we acquired in August. Speaker 100:08:15As a reminder, Shipstar's capability aligned closely with Freitas' mission to digitalize freight operations, enabling enterprise customers, primarily large shippers, to streamline complex procurement processes for long term freight contracts. We've started to introduce Shipsters' capabilities to Freitas' customer base, uncovering significant cross selling opportunities, further validating the strategic fit between the two solutions. Meanwhile, Shipster continued to grow its customer base in Q3, winning deals with a global leader in elevator and escalator manufacturing, a top 5 pharma company and a leading cosmetics brand. Sorry, I don't yet have permission to share the customer names. In addition to ships, Defreitas introduced other new features to improve our data offering, Freitas Terminal. Speaker 100:08:58This included broader rate benchmarking capabilities and experimenting with AI to automatically provide sophisticated, actionable insights for logistics decision making. Now, the 3rd pillar of Freitas' strategy focuses on network or network effects, in which every customer strengthens the value of our network for all the other customers. A great example is interlining, where airlines buy from airlines and therefore each new airline brings new value to other airlines on our network. Some big airline partners tell me that 15% of their bookings are interlining with other airlines. Just a few days ago, I visited a user who was the first to complete 1,000 interlining bookings. Speaker 100:09:37So we think that the interlining offering is finally set to really take off in 2025. Repeat usage amongst both freight forwarders and carriers remained high in Q3. Cohort analysis again proves that both freight forwarders and carriers who joined the platform not only stay but continue to grow their engagement over time. This growth is driven by expanding network coverage and new platform features. The ongoing growing engagement from both buyers and sellers proves the buyer brings seller brings buyer network effects that drives our growth. Speaker 100:10:13As an example of growing supply, over the 60 business days the last 60 business days in Q3, or the total 60 business days in Q3, we communicated over 50 launches and expansions of airline supply to our customers, ranging from expanded geographies to new services from existing airlines. In other words, new airline capacity was added to our network almost every day, even if there wasn't a brand new airline. On another note, during Q3, Freitas again hosted our very own annual Freightech Conference near Barcelona. It's exciting to see that Freitas can bring together leaders across the logistics industry to align on the industry vision and roadmap for digitalizing international freight. This event, of course, also fosters closer engagement with our customers at a top executive level. Speaker 100:10:59And now to provide more detail on our financial performance in Q3, I'll hand over to Ran. Speaker 200:11:06Thank you, Tzvi. Our 3rd quarter results surpassed expectations across all metrics. We exceeded our guidance for transaction and outperformed on gross booking value, driven by high transaction volumes and elevated market rates. Revenue grew at the fastest pace since going public, highlighting the adoption of our platform and the strength of our execution. Operational improvements and lower cost of goods sold also resulted in significant better than expected adjusted EBITDA, continuing the previous trend and keeping us on track to achieve positive adjusted EBITDA by the end of 2026 and to get there with cash at hand. Speaker 200:11:46Revenue for Q3 twenty 4 was $6,200,000 reflecting a 21% year over year increase, driven by strong performance across both transactional and subscription revenue. Platform revenue grew by 29% year over year to $2,300,000 with Web Cargo continuing to lead growth through high transaction volumes. Solutions revenue increased by 17% year over year to $3,900,000 supported by the steady expansion of SaaS offering and early contribution from the Shipstar integration. These results reflect the growing adoption of Freetos platform and our ability to scale effectively while meeting the diverse needs of our customers. Gross margins in Q3 again showed significant improvement with IFRS gross margins rising to 65%, compared to 54.9% in Q3 of 2023 and non IFRS gross margins reaching 72.7 percent, up from 69.5% last year. Speaker 200:12:53These gains reflect Freitas' focus on scaling efficiently while maintaining a disciplined approach to cost management. Adjusted EBITDA in Q3 2024 improved significantly to negative $2,800,000 outperforming our guidance range of negative $3,400,000 to 3,300,000 dollars and representing a $1,300,000 improvement year over year, compared to negative $4,100,000 in Q3 of 2023. This improvement was driven by a combination of revenue growth, improved gross margins and disciplined expense management. These results highlight the scalability of our platform and our ability to maintain cost efficiency as we grow. During the quarter, we paid approximately $3,400,000 in cash for the acquisition of ShipStar, as well as some shares, reflecting the acquisition consideration after closing adjustment but before holdbacks. Speaker 200:13:54Therefore, as of September 30, 2024, Freitas held $41,300,000 in cash and short term deposits, providing a solid foundation to continue execution on our growth strategy. This strong cash position gives us the confidence to achieve positive adjusted EBITDA by the end of 2026 without requiring additional funding. Our Q4 'twenty four guidance reflects continued strong momentum as we close out the year, with several metrics adjusted upwards. Transactions are now expected to range between $338,500,000 $348,500,000 This guidance is narrowing upwards compared to previous expectations and reflecting year over year growth of 18% to 21%. Gross booking value guidance has been increased to $257,000,000 to $265,000,000 representing year over year growth of 37% to 41%. Speaker 200:14:57Revenue guidance has been narrowed upwards to $6,400,000 to $6,500,000 indicating year over year growth of 21% to 24%. Finally, adjusted EBITDA guidance has been improved to a range of negative $3,200,000 to negative $3,100,000 reflecting further operational efficiencies and disciplined cost management. We are very pleased to be able to improve the guidance on adjusted EBITDA, despite the fact that we will be consolidating Shipstar for the full quarter for the first time, together with some hiring done to support the year to come. We are now finalizing budget planning and business planning for 2025, and we expect to continue to grow momentum of Q3 and Q4 throughout 2025. As Sveen mentioned, having built the Freetos financial operations to be a well oiled machine and ensuring that the company is on a strong growth path and fully funded to breakeven, I feel it is an appropriate time for me to leave and pursue a new opportunity. Speaker 200:16:01It's been a privilege to work with Zvi and the talented Freitas team, and I look forward to remaining a true supporter and shareholder of the company. With that, I'll turn it back to Zvi. Speaker 100:16:12Thanks, Ram. I want to take a moment to recognize Rand's contributions to Freitas. Since joining in 2016, Ran has been instrumental in shaping Freitas' financial operations, including our public listing on NASDAQ, strategic acquisitions and consistent growth. His leadership has left Freitas financially strong and well positioned for continued growth. Ran, thanks for your dedication and the impact you've had on Freitas' success. Speaker 100:16:36We wish you all the best in your next chapter. A search is underway for a replacement, and we have a strong finance team who will continue managing all operations during the transition. Rana is committed to be available and engaged as needed throughout Q1 as well. I'm excited to bring some fresh talent and new ideas onto the executive team. We're in the midst of 2025 planning and budgeting, and I can tell you that the team is very excited about the product roadmap and commercial initiatives we're planning for 2025, and we look forward to sharing those during upcoming investor calls. Speaker 100:17:09And now we'll be happy to take your questions. Operator00:17:14Okay. So for the Q and A session, please use the raise hand feature in Zoom. In the meantime, I will read a question that came in the chat. So I guess it goes to Ran. Why is EBITDA guidance down for Q4 over Q3 despite increased revenue? Speaker 200:17:35Yes. Thanks, Anat. So it drives mainly from 2 things. 1 is Ran, Operator00:17:41we can't hear you. Speaker 100:17:43I hear Ron. Speaker 200:17:45Can you hear me okay? Speaker 100:17:47Yeah, I hear you Ron. Speaker 200:17:50Okay, good. So I'll start from the beginning. So it mainly drives from 2 things. 1 is we are, for the first time we are consolidating ShipStar for the whole quarter. I may remind you that we closed the deal middle of August. Speaker 200:18:04So in Q3, we only consolidated them for half a quarter. This time, it's a full quarter. As you all know, they are still burning some cash and we are helping them, but they are supposed to be breaking even in 2025 and also giving us some free cash flow already in 2025. So the support that the Freytagos Group gives them for Q4, together with the fact that we are doing some staffing, some hiring to support the growth expected in 2025 in sales and marketing mainly. Those are the two elements that kind of slightly increases the EBITDA in Q4. Operator00:18:42Okay. Our next call will come from the line of Jason Helfstein. Just a minute. Speaker 300:18:58Thanks. Can you hear me okay? Operator00:19:00Yep. All good. Speaker 300:19:02Okay. So a few questions. First, just can you just give us some broad perspectives? Like, what what does the Trump administration in your mind mean for the industry? So kind of just broadly. Speaker 300:19:152nd, I know it's early, but if you have any initial thoughts about next year from a growth and a margin standpoint, obviously, you've given us the commentary on EBITDA. And then 3rd, specifically around the the guide, you know, basically, you're increasing this year's GBV by 8%. You're keeping revenue guidance unchanged. So just maybe talk about the dynamic there. Thank you. Speaker 100:19:47Thanks, Jason. Yeah. And I see on the chat that Mike asked the same as your first question about the Trump administration. So let me start with that. Look, of course, we don't know fully. Speaker 100:20:00I can say a few comments to put it in context. First of all, during the 1st Trump administration, there were a lot of tariffs imposed. At that time, they did not in any way reduce the trade with China or with anywhere else. So that was the experience in the first Trump administration. Of course, we don't know if the tariffs are a lot higher than perhaps this time, they will affect it. Speaker 100:20:22But you know, our experience last time was that there wasn't an effect. It wasn't a dampening of trade or freight. But the other thing to take into account is that we're as I mentioned in my remarks before, we're at an early stage of digitizing this industry. So although we're the leaders in digital, certainly for air cargo and Ocean's just getting started in a way, still 98% or something of the industry is offline. So we have huge growth room here. Speaker 100:20:52Now if international trade and international freight goes up a few percent like it usually does, then great. If it goes down a few percent, it doesn't really matter. You know, it doesn't make a material difference to our opportunity because there's just so much to digitalize, even if the industry trends down for a little bit. Having said that, you know, World Trade has been growing very strongly for decades. So I don't know if the Trump policies will dampen it somewhat, But I wouldn't bet against world trade in general, even if it goes down by a few percentage points for a while. Speaker 100:21:28Regarding your second question, so we're not putting out obviously we'll put our guidance for 2025 next quarter, but I can say that we're very excited about 2025. We hope and expect to grow faster in 2025 than we did this year. And in terms of EBITDA, you should see we've said that we expect to break even by the end of 2026. So you should see us in 2025 trending from where we are now towards the you know, roughly getting us halfway towards the 0. But that's very rough. Speaker 100:22:05We'll put out a specific guidance, in Q1 of in the Q1 call for the year. Jason, I'm sorry, I don't think I caught your third question. Could you repeat it? Speaker 300:22:16Stuart, yes. So you raised the full year gross bookings, I think it's by 8%, but you're not changing the guidance or the revenue guidance. So maybe just talk about the dynamic there? Speaker 100:22:29Yes. I mean, the reason is, Ron, tell me if you want to add anything to this, but I'll say that a lot of us, as you probably know, Jason, the GBV sort of went up, A, because transactions were performing strongly and B, because the prices in the market are a little higher than we expected. As I said earlier, that's partly due to the fact that the Suez Canal, believe it or not, has been virtually closed for more than a year and is still not functioning, plus some demand from e commerce like Temu and Shein taking up some capacity on air. So the rates are a bit higher, but a fair proportion of our transactional revenue of our platform revenue is in fact flat fees per transaction. So a lot of it is not actually tied to the price, some of it is. Speaker 100:23:17But that's why when prices in the market are higher than we expected, it only to a limited extent flows through to our platform revenue. Correct. Yes. Speaker 300:23:29Just maybe one quick follow-up. If the Canal was to reopen, like how do you think that impacts next year? Speaker 100:23:40Well, I think it would actually be good and that's good for us. I mean, it would definitely cause almost certainly would cause the Ocean prices to ease, to go down. So that would have a small negative effects. But there would also be some good positive effects. It could probably increase volumes in the industry to some extent, and it would free up some air cargo. Speaker 100:24:06We've actually, we've suffered a little bit that there's virtually no spot capacity in air cargo out of Asia as a sort of spillover from e commerce and from the Suez Canal. So, we'd be quite happy to see sort of the air cargo patterns normalizing a bit. So it would have a, you know, I think it would obviously be good for the world. But for us, it would have a mixed effect, probably a slight net positive, I would think. Speaker 300:24:32Appreciate it. Thank you. Speaker 100:24:34Sure. Operator00:24:36Okay. Thanks. The next question will come from Logan Lilhaug. Please unmute. Speaker 400:24:45Hey, good morning, guys. This is Logan on for George. So, yes, my first question is on Chipster. I'm just wondering if you can give us a little more information on kind of what the early takeaways are as you try to kind of go cross sell that with your existing customers. I'm just curious kind of what the response has been? Speaker 400:25:03And then the follow-up to that would be, I think you guys had said $800,000 was kind of the contribution you expected in the remainder of this year. Is that still a good number to use for Schibze? Speaker 100:25:16So the second question, I'll defer for Ran, and I don't know if we want to give an update on that because our plan because Shipster is rapidly being integrated into our Solutions segment. And so going forward, we're not planning to break out Shipster revenue because the products are already getting sort of tied together and sometimes we'll be doing more and more. I guess the answer to your first question is we'll be doing more and more joint deals. So it won't always make sense to break it out. So I'm not sure if we want to give an update on that specifically because it's becoming less and less relevant in a way. Speaker 100:25:46Overall but going back to your first question, overall, it's going well. I mean, it's only been we only closed it in August. So that's 3 months ago. And these are enterprise deals, so they take time. But already, Shipstead has closed several purchase orders on their own since we acquired them, which was good momentum. Speaker 100:26:06And we've already started several discussions of cross selling in both directions, both us talking to us introducing our product to their customers and vice versa. I say there, but it's, of course, us. It's all us now. So the cross selling, there's already some concrete cross selling opportunities. Given that these are enterprise deals, it will take some time to actually get purchase orders. Speaker 100:26:27But yes, so far, so good. So far, it's living up to our expectations, and the customers definitely understand the enterprise shippers, the big importers and exporters definitely understand the value of how these products complement each other. Speaker 400:26:44Okay, understood. And then just one other for me on the E2 Open integration last week. I'm just curious kind of what you think that maybe does to your pipeline of carriers. I know you've talked about it being delayed a little bit with some of the internal projects that they have going, but do you think it could speed up the pipeline, I guess, at all? Speaker 100:27:03Yes. So actually to make a distinction, so E2 Open is they have products for freight forwarders and for shippers, in other words, importers and exporters. And we partnered with them on that side. They won't help us as far as I know with airlines specifically. Airlines are going well. Speaker 100:27:21Like I said, we launched Qantas, which is a big partner. We've been launching new, you don't even see it. We don't even our press releases, but almost every day we add new countries or new products. So that's going fine. And even those big airlines that are delayed, it's happening. Speaker 100:27:37They just had some delays on their IT projects. So airlines is going very well. E2 Open is specifically they're a fairly big player in software for supply chain. And specifically some of the big freight forwarders that we work with, one which has publicly mentioned it is Crane, are using them. And so It's part of our strategy. Speaker 100:27:59We've done integrations into other leading software systems. We want to play nice with the ecosystem. Our customers want us want our Freitas product to work well with their suites of other products. And so, you know, it's part of an ongoing strategy, which I think we're doing well to make sure that our customers can use our software together with the other software that they have. Speaker 400:28:25Got it. Thank Speaker 100:28:27you. Thanks, Logan. Operator00:28:30Okay. That concludes the Q and A session. Thanks, everyone. Have a good week. Speaker 100:28:37Thanks.Read morePowered by Conference Call Audio Live Call not available Earnings Conference CallFreightos Q3 202400:00 / 00:00Speed:1x1.25x1.5x2x Earnings DocumentsSlide DeckPress Release(8-K) Freightos Earnings HeadlinesFreightos Schedules Earnings Release and Conference Call for May 20, 2025May 6 at 7:00 AM | prnewswire.comTrump tariffs trigger sharp drop in U.S. port and air-freight demand: FTApril 28, 2025 | msn.com3..2..1.. AI 2.0 ignition (don’t sleep on this)I just put together an urgent new presentation that you need to see right away. In short: I believe we are mere days away from a critical announcement from a key tech leader… One that will officially ignite “AI 2.0” – and potentially send a whole new class of stocks soaring. May 6, 2025 | Timothy Sykes (Ad)Freightos Unveils Enterprise Suite, Creating First End-to-End Global Freight Procurement PlatformApril 23, 2025 | prnewswire.comFreightos estimates 25% higher transactions in Q1April 15, 2025 | seekingalpha.comFreightos Reports Record Transactions for the First Quarter of 2025April 15, 2025 | prnewswire.comSee More Freightos Headlines Get Earnings Announcements in your inboxWant to stay updated on the latest earnings announcements and upcoming reports for companies like Freightos? Sign up for Earnings360's daily newsletter to receive timely earnings updates on Freightos and other key companies, straight to your email. Email Address About FreightosFreightos (NASDAQ:CRGO), together with its subsidiaries, operates a vendor-neutral booking and payment platform for international freight. It operates WebCargo, a platform for connecting carriers and forwarders; and Freightos.com, a platform for connecting service providers to importers/exporters. The company also offers software-as-a-service solutions, such as WebCargo Air for airline rates and ebookings; WebCargo AcceleRate, a multi-modal rate repository; data services; and WebCargo Airline Control Panel that enables airlines to control bookings and optimize pricing with real-time booking analytics. In addition, it provides digital customs brokerage services. The company is based in Jerusalem, Israel.View Freightos ProfileRead more More Earnings Resources from MarketBeat Earnings Tools Today's Earnings Tomorrow's Earnings Next Week's Earnings Upcoming Earnings Calls Earnings Newsletter Earnings Call Transcripts Earnings Beats & Misses Corporate Guidance Earnings Screener Earnings By Country U.S. Earnings Reports Canadian Earnings Reports U.K. Earnings Reports Latest Articles Palantir Stock Drops Despite Stellar Earnings: What's Next?Is Eli Lilly a Buy After Weak Earnings and CVS-Novo Partnership?Is Reddit Stock a Buy, Sell, or Hold After Earnings Release?Warning or Opportunity After Super Micro Computer's EarningsAmazon Earnings: 2 Reasons to Love It, 1 Reason to Be CautiousRocket Lab Braces for Q1 Earnings Amid Soaring ExpectationsMeta Takes A Bow With Q1 Earnings - Watch For Tariff Impact in Q2 Upcoming Earnings ARM (5/7/2025)AppLovin (5/7/2025)Fortinet (5/7/2025)MercadoLibre (5/7/2025)Cencora (5/7/2025)Carvana (5/7/2025)Walt Disney (5/7/2025)Emerson Electric (5/7/2025)Johnson Controls International (5/7/2025)Lloyds Banking Group (5/7/2025) Get 30 Days of MarketBeat All Access for Free Sign up for MarketBeat All Access to gain access to MarketBeat's full suite of research tools. Start Your 30-Day Trial MarketBeat All Access Features Best-in-Class Portfolio Monitoring Get personalized stock ideas. Compare portfolio to indices. Check stock news, ratings, SEC filings, and more. Stock Ideas and Recommendations See daily stock ideas from top analysts. Receive short-term trading ideas from MarketBeat. Identify trending stocks on social media. Advanced Stock Screeners and Research Tools Use our seven stock screeners to find suitable stocks. Stay informed with MarketBeat's real-time news. Export data to Excel for personal analysis. Sign in to your free account to enjoy these benefits In-depth profiles and analysis for 20,000 public companies. Real-time analyst ratings, insider transactions, earnings data, and more. Our daily ratings and market update email newsletter. Sign in to your free account to enjoy all that MarketBeat has to offer. Sign In Create Account Your Email Address: Email Address Required Your Password: Password Required Log In or Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google Forgot your password? Your Email Address: Please enter your email address. Please enter a valid email address Choose a Password: Please enter your password. Your password must be at least 8 characters long and contain at least 1 number, 1 letter, and 1 special character. Create My Account (Free) or Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google By creating a free account, you agree to our terms of service. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
There are 5 speakers on the call. Operator00:00:00Hello, and welcome to Freitas Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call. A press release with detailed financial results was released earlier today and is available on the Investor Relations section of our website, frettus.com/investors. My name is Anati Ron Heilborn, and I'm joined today by Doctor. Zvi Schreiber, the CEO of Freitas and Ranjalev, CFO. Following the prepared remarks, we will open the call for questions. Operator00:00:27We are sharing slides during the call, so we recommend using Zoom on a computer rather than dialing in by phone. The slides, as well as a recording of this earnings call, will be available on our website shortly after the call. Please be aware that today's discussion contains forward looking statements, which are subject to a number of risks and uncertainties. Actual results may differ materially due to various risk factors. Please refer to today's press release and our SEC filings for more information on risk factors and other factors which could impact forward looking statements. Operator00:01:02Copies of these reports are available online. In discussing the results of our operations, we'll be providing and referring to certain non IFRS financial measures. You can find reconciliations to the most directly comparable IFRS financial measures along with additional information regarding those non IFRS financial measures in the press release on our website atfreitas.com/investors. The company undertakes no obligation to update any information discussed in this call at any time. Please note that in December, management will participate in AGP's Transportation and Electric Vehicles Virtual Conference and in January, in the Needham Growth Conference, also virtually. Operator00:01:44Participation in investor conferences and events may be updated from time to time, and upcoming events are listed on Freda's investor website. Today's earnings call will begin with an overview of Q3 performance by Zvi. Next, Ran will present the financial results and the guidance for Q4. We will conclude with Q and A. Questions can be submitted in writing during the call by using the Q and A feature in Zoom. Operator00:02:13Sveep, please go ahead. Speaker 100:02:17Good morning, and thanks for joining us to discuss Ruetas' Q3 2024 results. Before we start discussing the quarter, I wanted to mention that we just announced that Ran will be leaving Freitas at the end of this year to pursue another job opportunity. An active search is underway for a new CFO. Ran will remain engaged throughout Q1 to ensure a smooth handover. Ran has built a strong finance team that will keep everything working smoothly during the transition. Speaker 100:02:43We all thank Ran for his incredible contributions to the company over 8 years. This quarter reflects another step forward in Freitas' mission to drive digital transformation in global freight with record transaction volumes, growth in unique buyer users and the successful integration of our recent acquisition of the Shipstead tender procurement solution, strengthening our position in the market. Our performance this quarter highlights the industry's growing reliance on digital solutions to bring transparency, efficiency and resilience to global freight and Freitas remains at the forefront of the shift. Before diving into the results, let's briefly discuss how market conditions have influenced our performance this quarter. Air Cargo Rates and volumes in Q3 remained at similar levels to Q2 and elevated compared to Q3 last year. Speaker 100:03:29Global air cargo volumes increased 11% year on year and rates were 30% higher on China US routes and 17% higher on China EU routes, in part due to an accelerated international direct to consumer e commerce trend. Meanwhile, ocean rates remained elevated given the ongoing Red Sea crisis, although they have recently began to ease as the peak season of shipping for the holidays comes to an end. Against this backdrop, let's turn to see how Freitas has performed this quarter. In my comments this quarter, we'll focus on our progress across 3 areas: 1 is Platform 2, Solutions and 3, Network. Platform and Solutions are, of course, the two main ways we deliver our valuable products to our customers and these are also the segments in which we report revenue. Speaker 100:04:13Network effects are how we ensure continued long term capital efficient growth. Let's start by discussing our platform growth. Our most important platform KPI remains the number of transactions. This quarter, we achieved 339,000 transactions, a 26% increase compared to the same period last year and marking at least our 19th consecutive quarter of record transactions. As a reminder, transactions are digital bookings placed between a buyer of freight services and a logistics service provider, a carrier or freight forwarder on our platform. Speaker 100:04:45This consistent growth reflects the increasing adoption of Freightor's digital platform as an essential tool for global freight operations. We're a leader in digital, but digital is still only a small percentage of the total addressable market, so we expect to keep this consistent growth momentum going for many years to come. On the sell side of the Platform, in Q3 we reached 55 carriers. Among new airlines are Qantas, which adds transpacific capacity with both passenger planes and freighter services across key U. S. Speaker 100:05:14And Australian hubs. We also added Air India via their General Sales Agent or GSA Euro Cargo Aviation. Progress is ongoing with a couple of big carriers whose integration timelines were delayed earlier this year due to IT challenges on their side, as we discussed on our last call. Those carriers remain on track to contribute to transaction volumes in 2025. And despite those delays, the transaction volume exceeded guidance in Q3. Speaker 100:05:41On the buy side of the platform, we increased unique buyer users to 19,700 in Q3, an increase of 14% year over year. This increase in both sellers and buyers contributed to a 35% year over year growth in the gross booking value or GBV, which reached $217,500,000 for the quarter. Higher freight prices, driven by the ongoing Red Sea crisis and international e commerce, also supported the strong GBV performance. Freitas has continued to focus on expanding the scope of transactions by integrating additional services such as trucking to provide a seamless door to door freight experience. In Q3, our less than truckload or LTL offerings performed well enhancing 1st mile and last mile solutions and highlighting the value of our multimodal capabilities. Speaker 100:06:30We continue to expand our integration to 3rd party solution providers as well. Last week, we announced an integration with E2 Open. E2 Open, ticker symbol ETWO, is a large provider of supply chain software. This partnership embeds our air cargo pricing and booking directly into E2 Open's own transportation management system, or TMS, offering Freight Forwarders instant access to dynamic air freight rates and real time booking capabilities. This drives real customer value, as you can see from this quote from Megan Kelly, VP of Enterprise Solutions at a large freight forwarder customer, Crane Worldwide Logistics. Speaker 100:07:07Platform transactional revenue experienced strong growth in Q3, reflecting growth in each part of our platform: Webcargo, freighters.com and Clearit. Webcargo continued its rapid expansion with high transaction volumes of freight forwarders booking with airlines. Freighters.com is where importers and exporters book with service providers. And although we're not investing and growing it this year, it still had its best quarter in some time, contributing a higher take rate per transaction by serving small importers and exporters seeking efficient freight solutions. Clearit, our digital customs broker, also had a good quarter. Speaker 100:07:39Together, these platforms highlight Freitas' ability to capture value from digital bookings across diverse segments of the Freight ecosystem. The second pillar of Freitas' strategy is solutions. Here we focus on growing recurring subscription revenue through SaaS and Data Products. Our subscription based solutions empower freight forwarders and importers and exporters to improve operational efficiency and make data driven decisions through cutting edge digital tools. Solutions revenue in Q3 continued to grow steadily, supported by the integration of Shipstar, a leading procurement and tenant management platform, which we acquired in August. Speaker 100:08:15As a reminder, Shipstar's capability aligned closely with Freitas' mission to digitalize freight operations, enabling enterprise customers, primarily large shippers, to streamline complex procurement processes for long term freight contracts. We've started to introduce Shipsters' capabilities to Freitas' customer base, uncovering significant cross selling opportunities, further validating the strategic fit between the two solutions. Meanwhile, Shipster continued to grow its customer base in Q3, winning deals with a global leader in elevator and escalator manufacturing, a top 5 pharma company and a leading cosmetics brand. Sorry, I don't yet have permission to share the customer names. In addition to ships, Defreitas introduced other new features to improve our data offering, Freitas Terminal. Speaker 100:08:58This included broader rate benchmarking capabilities and experimenting with AI to automatically provide sophisticated, actionable insights for logistics decision making. Now, the 3rd pillar of Freitas' strategy focuses on network or network effects, in which every customer strengthens the value of our network for all the other customers. A great example is interlining, where airlines buy from airlines and therefore each new airline brings new value to other airlines on our network. Some big airline partners tell me that 15% of their bookings are interlining with other airlines. Just a few days ago, I visited a user who was the first to complete 1,000 interlining bookings. Speaker 100:09:37So we think that the interlining offering is finally set to really take off in 2025. Repeat usage amongst both freight forwarders and carriers remained high in Q3. Cohort analysis again proves that both freight forwarders and carriers who joined the platform not only stay but continue to grow their engagement over time. This growth is driven by expanding network coverage and new platform features. The ongoing growing engagement from both buyers and sellers proves the buyer brings seller brings buyer network effects that drives our growth. Speaker 100:10:13As an example of growing supply, over the 60 business days the last 60 business days in Q3, or the total 60 business days in Q3, we communicated over 50 launches and expansions of airline supply to our customers, ranging from expanded geographies to new services from existing airlines. In other words, new airline capacity was added to our network almost every day, even if there wasn't a brand new airline. On another note, during Q3, Freitas again hosted our very own annual Freightech Conference near Barcelona. It's exciting to see that Freitas can bring together leaders across the logistics industry to align on the industry vision and roadmap for digitalizing international freight. This event, of course, also fosters closer engagement with our customers at a top executive level. Speaker 100:10:59And now to provide more detail on our financial performance in Q3, I'll hand over to Ran. Speaker 200:11:06Thank you, Tzvi. Our 3rd quarter results surpassed expectations across all metrics. We exceeded our guidance for transaction and outperformed on gross booking value, driven by high transaction volumes and elevated market rates. Revenue grew at the fastest pace since going public, highlighting the adoption of our platform and the strength of our execution. Operational improvements and lower cost of goods sold also resulted in significant better than expected adjusted EBITDA, continuing the previous trend and keeping us on track to achieve positive adjusted EBITDA by the end of 2026 and to get there with cash at hand. Speaker 200:11:46Revenue for Q3 twenty 4 was $6,200,000 reflecting a 21% year over year increase, driven by strong performance across both transactional and subscription revenue. Platform revenue grew by 29% year over year to $2,300,000 with Web Cargo continuing to lead growth through high transaction volumes. Solutions revenue increased by 17% year over year to $3,900,000 supported by the steady expansion of SaaS offering and early contribution from the Shipstar integration. These results reflect the growing adoption of Freetos platform and our ability to scale effectively while meeting the diverse needs of our customers. Gross margins in Q3 again showed significant improvement with IFRS gross margins rising to 65%, compared to 54.9% in Q3 of 2023 and non IFRS gross margins reaching 72.7 percent, up from 69.5% last year. Speaker 200:12:53These gains reflect Freitas' focus on scaling efficiently while maintaining a disciplined approach to cost management. Adjusted EBITDA in Q3 2024 improved significantly to negative $2,800,000 outperforming our guidance range of negative $3,400,000 to 3,300,000 dollars and representing a $1,300,000 improvement year over year, compared to negative $4,100,000 in Q3 of 2023. This improvement was driven by a combination of revenue growth, improved gross margins and disciplined expense management. These results highlight the scalability of our platform and our ability to maintain cost efficiency as we grow. During the quarter, we paid approximately $3,400,000 in cash for the acquisition of ShipStar, as well as some shares, reflecting the acquisition consideration after closing adjustment but before holdbacks. Speaker 200:13:54Therefore, as of September 30, 2024, Freitas held $41,300,000 in cash and short term deposits, providing a solid foundation to continue execution on our growth strategy. This strong cash position gives us the confidence to achieve positive adjusted EBITDA by the end of 2026 without requiring additional funding. Our Q4 'twenty four guidance reflects continued strong momentum as we close out the year, with several metrics adjusted upwards. Transactions are now expected to range between $338,500,000 $348,500,000 This guidance is narrowing upwards compared to previous expectations and reflecting year over year growth of 18% to 21%. Gross booking value guidance has been increased to $257,000,000 to $265,000,000 representing year over year growth of 37% to 41%. Speaker 200:14:57Revenue guidance has been narrowed upwards to $6,400,000 to $6,500,000 indicating year over year growth of 21% to 24%. Finally, adjusted EBITDA guidance has been improved to a range of negative $3,200,000 to negative $3,100,000 reflecting further operational efficiencies and disciplined cost management. We are very pleased to be able to improve the guidance on adjusted EBITDA, despite the fact that we will be consolidating Shipstar for the full quarter for the first time, together with some hiring done to support the year to come. We are now finalizing budget planning and business planning for 2025, and we expect to continue to grow momentum of Q3 and Q4 throughout 2025. As Sveen mentioned, having built the Freetos financial operations to be a well oiled machine and ensuring that the company is on a strong growth path and fully funded to breakeven, I feel it is an appropriate time for me to leave and pursue a new opportunity. Speaker 200:16:01It's been a privilege to work with Zvi and the talented Freitas team, and I look forward to remaining a true supporter and shareholder of the company. With that, I'll turn it back to Zvi. Speaker 100:16:12Thanks, Ram. I want to take a moment to recognize Rand's contributions to Freitas. Since joining in 2016, Ran has been instrumental in shaping Freitas' financial operations, including our public listing on NASDAQ, strategic acquisitions and consistent growth. His leadership has left Freitas financially strong and well positioned for continued growth. Ran, thanks for your dedication and the impact you've had on Freitas' success. Speaker 100:16:36We wish you all the best in your next chapter. A search is underway for a replacement, and we have a strong finance team who will continue managing all operations during the transition. Rana is committed to be available and engaged as needed throughout Q1 as well. I'm excited to bring some fresh talent and new ideas onto the executive team. We're in the midst of 2025 planning and budgeting, and I can tell you that the team is very excited about the product roadmap and commercial initiatives we're planning for 2025, and we look forward to sharing those during upcoming investor calls. Speaker 100:17:09And now we'll be happy to take your questions. Operator00:17:14Okay. So for the Q and A session, please use the raise hand feature in Zoom. In the meantime, I will read a question that came in the chat. So I guess it goes to Ran. Why is EBITDA guidance down for Q4 over Q3 despite increased revenue? Speaker 200:17:35Yes. Thanks, Anat. So it drives mainly from 2 things. 1 is Ran, Operator00:17:41we can't hear you. Speaker 100:17:43I hear Ron. Speaker 200:17:45Can you hear me okay? Speaker 100:17:47Yeah, I hear you Ron. Speaker 200:17:50Okay, good. So I'll start from the beginning. So it mainly drives from 2 things. 1 is we are, for the first time we are consolidating ShipStar for the whole quarter. I may remind you that we closed the deal middle of August. Speaker 200:18:04So in Q3, we only consolidated them for half a quarter. This time, it's a full quarter. As you all know, they are still burning some cash and we are helping them, but they are supposed to be breaking even in 2025 and also giving us some free cash flow already in 2025. So the support that the Freytagos Group gives them for Q4, together with the fact that we are doing some staffing, some hiring to support the growth expected in 2025 in sales and marketing mainly. Those are the two elements that kind of slightly increases the EBITDA in Q4. Operator00:18:42Okay. Our next call will come from the line of Jason Helfstein. Just a minute. Speaker 300:18:58Thanks. Can you hear me okay? Operator00:19:00Yep. All good. Speaker 300:19:02Okay. So a few questions. First, just can you just give us some broad perspectives? Like, what what does the Trump administration in your mind mean for the industry? So kind of just broadly. Speaker 300:19:152nd, I know it's early, but if you have any initial thoughts about next year from a growth and a margin standpoint, obviously, you've given us the commentary on EBITDA. And then 3rd, specifically around the the guide, you know, basically, you're increasing this year's GBV by 8%. You're keeping revenue guidance unchanged. So just maybe talk about the dynamic there. Thank you. Speaker 100:19:47Thanks, Jason. Yeah. And I see on the chat that Mike asked the same as your first question about the Trump administration. So let me start with that. Look, of course, we don't know fully. Speaker 100:20:00I can say a few comments to put it in context. First of all, during the 1st Trump administration, there were a lot of tariffs imposed. At that time, they did not in any way reduce the trade with China or with anywhere else. So that was the experience in the first Trump administration. Of course, we don't know if the tariffs are a lot higher than perhaps this time, they will affect it. Speaker 100:20:22But you know, our experience last time was that there wasn't an effect. It wasn't a dampening of trade or freight. But the other thing to take into account is that we're as I mentioned in my remarks before, we're at an early stage of digitizing this industry. So although we're the leaders in digital, certainly for air cargo and Ocean's just getting started in a way, still 98% or something of the industry is offline. So we have huge growth room here. Speaker 100:20:52Now if international trade and international freight goes up a few percent like it usually does, then great. If it goes down a few percent, it doesn't really matter. You know, it doesn't make a material difference to our opportunity because there's just so much to digitalize, even if the industry trends down for a little bit. Having said that, you know, World Trade has been growing very strongly for decades. So I don't know if the Trump policies will dampen it somewhat, But I wouldn't bet against world trade in general, even if it goes down by a few percentage points for a while. Speaker 100:21:28Regarding your second question, so we're not putting out obviously we'll put our guidance for 2025 next quarter, but I can say that we're very excited about 2025. We hope and expect to grow faster in 2025 than we did this year. And in terms of EBITDA, you should see we've said that we expect to break even by the end of 2026. So you should see us in 2025 trending from where we are now towards the you know, roughly getting us halfway towards the 0. But that's very rough. Speaker 100:22:05We'll put out a specific guidance, in Q1 of in the Q1 call for the year. Jason, I'm sorry, I don't think I caught your third question. Could you repeat it? Speaker 300:22:16Stuart, yes. So you raised the full year gross bookings, I think it's by 8%, but you're not changing the guidance or the revenue guidance. So maybe just talk about the dynamic there? Speaker 100:22:29Yes. I mean, the reason is, Ron, tell me if you want to add anything to this, but I'll say that a lot of us, as you probably know, Jason, the GBV sort of went up, A, because transactions were performing strongly and B, because the prices in the market are a little higher than we expected. As I said earlier, that's partly due to the fact that the Suez Canal, believe it or not, has been virtually closed for more than a year and is still not functioning, plus some demand from e commerce like Temu and Shein taking up some capacity on air. So the rates are a bit higher, but a fair proportion of our transactional revenue of our platform revenue is in fact flat fees per transaction. So a lot of it is not actually tied to the price, some of it is. Speaker 100:23:17But that's why when prices in the market are higher than we expected, it only to a limited extent flows through to our platform revenue. Correct. Yes. Speaker 300:23:29Just maybe one quick follow-up. If the Canal was to reopen, like how do you think that impacts next year? Speaker 100:23:40Well, I think it would actually be good and that's good for us. I mean, it would definitely cause almost certainly would cause the Ocean prices to ease, to go down. So that would have a small negative effects. But there would also be some good positive effects. It could probably increase volumes in the industry to some extent, and it would free up some air cargo. Speaker 100:24:06We've actually, we've suffered a little bit that there's virtually no spot capacity in air cargo out of Asia as a sort of spillover from e commerce and from the Suez Canal. So, we'd be quite happy to see sort of the air cargo patterns normalizing a bit. So it would have a, you know, I think it would obviously be good for the world. But for us, it would have a mixed effect, probably a slight net positive, I would think. Speaker 300:24:32Appreciate it. Thank you. Speaker 100:24:34Sure. Operator00:24:36Okay. Thanks. The next question will come from Logan Lilhaug. Please unmute. Speaker 400:24:45Hey, good morning, guys. This is Logan on for George. So, yes, my first question is on Chipster. I'm just wondering if you can give us a little more information on kind of what the early takeaways are as you try to kind of go cross sell that with your existing customers. I'm just curious kind of what the response has been? Speaker 400:25:03And then the follow-up to that would be, I think you guys had said $800,000 was kind of the contribution you expected in the remainder of this year. Is that still a good number to use for Schibze? Speaker 100:25:16So the second question, I'll defer for Ran, and I don't know if we want to give an update on that because our plan because Shipster is rapidly being integrated into our Solutions segment. And so going forward, we're not planning to break out Shipster revenue because the products are already getting sort of tied together and sometimes we'll be doing more and more. I guess the answer to your first question is we'll be doing more and more joint deals. So it won't always make sense to break it out. So I'm not sure if we want to give an update on that specifically because it's becoming less and less relevant in a way. Speaker 100:25:46Overall but going back to your first question, overall, it's going well. I mean, it's only been we only closed it in August. So that's 3 months ago. And these are enterprise deals, so they take time. But already, Shipstead has closed several purchase orders on their own since we acquired them, which was good momentum. Speaker 100:26:06And we've already started several discussions of cross selling in both directions, both us talking to us introducing our product to their customers and vice versa. I say there, but it's, of course, us. It's all us now. So the cross selling, there's already some concrete cross selling opportunities. Given that these are enterprise deals, it will take some time to actually get purchase orders. Speaker 100:26:27But yes, so far, so good. So far, it's living up to our expectations, and the customers definitely understand the enterprise shippers, the big importers and exporters definitely understand the value of how these products complement each other. Speaker 400:26:44Okay, understood. And then just one other for me on the E2 Open integration last week. I'm just curious kind of what you think that maybe does to your pipeline of carriers. I know you've talked about it being delayed a little bit with some of the internal projects that they have going, but do you think it could speed up the pipeline, I guess, at all? Speaker 100:27:03Yes. So actually to make a distinction, so E2 Open is they have products for freight forwarders and for shippers, in other words, importers and exporters. And we partnered with them on that side. They won't help us as far as I know with airlines specifically. Airlines are going well. Speaker 100:27:21Like I said, we launched Qantas, which is a big partner. We've been launching new, you don't even see it. We don't even our press releases, but almost every day we add new countries or new products. So that's going fine. And even those big airlines that are delayed, it's happening. Speaker 100:27:37They just had some delays on their IT projects. So airlines is going very well. E2 Open is specifically they're a fairly big player in software for supply chain. And specifically some of the big freight forwarders that we work with, one which has publicly mentioned it is Crane, are using them. And so It's part of our strategy. Speaker 100:27:59We've done integrations into other leading software systems. We want to play nice with the ecosystem. Our customers want us want our Freitas product to work well with their suites of other products. And so, you know, it's part of an ongoing strategy, which I think we're doing well to make sure that our customers can use our software together with the other software that they have. Speaker 400:28:25Got it. Thank Speaker 100:28:27you. Thanks, Logan. Operator00:28:30Okay. That concludes the Q and A session. Thanks, everyone. Have a good week. Speaker 100:28:37Thanks.Read morePowered by