TMC the metals Q4 2023 Earnings Call Transcript

Quartr
Provided by Quartr
March 25, 2024

Key Takeaways

  • The company agreed a $20 million unsecured credit facility with ARRIS Capital and extended AllSeas’s facility, boosting pro forma liquidity to $61 million.
  • The start of commercial production at Nori D shifted from Q4 2025 to end of Q1 2026 to accommodate system upgrades.
  • Production capacity per vessel increased over 130%, from 1.3 million to 3 million wet tons annually.
  • The team derived the first-ever nickel sulfate from seafloor nodules, confirming suitability for battery markets with a potentially lower carbon footprint.
  • Preliminary environmental results show individual benthic organisms alive one year post-test and over 90% of the sediment plume contained within 2 meters of the seafloor.
AI Generated. May Contain Errors.
Earnings Conference Call
TMC the metals Q4 2023
00:00 / 00:00

There are 6 speakers on the call.

Operator

Good afternoon, everyone, and thank you for participating in The Meadows Company's 4th Quarter and Full Year 2023 Corporate Update Conference Call. Joining us today are The Meadows Company's Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Gerard Baron and Chief Financial Officer, Craig Shezke. Following their remarks, we'll open the call for your questions. Before we go further, I would like to turn the call over to CFO, Craig Shezke, as he reads the company's Safe Harbor statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 that provides important cautions regarding forward looking statements and information about the use of non GAAP measures. Craig, please go ahead.

Speaker 1

Thank you very much. Please note that during the call, certain statements may be made, which will be forward looking and based on management's beliefs and assumptions from information available at this time. These statements are subject to known and unknown risks and uncertainties, many of which may be beyond our control. Additionally, please note that the company's actual results may differ materially from those anticipated, and except as required by law, we undertake no obligation to update any forward looking statement. Our remarks today may also include non GAAP financial measures, including with respect to free cash flows and additional details regarding these non GAAP financial measures, including reconciliations to the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures can be found in our slide deck being used with this call.

Speaker 1

And you're welcome to follow along with our slide deck. Or if joining by phone, you can access it anytime at investors. Metals.co. I'll now turn the call over to our Chairman and CEO, Jared Barron. Jared, please go ahead.

Speaker 2

Thanks, Craig, and thanks to all of you for joining us today for our Q4 2023 corporate update call. Firstly, I'd like to mention the great piece that ran last night on 60 Minutes regarding seafloor nodules and the United States' position on the lure of the sea and reflect a bit on just how far we've come. Just over 4 years ago, we hosted Bill Whitaker and the 60 Minutes team onboard the launch of vessel to provide what was for many people their first glimpse of this impending new industry. In fact, some of our team members and key investors have cited that piece as what originally put nodules and our company on their radar. And I'm amazed at just how much our team has accomplished in the 4 years since that original piece.

Speaker 2

In 2021, in advance of our transaction to go public, we put out 2 SEC compliant resource statements and an initial assessment on the Nori D contract area signed off by AMC Consultants, noting a net present value at the time of $6,800,000,000 In 2022, we completed the 1st successful integrated pilot system test in the CCZ since the 1970s, lifting 3,000 wet tons of nodules and helping to de risk our future offshore operations alongside our partner AllSeas in late 2021. And we completed our pyrometallurgical processing pilot de risking our flow sheet in advance of future onshore operations. We've also now signed a binding MOU with Pamco in Japan to initially process nodules at their existing RKEF facility. And we're also pleased to announce today that we successfully derived the first ever nickel sulfate from seafloor nodules, but more on that in a bit. And finally, we wrapped up the last of our 22 preproduction offshore campaigns, including the completion in late February of our environmental campaign 1 year following our pilot collection test.

Speaker 2

And our team is very encouraged by the initial results. So last night, Bill Whitaker and his 60 Minutes team revisited their original story, focusing on recent actions by U. S. Political and military and intelligence communities to catch up to China in this space. At the same time, the rest of the media seems to have caught up with the importance of this topic, which major new pieces just this month from the Wall Street Journal and the Financial Times, BBC, Politico and many, many others.

Speaker 2

The takeaway to me is clear. At last, the time is now for this resource and as the most advanced contractor with a multiyear head start, TMC is well positioned to leverage this increasingly favorable geopolitical landscape. Moving on to our current liquidity picture. I'm pleased to announce that along with ARRIS Capital, the family office of our Director and largest shareholder, Andre Karkar, we have today agreed to provide a $20,000,000 unsecured credit facility with a maturity date in 18 months. And the interest rate on this unsecured facility in the 6 month is the 6 month secured overnight funding rate plus 4%.

Speaker 2

Further, our partner AllSeas has also agreed to extend their existing credit facility for a further period until August 2025. The ATM program, the extended AllSeas unsecured credit facility and the new facility credit facility provided by Eris and myself all remain untapped today. And with existing cash at year end plus the $9,000,000 in additional registered direct offering funds from ARRIS Capital received in January. Pro form a year ending liquidity is $61,000,000 As we have said previously, our preferred form of financing moving forward will be at the asset level, And we are making good progress with a number of parties there. You can certainly expect to hear more about this very soon.

Speaker 2

And we've seen an uptick this year in both number and quality of inbound financing offers from institutions, including underwritten equity transactions and convertible note offers. But even with a rising share price, we'd much rather fund the project through other less diluted means as evidenced by today's credit facility announcements. And so this now means that TMC has sources of unsecured funding from each of its 3 largest shareholders. So believe us when we say we care deeply about minimizing dilution. And I hope this action speaks to our confidence in where things are headed with respect to potential strategic partners.

Speaker 2

The next slide provides an overview of our Q4 results and recent business developments since our last quarterly update. I won't read all of this detail to you, but I did want to flag an update to our expected first commercial production on nori D. We now expect to commence production offshore at the end of the Q1 2026 assuming an ISA review process of approximately 1 year from the submission of our application for an exploitation contract, which is still expected following the July 20 24 ISA session. Alongside our partner, Altice, we've refined our assumptions to hit the ground running with a larger potential production system on the Hidden Gem vessel, upgraded from the initial target of 1,300,000 tons annually to the new maximum annual production capacity of 3,000,000 wet tons, an increase of 130%. And this also reflects some revisions to the ISA application review timeline in the latest consolidated draft text released.

Speaker 2

We never like any delays to our production timelines, but we want to make sure that we get everything right the first time and avoid a situation where production has to slow down for further modifications after we've begun. A brief reminder of TMC's value proposition, a review of a brief reminder of TMC's value proposition, a review of some important industry headlines and an update on the progress of our Nori D project, a snapshot of the environmental case for TMC and nodule collection more broadly, a regulatory update on this month's ISA meeting, and finally, our financial update. But let's start at first principles. Why look to the seafloor nodules in the first place? Well, for starters, the abyssal plain represents an area of the planet with the least life, the lowest biomass per square meter, second only to polar ice.

Speaker 2

And the world has woken up to the fact that we need to shift away from fossil fuels and the current challenges of sourcing metals from the land are gaining increased attention. Nodules offer real tangible advantages over their terrestrial equivalents and containing high grades of 4 metals in 1 ore. Sourcing battery metals from nodules requires no digging or blasting and produces near 0 solid waste. And far offshore, we also don't have to displace human communities nor build the costly fixed infrastructure necessary to access mineral resources on land. And when you put all that together, it is clear that nodules hold significant potential to dramatically reduce the human and planetary costs of sourcing metals.

Speaker 2

And this resource is also remarkable for the direct correlation between its mineral composition and that of electric vehicle battery cathodes and wiring. Rich in nickel, copper, cobalt and manganese, these nodules closely fit the requirements for the majority the EV battery cathodes being sold today. And new chemistries are in development, though these can take decades to commercialize, if ever. And based on our conversation with major OEMs, many new batteries are expected to continue relying upon nickel rich chemistries. Of course, we cannot forget the additional demand pressures for the metals contained in nodules including infrastructure, the ongoing industrialization of the developing world and the addition of 2,000,000,000 people to the planet.

Speaker 2

As we've said many times before, our resource is an outlier among the world's nickel projects, not only Nori and Tomal ranked by mining.com as the largest 2 undeveloped nickel projects in the world, but the nickel equivalent grade of this resource truly stands apart. The nickel market has been reeling over the last year due to an influx of lower cost supply from underneath Indonesian rainforest. BHP estimated recently that 50% of the nickel cost curve was loss making at current nickel prices on an all in sustaining cost basis. So with a nickel equivalent grade of over 3% and 4 key metals in one resource, TMC is able to withstand commodity price volatility better than most and provide an economically viable counterweight to the portion of nickel market controlled and funded by China or Russia. It's fair to say that the eyes of the world are watching this new industry with major media outlets leading think tanks acknowledging that commercial operations will soon be a reality.

Speaker 2

And in a new analysis by the influential Breakthrough Institute, Oceanographer and Co Director of Climate and Energy, Siva Wang, found that sourcing key metals like nickel and copper from nodules could deliver far lower impacts than sourcing them on land despite much exaggerated claims to the contrary. And in a recent interview with CNBC, ISA Secretary General, Michael Lodge noted that growing interest in marine minerals by countries like China, India and Norway means that commercial operations now appear inevitable. This lines up with the takeaway last year from the New York Times reporter Eric Lipton that started this industry is a question of when rather than if and when is coming even sooner. So the nodule resource is also gaining support in Washington D. C.

Speaker 2

Over the last 2 years, congressional members have made repeated calls to action to the Defense and Energy Departments to begin planning for the development of processing and refining capabilities for deep sea nodules. Most recently with the introduction of the responsible use of Seafloor Resources Act. And with the signing into law of the National Defense Authorization Act by President Biden, the Pentagon has now been tasked with formulating a report assessing just how the U. S. Might process nodules domestically, but more on that shortly.

Speaker 2

Increasingly, policymakers and the broader political community are driving the conversation. As reported in The Wall Street Journal this month, a bill aimed at providing support for domestic nodule collection, processing and refining has been introduced by members of the House of Representatives with support from a broad coalition of leaders drawn from the offshore energy industry, marine mineral exploration and global research centers. Also this month, over 350 former political and military leaders, including former Secretaries of State and Defense, Hillary Clinton, Leon Panetta, urge the U. S. Senate to ratify the Law of the Sea Treaty and take its seat at the table on ocean matters.

Speaker 2

Of course, this recent spate of news has taken place within the context of the pending delivery of a report by the Pentagon to the House Armed Services Committee assessing the opportunities offered by nodules to diversify critical mineral supply chains away from China. So at a minimum, the report will outline controlling parties of deep sea resources, America's current production and processing capabilities and crucially, a roadmap laying out recommendations for how the U. S. Can leverage its domestic industrial expertise and capabilities to process nodules and play a leading role in the industry. Though the March 1 deadline was ambitious, our conversations with relevant parties in the DoD and Congress give us confidence that the team readying the report are well aware of the challenges of metal supply and the opportunities that nodules present.

Speaker 2

And we remain optimistic about the prospect of funding to do feasibility work on a potential U. S. Refinery, which can take nodule derived products as feedstock, whether through our existing DoD grant application or through congressional appropriations. This underscores the massive longer term potential that we represent for the United States, which could go from near total import dependence for nickel, cobalt and manganese to metal independence in all three, just from our contract areas alone. However, this does not change our capital light plan to begin production at existing RKF facilities such as PAMCO in Japan.

Speaker 2

And I'd now like to turn it over to Craig to discuss the progress of our NoriD project.

Speaker 1

Thanks, Jared. Speaking of PAMCO, we were pleased to announce in November of last year that we signed a binding MOU with PAMCO to process the first nodules when commercial production operations are expected to begin in 2026. PAMCO is planning a commercial size pilot in the Q2 of 2024 and 2,000 tons of nodules that we collected during Nori's mining test will be processed through PAMCO's existing RKF plant. We're also pleased to announce that we've demonstrated we can turn nodules into nickel sulfate, indicative of battery excuse me, there's been a bit of a change in the slide deck. There we go.

Speaker 1

We're also pleased to announce that we've demonstrated we can turn nodules into nickel sulfate indicative of battery market suitability pending the confirmation of the preliminary assays. The sulfate was produced in a program testing our efficient flow sheet design that processes intermediate nickel mat direct to nickel sulfate without making nickel metal and produces fertilizer byproducts instead of waste. And for nickel sulfate, we'd just like to quickly remind everyone what a game changer that is to potentially produce nickel sulfate at a much smaller carbon footprint than all other nickel flow sheets analyzed in last year's benchmark lifecycle assessment. As noted on our last call, we're devoting a majority of our resources to our environmental impact statement and pre feasibility work, And we'll start with the pre feasibility work. For the offshore segment of the PFS together with AllSeas, we've gone through several mine planning iterations and design reviews of the Project 0 nodule collection and transport system.

Speaker 1

For the onshore segment of the PFS, we've made great progress in Japan where PAMCO has done considerable work and has validated that seafloor nodules can be tolled through their current facility, producing intermediate products that align with our specifications. The expected buying agreements with AllSeas and TAMCO will be key inputs for the PFS modeling work, including CapEx and OpEx estimates for Project 0 expected to be coming later this year. Over the past 12 years, we have conducted 22 offshore campaigns to develop an environmental baseline throughout the water column, to trial our pilot collection system and evaluate the impacts of test mining. The breadth and the scale of this research program is unprecedented in the deep ocean and it will provide the regulator and society with the data needed to make informed decisions. And with our latest offshore campaigns now complete, we now have a far greater understanding of what the actual impacts of nodule collection look like as opposed to some of the previous conjecture, which frankly has no basis in any observed data.

Speaker 1

We can tell you it's a radically different picture and more on this shortly. With the data collection and compilation phase for pre commercial operations now complete, our team is working tirelessly on the development of our environmental impact statement that will form the backbone of our application for an exploitation contract. The EIS is the most work intensive element of our application along with our environmental mitigation and monitoring program. And it requires the publication of peer reviewed research papers based upon the hundreds of terabytes of gathered data before, during and after pilot test collection. These papers are in preparation and we look forward to sharing our findings in peer reviewed journals in the coming months to support our application to the ISA.

Speaker 1

Last year's collector system test again provided or excuse me, 2022's collection system test provided a historic moment in the development of this industry. And just beyond the over 3,000 tons of nodules collected and lifted in the surface, one of the most important outcomes of the test was the ability to observe real time impacts and generate those 100 terabytes of infield data. And this accumulation of baseline data over the past decade plus represents the most comprehensive deep sea data set ever collected in the Clarion Clipperton zone. Collected in partnership with many of the world's leading marine institutions and expert industry contractors, many of which are named on this page. The data set is generating much excitement among researchers who have acknowledged the rigor and scale of this science program.

Speaker 1

The data is also openly shared to public databases, including the ISA's deep data library of contractor data, as well as other open source databases like UNESCO's Ocean Biodiversity Information System, the world's largest catalog of marine organisms. Zooming in on our post collection test environmental campaign, our own Katie Allen will lay out some of the key tenets of the research performed late last year. We'd now like to play this video please.

Speaker 3

Last year, we spent 6 months at sea implementing an extensive environmental and geotechnical monitoring program. The program was designed to understand the impacts of collecting nodules from the sea floor using our fully integrated test mining system. The scientific information collected last year gave us insight into the immediate impact on the environment, but now we'd like to know how the environment has responded to that impact 1 year on. We'll be studying various zones of influence where sediment has settled out from our mining activities with a specific focus on understanding the limit of impact on the benthic communities in the region. We're looking for any signs of recovery to the ecosystem and if community structure and ecological function has adapted or changed since our test mining activities last year.

Speaker 3

We'll be deploying box core and multi core instruments to collect sediment and nodule samples from the seabed, and these samples will be analyzed for specific biological, geochemical and geological properties. We also have a remotely operated vehicle equipped with specialised cameras to observe sessile megafauna. Now these animals attach themselves to nodules and other hard substrates, so our intention is to revisit known locations of sponges and corals that were imaged and photographed last year and to assess their condition after being exposed to the different levels of sedimentation. The ROV will also assist in the deployment and placement of our aquatic eddy covariance landers. Now these landers will be strategically placed across our study site to measure oxygen fluxes on the sea floor and to contribute to our understanding of oxygen exchange rates of the benthic animals in the ecosystem.

Speaker 3

Whilst these activities are underway, a bio acoustic drifting array will be measuring acoustic signals in the water column from a 1000 to 2000 meters water depth. So this instrument will drift around the study area throughout the campaign and tell us about the daily vertical migration cycles of biomass at these specific depths. We also have moorings with a string of different instruments to measure currents, temperature, salinity, sedimentation rates, noise, and various other physical parameters in the water column. These will collect an additional year's worth of oceanographic data in the NORAD license area, and that will complement the baseline data sets that have been collected here in the past few years. Another piece of equipment that we have at our disposal is an autonomous underwater vehicle, also known as an AUV.

Speaker 3

So the AUV will map and image the seafloor to detail the extent of our sedimentation footprint and assess the megafauna communities in the different zones of influence. And we'll also use it to produce a high resolution base map of the site where we expect small scale commercial production to occur in the future. We have a responsibility to educate ourselves and to make conscious decisions about where we extract Earth's metals from and how we do it. The impact monitoring work we are doing out here will build on the comprehensive scientific data set gathered during last year's test mining program, and it'll ensure a greater understanding of ecosystem responses to our mining activities. This is one of the first times that a potential new extractive industry is emerging in a responsible way, with the environment being put first and governing the regulatory decision making process.

Speaker 1

Importantly, on the next slide, you'll also see some of the images on the left side of this page taken right after that collection test, compared on the right side of this page to images taken from the 1 year following post collection test campaign. Now qualitative data shows that these are individual organisms, the exact same organisms on the left as they are on the right that are present and alive 1 year following the collection test. And this even applies to organisms that were right next to the vehicle tracks. This information of course is preliminary and anecdotal, and it's going to continue to be analyzed and shared. But it's one of the reasons that our team is so encouraged by the initial results of the monitoring campaign 1 year following the collection test.

Speaker 1

Now during that collection test, we also successfully monitored the plume using myriad assets that were in the water, which are described in this infographic. This is an image presented to scale unlike much of the speculative imagery presented by opposition groups. You'll notice that the mid water plume is represented by a small white whisk in the middle of this page. And most of it frankly will be so dilute that it wouldn't even be visible to the naked eye. The seafloor plume also known as the benthic plume also barely registers on the bottom of the graphic.

Speaker 1

Leading experts in the field deep sea sediment plume dynamics, including a team led by Doctor. Thomas Peacock at MIT and researchers at the Scripps Ocean Institute found that 92% to 98% of sediment disturbed during offshore system trials conducted by our fellow contractor GSR remain within 2 meters of the seafloor. And as noted in conclusion of the study, it's quite a different picture of what the plumes look like compared to some of the conjecture. Now on our own ground in the Nordea area, preliminary findings by leading experts at DHI support the findings of MIT. Our team set over 50 monitoring stations to monitor every aspect of the plume during noise collector trials last year.

Speaker 1

And in field observed data indicate that the sediment plume is low lying, over 90% of the sediment initially stays less than 2 meters above the seafloor. The sediment plume initially forms a turbidity current, which is a gravity driven spreading of sediment laden water under its own weight away from the collector tracks following contours in the seafloor, behaving more like a liquid running along the seafloor than a gas which might waft higher into the water column. In fact, as noted on the right hand side of this page, most of the green and blue bands from this DHI model will be clear enough to swim in and much of it will be clear enough to drink, of course, if it were fresh water. This is a clear example of the speculation of opposition groups initially getting it wrong and frankly majorly wrong. And in field observed data needs to take precedence over such speculation.

Speaker 1

Perhaps this is why Greenpeace in particular has pivoted from once calling for more scientific research to now trying to stop our own scientific research. But in this effort, they have not succeeded as our key offshore campaigns are now complete prior to our application and they can't stop the increasing flow of data that we're now openly sharing with the world, including the international CVET authority, which brings me to the regulatory update. And we've been very encouraged by the progress at the most recent ISA meeting in Jamaica. As further evidenced by the positive commentary from Secretary General Michael Lodge on this industry's inevitability. Our team is on the ground in Jamaica as we speak and we are getting regular real time updates on that ongoing process, all going very constructively.

Speaker 1

Regarding negotiations on the final rules, regulations and procedures, the consolidated regulatory text was released in late February, signaling the transition to the phase of final mining code negotiations. And as noted earlier, we maintain our previous guidance on our intention to launch our application for an exploitation contract following the July 2024 ISA meeting occurring later this year. And assuming a 1 year review period, estimated production occurring towards the end of Q1 of 2026. On the next slide, you'll see the timeline for exploitation application review from the draft regulations. This breakdown has been updated based on the draft consolidated text and has been reflected in our current estimate for beginning production around the end of Q1, 2026, assuming a review process of approximately 1 year.

Speaker 1

I'd like to remind everyone of the highlighted portions of this slide. Oftentimes, people think about the regulatory process as some black box, when in reality, the steps for approval are even more clear and codified than many land based jurisdictions. 1 of the key decisions on our application is the recommendation from the Legal and Technical Commission or LTC. It's another decision made by some executive branch politician back in the national capital where there's a risk of revocation whenever there's a new administration. These are 41 individuals of the LTC that review the application and are all subject matter experts.

Speaker 1

If consensus on approval for a recommendation is not reached, decision is made by simple majority vote. And if the LTC recommends approval, the council reviews and if acceptable, approve that recommendation. You would need 2 thirds majority of the ISA Council to overturn an otherwise positive LTC recommendation. So certainly, we expect plenty back and forth and questions from the LTC, both before and following our application. But we feel very positively about the ability of our application to stand on its merits during what is a well thought out review process.

Speaker 1

On to project economics. As shared in previous update calls, in March of 2021, A and C consultants issued an SEC Reg SK 1300 compliant initial assessment of the project economics for the Nori D area. This initial assessment is available in the Investors section of our website and the Nori D Financial Model can be found beginning on Page 310 of that document. The initial assessment arrived at a net present value of $6,800,000,000 for norady at the beginning of last year. Running the same model since the updated for current metal prices, net present value of Nori D would be approximately $8,100,000,000 Despite a higher share price now than our previous report, we're still only trading at roughly 6% of the underlying NPV for the Nordea area at current metal prices, which remains a massive discount to peer developers, which does means that our valuation can naturally improve if we keep on delivering on our project milestones.

Speaker 1

So on to the financial update. In the last quarter of 2023, TMC reported a net loss of $33,400,000 or $0.10 per share compared to TMC's net loss of $109,500,000 or $0.41 a share for the same period of 2022. The net loss for the last quarter of 2023 included exploration and evaluation expenses of $26,700,000 versus $104,300,000 in Q4 2022 and general and administrative expenses of $6,500,000 versus $7,000,000 in Q4 2022. Exploration and evaluation expenses decreased by $77,600,000 in the last quarter of 2023 compared to the same period in 2022. The significant decrease is primarily due to the recognition of costs representing the fair value of the AllSeas warrant in the quarter of 2022, the completion of the pilot mining test in the same period last year and a reduction in environmental study cost as the collector test was completed in 2022, partially offset by the monitoring work on Nori D, which is carried out in the Q4 of 2023.

Speaker 1

These cost reductions are partially offset by an increase in engineering work, which advanced during the course of 2023, an increase in in exploration labor costs mainly attributable to an increase in headcount and the higher sponsorship, training and stakeholder engagement costs. General and administrative expenses decreased slightly by $500,000 in the last quarter of 2023 compared to the last quarter of 2022. Within the other items, the largest movement between the last quarter of 2023 and the same period of 2022 is a change in the fair value of the warrants liability in alignment with the change of the company's share price. In the last quarter of 2023, the net cash used in operating activities amounted to $15,200,000 compared to $19,800,000 for the last quarter of 2022. The large gap between the net loss for Q4 2023 and the cash used in operating activities for the same period last year is due to a change in working capital, including an increase in accounts payable and accrued liabilities.

Speaker 1

Free cash flow for the last quarter of 2023 was negative $15,600,000 compared to negative $20,000,000 in the last quarter of 2022. Regarding our balance sheet, as at December 31, 2023, we closed the year with cash balance of $6,800,000 and held no debt. We believe that our cash on hand along with the undrawn $25,000,000 unsecured credit facility just now extended through August 2025 with an affiliate of AllSeas and the new $20,000,000 unsecured credit facility provided by Jared Barron and Arris Capital LLC will be sufficient to meet our working capital and capital expenditure requirements for at least the next 12 months from today. The right of use asset, the new line item here you see for $5,700,000 in our balance sheet as at December 31, 2023, represents the net carrying value of the exclusive right to use the hidden gem in support of the development of the Project 0 Offshore Nodule Collection System. In consideration for the exclusivity, we issued 4,150,000 common shares to AllSeas in August of 2023 as previously disclosed.

Speaker 1

On February 21, 2023, Nori entered into an investment agreement with low carbon royalties to finance low carbon emitting energy production and technologies in support of the energy transition. The value of the investment of $8,400,000 as December 31, 2023 represents the company's shareholding in low carbon royalties, net of equity accounted loss for the year. As part of this agreement, Noreen contributed a 2% gross overriding royalty on its future revenue stream to low carbon royalties. And there's also a right potentially through self funding option to buy back 3 quarters of that royalty over time. And the right to the royalty payments was heavily discounted, reflecting the current stage of the project and valued at $14,000,000 and recorded in the Q1 of 2023 as a gain on disposition.

Speaker 1

Now in connection with the preparation of the 2023 year end financial statements and some new information from the technical team of the company's auditors, company reevaluated the accounting for this transaction and concluded that the sale of future revenue falls within the scope of ASC 4 70 and restated the offsetting entry to the proceeds as it received from low carbon royalties as a royalty liability. This is a non core and non cash item and the impact of this restatement is described in detail in the company's note 22 of our annual report on Form 10 ks. It It is also described in the 8 ks that came along with our press release filed post close today. I will now turn it back over to Jared for some closing remarks, and then we'll get to Q and A.

Speaker 2

Thank you, Greg. And as I said at the beginning, the time is now for this new industry. With our own research vessel back in ports and the heaviest offshore preproduction spending in our rearview. Our team's attention is now focused on analyzing the copious amounts of environmental data and putting together an application for an exploitation contract for the Nori area, expected to be submitted following the July 2024 ISA session. And after seeing the initial results following the conclusion of our latest environmental campaign, I'm confident there are no showstoppers and we're looking forward to continuing the release of all this data with stakeholders around the world.

Speaker 2

In the meantime, our executive team will continue to work of securing strategic partnerships, and this is certainly where I'll be devoting nearly all of my time in the coming weeks. I would like to extend my sincere thanks to the TNC team, including our partners, our contractors and of course, our sponsoring states. And thanks to everyone who tuned in to our call today and for your attention. With that, I would like to hand it back to the operator for Q and A.

Operator

Thank you, sir.

Speaker 1

As we're waiting for that to compile, we're going to take a question from the web chat. Milo Munson has asked, is the 6% of share price on Nouri assets or all assets? What percentage is it of all assets? It's a good question. Look, we've always laid out what the valuation is based on Nori D, which is our most advanced project on which we're spending close to $500,000,000 already on that project to bring it to where it is now.

Speaker 1

And being able to leverage that investment is something that's really starting to bear fruit now that the geopolitical tailwinds are blowing much stronger. Nori D represents roughly 22% of the total estimated resource across nori and Tamil. Now we did estimate, when we went public that the full field net present value, if extrapolating the same assumptions from noriD would be $31,000,000,000 of net present value. But again, we like just focusing on the 6,800,000,000 as calculated with AMC Consultants in the nori d initial assessment as their valuation guidepost. And our market cap represents roughly 6% of the updated value of that nori D initial assessment if you just use current metal prices, roughly $8,000,000,000 So to answer your question, it's focused really just on Nore D, recognizing that there is significant upside from the other 78% of our total estimated resource.

Operator

Thank you. And I'm sure we have a question on the phone line. And our question from the phone line comes from the line of Dmitry Silversteyn from Water Tower Research. Please go ahead.

Speaker 1

Good afternoon. Thank you for taking my call. Just wanted to get maybe a little bit more detail on what was or what were the main elements that resulted in the modest extension of the time to offshore production into the Q1 of 2026 versus the original date, which I think was given out as the Q4 of 2025.

Speaker 2

Yes. Hi, Dmitry. Look, there's one driving reason and that is moving the production number of that boat from 1,300,000 tons to 3,000,000 tons. And it was a decision that we had to take at the time, But of course, the economics are so much better when we can be handling the bigger production capacity. But what that requires is an upgrade.

Speaker 2

It requires us to make a couple of modifications for material handling. It required a slightly different riser configuration, all of which has been managed by Allseas. And so that put a little bit of a dampener in the supply chain and that's what resulted in that later timeframe.

Speaker 1

Understood. And then if I can follow-up on the March meetings that are going on right now with ISA. As you look at what will come out of it on the other end, what would be sort of the likely outcome that you're looking for that you would interpret as good news versus, let's say, disappointing outcome?

Speaker 2

Look, this is the first time that a consolidated text has ever been presented to the council. And so it's a really important milestone. And what we're looking out of this session is continued progress. And that's what we're seeing. It was a productive week last week.

Speaker 2

There were this week, we expect to see the same and that is just making progress towards further refining that consolidated text. And what we are also noting is that there is a lot of intercessional work continuing to be done by the member states. And that is increasing. And we expect that the period between the end of the March session and the beginning of the July session is when we're going to see a lot of those loose ends tidied up. And so as for that news, look, we haven't seen any.

Speaker 2

You always see a bit of noise around at this time, of course. And but fundamentally, the noise is very different to the reality and of what's happening. You have 168 members who are working earnestly to put in place regulations because the one thing that everyone agrees is that regulating this industry is the best way of protecting the ocean environment. And so that's what people are doing. And of course, we are very close to those regulations because we're going to need to operate under them.

Speaker 2

And we're not seeing anything that's keeping us up at night.

Speaker 1

Got it. Got it. That's helpful. And then final question, if I may. The cash on hand and the liquidity that you have access to, typically you talk about lasting that for the next 12 months or something like that.

Speaker 1

I didn't hear that statement on this call. So how do you see your liquidity position right now? And how urgently is the need to find a strategic partner, let's say, in 2024? Yes. Look, I mean, sorry, Jared, I can go first, if you don't mind.

Speaker 1

Just quickly on that, Dmitry, I did say that and we did include it in our press release that yes, we do believe that cash on hand plus these credit facilities totaling $45,000,000 is sufficient to meet our working capital and CapEx requirements for at least the next 12 months. Keep in mind too, the last number that we have provided, which I still think is a good guy post was $35,000,000 to $45,000,000 of additional cash needed to launch our application. And I think what you should keep in mind is while we continue to get many inbound proposals for financing, we have our 3 largest shareholders who care very much about minimizing dilution. In fact, if you look at our total shareholder base in excess of 50% of P&C shares are held either by insiders or affiliates. So there's very much a desire internally to do the right deal.

Speaker 1

And that's why all of our focus is on the strategic side right now. And I think confidence provided by not only the extension of the AllSeas credit facility, but the new credit facility from Jared and Andre, I think it just shows the confidence in those potential options. Okay. Okay. Thank you.

Speaker 2

Yes. The easiest thing to do is to print equity. And as Craig said, we really do care about that equity stack because that's where we care about our shareholders, we care about our employees who, of course, are incentivized by the equity. And we have a very direct insight into obviously how those negotiations are going with interested parties. And we think this is the right course for the benefit of all shareholders.

Speaker 1

Fair enough. Thank you, Joe.

Speaker 2

Joe. Thanks, Dmitry.

Operator

Thank you. And I show our next question comes from the line of Matthew O'Keefe from Cantor Fitzgerald. Please go ahead.

Speaker 4

Yes, thanks for taking my question. Just wanted to touch on the if you could touch on the timing and maybe some of the scope of the upcoming feasibility study. Is that still on track for kind of midyear? And maybe you could discuss a little bit about how it's going to differ from the one in hand?

Speaker 2

Sure. Do you want me to say that, Craig?

Speaker 1

Sure. Happy to add color on it, too.

Speaker 2

Yes. Look, the it will be a pre feas that is going to be completed by mid year. And of course, normally, when you move from pre feas to fees, it's to do with tightening up the cost scope and certainty around the budget. And it normally has to do with large capital expenditure. Now of course, we already have our 1st production asset.

Speaker 2

It's the hidden gem. It's owned by ALCs, and it's the vessel that we use for the collector test. And we're working earnestly with our onshore partner at the moment, that's Pacific Metals up in Japan, who have an existing purpose built nickel processing plant, which we're able to tap directly into. And so that pre feas is going to be really significant to just answer many of the technical issues and support our application. That's the main purpose of it because we have a good insight into how those numbers are looking.

Speaker 4

Okay. Thanks. So will we get a sense from it as investors and analysts sort of what the what I mean you'll be paying PAMCO, you'll be paying all Cs to collect the nodules, PAMCO to process them. Will that kind of detail be available in that? And because in my model, it shows some fairly robust potential for some fairly robust economics.

Speaker 2

Absolutely.

Speaker 1

Yes. Certainly, Matt, yes. We would anticipate that as the pre feasibility is coming out and we're preparing for the application, there's going to be a point where we're going to be able to provide guidance to the market and a viewpoint of what to expect from Project Fear Economics, especially now that we're talking about a larger initial production system. So absolutely, we know frankly we've had a lot of investors who have been waiting for that and we want to make sure that we got all the I's and cross the T's before we can release that. But, yes, rest assured it's coming and we agree with you.

Speaker 1

We believe the economics are going to be robust.

Speaker 4

Okay. No, that's great. Thanks. Looking good so far. Appreciate it.

Speaker 4

Thank you.

Speaker 2

Thanks, Matt.

Operator

Thank you. And I show our next question comes from the line of Vasu Patel from Patel Holdings LLC. Please go ahead.

Speaker 5

Hi. So, one of the questions I have is for the application for the ISA that we're submitting for NORAD. As said in the past, there's going to be cost attached to it. Is there approximate amount value to what the costs are? And will they be covered from the current cash assets?

Speaker 5

Or do any of the credit facilities have to be tapped into?

Speaker 1

Yes. Look, I mean the application itself, you're in the ballpark of the $1,000,000 fee for the application, but the real cost of the application is all of the work that goes into analyzing and collating the data and putting forth document of many, many hundreds of pages. We've already finished now our sort of offshore campaign following 1 year on from the collection test and a lot of that information is now being analyzed. It's going to be a key tenant of the environmental impact statement. We're also talking about pre feasibility study that Jared and I just mentioned.

Speaker 1

So the amount that we said $35,000,000 $45,000,000 of incremental funding, which does not include any tapping of our credit facilities, that is still a good number to keep in mind for what it's going to take to get the application over the line. So yes, there is more work to be done and it will cost some money, but we feel now very, very good about the liquidity options at our disposal.

Speaker 5

Got it. And this question really refers to future mining around 2026. As of right now, there's one vessel, there's a hidden gem vessel. But looking forward, how will production be ramped up once the application for exploitation is approved?

Speaker 2

Good question. The one of the things we've established is that processing our nodules can happen through retro kiln electric furnace. And what we know is that there are hundreds of those lines that have been built in China, in Japan and more recently in Indonesia. And they've been built to process nickel laterite oil. And so it's a win win.

Speaker 2

That industry has the capacity to take all of the production that will come off the NORAD block and more into parties that we are currently in talks with. So we do not see the need to have to go and spend money building processing plants to handle the scale up for the 1st phase. And think of processing in 2 steps. One of it is known as the pyrometallurgical process and the other is the hydrometallurgical process. And one of the things that I think the United States and Washington DC policymakers have clocked onto is that they could potentially import that intermediate product that we will produce from nodules into the United States for U.

Speaker 2

S. Battery makers to make battery cells. And of course, once you do that, it means the material is in the United States and it will stay here. It will be used to make batteries, but at end of life, it will be recycled. And recycling in decades to come will become a very important part of the supply chain.

Speaker 2

So the onshore side means there are no limitations to how we scale up the onshore processing. When it comes to the offshore, what we are already doing, as we announced in a previous release, is looking for a second production vessel. But as we get closer to production, we're also finding people knocking on our door saying, hey, we have one of those ships exactly like the Hidden Gem and we'd like to see it busy or we'd like to explore. Could Allseas use it as their production vessel number 2. And so think of it as a cookie cutter approach, but and that's how we're going to do the early scale up for the nori D block.

Speaker 2

In the future, I think what we'll have is bigger production platforms as we start to drive costs out of the business, better economics. And the simple math is that we just announced that we're moving the production platform to 3,000,000 tons. There is the possibility of moving production well beyond that, that it would not be with a boat like we have now. But for the moment, it's cookie cutter, put more boats on the water and it's tapping into already built permitted and financed onshore processing plants in parts of Asia.

Speaker 5

Sounds good. Thank you so much.

Speaker 1

Pleasure. And we're going to move from the phone line to some questions in the chat. Jared, there's a question for you specifically on the current influence from China on Deepsea Mining, as well as the further new 5 year agreement between Russia and the ISA. Maybe if you want to comment at all on what you're seeing from China in terms of on the ground negotiations with the International Seabed Authority?

Speaker 2

Sure. Look, China is, I guess, the most powerful voice at the ISA. And if you listen to Bill Whitaker's 60 Minutes show on Sunday, the reason for that is the United States are not there. And what China are doing, which we appreciate, is saying all of the member states have signed on to the convention of the Law of the Sea and that came up with that came with it, legal obligations to put in place the exploration and exploitation regulations to allow the development of this industry. No matter which way you look at it, China has the absolute market leadership when it comes to these base metals.

Speaker 2

And the reason for that is they are very forward looking. And we could learn a lot from how they deploy capital and how they see demand into the future and do things about it. And so I think that we're encouraged to see China in the industry. We know they have 5 contracts. 2 of them are in the CCZ, which is where we operate.

Speaker 2

China wants regulations to be established to protect the environment, and we want them as well. And I think that's one of the great gifts that come from this legal framework to have a central regulator that represents 168 member countries plus the European Union means that you have a chance of getting it right. Because when you outsource mining to developing countries, you are also outsourcing the environmental oversight. And that doesn't always work out so well. So I think there's no doubt China already has a position at the table.

Speaker 2

They are obviously a strong advocate for environmental regulations. And I think we should embrace that and appreciate that they are there, supporting the establishment of this industry.

Speaker 1

Thanks. There was a question from Tyler McNeil. Any updates to the DPA, Department of Defense Title III grants? Yes, we've been in communication and we'd also been looking very closely at the DoD grant program and there was nearly $400,000,000 of new funds allocated to it earlier this year. So that process is ongoing.

Speaker 1

I would say stay tuned on that front. These processes always tend to take a little bit longer than one anticipates. And I think that applies to the direction from the House Armed Services Committee to the Pentagon to deliver a report on the potential processing and refining of nodules. But frankly, that report we think is going to be very important to underscore our national security relevance for the United States. And I think we're also seeing that it's really not just about the Department of Defense DPA Title III program, but increasing focus on nodules from the United States.

Speaker 1

It also means that there are other more direct forms of potentially getting funding to do similar feasibility work. So rest assured the TMC is aggressively pursuing all potential opportunities on that front. And it really has to do with the fact that I think now there is a growing momentum from the military, political and intelligence communities. And when you're talking about 100 of these former leaders signing on to something, that's really a momentum of its own and showing that a lot of the education, frankly, that we've been doing along with other contractors about what this resource is, has been fruitful and we expect more of it this year. Also, Jared, a question for you from Sean Dray.

Speaker 1

Certainly, we had a strong partnership with Nauru. Do we have any other plans in the near future to develop further partnerships with countries, any other expectations of countries who might want to become sponsoring states, any focus on us on that front?

Speaker 2

Look, we are frequently contacted by countries, particularly developing countries, who would like our help or our partnership to help them get into this industry. And at the moment, our hands are pretty full. However, we are exploring how we can help some of those nations participate because particularly developing countries who would otherwise not have access to any economic opportunities like this, now is the time for them to participate. So nothing to report. And we do have a laser focus inside the business on our Nouri contract area at the moment, of course.

Speaker 2

And but there might be something in the future.

Speaker 1

And the last question that we have time for, from Tim Panetti. Do we have any updates in terms of discussions with auto OEMs and any news on their focus on this new industry?

Speaker 2

Well, I can confirm that we continue to talk to them. But I don't think the auto OEMs are going to move until we're closer to production. And quite frankly, our job at the moment is to keep them informed, keep them up to date on the environmental evidence that is coming to hand. And at the right time, we will be a great partner for them because in the future, of course, between carbon equalization measures and battery passport initiatives, the CO2 footprint is going to be really important. And we know what our CO2 footprint is going to look like.

Speaker 2

We also know through our life cycle analysis what our impacts on other areas will be as well, whether it's sequestered carbon or water usage, freshwater systems and so on. And I think that those matters are going to be really important to measure because when you compare them to alternative supply in the marketplace, they're going to look really low impact at the bottom end of the scale. And that means that customers will be rewarded for choosing those products or the materials that come with a higher impact. So our job is to continue to develop those systems, continue to provide that environmental evidence, which of course we'll make available to the world, but help put it into context as it becomes available for those OEMs. And we've got a cordial, respectful relationship, some better than others.

Speaker 2

But when the time is right, I'm confident that they will be there.

Speaker 1

Thanks. Look, thanks to everybody for taking time to join us on the call today. We're certainly looking forward to sharing more progress on our next quarterly call, which is just right around the corner. And we'll turn that back over to the operator for any final comments and disconnection.

Operator

Thank you, sir. This concludes today's conference call. Thank you all for participating. You may all disconnect.

Powered by Quartr