NYSE:EARN Ellington Credit Q4 2023 Earnings Report $5.36 +0.04 (+0.75%) As of 09:36 AM Eastern This is a fair market value price provided by Polygon.io. Learn more. Earnings HistoryForecast Ellington Credit EPS ResultsActual EPS$0.27Consensus EPS $0.23Beat/MissBeat by +$0.04One Year Ago EPSN/AEllington Credit Revenue ResultsActual Revenue$0.38 millionExpected Revenue$2.57 millionBeat/MissMissed by -$2.19 millionYoY Revenue GrowthN/AEllington Credit Announcement DetailsQuarterQ4 2023Date3/6/2024TimeN/AConference Call DateThursday, March 7, 2024Conference Call Time11:00AM ETUpcoming EarningsEllington Credit's Q1 2025 earnings is scheduled for Tuesday, May 13, 2025, with a conference call scheduled on Wednesday, May 14, 2025 at 11:00 AM ET. Check back for transcripts, audio, and key financial metrics as they become available.Conference Call ResourcesConference Call AudioConference Call TranscriptSlide DeckPress Release (8-K)Annual Report (10-K)Earnings HistoryCompany ProfileSlide DeckFull Screen Slide DeckPowered by Ellington Credit Q4 2023 Earnings Call TranscriptProvided by QuartrMarch 7, 2024 ShareLink copied to clipboard.There are 10 speakers on the call. Operator00:00:00Thank you for standing by, and welcome to the Ellington Residential Mortgage REIT 2023 Quarter Financial Results Conference Call. Today's call is being recorded. And at this time, all participants have been placed It is now my pleasure to turn the conference over to Aladdin Shillelai, Associate General Counsel. Operator00:00:36Sir, you may begin. Speaker 100:00:41Thank you. Before we begin, I would like to remind everyone that certain statements made during this conference call may constitute forward looking statements within the meaning of the Safe Harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Forward looking statements are not historical in nature and are subject to a variety of risks and uncertainties that could cause the company's actual results to differ from its beliefs, expectations, estimates and projections. Consequently, you should not rely on these forward looking statements as predictions of future events. We strongly encourage you to review the information that we have filed with the SEC, including the earnings release and the Form 10 ks for more information regarding these forward looking statements and any related risks and uncertainties. Speaker 100:01:24Unless otherwise noted, statements made during this conference call are made as of the date of this call and the company undertakes no obligation to update or revise any forward looking statements whether as a result of new information, future events or otherwise. Joining me on the call today are Larry Penn, Chief Executive Officer of Allington Residential Mark Zekotsky, our Co Chief Investment Officer and Chris Smernoff, our Chief Financial Officer. As described in our earnings press release, our Q4 earnings conference call presentation is available on our website, earnreit.com. Our comments this morning will track to the presentation. Please note that any references to figures in this presentation are qualified in their entirety by the notes at the back of the presentation. Speaker 100:02:07With that, I will now turn the Speaker 200:02:09call over to Larry. Speaker 300:02:11Thanks, Eladine, and good morning, everyone. We appreciate your time and interest in Ellington Residential. As with much of 2023, in the Q4 markets gyrated between a sell off and a rally with tumultuous October giving way to a market rally in November December. In October, interest rate volatility spiked as U. S. Speaker 300:02:32Treasury yields rose to 15 year highs and that drove yield spreads sharply wider on most fixed income products. Markets then reversed course in anticipation of the conclusion of the Federal Reserve's hiking cycle with interest rates and volatility both declining into year end. With rates lower and trading in a more stable range, demand for spread products picked up and capital flowed into fixed income funds. With the notable exception of CMBS, which has its own unique challenges, virtually all fixed income spreads tightened for the Q4, including in the markets where EARN invests, namely agency and non agency RMBS and now corporate CLOs, where we've been investing to an ever increasing extent after our recent pivot. Turning to the investor presentation. Speaker 300:03:23On Slide 3, you can see that medium and long term interest rates despite spiking to multiyear highs in October actually declined overall for the quarter. And the 30 year Freddie mortgage survey rate despite reaching a 23 year high mid quarter also finished lower on the quarter. Incredibly, despite all of the fluctuations during the year, both the 10 year treasury yield and the 30 year mortgage survey rate finished 2023 within one basis point of where they started the year as you can see here on this slide as well. As the backdrop for our mortgage backed securities portfolio, you can also see on Slide 3 that option adjusted yield spreads tightened across agency coupons during the Q4 and that the most pronounced price increases were on lower and intermediate coupons. Dollar prices on Fannie 2.5s through 4.5s were up more than 5 points sequentially. Speaker 300:04:18The outperformance of those coupons benefited EARN's Agency MBS portfolio specifically because coming into the quarter roughly 2 thirds of our Agency MBS had coupons of 4.5% or less. Meanwhile, as the backdrop for our CLO portfolio, corporate credit spreads followed a similar pattern, first widening in October and then tightening in November December and tightening overall for the quarter as an economic soft landing narrative permeated the market. You can see on the bottom of Slide 3 that credit spreads on both high yield and investment grade tightened significantly over the quarter, while prices on the Morningstar LSTA Leveraged Loan Index rose. Turning now to EARNS results. In the Q4, we generated net income of $0.75 per share and a non annualized economic return of 7.7%, while our adjusted distributable earnings grew to $0.27 per share and more than covered our dividend. Speaker 300:05:19As with other market disruptions we've seen before, the key in the Q4 was to avoid forced selling when the market sold off in October in order to preserve equity and earnings power and be in a position to participate in the subsequent market recovery. In the Q4, we again relied on EARN's risk management and strong liquidity position to accomplish this. That said, we did sell pools in the 4th quarter to free up capital from MBS to CLOs and the majority of our sales took place in November as yield spreads were tightening. We ended up increasing the size of our CLO portfolio by $13,600,000 during the quarter. On slide 12 of the earnings presentation, you can see some of the underlying characteristics of our CLO portfolio as of year end. Speaker 300:06:04The corporate loans underlying our CLO investments span a diverse array of industries and the overwhelming majority are floating rate, 1st lien, senior secured loans. Our rotation into CLOs has continued into the New Year with our agency portfolio now incrementally smaller and the size of our CLO portfolio now up an additional 70% from year end to approximately $30,000,000 Even after the recent credit spread tightening in the sector, we still see returns on equity for new CLO investments in the high teens to low 20s. Besides contributing to and diversifying earnings GAAP results, our high yielding CLO investments have also helped drive the substantial growth of our net interest margin and thereby have supported our ADE as well. In addition, because we employ less leverage on our CLOs compared to agency, the portfolio rotation has also driven down our leverage ratios. At year end, our debt to equity ratio adjusted for unsettled trades declined to 5.3:one down from 7.3:one at September 30. Speaker 300:07:13I'll now pass it over to Chris to review our financial results for the Q4 in more detail. Speaker 400:07:19Thank you, Larry, and good morning, everyone. Please turn to Slide 5 for a summary of Ellington Residential's 4th quarter financial results. For the quarter ended December 31, we reported net income of $0.75 per share and adjusted distributable earnings of $0.27 per share. AD excludes the catch up amortization adjustment, which was positive $566,000 in the 4th quarter. During the quarter, positive net interest income and net gains on our Agency MBS significantly exceeded net losses on our hedges, driving strong performance from our Agency portfolio. Speaker 400:07:56Our CLO portfolio also generated strong returns driven by net interest income and net gains as did our non agency RMBS and interest only portfolios. On Slide 5, you can see that our overall net interest margin expanded to 2.19% from 1.34% quarter over quarter, which drove the increase in ADE. Broken out by product, our agency NIM increased to 2.02% from 1.26%, driven by higher asset yields and a lower cost of funds. Meanwhile, our credit NIM, which includes CLOs and non agency RMBS, increased to 6.28% from 4.55%, boosted by high asset yields on our larger CLO portfolio. Please turn now to our balance sheet on Slide 6. Speaker 400:08:48Book value per share was $7.32@yearend compared to $7.02 per share at December 30. Including the $0.24 per share in dividends in the quarter, our economic return for the quarter was 7.7%. We ended the quarter with $61,000,000 in cash plus unencumbered assets, which was approximately 45 percent of total equity. Next, please turn to Slide 7 for a summary of our portfolio holdings. Our agency RMBS holdings decreased by 8% sequentially to $728,000,000 as of December 31, as net sales and paydowns exceeded net gains. Speaker 400:09:28Our Agency MBS portfolio turnover was 25% for the quarter. Our aggregate holdings of non agency RMBS and interest only securities also shrunk in size by 13% quarter over quarter. Over the same period, we increased our CLO holdings more than fourfold to $17,400,000 as of December 31, compared to $3,800,000 as of September 30. At year end, our deployed equity was allocated 89% to mortgage related securities and 11% to CLOs. Our debt to equity ratio adjusted for unsettled trades decreased to 5.3x as of December 31 as compared to 7.3x as of September 30. Speaker 400:10:15The decline was primarily due to an increase in shareholders' equity and a significantly lower leverage on the CLO portfolio relative to our agency holdings. Similarly, our net mortgage asset to equity ratio decreased to 6.5 times from 7.2 times over the same period, despite our holdings holding a net long TBA position at December 31 as compared to a net short TBA position at September 30. On slide 9, you can see the details of our interest rate hedging portfolio. During the quarter, we continue to hedge interest rate risk primarily through the use of interest rate swaps. We ended the 4th quarter with a net long TBA position on a notional basis, but a small net short position as measured by 10 year equivalents. Speaker 400:11:07Lastly, on Slide 12, you can see that nearly all of the loans underlying our CLO portfolio are floating rate and as such carry minimal interest rate risk. I will now turn our presentation over to Mark. Speaker 500:11:22Thanks, Chris. The 4th quarter was really a tale of 2 markets. The 1st part of the quarter was characterized by a continued rate sell off, wider spreads, fund outflows and market uncertainty about how high the Fed would need to hike short rates before achieving a noticeable improvement on inflation. But then starting in late October early November with economic indicators and comments from Chairman Powell pointing to a possible end to the rate hike cycle, markets started to make a U-turn. Rates dropped, spreads tightened and there was a significant fund in bank buying of Agency MBS and other spread products. Speaker 500:12:03In Agency, sector outperformance in the 2nd part of the quarter exceeded underperformance in the 1st part. And overall for the quarter, Agency MBS significantly outperformed hedging instruments. I'm happy to report that EARN was well positioned to capture this agency outperformance, posting a total economic return of almost 8% for the quarter. During the market sell off in the 1st part of the quarter, we were able to manage the interest rate volatility and keep our Agency MBS portfolio largely intact. We were confident that it was just a matter of when, not if spreads would recover and maintaining our portfolio allowed us to capitalize in the spread tightening when it did eventually occur. Speaker 500:12:45During Q4, the market pivot and Fed expectations was the catalyst that led to lower implied and realized volatility, which lowered actual and expected hedging costs and prompted capital inflows from banks and investment funds. If and when the first rate cut occurs later this year, we think that could be another catalyst for continued outperformance for Agency MBS. We were able to take advantage of the market strength to shrink our Agency MBS portfolio incrementally and redeploy that capital into CLOs. That rotation not only enhanced our diversification, but it also took our leverage down significantly and yet we were still able to grow ADE. In Q4, earned CLO portfolio grew by $13,600,000 as we predominantly added seasoned CLO mezzanine tranches, but also longer duration CLO equity, shorter duration CLO equity and newer vintage CLO mezz. Speaker 500:13:42Seasoned mezzanine investments outperformed throughout Q4 as prepayment speeds accelerated and CLO cash balances grew, driving expectations of a deal deleveraging in January and that strong performance has continued into 2024. CLO credit spreads tightened across the board in Q4 with BBBs generally rallying around 30 to 50 bps and BBBs rallying even more, albeit with significant dispersion. However, these sectors lag the high yield corporate bond market, whereby some measures spreads tightened almost 100 basis points for the quarter. Q3 earnings were better than expected for many high yield borrowers with JPMorgan estimating that 86% of high yield companies generated Q3 earnings that were either neutral or positive for their credit profiles. And investors generally grew more comfortable with non investment grade credits in Q4 as fundamentals improved. Speaker 500:14:41Improvements in the leverage loan market drove strength in junior CLO tranches given that they are more levered to credit performance than senior tranches are. This said, the most credit sensitive CLO profiles that is those with the lowest credit enhancement and or most distressed portfolios continued to lag as investors anticipated further credit losses. In Q1 of 2024, we anticipate further strength in our CLO portfolio due to declining credit markets just and continued pull to par in seasoned CLO mezz. Approximately 40% of the leverage loan index traded above par at the end of Q4, which has incentivized lots of borrowers to refinance their debt so far in 2024. This is benefiting both seasoned CLO mezz to faster deal pay downs and CLO equity to lower near term default risk as underlying corporate borrowers raise incremental liquidity. Speaker 500:15:38We also expect the technical backdrop for the leverage loan market to remain attractive as many new CLOs are expected to ramp up portfolios in Q1, driving demand for loans with a forward calendar of loan supply that remains light. Looking ahead, we see lots of reasons to be optimistic about EARN's future performance. The most aggressive Fed hiking campaign ever is now behind us. SOFA went from 0 to over 5% in 14 months. The Fed balance sheet has shrunk by well over $1,000,000,000,000 since its peak post COVID size. Speaker 500:16:13Couple that with large bank failures putting almost 100,000,000,000 of agency MBS and CMOs into the market and you had the recipe for substantial spread widening, which we've seen over the past couple of years. But now the Fed should soon become a tailwind as opposed to a headwind. And looking ahead, in addition to this expected support from the Fed, we see 5 major factors supporting future MBS performance. 1st, spreads are wide, not as wide as October, but still much wider than historical averages and they should be. The Fed is a seller not a buyer and banks while buying are a shadow of their former selves. Speaker 500:16:50But being wide and staying wide works out just fine for EARN. We have a big levered NIM to capture. 2nd, supply and it's especially low relative to the mountain of treasury supply. So relative performance versus hedging instruments are supported by this technical. 3rd, prepayment risk for most coupons is benign and the cost of prepayment protection is reasonable. Speaker 500:17:134th, flows into mutual funds to buy Agency MBS both active and passive has been quite strong as have fixed income annuity sales. Banks have also started to buy in Q4. And 5th, volatility is a lot lower, both actual and implied. So delta hedging costs are lower and that makes option adjusted spreads wider. We have room to add leverage at earn. Speaker 500:17:36We have tools to further grow ADE and CLOs are helping to deliver a diversified return stream. Now back to Larry. Speaker 300:17:45Thanks, Mark. I was pleased with how we navigated the market gyrations throughout 2023 and finished the year on a high note. Now with yield spread still wide on historical basis, with markets expecting cuts instead of hikes and with volatility normalizing, Agency MBS are attracting incremental demand from investors, albeit tempered by uncertainty around the timing of cuts. When those rate cuts eventually come and we ultimately see a steep yield curve again that should be a further tailwind to the sector. I'm excited about our growing corporate CLO portfolio. Speaker 300:18:22EARN's small size and liquid portfolio has been an advantage here as we've been able to ramp up quickly in a terrific strategy where we see a big opportunity for EARN. While Ellington has long standing and deep experience managing CLO portfolios, EARN began investing in that product just this past September and that pivot is already contributing nicely to earnings. Including investments through today, CLO investments are now a full 17% allocation of EARN's total equity. I expect them to be a significant driver of earnings and ADE moving forward. The CLO market has proven its ability to generate attractive returns over market cycles and over a long term horizon. Speaker 300:19:05In the short term and as Mark mentioned, credit spread tightening in some segments of the CLO market has continued to lag a larger rally in corporate bond credit spreads and we expect that money manager inflows into high yield and leverage loans will help narrow that gap. As Mark also mentioned, we expect faster leverage loan prepayment speeds to drive faster prepayments on many of our seasoned CLO mezzanine positions, we hold at significant discounts to par. We've grown earned CLO portfolio by another 70% so far in 2024 And these discounted season CLO mezzanine positions have continued to be a focus of ours given their total return potential in an environment with this potential for higher loan prepayment speeds. The CLO market suits EARN extremely well. It not only offers high current interest income, but it has always been a fertile ground for both relative value and absolute value opportunities as well as for trading opportunities given the dispersion in collateral credit performance from deal to deal. Speaker 300:20:09Going forward, Ellington's extensive expertise and track record in the CLO market should be a big benefit for EARN. Our CLO portfolio has continued to contribute nicely to our results so far in 2024, but net losses in Agency MBS have led to an overall economic return for EARN that we currently estimate at negative 1.9% year to date through February. The Agency MBS market has underperformed many other fixed income sectors so far in 2024 driven by higher rates and uncertainty around the timing of Federal Reserve rate cuts. This of course follows a strong Q4 for Agency MBS, which led to the positive 7.7 percent non annualized economic return that we generated last quarter. For the past few years, it's undeniable that Agency MBS has been a volatile strategy for all the Agency mortgage REITs including EARN. Speaker 300:21:02But I firmly believe that our CLO strategy will prove to be a less volatile strategy and thereby stabilize and enhance EARN's returns over time. With that, we'll now open the call to questions. Operator, please go ahead. Operator00:21:16Thank Our first question will come from Doug Harter with UBS. Please go ahead. Speaker 600:21:36Thanks. Can you talk a little bit more about how you see the equity allocation to CLOs playing out, kind of how much of equity could this be? Speaker 300:21:52Hi, Doug. How are you doing? Speaker 500:21:54Good morning. Good Speaker 300:21:56morning. Yes. So I guess, it's I'm not going to answer that question directly. I'm just going to say that I love this strategy. We have a great team here and a great track record. Speaker 300:22:14The more the better as far as I'm concerned. We as you know, we have constraints that we operate under as a REIT. We have the REIT tests, which are effectively mostly income based. And at 40 Act, we have tests, which are mostly more sort of capital allocation based, but it also depends on your financing strategy, your subsidiary structure. So we continue to grow and I don't want to try to forecast where it's going. Speaker 600:22:50Okay. And then I guess just as you think about risk adjusted returns kind of comparing agency and CLOs, how do you think about kind of the upside, downside in each to kind of the base case and kind of how that factors into kind of where you want to be? Speaker 300:23:11Sure. Well, first of all, from a NIM perspective, you can see that, I think Chris mentioned our the NIM on our agency portfolio was probably in the low 200s, something like that. And the credit portfolio, including CLOs, I think 600. So even with a small bit of leverage, the CLO portfolio generates a greater leverage NIM, dollar for dollar. Spreads have tightened. Speaker 300:23:43You can sort of see if you go back to Slide 3, you can sort of see it differs based on coupon. But if you look at 4.5s, for example, in the ZV spread, I'm just looking at year end, something around the 9,100 level, even if you leverage that a fair bit, you're still not quite there versus where you are on the CLO portfolio on a leveraged in basis. So now the CLO portfolio obviously has kind of tail credit risk in a especially in a deep recession or something like that. So that's a factor for sure. It also has much fewer delta hedging costs, right? Speaker 300:24:21I mean the thing that's been really tough for agency REITs including us for the last few years is these big moves in the market, big gyrations in rates cause and for us we like to stay hedged in interest rates and that's frankly over a long period of time that's been key to our success. But it really cuts into book value over time, those delta hedging costs. And ultimately, that's going to cut into your dividend as well, right? So yes, so the other thing though I would say is from a trading perspective, like given the liquidity of agency, the opportunity for trading profits including dialing up and down to what extent we hedge with TBAs is probably that opportunity is probably greater in agencies because if you can make a point just this is a hypothetical. If you can make a point on your assets by being timely in terms of when you add, when you take off, how you hedge, that's leveraging that 7 or 8 times. Speaker 300:25:29I mean that's a massive amount of boost to earnings. So there's a lot of pros and cons, right, for each sector. And there are opportunities for trading gains as well in CLOs. But it's not I wouldn't say that the assets that we're buying there are super liquid. So it's they're different. Speaker 300:25:50And like I said, we I love the strategy and I'd love to continue to see this grow as much as Speaker 600:25:59possible in CLOs. I appreciate that. Thank you. Operator00:26:04And our next question will come from Nikhil Goberman with Citizens JMP. Please go ahead. Speaker 700:26:11Hey, good morning, everybody. Hope everyone's doing well. First question, I guess, is did I hear correctly that you said book value was down about 1.9% thus far this year? Was that total economic return? Speaker 300:26:25Total economic return. Speaker 700:26:27Okay, cool. Thank you. Speaker 200:26:28Yes, I think that was through the end of February. Speaker 700:26:32Right, so including the 2 dividends. What are you guys targeting a sort of leverage ratio range going forward given the sort of dip the pretty dramatic dip that the leverage ratio took in the 4th quarter? Is there an area that you're sort of trying to get to? Speaker 300:26:56It's just a blend of really the appropriate leverage for each asset class, right? So for agencies, we've taken it up into the 9s before in terms of leverage. And in non agencies and now in CLOs, we've had almost no leverage. We but we'll start to add leverage to CLO portfolio at some point. And as I well, maybe I didn't mention it exactly in answering the first question, but Speaker 500:27:23you can Speaker 300:27:24comfortably have half a turn of leverage on CLOs. So it's just going to be a blend of where the capital allocation is. And of course, in agencies, we also depending on the opportunity that kind of upper limit of something in the 9 to 1 leverage area, yes, we can always go lower than that. And as I said a few seconds ago, the sometimes we do that because we do want to take advantage of the spread volatility to sort of buy low and sell high, if you will, throughout the year. Speaker 700:28:04Got you. Thank you for that. And one more if I could, this is sort of a longer term question. What are you guys thoughts on what kind of interest rate environment it would take for to see a meaningful pickup in prepay speeds sort of back towards, I guess, historical levels of a few years ago? Speaker 300:28:23Mark? Speaker 200:28:25Yes. So it's sort of interesting. We got a we get the prepayment reports monthly and we got one last night. And what I would say is that while prepayment speeds serve an aggregate have been benign, Technological improvements including AI is definitely something that is being embraced by some of the big non bank lenders. And so there are pockets of the market. Speaker 200:28:57If you look at sort of their Ginnie pools out there now that pay over 80 CPR from these real high coupon ones with a lot of VA. What we were getting at or what I was getting at in the prepared remarks is that if you there's the vast majority of what's out there is still a couple of 100 basis points away from being refinanceable. There's you have a lot of runway in rates for many of the coupons that we own that and so you have to worry about prepayments. And the other thing I would say is that it's not real expensive to buy prepayment protection. So it's not as though prepayments don't exist and mortgage bankers aren't going to be aggressive about trying to solicit refis when they can. Speaker 200:29:48They certainly will be. It's just the vast majority of the market and the vast majority of what we own, you still have a lot of it would take still a significant move in rates to get it refinancable. And so but still look rates are unpredictable, implied volatility is high. Even though the forward curve predicts rates are coming down, there's a lot of dispersion around it. So still for most coupons pricing, some of the higher coupons we're still choosing to buy pools with prepayment protection. Speaker 200:30:24We think it's relatively affordable. And one thing that was a big part of last year was looking for pools. And I think we mentioned it a few calls ago, looking for specified pools that have faster than market projected prepayment speeds and that certainly helped us when you get into things like 2.5s and 3s and 3.5s. We have big discounts even finding pools your 1 or 2 CPR faster makes a huge difference in yield. So prepayment modeling, prepayment speeds, prepayment risk, it's still out there. Speaker 200:30:54It's just right now given the current distribution of coupons in the market, the real scary prepayments are only affecting a very small subset of what's out there and that's sector that we have avoided. But we I'm not surprised to see some of these very fast prepayment speeds because there's still a lot of capacity within the mortgage banking community and the technology has gotten better. And so we look for them to be aggressive whenever they have opportunities to be aggressive on refis. Speaker 700:31:29Got you. Thank you, Mark. And as always, best of luck guys going forward. Thanks. Speaker 200:31:33Thank you. Thank you. Operator00:31:37And our next question will come from Matthew Ertner with Jones Trading. Please go ahead. Speaker 800:31:43Hey guys, thanks for taking the question. Kind of following up on that CPR, you guys took off some of the lower coupons during the quarter. Could you kind of talk through the thoughts there? Yes. We just saw opportunities during the quarter Speaker 200:32:00to rotate up in coupon. I think our portfolio went up about 10 basis points or so in coupon. The relative performance of lower coupons versus current coupons is really impacted by flows into the big bond indices, right? So if you look at the mortgage index or you look at the distribution of mortgage coupons in something like the Barclays AG, it's heavily weighted to 2s and 2.5s. And so the relative performance of those coupons is very much impacted by flows into the ag. Speaker 200:32:38And there's a couple of real big $100,000,000,000 plus ETFs that track the ag. So we saw opportunities where a lot of flows came into ag type portfolios where lower coupons outperformed. We saw an opportunity to go up in coupon. We thought it would add certainly adds ADE. We thought it would also add total return. Speaker 200:33:03So we'll continue to be opportunistic about that. Speaker 800:33:07That's helpful there. And then allocating capital to CLOs, continuing that strategy, are there any other places where you feel like you guys could opportunistically deploy additional capital for total return? Speaker 300:33:21That's where we're focusing on now, no. Speaker 800:33:24Okay. Thank you. Operator00:33:28And our next question will come from Eric Hagen with BTIG. Please go ahead. Speaker 900:33:34Hey, thanks. Good morning. Hope all is well. One more on just kind of the market dynamics. I mean, what do you feel like would support more dollar roll specialness in the market? Speaker 900:33:41Do you feel like it's reasonable to expect that that could come back if there's any changes to Fed policy? Speaker 200:33:49I would say that for some of these higher coupons, I think the dollar rolls have predictably gotten weaker because you've sort of built up now an array of kind of faster paying pools. If you look at things like Fannie 6 now, they've been production for a few months, you have some pools that have come up the seasoning ramp. So I don't look for specialness to be there. In the lower coupons, you can get specialness if you get a lot of flows, I was talking before about into these Ag indices because when money comes into an Ag Index and whoever is managing it wants to buy a bunch of Fannie Twos and 2.5s to get there to minimize tracking error, you really need to get that from other investors, right? They initially will buy from the primary dealers, but the primary dealers are then going to want to buy that from other portfolios. Speaker 200:34:42And a lot of those bonds are locked up in the Fed and locked up in banks. There's obviously news on Truist a week or so ago. And when that news came out, it caused lower coupons to underperform. So I think in the lower coupon stuff, you can see some more volatility in the rolls. But still there, we tend to find if you're thoughtful about fast paying pools, you can find pools that pick up carry versus the rolls. Speaker 200:35:11So I don't see a lot of specialness going forward for the higher end production coupons where you're starting to see a float that's faster. And I think for the lower coupon stuff, you can see it, but it's kind of month to month. Like there was a month ago, I think the Ginnie II III roll was special. So you get sort of these one off things. But where most of the production is centered, I don't think you're going to have a lot of specialists, which is really a big difference from the 2021 period where production was Fannie Twos and 2.5s and they were routinely special and everyone spoke about that and they were special because the Fed and banks were buying so much and they weren't rollers. Speaker 200:35:57That we don't have that dynamic right now. So the way the rolls work out, I think it favors in aggregate having more specified pools and less TBA. And I think broadly that's sort of how the industry has moved, the REIT industry. Speaker 600:36:14Yes. Hey, that's a good Speaker 900:36:16perspective. As far as running the portfolio, I mean, what do you guys feel like is the minimum level of liquidity you feel comfortable with having it at these spread levels? Like how much do you feel comfortable with ahead of the Fed cut versus like a cut actually taking place? Do you feel like that would be a catalyst to carry more leverage? Or is it potentially conditional on other factors? Speaker 200:36:37We mentioned in the prepared remarks that if you look at work on Bloomberg or whatever else, people are predicting cuts this year. I think when they if and when they actually happen, I do think that will be a catalyst for some incremental buying. So I do think that will be supportive. In terms of how we manage our cash, we don't that is sort of sacrosanct in that we're going to manage our cash according to market stresses and according to the repo roll calendar and we won't change sort of the guardrails we have around minimum levels of cash as a function of what the Fed is going to do. That we just that's how we run it's how we run EARN, that's how we run EFC, how we run private funds that there is a certain amount of cash we're going to keep on hand. Speaker 200:37:41And the way we determine that is it's sort of a it looks at the portfolio and looks at the leverage and looks at where things can go in a shock. And then with the agency stuff, you have to look at there's a calendar to it. So you get new factors when the prepayments come out. So we got new factors yesterday. Repo lenders did margin call you versus lower balance, but you don't actually get that cash to the 25th. Speaker 200:38:06So there's a calendar component to it. But we have room to add leverage. We mentioned that in the prepared remarks, but it's not because we're going to change the way we manage the cash. Speaker 500:38:18But I'd say sort of the Speaker 200:38:20way we manage the cash is something that we've been doing for a long time. I think it served us very well, certainly served us extremely well in stresses like during COVID. But away from that, EARN has plenty of liquidity to it's been putting more capital in the CLOs we've spoken about, but it still has more room to leverage just the general pool strategy as well. Speaker 600:38:46Yes. Hey, thank you guys so much. Speaker 800:38:50Thank you, Eric. Speaker 300:38:52Thanks. Operator00:38:55And that was our final question for today. Thank you for participating in the Ellington Residential Mortgage REIT 4th Quarter 20 23 Earnings Conference Call. You may disconnect your line at this time and have a wonderful day.Read morePowered by Conference Call Audio Live Call not available Earnings Conference CallEllington Credit Q4 202300:00 / 00:00Speed:1x1.25x1.5x2x Earnings DocumentsSlide DeckPress Release(8-K)Annual report(10-K) Ellington Credit Earnings HeadlinesWall Street's Most Accurate Analysts Give Their Take On 3 Financial Stocks With Over 10% Dividend YieldsMay 5 at 8:32 AM | benzinga.comUBS Adjusts Price Target for Ellington Credit (EARN) Amid Economic Uncertainty | EARN Stock NewsApril 17, 2025 | gurufocus.comBlackrock’s Sending THIS Crypto Higher on PurposeWhile everyone's distracted by Bitcoin's moves, a stealth revolution is underway. One altcoin is quietly positioning itself to overthrow the entire banking system.May 7, 2025 | Crypto 101 Media (Ad)Ellington Credit Company EARNApril 11, 2025 | morningstar.comEllington Credit: A New Entrant To The CLO SectorApril 10, 2025 | seekingalpha.comEllington Credit: A New Entrant To The CLO SectorApril 10, 2025 | seekingalpha.comSee More Ellington Credit Headlines Get Earnings Announcements in your inboxWant to stay updated on the latest earnings announcements and upcoming reports for companies like Ellington Credit? Sign up for Earnings360's daily newsletter to receive timely earnings updates on Ellington Credit and other key companies, straight to your email. Email Address About Ellington CreditEllington Credit (NYSE:EARN) Company, a real estate investment trust, acquires, invests in, and manages residential mortgage-and real estate-related assets. It acquires and manages residential mortgage-backed securities (RMBS), including agency pools and agency collateralized mortgage obligations (CMOs); and non-agency RMBS, such as non-agency CMOs, such as investment grade and non-investment grade. The company has elected to be taxed as a real estate investment trust. As a result, it would not be subject to corporate income tax on that portion of its net income that is distributed to shareholders. The company was formerly known as Ellington Residential Mortgage REIT and changed its name to Ellington Credit Company in April 2024. Ellington Credit Company was incorporated in 2012 and is based in Old Greenwich, Connecticut.View Ellington Credit ProfileRead more More Earnings Resources from MarketBeat Earnings Tools Today's Earnings Tomorrow's Earnings Next Week's Earnings Upcoming Earnings Calls Earnings Newsletter Earnings Call Transcripts Earnings Beats & Misses Corporate Guidance Earnings Screener Earnings By Country U.S. Earnings Reports Canadian Earnings Reports U.K. Earnings Reports Latest Articles Archer Stock Eyes Q1 Earnings After UAE UpdatesFord Motor Stock Rises After Earnings, But Momentum May Not Last Broadcom Stock Gets a Lift on Hyperscaler Earnings & CapEx BoostPalantir Stock Drops Despite Stellar Earnings: What's Next?Is Eli Lilly a Buy After Weak Earnings and CVS-Novo Partnership?Is Reddit Stock a Buy, Sell, or Hold After Earnings Release?Warning or Opportunity After Super Micro Computer's Earnings Upcoming Earnings Monster Beverage (5/8/2025)Coinbase Global (5/8/2025)Brookfield (5/8/2025)Anheuser-Busch InBev SA/NV (5/8/2025)ConocoPhillips (5/8/2025)Shopify (5/8/2025)Cheniere Energy (5/8/2025)McKesson (5/8/2025)Enbridge (5/9/2025)Petróleo Brasileiro S.A. - Petrobras (5/12/2025) Get 30 Days of MarketBeat All Access for Free Sign up for MarketBeat All Access to gain access to MarketBeat's full suite of research tools. Start Your 30-Day Trial MarketBeat All Access Features Best-in-Class Portfolio Monitoring Get personalized stock ideas. Compare portfolio to indices. Check stock news, ratings, SEC filings, and more. Stock Ideas and Recommendations See daily stock ideas from top analysts. Receive short-term trading ideas from MarketBeat. Identify trending stocks on social media. Advanced Stock Screeners and Research Tools Use our seven stock screeners to find suitable stocks. Stay informed with MarketBeat's real-time news. Export data to Excel for personal analysis. Sign in to your free account to enjoy these benefits In-depth profiles and analysis for 20,000 public companies. Real-time analyst ratings, insider transactions, earnings data, and more. Our daily ratings and market update email newsletter. Sign in to your free account to enjoy all that MarketBeat has to offer. Sign In Create Account Your Email Address: Email Address Required Your Password: Password Required Log In or Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google Forgot your password? Your Email Address: Please enter your email address. Please enter a valid email address Choose a Password: Please enter your password. Your password must be at least 8 characters long and contain at least 1 number, 1 letter, and 1 special character. Create My Account (Free) or Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google By creating a free account, you agree to our terms of service. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
There are 10 speakers on the call. Operator00:00:00Thank you for standing by, and welcome to the Ellington Residential Mortgage REIT 2023 Quarter Financial Results Conference Call. Today's call is being recorded. And at this time, all participants have been placed It is now my pleasure to turn the conference over to Aladdin Shillelai, Associate General Counsel. Operator00:00:36Sir, you may begin. Speaker 100:00:41Thank you. Before we begin, I would like to remind everyone that certain statements made during this conference call may constitute forward looking statements within the meaning of the Safe Harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Forward looking statements are not historical in nature and are subject to a variety of risks and uncertainties that could cause the company's actual results to differ from its beliefs, expectations, estimates and projections. Consequently, you should not rely on these forward looking statements as predictions of future events. We strongly encourage you to review the information that we have filed with the SEC, including the earnings release and the Form 10 ks for more information regarding these forward looking statements and any related risks and uncertainties. Speaker 100:01:24Unless otherwise noted, statements made during this conference call are made as of the date of this call and the company undertakes no obligation to update or revise any forward looking statements whether as a result of new information, future events or otherwise. Joining me on the call today are Larry Penn, Chief Executive Officer of Allington Residential Mark Zekotsky, our Co Chief Investment Officer and Chris Smernoff, our Chief Financial Officer. As described in our earnings press release, our Q4 earnings conference call presentation is available on our website, earnreit.com. Our comments this morning will track to the presentation. Please note that any references to figures in this presentation are qualified in their entirety by the notes at the back of the presentation. Speaker 100:02:07With that, I will now turn the Speaker 200:02:09call over to Larry. Speaker 300:02:11Thanks, Eladine, and good morning, everyone. We appreciate your time and interest in Ellington Residential. As with much of 2023, in the Q4 markets gyrated between a sell off and a rally with tumultuous October giving way to a market rally in November December. In October, interest rate volatility spiked as U. S. Speaker 300:02:32Treasury yields rose to 15 year highs and that drove yield spreads sharply wider on most fixed income products. Markets then reversed course in anticipation of the conclusion of the Federal Reserve's hiking cycle with interest rates and volatility both declining into year end. With rates lower and trading in a more stable range, demand for spread products picked up and capital flowed into fixed income funds. With the notable exception of CMBS, which has its own unique challenges, virtually all fixed income spreads tightened for the Q4, including in the markets where EARN invests, namely agency and non agency RMBS and now corporate CLOs, where we've been investing to an ever increasing extent after our recent pivot. Turning to the investor presentation. Speaker 300:03:23On Slide 3, you can see that medium and long term interest rates despite spiking to multiyear highs in October actually declined overall for the quarter. And the 30 year Freddie mortgage survey rate despite reaching a 23 year high mid quarter also finished lower on the quarter. Incredibly, despite all of the fluctuations during the year, both the 10 year treasury yield and the 30 year mortgage survey rate finished 2023 within one basis point of where they started the year as you can see here on this slide as well. As the backdrop for our mortgage backed securities portfolio, you can also see on Slide 3 that option adjusted yield spreads tightened across agency coupons during the Q4 and that the most pronounced price increases were on lower and intermediate coupons. Dollar prices on Fannie 2.5s through 4.5s were up more than 5 points sequentially. Speaker 300:04:18The outperformance of those coupons benefited EARN's Agency MBS portfolio specifically because coming into the quarter roughly 2 thirds of our Agency MBS had coupons of 4.5% or less. Meanwhile, as the backdrop for our CLO portfolio, corporate credit spreads followed a similar pattern, first widening in October and then tightening in November December and tightening overall for the quarter as an economic soft landing narrative permeated the market. You can see on the bottom of Slide 3 that credit spreads on both high yield and investment grade tightened significantly over the quarter, while prices on the Morningstar LSTA Leveraged Loan Index rose. Turning now to EARNS results. In the Q4, we generated net income of $0.75 per share and a non annualized economic return of 7.7%, while our adjusted distributable earnings grew to $0.27 per share and more than covered our dividend. Speaker 300:05:19As with other market disruptions we've seen before, the key in the Q4 was to avoid forced selling when the market sold off in October in order to preserve equity and earnings power and be in a position to participate in the subsequent market recovery. In the Q4, we again relied on EARN's risk management and strong liquidity position to accomplish this. That said, we did sell pools in the 4th quarter to free up capital from MBS to CLOs and the majority of our sales took place in November as yield spreads were tightening. We ended up increasing the size of our CLO portfolio by $13,600,000 during the quarter. On slide 12 of the earnings presentation, you can see some of the underlying characteristics of our CLO portfolio as of year end. Speaker 300:06:04The corporate loans underlying our CLO investments span a diverse array of industries and the overwhelming majority are floating rate, 1st lien, senior secured loans. Our rotation into CLOs has continued into the New Year with our agency portfolio now incrementally smaller and the size of our CLO portfolio now up an additional 70% from year end to approximately $30,000,000 Even after the recent credit spread tightening in the sector, we still see returns on equity for new CLO investments in the high teens to low 20s. Besides contributing to and diversifying earnings GAAP results, our high yielding CLO investments have also helped drive the substantial growth of our net interest margin and thereby have supported our ADE as well. In addition, because we employ less leverage on our CLOs compared to agency, the portfolio rotation has also driven down our leverage ratios. At year end, our debt to equity ratio adjusted for unsettled trades declined to 5.3:one down from 7.3:one at September 30. Speaker 300:07:13I'll now pass it over to Chris to review our financial results for the Q4 in more detail. Speaker 400:07:19Thank you, Larry, and good morning, everyone. Please turn to Slide 5 for a summary of Ellington Residential's 4th quarter financial results. For the quarter ended December 31, we reported net income of $0.75 per share and adjusted distributable earnings of $0.27 per share. AD excludes the catch up amortization adjustment, which was positive $566,000 in the 4th quarter. During the quarter, positive net interest income and net gains on our Agency MBS significantly exceeded net losses on our hedges, driving strong performance from our Agency portfolio. Speaker 400:07:56Our CLO portfolio also generated strong returns driven by net interest income and net gains as did our non agency RMBS and interest only portfolios. On Slide 5, you can see that our overall net interest margin expanded to 2.19% from 1.34% quarter over quarter, which drove the increase in ADE. Broken out by product, our agency NIM increased to 2.02% from 1.26%, driven by higher asset yields and a lower cost of funds. Meanwhile, our credit NIM, which includes CLOs and non agency RMBS, increased to 6.28% from 4.55%, boosted by high asset yields on our larger CLO portfolio. Please turn now to our balance sheet on Slide 6. Speaker 400:08:48Book value per share was $7.32@yearend compared to $7.02 per share at December 30. Including the $0.24 per share in dividends in the quarter, our economic return for the quarter was 7.7%. We ended the quarter with $61,000,000 in cash plus unencumbered assets, which was approximately 45 percent of total equity. Next, please turn to Slide 7 for a summary of our portfolio holdings. Our agency RMBS holdings decreased by 8% sequentially to $728,000,000 as of December 31, as net sales and paydowns exceeded net gains. Speaker 400:09:28Our Agency MBS portfolio turnover was 25% for the quarter. Our aggregate holdings of non agency RMBS and interest only securities also shrunk in size by 13% quarter over quarter. Over the same period, we increased our CLO holdings more than fourfold to $17,400,000 as of December 31, compared to $3,800,000 as of September 30. At year end, our deployed equity was allocated 89% to mortgage related securities and 11% to CLOs. Our debt to equity ratio adjusted for unsettled trades decreased to 5.3x as of December 31 as compared to 7.3x as of September 30. Speaker 400:10:15The decline was primarily due to an increase in shareholders' equity and a significantly lower leverage on the CLO portfolio relative to our agency holdings. Similarly, our net mortgage asset to equity ratio decreased to 6.5 times from 7.2 times over the same period, despite our holdings holding a net long TBA position at December 31 as compared to a net short TBA position at September 30. On slide 9, you can see the details of our interest rate hedging portfolio. During the quarter, we continue to hedge interest rate risk primarily through the use of interest rate swaps. We ended the 4th quarter with a net long TBA position on a notional basis, but a small net short position as measured by 10 year equivalents. Speaker 400:11:07Lastly, on Slide 12, you can see that nearly all of the loans underlying our CLO portfolio are floating rate and as such carry minimal interest rate risk. I will now turn our presentation over to Mark. Speaker 500:11:22Thanks, Chris. The 4th quarter was really a tale of 2 markets. The 1st part of the quarter was characterized by a continued rate sell off, wider spreads, fund outflows and market uncertainty about how high the Fed would need to hike short rates before achieving a noticeable improvement on inflation. But then starting in late October early November with economic indicators and comments from Chairman Powell pointing to a possible end to the rate hike cycle, markets started to make a U-turn. Rates dropped, spreads tightened and there was a significant fund in bank buying of Agency MBS and other spread products. Speaker 500:12:03In Agency, sector outperformance in the 2nd part of the quarter exceeded underperformance in the 1st part. And overall for the quarter, Agency MBS significantly outperformed hedging instruments. I'm happy to report that EARN was well positioned to capture this agency outperformance, posting a total economic return of almost 8% for the quarter. During the market sell off in the 1st part of the quarter, we were able to manage the interest rate volatility and keep our Agency MBS portfolio largely intact. We were confident that it was just a matter of when, not if spreads would recover and maintaining our portfolio allowed us to capitalize in the spread tightening when it did eventually occur. Speaker 500:12:45During Q4, the market pivot and Fed expectations was the catalyst that led to lower implied and realized volatility, which lowered actual and expected hedging costs and prompted capital inflows from banks and investment funds. If and when the first rate cut occurs later this year, we think that could be another catalyst for continued outperformance for Agency MBS. We were able to take advantage of the market strength to shrink our Agency MBS portfolio incrementally and redeploy that capital into CLOs. That rotation not only enhanced our diversification, but it also took our leverage down significantly and yet we were still able to grow ADE. In Q4, earned CLO portfolio grew by $13,600,000 as we predominantly added seasoned CLO mezzanine tranches, but also longer duration CLO equity, shorter duration CLO equity and newer vintage CLO mezz. Speaker 500:13:42Seasoned mezzanine investments outperformed throughout Q4 as prepayment speeds accelerated and CLO cash balances grew, driving expectations of a deal deleveraging in January and that strong performance has continued into 2024. CLO credit spreads tightened across the board in Q4 with BBBs generally rallying around 30 to 50 bps and BBBs rallying even more, albeit with significant dispersion. However, these sectors lag the high yield corporate bond market, whereby some measures spreads tightened almost 100 basis points for the quarter. Q3 earnings were better than expected for many high yield borrowers with JPMorgan estimating that 86% of high yield companies generated Q3 earnings that were either neutral or positive for their credit profiles. And investors generally grew more comfortable with non investment grade credits in Q4 as fundamentals improved. Speaker 500:14:41Improvements in the leverage loan market drove strength in junior CLO tranches given that they are more levered to credit performance than senior tranches are. This said, the most credit sensitive CLO profiles that is those with the lowest credit enhancement and or most distressed portfolios continued to lag as investors anticipated further credit losses. In Q1 of 2024, we anticipate further strength in our CLO portfolio due to declining credit markets just and continued pull to par in seasoned CLO mezz. Approximately 40% of the leverage loan index traded above par at the end of Q4, which has incentivized lots of borrowers to refinance their debt so far in 2024. This is benefiting both seasoned CLO mezz to faster deal pay downs and CLO equity to lower near term default risk as underlying corporate borrowers raise incremental liquidity. Speaker 500:15:38We also expect the technical backdrop for the leverage loan market to remain attractive as many new CLOs are expected to ramp up portfolios in Q1, driving demand for loans with a forward calendar of loan supply that remains light. Looking ahead, we see lots of reasons to be optimistic about EARN's future performance. The most aggressive Fed hiking campaign ever is now behind us. SOFA went from 0 to over 5% in 14 months. The Fed balance sheet has shrunk by well over $1,000,000,000,000 since its peak post COVID size. Speaker 500:16:13Couple that with large bank failures putting almost 100,000,000,000 of agency MBS and CMOs into the market and you had the recipe for substantial spread widening, which we've seen over the past couple of years. But now the Fed should soon become a tailwind as opposed to a headwind. And looking ahead, in addition to this expected support from the Fed, we see 5 major factors supporting future MBS performance. 1st, spreads are wide, not as wide as October, but still much wider than historical averages and they should be. The Fed is a seller not a buyer and banks while buying are a shadow of their former selves. Speaker 500:16:50But being wide and staying wide works out just fine for EARN. We have a big levered NIM to capture. 2nd, supply and it's especially low relative to the mountain of treasury supply. So relative performance versus hedging instruments are supported by this technical. 3rd, prepayment risk for most coupons is benign and the cost of prepayment protection is reasonable. Speaker 500:17:134th, flows into mutual funds to buy Agency MBS both active and passive has been quite strong as have fixed income annuity sales. Banks have also started to buy in Q4. And 5th, volatility is a lot lower, both actual and implied. So delta hedging costs are lower and that makes option adjusted spreads wider. We have room to add leverage at earn. Speaker 500:17:36We have tools to further grow ADE and CLOs are helping to deliver a diversified return stream. Now back to Larry. Speaker 300:17:45Thanks, Mark. I was pleased with how we navigated the market gyrations throughout 2023 and finished the year on a high note. Now with yield spread still wide on historical basis, with markets expecting cuts instead of hikes and with volatility normalizing, Agency MBS are attracting incremental demand from investors, albeit tempered by uncertainty around the timing of cuts. When those rate cuts eventually come and we ultimately see a steep yield curve again that should be a further tailwind to the sector. I'm excited about our growing corporate CLO portfolio. Speaker 300:18:22EARN's small size and liquid portfolio has been an advantage here as we've been able to ramp up quickly in a terrific strategy where we see a big opportunity for EARN. While Ellington has long standing and deep experience managing CLO portfolios, EARN began investing in that product just this past September and that pivot is already contributing nicely to earnings. Including investments through today, CLO investments are now a full 17% allocation of EARN's total equity. I expect them to be a significant driver of earnings and ADE moving forward. The CLO market has proven its ability to generate attractive returns over market cycles and over a long term horizon. Speaker 300:19:05In the short term and as Mark mentioned, credit spread tightening in some segments of the CLO market has continued to lag a larger rally in corporate bond credit spreads and we expect that money manager inflows into high yield and leverage loans will help narrow that gap. As Mark also mentioned, we expect faster leverage loan prepayment speeds to drive faster prepayments on many of our seasoned CLO mezzanine positions, we hold at significant discounts to par. We've grown earned CLO portfolio by another 70% so far in 2024 And these discounted season CLO mezzanine positions have continued to be a focus of ours given their total return potential in an environment with this potential for higher loan prepayment speeds. The CLO market suits EARN extremely well. It not only offers high current interest income, but it has always been a fertile ground for both relative value and absolute value opportunities as well as for trading opportunities given the dispersion in collateral credit performance from deal to deal. Speaker 300:20:09Going forward, Ellington's extensive expertise and track record in the CLO market should be a big benefit for EARN. Our CLO portfolio has continued to contribute nicely to our results so far in 2024, but net losses in Agency MBS have led to an overall economic return for EARN that we currently estimate at negative 1.9% year to date through February. The Agency MBS market has underperformed many other fixed income sectors so far in 2024 driven by higher rates and uncertainty around the timing of Federal Reserve rate cuts. This of course follows a strong Q4 for Agency MBS, which led to the positive 7.7 percent non annualized economic return that we generated last quarter. For the past few years, it's undeniable that Agency MBS has been a volatile strategy for all the Agency mortgage REITs including EARN. Speaker 300:21:02But I firmly believe that our CLO strategy will prove to be a less volatile strategy and thereby stabilize and enhance EARN's returns over time. With that, we'll now open the call to questions. Operator, please go ahead. Operator00:21:16Thank Our first question will come from Doug Harter with UBS. Please go ahead. Speaker 600:21:36Thanks. Can you talk a little bit more about how you see the equity allocation to CLOs playing out, kind of how much of equity could this be? Speaker 300:21:52Hi, Doug. How are you doing? Speaker 500:21:54Good morning. Good Speaker 300:21:56morning. Yes. So I guess, it's I'm not going to answer that question directly. I'm just going to say that I love this strategy. We have a great team here and a great track record. Speaker 300:22:14The more the better as far as I'm concerned. We as you know, we have constraints that we operate under as a REIT. We have the REIT tests, which are effectively mostly income based. And at 40 Act, we have tests, which are mostly more sort of capital allocation based, but it also depends on your financing strategy, your subsidiary structure. So we continue to grow and I don't want to try to forecast where it's going. Speaker 600:22:50Okay. And then I guess just as you think about risk adjusted returns kind of comparing agency and CLOs, how do you think about kind of the upside, downside in each to kind of the base case and kind of how that factors into kind of where you want to be? Speaker 300:23:11Sure. Well, first of all, from a NIM perspective, you can see that, I think Chris mentioned our the NIM on our agency portfolio was probably in the low 200s, something like that. And the credit portfolio, including CLOs, I think 600. So even with a small bit of leverage, the CLO portfolio generates a greater leverage NIM, dollar for dollar. Spreads have tightened. Speaker 300:23:43You can sort of see if you go back to Slide 3, you can sort of see it differs based on coupon. But if you look at 4.5s, for example, in the ZV spread, I'm just looking at year end, something around the 9,100 level, even if you leverage that a fair bit, you're still not quite there versus where you are on the CLO portfolio on a leveraged in basis. So now the CLO portfolio obviously has kind of tail credit risk in a especially in a deep recession or something like that. So that's a factor for sure. It also has much fewer delta hedging costs, right? Speaker 300:24:21I mean the thing that's been really tough for agency REITs including us for the last few years is these big moves in the market, big gyrations in rates cause and for us we like to stay hedged in interest rates and that's frankly over a long period of time that's been key to our success. But it really cuts into book value over time, those delta hedging costs. And ultimately, that's going to cut into your dividend as well, right? So yes, so the other thing though I would say is from a trading perspective, like given the liquidity of agency, the opportunity for trading profits including dialing up and down to what extent we hedge with TBAs is probably that opportunity is probably greater in agencies because if you can make a point just this is a hypothetical. If you can make a point on your assets by being timely in terms of when you add, when you take off, how you hedge, that's leveraging that 7 or 8 times. Speaker 300:25:29I mean that's a massive amount of boost to earnings. So there's a lot of pros and cons, right, for each sector. And there are opportunities for trading gains as well in CLOs. But it's not I wouldn't say that the assets that we're buying there are super liquid. So it's they're different. Speaker 300:25:50And like I said, we I love the strategy and I'd love to continue to see this grow as much as Speaker 600:25:59possible in CLOs. I appreciate that. Thank you. Operator00:26:04And our next question will come from Nikhil Goberman with Citizens JMP. Please go ahead. Speaker 700:26:11Hey, good morning, everybody. Hope everyone's doing well. First question, I guess, is did I hear correctly that you said book value was down about 1.9% thus far this year? Was that total economic return? Speaker 300:26:25Total economic return. Speaker 700:26:27Okay, cool. Thank you. Speaker 200:26:28Yes, I think that was through the end of February. Speaker 700:26:32Right, so including the 2 dividends. What are you guys targeting a sort of leverage ratio range going forward given the sort of dip the pretty dramatic dip that the leverage ratio took in the 4th quarter? Is there an area that you're sort of trying to get to? Speaker 300:26:56It's just a blend of really the appropriate leverage for each asset class, right? So for agencies, we've taken it up into the 9s before in terms of leverage. And in non agencies and now in CLOs, we've had almost no leverage. We but we'll start to add leverage to CLO portfolio at some point. And as I well, maybe I didn't mention it exactly in answering the first question, but Speaker 500:27:23you can Speaker 300:27:24comfortably have half a turn of leverage on CLOs. So it's just going to be a blend of where the capital allocation is. And of course, in agencies, we also depending on the opportunity that kind of upper limit of something in the 9 to 1 leverage area, yes, we can always go lower than that. And as I said a few seconds ago, the sometimes we do that because we do want to take advantage of the spread volatility to sort of buy low and sell high, if you will, throughout the year. Speaker 700:28:04Got you. Thank you for that. And one more if I could, this is sort of a longer term question. What are you guys thoughts on what kind of interest rate environment it would take for to see a meaningful pickup in prepay speeds sort of back towards, I guess, historical levels of a few years ago? Speaker 300:28:23Mark? Speaker 200:28:25Yes. So it's sort of interesting. We got a we get the prepayment reports monthly and we got one last night. And what I would say is that while prepayment speeds serve an aggregate have been benign, Technological improvements including AI is definitely something that is being embraced by some of the big non bank lenders. And so there are pockets of the market. Speaker 200:28:57If you look at sort of their Ginnie pools out there now that pay over 80 CPR from these real high coupon ones with a lot of VA. What we were getting at or what I was getting at in the prepared remarks is that if you there's the vast majority of what's out there is still a couple of 100 basis points away from being refinanceable. There's you have a lot of runway in rates for many of the coupons that we own that and so you have to worry about prepayments. And the other thing I would say is that it's not real expensive to buy prepayment protection. So it's not as though prepayments don't exist and mortgage bankers aren't going to be aggressive about trying to solicit refis when they can. Speaker 200:29:48They certainly will be. It's just the vast majority of the market and the vast majority of what we own, you still have a lot of it would take still a significant move in rates to get it refinancable. And so but still look rates are unpredictable, implied volatility is high. Even though the forward curve predicts rates are coming down, there's a lot of dispersion around it. So still for most coupons pricing, some of the higher coupons we're still choosing to buy pools with prepayment protection. Speaker 200:30:24We think it's relatively affordable. And one thing that was a big part of last year was looking for pools. And I think we mentioned it a few calls ago, looking for specified pools that have faster than market projected prepayment speeds and that certainly helped us when you get into things like 2.5s and 3s and 3.5s. We have big discounts even finding pools your 1 or 2 CPR faster makes a huge difference in yield. So prepayment modeling, prepayment speeds, prepayment risk, it's still out there. Speaker 200:30:54It's just right now given the current distribution of coupons in the market, the real scary prepayments are only affecting a very small subset of what's out there and that's sector that we have avoided. But we I'm not surprised to see some of these very fast prepayment speeds because there's still a lot of capacity within the mortgage banking community and the technology has gotten better. And so we look for them to be aggressive whenever they have opportunities to be aggressive on refis. Speaker 700:31:29Got you. Thank you, Mark. And as always, best of luck guys going forward. Thanks. Speaker 200:31:33Thank you. Thank you. Operator00:31:37And our next question will come from Matthew Ertner with Jones Trading. Please go ahead. Speaker 800:31:43Hey guys, thanks for taking the question. Kind of following up on that CPR, you guys took off some of the lower coupons during the quarter. Could you kind of talk through the thoughts there? Yes. We just saw opportunities during the quarter Speaker 200:32:00to rotate up in coupon. I think our portfolio went up about 10 basis points or so in coupon. The relative performance of lower coupons versus current coupons is really impacted by flows into the big bond indices, right? So if you look at the mortgage index or you look at the distribution of mortgage coupons in something like the Barclays AG, it's heavily weighted to 2s and 2.5s. And so the relative performance of those coupons is very much impacted by flows into the ag. Speaker 200:32:38And there's a couple of real big $100,000,000,000 plus ETFs that track the ag. So we saw opportunities where a lot of flows came into ag type portfolios where lower coupons outperformed. We saw an opportunity to go up in coupon. We thought it would add certainly adds ADE. We thought it would also add total return. Speaker 200:33:03So we'll continue to be opportunistic about that. Speaker 800:33:07That's helpful there. And then allocating capital to CLOs, continuing that strategy, are there any other places where you feel like you guys could opportunistically deploy additional capital for total return? Speaker 300:33:21That's where we're focusing on now, no. Speaker 800:33:24Okay. Thank you. Operator00:33:28And our next question will come from Eric Hagen with BTIG. Please go ahead. Speaker 900:33:34Hey, thanks. Good morning. Hope all is well. One more on just kind of the market dynamics. I mean, what do you feel like would support more dollar roll specialness in the market? Speaker 900:33:41Do you feel like it's reasonable to expect that that could come back if there's any changes to Fed policy? Speaker 200:33:49I would say that for some of these higher coupons, I think the dollar rolls have predictably gotten weaker because you've sort of built up now an array of kind of faster paying pools. If you look at things like Fannie 6 now, they've been production for a few months, you have some pools that have come up the seasoning ramp. So I don't look for specialness to be there. In the lower coupons, you can get specialness if you get a lot of flows, I was talking before about into these Ag indices because when money comes into an Ag Index and whoever is managing it wants to buy a bunch of Fannie Twos and 2.5s to get there to minimize tracking error, you really need to get that from other investors, right? They initially will buy from the primary dealers, but the primary dealers are then going to want to buy that from other portfolios. Speaker 200:34:42And a lot of those bonds are locked up in the Fed and locked up in banks. There's obviously news on Truist a week or so ago. And when that news came out, it caused lower coupons to underperform. So I think in the lower coupon stuff, you can see some more volatility in the rolls. But still there, we tend to find if you're thoughtful about fast paying pools, you can find pools that pick up carry versus the rolls. Speaker 200:35:11So I don't see a lot of specialness going forward for the higher end production coupons where you're starting to see a float that's faster. And I think for the lower coupon stuff, you can see it, but it's kind of month to month. Like there was a month ago, I think the Ginnie II III roll was special. So you get sort of these one off things. But where most of the production is centered, I don't think you're going to have a lot of specialists, which is really a big difference from the 2021 period where production was Fannie Twos and 2.5s and they were routinely special and everyone spoke about that and they were special because the Fed and banks were buying so much and they weren't rollers. Speaker 200:35:57That we don't have that dynamic right now. So the way the rolls work out, I think it favors in aggregate having more specified pools and less TBA. And I think broadly that's sort of how the industry has moved, the REIT industry. Speaker 600:36:14Yes. Hey, that's a good Speaker 900:36:16perspective. As far as running the portfolio, I mean, what do you guys feel like is the minimum level of liquidity you feel comfortable with having it at these spread levels? Like how much do you feel comfortable with ahead of the Fed cut versus like a cut actually taking place? Do you feel like that would be a catalyst to carry more leverage? Or is it potentially conditional on other factors? Speaker 200:36:37We mentioned in the prepared remarks that if you look at work on Bloomberg or whatever else, people are predicting cuts this year. I think when they if and when they actually happen, I do think that will be a catalyst for some incremental buying. So I do think that will be supportive. In terms of how we manage our cash, we don't that is sort of sacrosanct in that we're going to manage our cash according to market stresses and according to the repo roll calendar and we won't change sort of the guardrails we have around minimum levels of cash as a function of what the Fed is going to do. That we just that's how we run it's how we run EARN, that's how we run EFC, how we run private funds that there is a certain amount of cash we're going to keep on hand. Speaker 200:37:41And the way we determine that is it's sort of a it looks at the portfolio and looks at the leverage and looks at where things can go in a shock. And then with the agency stuff, you have to look at there's a calendar to it. So you get new factors when the prepayments come out. So we got new factors yesterday. Repo lenders did margin call you versus lower balance, but you don't actually get that cash to the 25th. Speaker 200:38:06So there's a calendar component to it. But we have room to add leverage. We mentioned that in the prepared remarks, but it's not because we're going to change the way we manage the cash. Speaker 500:38:18But I'd say sort of the Speaker 200:38:20way we manage the cash is something that we've been doing for a long time. I think it served us very well, certainly served us extremely well in stresses like during COVID. But away from that, EARN has plenty of liquidity to it's been putting more capital in the CLOs we've spoken about, but it still has more room to leverage just the general pool strategy as well. Speaker 600:38:46Yes. Hey, thank you guys so much. Speaker 800:38:50Thank you, Eric. Speaker 300:38:52Thanks. Operator00:38:55And that was our final question for today. Thank you for participating in the Ellington Residential Mortgage REIT 4th Quarter 20 23 Earnings Conference Call. You may disconnect your line at this time and have a wonderful day.Read morePowered by