Bridgewater Bancshares Q3 2023 Earnings Call Transcript

Quartr
Provided by Quartr
October 26, 2023

There are 7 speakers on the call.

Operator

Good morning, and welcome to the Bridgewater Bancshares 2023 Third Quarter Earnings Call. My name is Debbie, and I will be your conference operator today. All participants have been placed in listen only mode. After Bridgewater's opening remarks, there will be a question and answer session. Please note that today's call is being recorded.

Operator

At this time, I would like to introduce Justin Horstman, Director of Investor Relations, to begin the conference call. Please go ahead.

Speaker 1

Thank you, Debbie, and good morning, everyone. Joining me on today's call are Jerry Bach, Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer Joe Shebowski, Chief Financial Officer Jeff Kjellberg, Chief Credit Officer and Nick Place, Chief Lending Officer. In just a few moments, We will provide an overview of our 2023 Q3 financial results. We will be referencing a slide presentation that is available on the Investor Relations section of Bridgewater's website, investors. Bridgewaterbankmn.com.

Speaker 1

Following our opening remarks, we will open the call for questions. During today's presentation, we may make projections or other or other forward looking statements regarding future events or the future financial performance of the company. We caution that such statements are predictions and that actual results may differ materially. Please see the forward looking statement disclosure in our 2023 Q3 earnings release for more information about risks and uncertainties which may affect us. The information we will provide today is as of and for the period ended September 30, 2023, We undertake no duty to update the information.

Speaker 1

We may also disclose non GAAP financial measures during this call. We believe certain non GAAP Our financial measures in addition to the related GAAP measures provide meaningful information to investors to help them understand the company's operating performance and trends and to facilitate comparisons with the performance of our peers. We caution that these disclosures should not be viewed as a substitute for operating results determined in accordance with GAAP. Please see our 2023 Q3 earnings release for reconciliations of non GAAP disclosures to the comparable GAAP measures. I would now like to turn the call over to Bridgewater's Chairman, President and CEO, Jerry Bach.

Speaker 2

Thank you, Justin, and thank you, everyone, for joining us today. I'll start with a quick overview of the Q3, which had several encouraging trends. First, after net interest margin compression began to slow in the last quarter, We're pleased to begin seeing the stability in the margin during the Q3. While the margin declined 8 basis points quarter over quarter, We saw signs of stabilization on a month to month basis throughout the quarter. Joe will talk more about the margin dynamics shortly.

Speaker 2

2nd, given the prolonged higher interest rate environment, we've been focused on enhancing our balance sheet composition to set us apart for longer term profitability and success. Concentrated efforts are being made to build our deposit base, Reduce our reliance on higher cost borrowings and slow our pace of loan growth in the near term. For the 2nd consecutive quarter, we saw improvements In our overall funding base as core deposits increased 11% on an annualized basis and total borrowings declined 30% from the 2nd quarter with no overnight borrowings on quarter end. While we have determined a long track record of Generating robust and profitable loan growth over the years, we have intentionally slowed the pace of loan growth in 2023 And actually saw balances decline slightly in the 3rd quarter. While this was due in part to an uptick in payoffs and paydowns during the quarter, We're also being more thoughtful about our growth in the current environment.

Speaker 2

As a result, we expect more limited loan growth in the near term. Combined with growing deposits and capital, reducing the loan to deposit ratio and stabilizing the net interest margin, This will give us the ability to generate profitable growth when the environment becomes more favorable. Bridgewater has always been a growth engine and we certainly don't See that changing. However, we believe being more selective today will position us better for the long term. Expenses remain very well controlled on a year to year basis.

Speaker 2

However, as expected, we saw an increase in non interest expense In the Q3, primarily related to ongoing investments we are making in our people. Lastly, asset quality remains Just one basis point of net charge offs, consistently low levels of non performing assets and stable levels of watch and substandard loans. While we continue to be very proactive and diligent on this front, we remain pleased with the performance and quality of our loan portfolio. In addition to these encouraging trends, our overall focus remained on driving steady tangible book value growth for our shareholders, which we have done for 27 consecutive quarters. In fact, only 12% of banks between $310,000,000,000 in assets have been able to grow tangible book value each of the past 8 quarters.

Speaker 2

Before I hand it over to Joe, I want to take a minute to share some additional insights into other activities happening across the bank. The BWB culture remains a focus. Engaged team members translate to better service, Less turnover and ultimately a more committed workforce. We see great engagement with our team members. Participation in events including health and wellness, mentorship, DE and I and volunteering remains high and turnover remains well below industry norms.

Speaker 2

And we continue to receive recognition locally and nationally for our culture. In addition, we are continuing to proactively engage with existing and potential clients, which includes expanded outreach to targeted verticals in C and I. We indicated at the beginning of the year that C and I was a focus for us and we are making inroads in certain niche areas where we have strong connections like women led businesses and entrepreneurs and companies running on the EOS operating system. Networking is something we do better than anyone, and we are using the strength to extend outreach into these opportunities. While we are still in the early stages, we have had early success in creating new C and I opportunities.

Speaker 2

Being efficient has always been important to BWB. Investments in technology, specifically streamlining workflows are creating efficiencies across the business. Investments in our project management function are ensuring we execute effectively on large internal initiatives and reap the rewards as soon as possible. While the overall environment remains challenging for many banks, I remain very optimistic and how Bridgewater is positioned moving forward. With that, I'm going to turn it over to Joe.

Speaker 3

Thank you, Jerry. Turning to Slide 4, the net interest margin declined just 8 basis points to 2.32 for the 3rd quarter. This compared to our September standalone margin of 2.30, which was down just 3 basis points from the month of June standalone margin of 2.33%. Even more encouraging is the margin showed signs of stabilization on a month to month basis during the quarter. The chart in the bottom right shows the trend in monthly core margin compression, which excludes loan fees as they can be lumpy from month to month.

Speaker 3

After seeing several months of mid teens margin compression in late 2022 early 2023, We saw a gradual slowing begin in the Q2 of 2023. This trend continued into the Q3 with the core margin remaining relatively stable throughout July, August September. This was driven by a moderation in rising funding costs as core deposits grew and borrowings declined, coupled with the continued slow but steady increase in earning asset yields. We would expect the quarterly margin to stabilize over the near term As the compression continues to slow, keeping in mind that funding costs are and will remain under pressure given other market alternatives. As we've mentioned in the past, the margin outlook is dependent on several factors, including future changes in interest rates, the shape of the yield curve and the pace of Core deposit growth.

Speaker 3

Slide 5 shows the various components of the margin. Portfolio loan yields moved higher and should continue to do so for the foreseeable future. As we look ahead, we have over $500,000,000 of fixed and adjustable rate loans scheduled to reprice over the next year And nearly $600,000,000 of variable rate loans efficiently floating. Another factor here is loan fees, which have had around a 10 basis point impact on the aggregate portfolio loan yield over the past few quarters. However, this is down meaningfully from our 30 basis point run rate in mid-twenty 22 as payoffs have declined and subsequent deferred loan origination fee realization as well.

Speaker 3

In addition to loan yields, the yield on our securities portfolio has also continued to increase, up 15 basis points from the 2nd quarter to 4.39%. While loan growth has been more muted, Keep in mind that we do not have any held to maturity securities. While rising funding costs continue to outpace earning asset yields, The rise in cost of funds has slowed meaningfully. This was largely due to strong core deposit growth and a decrease in our reliance on borrowings and overnight money. In fact, our overall funding costs increased just 19 basis points in the 3rd quarter compared to a 50 basis point increase in the 2nd quarter.

Speaker 3

That said, funding costs are still under pressure and we expect to see deposit costs continue to move slowly higher given competition from other bank and non bank alternatives and the Fed's uncertain interest rate outlook. Turning to Slide 6, we have demonstrated a long track record of Strong revenue and profitability. While this has been a more challenging revenue environment, due in part to our spread based model, primarily due to $493,000 of FHLB prepayment income, similar to what we saw in the Q1. Turning to Slide 7, expenses have remained very well controlled year to date. After a 6.7% decline in the 1st quarter And an increase of just 1.4% in the 2nd quarter, we indicated that we would see an increased pace in the second half of the year.

Speaker 3

This was the case as non interest expense increased 6.7% in the 3rd quarter, the majority of which was related to incentives across the entire employee base. Historically, our non interest expense growth has tracked closely with asset growth. On a year to date basis, Non interest expense in 2023 is up just 6% from 2022, below our year over year asset growth of 10.4%. Even with our expense discipline, our efficiency ratio has increased into the mid-fifty percent range due to the ongoing revenue headwinds. We still maintain a highly efficient operating model relative to other banks and expect that to remain the case.

Speaker 3

Overall, we feel good about our ability to control expenses, while still making key investments in the business and our people. With that, I'll turn it over to Nick.

Speaker 4

Thanks, Joe. Turning to Slide 8, deposit growth was a highlight for the 2nd consecutive quarter. Total deposits increased 10.8 percent annualized during the quarter, including $70,000,000 of core deposit growth or 11% annualized. To supplement our core deposit growth, we added $27,000,000 of broker deposits consistent with the funding strategy we've had in place since the bank was founded. When combined with core deposits, this helped to offset the liquidation of $195,000,000 of higher cost overnight borrowings during the quarter.

Speaker 4

In terms of our deposit growth outlook, it's important to remember that the nature of our deposit base results in longer client acquisition and onboarding times. We remain confident in our ability to continue deposit momentum over time as our pipelines remain strong. However, deposit growth can fluctuate quite a bit from quarter to quarter with the growth often not being linear. That said, over the past two quarters, we have added over $115,000,000 of core deposits, which speaks to the strength of our bank, our brand in the Twin Cities and the relationships we have developed with our clients. During the Slide 9, loan growth came in lower than we were expecting as balances declined 1.5% annualized during the quarter.

Speaker 4

This was largely due to higher than expected payoffs and paydowns, which increased $67,000,000 from the 2nd quarter. Had payoffs and paydowns remain consistent with 2nd quarter levels, loan growth would have been 5.6% annualized much closer to our expectations. However, as Jerry mentioned earlier, we are taking a more thoughtful approach to our near term growth strategy to optimize profitability over the longer term. This includes a continued focus on supporting our core clients in the current environment, while being more selective on new client relationships. We are still seeing loan demand in the market that would support a higher growth rate today, but to do so we would need to compromise on pricing and bring in more higher cost funding.

Speaker 4

Throw in where we are at in the credit cycle, it just doesn't make sense from a profitability standpoint. Ultimately, this the past two quarters, we have lowered our loan to deposit ratio from 108% to 101%. As this ratio improves, You can see that while new loan originations and advances have declined year over year, they rebounded over 20% in the 3rd quarter. Payoffs and paydowns have been on a similar trajectory with steady declines over the past year, but as we've mentioned, there was a notable increase in the Q3 as interest rates began to stabilize. We also continue to use loan participations as a tool to manage our loan growth, including the sale of $134,000,000 year to date.

Speaker 4

On Slide 11, you can see there was not a lot of movement in the various loan portfolios given relatively stable loan balances during the quarter. The movement we did see was primarily related to balances migrating from construction to multifamily as these projects completed their construction phase. Overall, we remain comfortable with the diversification we have across our loan portfolio. With that, I'll turn it over to Jeff.

Speaker 5

Thanks Nick. Turning to Slide 12, we continue to feel good about our asset quality as non performing assets remained at very low levels Making up just 0.02 percent of total assets at the end of September, net charge offs were just 1 basis point With cumulative net charge offs of just $446,000 since 2019, and we again had virtually no loans 30 to 89 days past due. All of this is largely due to our measured risk selection, consistent underwriting standards, active credit oversight and experienced lending and credit teams. While we are still not seeing early signs of credit weakness, the higher for longer interest rate environment is putting pressure on businesses, which will likely result in credit normalization over time. We also remain well reserved at 1.36% of gross loans.

Speaker 5

We had no provision for credit losses during the quarter given the stable loan balances, but we did have a negative $600,000 provision for unfunded commitments, which are primarily construction loans. As we continue to fund these commitments and with our limited loan growth outlook, We would expect to continue to see lower provisions in the near term, depending on the economic conditions and our overall credit quality. On Slide 13, you can see that our watch and substandard loans remained relatively stable during the quarter. Overall, we feel good about the risk profile of the portfolio and feel it is well positioned moving forward. Turning to Slide 14, we provide some more information on our CRE and office portfolios.

Speaker 5

The majority of our non owner occupied CRE book is fixed rate, which helps from a repricing risk standpoint. We continue to actively engage with our clients that have maturing loans We're resetting rates over the next 12 months to identify possible cash flow stream and recommend solutions early in the process if necessary. We have completed this process for loans maturing and repricing in 2023 and are now focusing on our 2024 loans. As of quarter end, we had $195,000,000 in non owner occupied CRE office exposure, which is about 5% of total loans. This includes only 4 loans located in the central business districts totaling $35,000,000 We continue to monitor this portfolio closely And we feel good about the outlook given the lower average loan amount, diversified client base and primarily Midwestern suburban office exposure.

Speaker 5

Overall, we haven't seen noticed any material changes in these portfolios since the last quarter and they continue to perform well. I'll now turn it back over to Joe.

Speaker 3

Thanks, Jeff. Turning to Slide 15, you could see that our liquidity profile has continued to improve throughout the year. At the end of the Q3, we had $2,200,000,000 of on and off balance sheet liquidity, a robust 2.7 times the level of our uninsured deposits. Slide 16 highlights our tangible book value growth and strong capital ratios. Tangible book value per share increased another 1.8 to $12.37 in the Q3.

Speaker 3

We continue to demonstrate an ability to consistently grow tangible book value through various market ups and downs. From a capital standpoint, we saw an increase in all of our capital ratios for the 2nd consecutive quarter, including tangible common equity, which increased from 7.39 percent to 7.61% and CET1, which increased to over 9%. We are focused on continuing to build these ratios over time given our more moderated pace of loan growth and continued earnings retention. From a capital priority standpoint, organic growth remains our primary focus. Beyond that, we continue to review and monitor potential M and A opportunities.

Speaker 3

We also have a $25,000,000 stock repurchase program that was approved by the Board in 2022, which we will continue to evaluate going forward. Turning to Slide 17, I'll summarize our thoughts on our near term outlook. Coming into the year, we expected high single digit loan growth in 2023. We are relatively in line running on a year to date annualized basis at around 6%. However, given the persistent high interest rate environment, we expect limited loan growth in the near term as we focus on building our funding base to be able to deploy in a more favorable lending environment.

Speaker 3

As Nick mentioned, We expect core deposit growth to continue to trending up over time, but I'll reiterate it's not linear on a linked quarter basis given the nature of our deposit base. Our current loan to deposit ratio of 101% has declined back into our target range of 95% to 105%. As we moderate loan growth, we'd like to see that ratio continue to trend toward the bottom end of that range in the near term. We would expect margin stabilization over the near term as the quarterly compression continues to slow. Obviously, there are still a lot of moving pieces, including ongoing funding pressures, We are pleased with the progress and where we are from a margin standpoint.

Speaker 3

On the expense front, we expect to see ongoing non interest expense growth As we feel it is important to continue investing in the business and our people to support future growth opportunities. Expense growth has typically aligned with asset growth, We would expect that to be the case for the full year of 2023. We also expect lower levels of provision expense given the slower pace of loan growth, Unfunded commitments continuing to fund and a moderation in the volume of newly originated projects with unfunded commitments. I'll now turn it back over to Jerry.

Speaker 2

Thanks, Joe. Finishing up on Slide 18, despite the challenging macroeconomic environment, The strategic priorities we identified at the beginning of the year are still in place and we have shared those with you today. We have made good progress on each of them. I would also reiterate our continued ability to grow tangible book value. The current banking environment has presented several challenges, including meaningful margin compression and a slower pace of loan growth than we have been used to.

Speaker 2

But despite all of that, Economic Cycles. With that, we will open this up for questions.

Operator

We will now begin the question and answer session. The first question comes from Jeff Rulis with D. A. Davidson. Please go ahead.

Speaker 6

Thanks. Good morning. Looking at the limited growth, I just want to kind of poke That a little bit, you guys were pretty clear on it. Just want to kind of gauge the level of participations, If you have any visibility on pay downs or amortization schedule ahead to try to figure out sort of where we are, how long We have maybe limited net growth or where that turn may be if possible?

Speaker 4

Good morning, Jeff. This is Nick. Yes, we a lot of the participation that we had funded through the quarter We're related to prior originated loans that included construction transactions that had a participant on them. We have pulled back a bit on our selling a lot of participations on new transactions as an effort to Continue to supplement the growth that we're looking for long term. So and we do feel good about the quarter, although we Balances were down slightly.

Speaker 4

That actual advances and originations were up quarter over Quarter. So it was a bit lumpy with some increased payoffs that some of which were delayed from Q2 and pushed into Q3 and some of which were moved up from 4th and the 3rd. So, we're as we look out at our pipeline of payoffs, it looks to be a bit more Like it had been earlier in the year. As we sort of project forward, it felt like it was just a bit exacerbated and lumpy there in Q3.

Speaker 6

Okay. And Nick, I don't know if you could hazard a guess for 'twenty four expectations on net growth, we'd be in the Need that high single digit or do you think we revert to kind of historical Bridgewater over a couple of quarters?

Speaker 4

No, I think your first thought there is right. I think, you know, as we look farther out, Throughout 2024, that feels like that mid single digits is kind of where we're looking at it. I mean, like we've always mentioned though, Our growth isn't always perfectly smooth and linear. It may sort of be lumpy at times and in all likelihood just given where we're at, It would likely be more heavily weighted toward the back half of the year as we're thinking through it.

Speaker 6

Got it. Maybe switching gears, Joe, Appreciate the comments on kind of that historical coupling of asset growth and expense growth that assets were down in the quarter and expenses up 7% linked, that's kind of a near term jog, but I'm trying to kind of rationalize Where expenses head in the next couple of quarters relative to if loan growth is going to be pretty muted, Just want to get a sense for and some of that expense base you can't control with sort of the FDIC side, but just Kind of near term and then even a similar question is asked Nick, just kind of expense growth in 'twenty four, do you think we revert back to kind of historical Kind of pairing of asset growth and cost growth?

Speaker 3

Yes, I think you're thinking about it the right way, Jeff. I think We look at it more over the year and over the long haul. And as we've always said, that relationship has held up, Whether it's on a growth rate basis or if you look at non interest expense to average assets, that ratio, If you take a step back and you look at it on the full year, that's relatively in line. So to Nick's point, mid single digit loan growth next year, I I'd also expect expenses to run-in line with that. So I think it's hard from a quarter over quarter basis, we don't think about it that way.

Speaker 3

We think about more over the long haul and as we guided last quarter, we expected a step up in the 3rd quarter On a linked quarter basis, but again looking back on a year to date basis, it's only 6%. And if you think of asset growth over the last year, It's 10%. So that relationship remains intact.

Speaker 6

And maybe a credit related question just So curious, second guessing on multifamily loans of late, just in the kind of listening to some other calls, At 37% of the portfolio, maybe Jeff, just a question on Kind of the long term viability of that sector, what's been very historically very clean. Just want to kind of revisit from How you feel about your comfort level with the multifamily segment in general?

Speaker 5

Great question. And like you said, there has been a lot of press out there on the just the overall national multifamily market recently. We feel good about the portfolio. We feel good about the Twin Cities market. We've talked to you about this before, but The market in the Twin Cities has always been has never really been a bloom robust market, been much more stable characteristics in terms of rent growth and With occupancy levels, there was a recent report just nationally on multifamily that we're trying to gauge overbuilt market by looking at the number of units under Construction, relative to the total inventory in the market and the Twin Cities came in at 5%, which was lower than the national average.

Speaker 5

So I think it Tells you that there's just it's not being overbuilt. Also with some of the pressures on the single family market with the lack of inventory on the market and Interest rate environment floating up that bodes well for the multifamily market as well in terms of the need for housing. With that said, with our covenant testing and interest rates folding up, we have seen some compression in debt service coverage ratios of projects. We expect that will be somewhat short term and then over the long term that will come back to more normalized ratio. And I guess the last thing I want to add is just that affordable housing units represent a significant portion of our market and The Twin Cities like everywhere is lacking in affordable units.

Speaker 5

So I think that that is another just data point that reflects stabilization in the portfolio.

Speaker 6

And if I could, Jeff, just overall outside of multifamily, just looking at credit in general, your thoughts, The watch list balances down a bit, so it's standard up a bit, but boy NPAs and net charge offs continue to be pretty great, but overall Kind of body language on credit?

Speaker 5

No, just no, Feel good. We're probably more dialed into the portfolio between covenant testing, Looking at repricing of loans, I think that that's probably the a lot of banks are looking at that the same way as one of the bigger risk factors out there. As I mentioned And the deck shows this we have a lot of fixed rate product because of our commercial real estate focus. So that helps from a repricing standpoint. But we're just continuing to dive in wherever we can in order to try to identify potential risk factors That would impact the portfolio, but right now we're not seeing too much.

Speaker 6

Great. I appreciate it. I'll step back.

Operator

This concludes our question and answer session. I would like to turn the call back over to Jerry Bock for any closing remarks.

Speaker 2

Thanks for joining the call today. We at BWB remain optimistic about the future And we are seeing encouraging trends and continue to push our strong culture, our brand, our networking events. We have some of the best clients I think in the nation and obviously our employees too. So thanks for your time today and we'll talk to you next quarter. Bye.

Operator

This concludes the presentation. Thank you for attending today's conference. You may now disconnect.

Powered by Quartr

Key Takeaways

  • Net interest margin compression slowed with Q3 margin down just 8 bps to 2.32%, showing month-to-month stabilization as rising deposit costs moderated and borrowings declined.
  • Core deposits increased 11% annualized and total borrowings fell 30% Q/Q, enabling the bank to intentionally slow loan growth and target a loan-to-deposit ratio within the 95-105% range.
  • Non-interest expense rose 6.7% in Q3 due to employee incentives but remains controlled with YTD expense growth of 6% vs. asset growth of 10.4%, supporting a mid-50s efficiency ratio.
  • Asset quality stayed strong with net charge-offs of 1 basis point, non-performing assets at 0.02% of total assets, stable watch/substandard levels, and a 1.36% reserve coverage ratio.
  • Tangible book value per share grew 1.8% to $12.37 in Q3, marking 27 consecutive quarters of growth; tangible common equity and CET1 ratios improved to 7.61% and over 9%, with capital focused on organic growth, M&A and a $25M repurchase program.
AI Generated. May Contain Errors.
Earnings Conference Call
Bridgewater Bancshares Q3 2023
00:00 / 00:00