National Bank of Canada Q2 2024 Earnings Call Transcript

There are 13 speakers on the call.

Operator

Good afternoon, and welcome to National Bank of Canada's Second Quarter Results Conference Call. I would now like to turn the meeting over to Marianne Ratti, Vice President and Head of Investor Relations. Please go ahead, Marianne.

Speaker 1

Merci, and good afternoon, everyone. We will begin the call with remarks from Laurent Ferreira, President and CEO Marie Chantal Jain Gras, CFO and Bill Bonnell, Chief Risk Officer. Also present for the Q and A session are Jisib Blanchet, Head of Personal Banking and Client Experience Michael Denham, Head of Commercial and Private Banking Nancy Paquette, Head of Wealth Management Etienne Dubuc, Head of Financial Markets, also responsible for CreditG and Stephane Achon, Head of International, responsible for ABA Bank. Before we begin, I would like to refer you to Slide 2 of our presentation for information on forward looking statements and non GAAP financial measures. The bank uses non GAAP measures such as adjusted results to assess its performance.

Speaker 1

Management will be referring to adjusted results unless otherwise noted. I will now turn the call over to Laurent.

Speaker 2

Merci, Marion, and thank you, everyone, for joining us. This morning, National Bank reported strong financial results for the Q2 of 2024 with earnings per share of 2.54 dollars up 9% year over year and a return on equity of 17%. This performance reflects the disciplined execution of our strategy across business segments and the diversified earnings power of the bank. Our capital level is strong with a CET1 ratio of 13.2%. This allows us to invest in business growth and to return capital to shareholders through sustainable dividend increases.

Speaker 2

We've announced a $0.04 dividend increase this morning, bringing our quarterly dividend to $1.10 effective Q3 2024. Looking at the Canadian economy, it continues to show signs of deceleration. We are seeing further normalization in the credit environment and the unemployment rate has been on the rise since monetary tightening began and now stands above 6%. Interest rates have been holding year to date and housing and rental costs remain high. As core inflation has eased in recent months, we believe the Bank of Canada may now be in position to offer some interest rate relief in the second half of the year.

Speaker 2

With continued uncertainty as to the path of the economy, our disciplined diversified business mix and defensive posture provide us with resiliency and flexibility. This is illustrated by our strong results across our business segments in Q2. Personal and Commercial Banking delivered solid revenue growth of 6% year over year supported by concurrent growth in average loans and deposits. Our personal banking loan book grew 3% over last year, and we are seeing better volumes within our internal mortgage origination channels. Our commercial banking loans provide our commercial banking loan portfolio grew 12% year over year, reflecting broad based growth.

Speaker 2

Our Wealth segment generated net income of $205,000,000 in the 2nd quarter, up 15% over last year on the back of double digit revenue growth and positive operating leverage. Net income grew 7% over the same period and 3% sequentially, reflecting a strong deposit base. Compared to last year, fee based revenues were up 13% and transaction revenues were up 12%, benefiting from strong markets and a growing franchise. Our Financial Markets business delivered net income of $322,000,000 for the quarter, up 20% year over year. Global Markets revenues were up 18% from last year, led by continued momentum in securities finance and a strong performance in our Rates business.

Speaker 2

Corporate and Investment Banking revenues were up 9% year over year with a solid performance across the franchise and strong debt underwriting. Our Financial Markets business continues to benefit from a well diversified business mix and disciplined risk management. Credigy generated solid returns in Q2 with 5% average asset growth sequentially driving higher revenues and strong returns. Net interest income was up 6% quarter over quarter. Underlying performance portfolio performance is in line with expectations and the team continues to focus on opportunities with attractive risk reward profiles, primarily in the secured space.

Speaker 2

Finally, ABA Bank generated net income growth of 16 percent year over year. Margins improved sequentially as a result of strong growth in demand deposits. Our customer base expansion translated into year over year growth in loans and deposits of 18% 20%, respectively. These results reinforce the strength of ABA's financial ecosystem underpinned by its leading position in digital transactions, deposit gathering, payments and cash management. Looking ahead, we remain committed to our disciplined approach to capital, credit and cost and to generating long term value to our shareholders.

Speaker 2

Before I turn it over to Marie Chantal, a few weeks ago, we announced that Bill Beneil will be retiring from his CRO role at the end of the fiscal year and that Jean Sebastien Caisse will be appointed his successor effective November 1. JIS has been a key member of the risk management and compliance team since he joined the bank in 2015. He quickly rose through the ranks since that time, thanks to both his technical expertise, but also his vision and leadership qualities. Having worked closely with him and Bill through those years, he brings deep experience and understanding of our risk landscape to the role. I look forward to welcoming him to the senior leadership team this fall.

Speaker 2

As for Bill, it goes without saying that he has made an indelible mark on

Speaker 3

the bank as a steward of our risk culture over the last 12 years.

Speaker 2

I am very happy and fortunate to count on him for a little while longer as our CRO and then as a strategic advisor before a well deserved retirement. Marie Chantal, over to you.

Speaker 1

Thank you, Laurent, and good afternoon, everyone. My comments will begin on Slide 7. The bank delivered strong results in the Q2. PPPP grew 12% year over year, driven by solid organic growth across all business segments and underpinned by diversified revenue stream. Our balanced approach to growth and cost management across the bank contributes to our performance.

Speaker 1

Operating leverage was positive at 2%. Our highly efficient businesses generated an all bank efficiency ratio below 52%. We remain disciplined around expense management. Revenue growth of 10% year over year generated higher variable compensation, particularly in financial markets and in Wealth Management. Excluding variable compensation, expenses rose 5% year over year as we dynamically balance business growth and investments to gain efficiency and improve the client experience.

Speaker 1

Salaries and benefits increased 5% year over year, mainly due to the annual salary increase. We continue to prudently manage the FTE count in Canada, which remained relatively stable compared to last quarter. Our action towards simplifying and optimizing our products, processes and channel continue to pay off.

Speaker 4

Now in

Speaker 1

the other segment. Total revenue from treasury activities was lower in the 2nd quarter. This was primarily driven by the impact of interest rate volatility on asset and liability management and to a lesser extent from some prefunding opportunities in the first half of the year aligned with our prudent approach to liquidity and funding management higher expenses from variable compensation and a temporary overlap in occupancy costs as we transition to our new head office also lowered earnings for this segment in the Q2. For the remainder of the year, we do not expect PTPP in the other segment to improve from Q2 level. Looking at the results of the business segments and the bank as a whole, we are pleased with the performance in the first half of the year.

Speaker 1

Our balanced approach to growth and investment continues to serve us well, particularly in an economic environment that remains uncertain. Now turning to Slide 8. Sequentially, non trading NII was down approximately 1% and was up in Web Management supported by its diversified deposit base at Credigy driven by robust asset growth year to date and at ABA benefiting from balance sheet growth and a favorable deposit mix. The Albaq non trading NIM fell 4 basis points sequentially to 2.17%, largely reflecting lower NII from treasury. Our margin in P&C Banking remained stable again this quarter at 2.36%.

Speaker 1

As a management team, our primary focus is to grow the franchise with the right balance between volume growth, margins and credit quality. We are pleased with our margin performance and expansion since the beginning of this rate cycle. Moving to Slide 9. Loans were up 9% year over year and 2% quarter over quarter. In Commercial Banking, loans increased 3% sequentially, in part driven by continued opportunities in the Residential Insured segment.

Speaker 1

In Personal Banking, loans increased 1%, while Corporate Banking volumes were up 1% quarter over quarter following several quarters of strong drawing. At Credigy, the sale of the loan portfolio offset organic growth this quarter, but bear in mind that the overall asset growth has been strong year to date. At ABA, loans grew 3% sequentially, mainly driven by net client acquisition. Deposits, excluding wholesale funding, grew 4% year over year and 2% quarter over quarter. Personal deposits rose 2% sequentially with growth in term deposits across retail businesses and in demand deposits at ABA.

Speaker 1

In Personal Banking, demand deposits increased modestly over the quarter. Nonretail deposits were up $2,000,000,000 sequentially, primarily driven by Commercial Banking. We maintained a strong loan to deposit ratio of 98% as at Q2. Our ratio is aligned with our diversified business model. And now turning to capital on Slide 10.

Speaker 1

We ended Q2 with a CET1 ratio of 13.2%. 2nd quarter earnings net of dividends contributed 38 basis points to our ratio, underscoring our internal capital generation capacity. Robust organic business growth contributed to an increase of 29 basis points of RWA, excluding FX. Credit risk RWA was up, representing 30 basis points of CP1, mainly from strong balance sheet growth and to a lesser extent from credit migration in nonretail portfolios. To conclude, I am pleased that for the past few quarters, we have successfully been able to navigate a challenging backdrop and report solid financial performance.

Speaker 1

Our diversified business model, strong balance sheet and disciplined execution provide a firm foundation for the bank to generate profitable growth. I will now turn the call over to Bill.

Speaker 5

Merci, Marie Chantal, and good afternoon, everyone. I'll begin on Slide 12 with comments on the macro environment and our credit performance in the Q2. While core inflation has eased in recent months, significant uncertainties remain in the forward path of interest rates, economic growth and unemployment. To echo Laurent's comments, the Canadian economy continues to show signs of deceleration. Against this macro backdrop, our credit portfolios have continued to demonstrate resilience in the 2nd quarter, with total provisions for credit losses of $138,000,000 or 24 basis points versus 21 basis points in Q1.

Speaker 5

Impaired provisions increased 3 basis points sequentially to 20 basis points or $114,000,000 Retail impaired provisions increased as normalization trends continued. Nonretail impaired provisions increased quarter over quarter due primarily to a couple of files in the wholesale trade sector. At Credigy, continued seasoning of acquired portfolios generated stable impaired provisions. At EBA, impaired provisions declined quarter over quarter. However, as we discussed on prior calls, we think they could remain elevated for a few more quarters.

Speaker 5

Provisions on performing loans declined to $22,000,000 or 4 basis points. The primary drivers this quarter were portfolio growth and migration. Looking ahead, we expect delinquencies and impaired provisions continue their upward path. The retail portfolio should continue its normalization and the non retail book is subject to periodic luckiness as we saw this quarter. With these factors in mind, we maintain our 15 to 25 basis points guidance for full year impaired provisions and still expect to end up around the middle of that range.

Speaker 5

Turning to Slide 13. We continue to prudently build our total allowances for credit losses, which reached more than $1,400,000,000 represents a strong coverage of 4.5 times our last 12 months net charge offs. Performing ACLs increased for the 8th consecutive quarter and now represents 2.9 times the last 12 months impaired PCLs. In Appendix 10, additional metrics on our allowances are provided, which demonstrate our prudent coverage levels. Turning to Slide 14.

Speaker 5

Our gross impaired loan ratio increased 6 basis points to 54 basis points. As we called out on the slide, the GIL ratio in our domestic loan portfolios was 36 basis points, still below pre pandemic levels. Formations were higher quarter over quarter, with the main drivers being the commercial and corporate portfolios. As I've mentioned on prior calls, formations and recoveries in wholesale portfolios can be lumpy from quarter to quarter and Q2 was unusually lumpy. The new formations were spread across a handful of regions and sectors, including wholesale trade, transportation, real estate.

Speaker 5

And I'll point out here that for a couple of those files, we took only a small or no specific provision, reflecting the quality of the collateral and loan structure. At ABA, formations were stable quarter over quarter in Canadian dollar terms due to currency impact, but in U. S. Dollar terms declined $28,000,000 from $44,000,000 last quarter. On Slide 15, we present highlights from our Canadian RESL portfolio.

Speaker 5

The geographic and product mix remained stable with Quebec accounting for 54% and insured mortgages accounting for 29% of total RESOL. Higher risk uninsured borrowers represent around 50 basis points of the total RESOL portfolio. 90 day delinquencies and uninsured mortgages in HELOCs remain low at 13 basis points and 10 basis points respectively. You can find additional details on our Canadian mortgages on Slide 16. I'll note that for more I'll note that more than half of our mortgage portfolio has now been repriced at higher interest rates and 90 day delinquencies remain well below the pre pandemic level.

Speaker 5

We've included additional insights on trends in 90 day delinquencies for the entire Canadian retail portfolio in Appendix 26, and I'll take a moment to share a few comments on the trends across different products and segments or regions. First, delinquencies and credit cards, which is a relatively small portfolio for us, have increased the most since the 2022 lows, having exceeded pre pandemic levels early this year. And diving deeper into that portfolio, we find that the segments most impacted are non homeowners and clients outside Quebec. 2nd, variable rate mortgage delinquencies have also seen a significant increase over this period with the insured segment and the outside Quebec region showing the largest relative increase. And finally, diving deeper into the uninsured variable rate mortgage portfolio, we see that delinquencies in the Quebec region still remain below their pre pandemic levels.

Speaker 5

In conclusion, we are pleased with the strong credit performance again this quarter, which reflects our defensive positioning, resilient mix and prudent provisioning. And with that, I'll turn the call back to the operator for the Q and A.

Operator

Thank you, Mr. Bonnell. Our first question is from Matti Uli from Canaccord. Please go ahead.

Speaker 6

Hey, good afternoon and thanks for taking my question. Maybe starting with ABA, PCLs in that business continue to be very low and I think they actually saw impaired decline quarter over quarter.

Speaker 7

Can you maybe just talk us through what gives you confidence

Speaker 6

in the current level of build for that business? And maybe what you're seeing in general economic indicators in that market?

Speaker 5

Yes. Sure, Matthew. It's Bill. Happy to answer that. So in Cambodia, we have seen some recent strength.

Speaker 5

So far in the beginning of the year, exports have really picked up. We've seen foreign direct investments pick up with U. S. Being now the 3rd largest foreign direct investor after Singapore. And just recently, Moody's upgraded their outlook for the country from negative to stable.

Speaker 5

So it reflects kind of some good things happening. However, we feel that the it will take some time for the benefits of those activities to really be felt through the economy, which is why we were calling out the fact that we expect elevated formations for the next 2 or 3 quarters. And does that answer your question or do you have another question?

Speaker 6

No, that answers that question. And then maybe on the financial market side, another good quarter and specifically called out DCM. But can you maybe just talk about the visibility you have into C and IB pipeline going to back half of the year?

Speaker 8

Sure. Thanks, Matthew, for the question. And it's been a great quarter for us on the advisory side. And we are so maybe if I comment on what the quarter was like, the start of the show was really DCM, where it was a great environment with Canadian borrowers being active on both sides of the border and Canadian investors actively deploying and that provided a broad support for new issues in the rallying Canadian credit market. And then you have the government side because of the increasing borrowing requirements, the pace of new issue has been robust as issuers took advantage of strong demand in the fixed income markets.

Speaker 8

And we see that trend continuing in the next quarter. It was also busier on the equity new issue market with significant activity and notably in the mining sector, so encouraging trend there. And M and A was also a bit busier in Q2, although a bit slower than last year, and we're looking for an acceleration during the second half of the year. So that's really what we see. I mean, I touched on DCM.

Speaker 8

We see it getting quite busy on the equity side, especially in the last 2 weeks and there is a lot of cash on the sidelines and a lot of pent up demand. And I think that that will that provides a pretty strong picture for the second half of the year on the advisory side.

Speaker 6

All right. Thanks for taking my questions.

Operator

Thank you. Our following question is from Meny Grauman from Scotiabank. Please go ahead.

Speaker 9

Hi, good afternoon. Just following up on that discussion of financial markets, if we can take it to the outlook for net income for the year, I think year to date up 11%. So I think in the past you talked about guidance being quite a bit lower, but obviously, you're highlighting some positives here, especially on the DCM side. Just wondering if you could update that guidance in terms of what to expect for the year as a whole in terms of earnings growth for Financial Markets segment?

Speaker 8

Yes. Thanks, Manny, for the question. So we're really happy with the results so far, especially on the trading side. I think it's a combination of a good environment, strong client activity and really solid execution from the teams. So on the fixed side, you're seeing volatility remaining high and all segments being really busy.

Speaker 8

So we're seeing a nice revenue progression in our liquidity providing activity, and we continue to rank number 1 in total domestic bond trading for each month of the quarter. So really happy to see that. And rate structured products were also a nice tailwind this quarter with record issuance and revenues. And on the equity side, we continue to benefit from strong market conditions, whether it is structured products, financing trades and market making. The strong equity markets have resulted in increased product sales, increased client flow in structured funding trades and a pickup also on the securities lending side.

Speaker 8

If we look at the what we see, so we feel real good about the first half of the year and how balanced the performance has been. And then we feel increasingly confident that the business the businesses are well positioned to deliver net income growth for fiscal 2024. I think on the interest rate side, we will continue to see volatility as central banks will take diverging paths on their way to easing. And that bodes well for activity on trading, should have a lot of cross border activity, but also in the debt capital markets, as I mentioned, as government and corporate issuers will continue to take advantage of improving borrowing conditions. And the persistent strength of the equity markets, I feel, will continue to be a tailwind for our structured products franchise.

Speaker 8

So sales are strong and that will compensate, we feel, for low equity trading volumes and low implied volatilities. And on the securities finance side, it's really a good environment. Clients are deploying aggressively at good spreads and we also see strong demand on structured funding trades. And that I think that, that will offset for corporate lending, which where we see a possible slight slowdown in the pace due really to the opening of capital markets. And but we're like I said, we're looking for M and A to accelerate in the second half.

Speaker 8

So we have a really interesting pipeline there. So I think we'll be busy the next few months. Does that answer your question, Meny?

Speaker 9

Well, does that mean that the guidance that you provided before is probably no longer valid, that you're probably looking at quite a bit more earnings growth than what you had suggested earlier in the year?

Speaker 8

Well, like I said, we feel increasingly confident that we will achieve that guidance, But I don't think we want to update that guidance yet.

Speaker 9

Okay. And then just a follow-up in terms of if I look at the TEB line across peers on a year over year basis down, call it on average 90% year over year. And I think that is the dividend received deduction coming through as expected. If I look at your TEB line, down 34% year over year. So a significant outlier there.

Speaker 9

And I'm just trying to understand, is there still more downside here related to the DRD? And then if not, then what's going on here? Is it there's other things offsetting an impact of the DRD? Or are you able to somehow offset the DRD itself? I'm trying to understand your performance here.

Speaker 9

It really stands out relative to peers.

Speaker 8

Yes. So I think what you're referring to, Manny, is that it's the PEB adjustment in non interest income. And that one is not related to dividends. It's related to income from our foreign trading operations, notably in Europe. And so that PED in relation to non interest income, that reflects the difference in tax rates in various jurisdictions where we carry on business.

Speaker 8

So that PB will fluctuate with changes in while the balance sheet we've deployed there and changes in interest rates. And it will also fluctuate as our trading revenues in those markets go up and down.

Speaker 9

So I mean just to be clear in terms of the line that I'm looking at here in terms of the TB on trade like if I look at trading activity revenue and the TB line of $84,000,000 in Q2, there's the DRD impact is not going through that specific line. Is that what you're

Speaker 8

So you've seen the drop from previous TEB numbers. And so really the drop in the dividend impact was in the interest income part of the TEB, where we went from something like 75 to 14,

Speaker 10

if I remember correctly.

Speaker 8

And that's aligned with the guidance of about $60,000,000 per quarter that we gave in Q1. Okay. Thank you.

Operator

Thank you. Our following question is from Namar Persaud from Cormark Securities. Please go ahead.

Speaker 7

Yes. Bill, you mentioned taking small to no provisions in some of these non retail formations. Can you expand on what gives you the confidence here? I'm assuming that these are clients you've done specific work on each of these files and that's what gives you the confidence in these sectors you called out. So I think it was transportation, wholesale trading, real estate.

Speaker 7

Just provide some thoughts there on what gives you the confidence to not provide.

Speaker 5

Yes, sure, Lamar. I'm happy to. Certainly, it's not all of the formations that had low provisions. Someone certainly did. And as I said, it was a lumpy quarter.

Speaker 5

Specifically, I was referring to in the real estate sector, the new formation of gross impaired loan increase was driven primarily by one file, and we always look very specifically at the file when it becomes impaired, and we make our best judgment of what we think the end realized loss would be. And in this case, it's one very well located retail property that's in the process of redeveloping into multi residential and retail mix. It had cash flow problems because of low occupancy in the retail portion and higher interest rates, of course, hitting the cash flow. So it led that led to the impairment. But even at refreshed valuation at the time of impairment, the current LTV is still in the 60s and provides ample coverage for the loan.

Speaker 5

So we don't expect to end up realizing a loss on that one. And in the transportation sector, although it's in the transportation sector, it's

Speaker 3

actually a

Speaker 5

few specific loans secured by properties that are multiuse or industrial, and they are used by the owner who guarantees the loans that is in the transportation sector, but our exposure is directly secured by these properties. And again, well located, they were structured as real estate loans, Canadian style. And we will it's going through a process. And if necessary, if through the process, there needs to be an adjustment in evaluations, we'll make it. But currently, we don't expect to take any material loss there.

Speaker 5

So that's how we go about analyzing the specific provisions, and it really is case by case with all the factors considered. Does that help answer your question?

Speaker 7

Yes, that's perfect. Thank you. And then just kind of moving on to my next question here. A a Quebec specific strength, a specific sector? And what do you kind of expect moving forward?

Speaker 7

Because that number stood out to me on the positive side.

Speaker 8

Yes. So

Speaker 5

it is it's Michael, Denim here. So the growth has been across the country, Quebec, but Ontario, Western Canada. So a lot of the growth is coming from real estate, multiunit residential real estate, but it's also broad board, national accounts teams out west are caring for a lot of growth as well. So it's well diversified across geographies and across sectors. And again, it is lumpy.

Speaker 5

We've been in the kind of high single digit, low double digit range for the past few quarters. And just based on the kind of pipeline level activity we're seeing right now, we expect to be kind of more or less in that range going forward.

Speaker 8

Great. Thank you.

Operator

Thank you. Our following question is from Nigel D'Souza from Veritas Investment Research. Please go ahead.

Speaker 7

Thank you. Good afternoon. I wanted to follow-up on the delinquency rate data you had on Slide 26 and touch on the divergence we're seeing between the uninsured and insured variable rate mortgages. And what I'm trying to understand here is that both the uninsured and insured portfolios would be stress tested. They both have a similar product structure with adjustable payments.

Speaker 7

So other than lower equity in the insured portfolio, what's driving the divergence in delinquency rates in both categories?

Speaker 5

Hi, Nigel, it's Bill. I think you've bailed it. The less equity in the loan typically means more leverage for the household. So when you think of insured mortgages, often it's first time homebuyers that have perhaps less ability to withstand sudden changes in rates and market values or changes in circumstances. And that's really the driver.

Speaker 5

We also see aligned with that, you see a pretty correlated it's pretty correlated between the size of the mortgage and performance too because the dollar impact of a 400 basis point increase on a $300,000 mortgage in Quebec is different than on a $800,000 mortgage in a more expensive city. So same interest rate change just doesn't hit the household budget as much and is more easily offset by wage growth and other aspects. Does that help answer your question?

Speaker 7

Just to clarify a little bit finer on that. So is it geographic mix in stores tilted more outside of Quebec? And also, are you seeing any other factors like vintages? Like are there more recent vintages in the intra portfolios that are going delinquent? Or any other differences there in the maturity profile?

Speaker 5

Yes. I'd say, Bejal, that the biggest correlation, less vintages, maybe we can come back to you on that, but it really is the geography for those factors that are described. And I think in my prepared text, I called out that even after 400 plus basis points of increase in the variable rate mortgages, in the uninsured variable rate mortgages, the Quebec borrower, the delinquency rate is still below the pre pandemic level. And that's a factor of what we've talked about, about the Quebec households being more resilient with more dual family dual income families and with more the economy more diversified, but primarily, it's the lower house price has a real impact on the size of the payment shock when interest rates go up. So does that help answer your question?

Speaker 7

It does. That's really helpful. And then if I could switch to ABA, Danny. I think there's an increase in the net interest margin for ABA this quarter. Just want to confirm if that's right.

Speaker 7

And if so, what drove that increase? And also, could you refresh me on what ROE is that business generating currently at ABA?

Speaker 3

So with regard to the margin, just to tell you, the margin has indeed improved and it's a factor of 2 elements, if you want. The first one is our pricing strategy, and we've seen rate decreases on the term deposits. That's the first element. But the first and foremost element has been the deposit mix that has changed amongst the clientele at EBA. So last year, we saw more deposits going into term.

Speaker 3

And this year, it's the 2nd quarter in a row. We're seeing as the economy is taking a longer time to recover to its high levels of pre pandemic, we've got a few lesser degree of investments in term deposits. We're actually at 71% of our deposits that are into pure account and savings account. So that's the first element. As to the ROE of that subsidiary, we don't divulge ROE volumes specifically per subsidiary, but I'm sure you can make a guess that it's been a worthwhile investment for us.

Speaker 7

And the reason why I asked that is strategic question here, but I'm sure that's a very healthy ROE. So is there any consideration that perhaps if that ROE is near the high end of its potential range to divest and reallocate that capital domestically or to grow financial markets or wealth? How do you think about that business? Or is it something that's

Speaker 8

not on

Speaker 7

the table?

Speaker 3

I'll answer no. It's not on the table, and I'll answer with one element. It's still an extremely young market. Population is very young. The second element is only 10% of Cambodians have loans right now.

Speaker 3

So we've got the opportunity of driving this balance sheet for many years to come. The demographics are excellent. And the returns on the margins exceed undoubtedly what we can see domestically. So I'll leave it to that.

Speaker 7

Okay. That's it for me. Thank you.

Operator

Thank you. Following question is from Mike Ryszbanovich from KBW Research. Please go ahead.

Speaker 8

Good afternoon. I want to go

Speaker 10

back to Bill on the impaired loan formations on commercial. And what I'm a little bit confused about is why such a substantial move during the quarter? I don't see anything on the macro side in terms of data that would have suggested anything like this move sequentially based on what we have for Feb, March April. So in your view, what was the key driver that really drove this big jump sequentially?

Speaker 5

Mike, it really goes to what I said. You can call it lumpiness, you can call it multiple idiosyncratic events that just happen at the same time. With a retail portfolio, you can it's definitely more trends. And even from quarter to quarter, you can be pretty confident on the direction and the size of the trend change, because it's multiple, multiple small individual accounts. With wholesale, with corporate and commercial, it's just the files happen when they happen for multiple reasons.

Speaker 5

And as we pointed out, these were different geographies, these were different sectors. And from time to time, they happen within 3 week or 6 week period and other times, they are more evenly spread out. So really, it just goes down to lumpiness. There's nothing else I'd call out here.

Speaker 7

Okay.

Speaker 10

So it's something you're confident is not something to be alarmed about in terms of the direct correlation to your PCL. But what would you say to the premise that some investors may have when they sort of look at these impairments rise so quickly? And some may believe that the PCL is willing to put that PCL number up earlier than others? Like I'm not sure if you have a view on that, but I'd love to hear your opinion on that.

Speaker 5

Sure. I would start off with saying that the nature of the portfolio doesn't need to be you know, trying trying to equate impaired loans and Stage 3 provisions really depends on how much credit cards you have because there aren't any impaired loans and credit cards that goes through write off. And so you can have higher Stage 3 provisions, but lower gross impaired loans. So the nature of the portfolio and business mix is one thing. 2nd, in looking at the nature of the loan portfolio, the percentage of insured loans does matter.

Speaker 5

As we pointed out, the delinquencies in insured variable rates have been going up. So over time, I would expect to see more impaired loans that are insured start as insured variable rates. It doesn't mean that the risk content leading into Stage 3 provisions is there, but it does impact an increase in gross impaired loans. And you'll note that we in our mortgage portfolio, we've got the highest percentage of insured mortgages. 2nd, in the commercial, we had a similar situation where a significant part of our growth coming out of 2021 was in the insured multi residential portfolio.

Speaker 5

If there's deterioration and that becomes impaired, again, it will impact the gross impaired loans, but doesn't lead to risk content. And finally, for us specifically, as we talked on, I think, the last 2 or 3 calls, in ABA, with the secured nature, the low LTV nature of it, there has been a significant increase in gross impaired loans, but we do continue to expect the net charge offs, so the realized loss at the end of the process to remain that rate to remain relatively low. So it's not a one for 1 gross impaired loans versus what will be the Stage 3 provisions or the write offs even if you get to the very end. It needs to be a little more nuanced based on the portfolio. Does that help?

Speaker 7

Yes, that's super helpful. And just

Speaker 10

in case I missed earlier, I believe you did reiterate the 20 roughly 20 basis point loss ratio for the current was that for the current year?

Speaker 5

Yes. So my specific language, same as last quarter and last couple of quarters was for the fiscal year impaired PCLs between 15% to 25%, and we still expect to end up around the middle of that range. And just on that, I don't want to give you the impression that even after 12 years in the seats, I can forecast precisely within the 2nd decimal point what provisions will be. That's not the case. However, we do look so far this year, we're below 20.

Speaker 5

This quarter, it was a lumpy quarter, which I don't expect to happen every quarter or consecutive quarters. It can, but I don't expect it. And the trends that we talked about driving some of the Canadian provisions are coming from those normalization trends. And where those normalization trends are the fastest are in areas that we are underweight. And where there's the most resilience is areas that we're overweight.

Speaker 5

So I also need to balance in Credigy and ABA, which aren't perfectly correlated. But as we sit here today, the my expectations for the full year is it should be pretty close to the middle of the range. We'll talk again in August, and I'll update it, but that's what I reaffirmed.

Speaker 10

Got it. Thank you. Very insightful. Thanks, Will.

Operator

Thank you. Our following question is from Sohrab Movahedi from BMO Capital Markets. Please go ahead.

Speaker 6

Okay. Thank you. I just wanted to maybe just change channels here a little bit. It looks the wealth, if I'm not mistaken, a record earnings quarter, You've been around this $200,000,000 a quarter for the first half of this year every quarter. Just can I get a sense of how you see this business playing out over the next few quarters and what you think will help sustain this sort of performance?

Speaker 1

Yes. Thank you, Sorad. So this is Nancy. You're right. This is our highest quarter in terms of revenue this quarter.

Speaker 1

And it's led mostly by based and transactional revenues, as you've seen. We also have a growth momentum in terms of clients and assets under management. So our unique positioning with our open architecture, there's still some substantial for us in there. We like our diversified business mix. We like our client acquisition.

Speaker 1

So I think those are the trends that we're going to continue to build on to grow for the next quarters.

Speaker 6

So it doesn't so just to be clear, Nancy, it doesn't sound like you're saying I need equity markets to be cooperating with me necessarily.

Speaker 1

Well, as you know, our business is influenced by the markets as well. So definitely, markets are a growth contributor, but the fundamentals are good. And the diversified mix of our business will bring us good results no matter where markets go in the long term.

Speaker 6

Okay. And if I can just ask Lucie to maybe talk a little bit about how she sees the second half of the year playing out, both in terms of lending volumes and net interest margin for the P and C segment? I would appreciate that. Thank you.

Speaker 4

Yes. Thank you, Flora. When I look at the second half, I think we will have some more pickup in the mortgage business. And I believe we will end the year in the mid single digit on the mortgage growth. I think our credit card growth will continue to be low double digit, which is a reflection also of the quality of our portfolio and the prudence that we see from consumers, and it's also helpful on the credit side.

Speaker 4

And we will continue to have also good momentum in personal loans.

Speaker 6

Yes. And do you expect margins to be trending higher, lower, stable? How do you see that playing out?

Speaker 4

Yes. Thank you. So the margin, we look at it from the P and C overall business. And this quarter, we've seen more resiliency. The deposit spreads have continued to slightly benefit.

Speaker 4

And also, the loan spreads have improved. So the margin environment on the loan side is positive. But for the next quarter, we may see some pressure on the deposit side as the portfolio renew. We have, let's say, mostly a 2 year duration in the term deposit portfolio. And 2 years ago was probably the largest term deposit spread we've had.

Speaker 4

So it will impact it will have an impact on some pressure on the deposits. And also, the business mix can play in also with a little more loan growth than deposit growth.

Speaker 8

Okay. Thank you very much.

Operator

Thank you. Our following question is from Doug Young from Desjardins Capital Markets. Please go ahead.

Speaker 11

Yes. Good afternoon. I just have a few hopefully quick ones. Bill, to you, on the guidance of mid part of that range, so implies compared PCLs in the low 20 basis point range. And I get, I think, some of the comments you've made in the past discussions here.

Speaker 11

Is there a line of sight? And I know commercial can be lumpier. Is it more line of sight on some commercial stuff you see coming down the pipe? Is it more just a trend out of what you're seeing on the retail side that pushes you to expect the low 20 basis points in Q3, Q4? Is this converted?

Speaker 11

Because I'm just trying to kind of get a sense.

Speaker 5

Yes. I think it's the thanks for the question. I think it's the trend really that we've been talking about for, I think, at least 3 or 4 quarters, a normalization trend. As you know, the impact of monetary policy is delayed, so it should be no surprise of when the impact started being seen. We talked, I think, through last year, the second half of last year about what we were seeing in early delinquencies.

Speaker 5

And now we're seeing those play out in the late stage delinquencies. And the trends are moving pretty close to what we expected. As I said, commercial and corporate can be lumpy, Not wanting to call out any visibility on specific sectors or aiming because generally, our watch list has been relatively stable in the last quarter or 2. So there's nothing really calling out. I would just say the trends have continued as we expected, albeit, as I said, lumpy quarter in Q2.

Speaker 5

And for those reasons, just confirming the same guidance I gave last quarter. Okay.

Speaker 6

And then ABA, can you update us

Speaker 11

with the LTV on the portfolio and when the collateral was secured was last updated? I assume that's updated every quarter, but

Speaker 3

It is and hardly has changed. We're still in the 40s. And it's actually very stable because the underwriting practices have not changed. And when we assess even the GIL LTV, it's actually lower than the average portfolio. So we're very pleased with that.

Speaker 11

Okay. And then lastly, you talked a bit about the TV and some stuff in Europe. And I'm just curious of the impact or if you can provide what you think the impact would be on GMT or if there's any impact from the GMT as we look forward?

Speaker 1

Doug, it's Marie Chantal here. Happy to take that question. So in terms of global minimal tax, as you know, these rules were included in the Bill C69 that was just announced early May. And we are currently assessing our income tax exposure arising from these rules. We'll be in better position to comment later in the year.

Speaker 1

We're expecting some impact. But as always, our intention is to provide more clarity as soon as we have finalized our interpretation of these rules.

Speaker 9

Appreciate it. Thank

Speaker 1

you. You're welcome.

Operator

Thank you. Our following question is from Paul Holden from CIBC. Please go ahead.

Speaker 12

Thanks. Good afternoon. Bill, maybe a quick question for you, because I've heard a number of others ask on ABA and sort of the delinquency trends versus provisions. Maybe you can give us an update on collections to date, given the low LTVs that have been highlighted on the portfolio?

Speaker 5

Yes. Hi, Paul. Thanks. I'll answer it in the first half. I'm not bad.

Speaker 5

I think the same trends as we talked about, I think, in the last call or the last couple of calls. But year to date for those files that have gone through and closed through the workout process, it's around 75% of them that had zero loss. And as I'll call out as well, you can see in our SFI, I think it's on Page 28 in the SFI where you see write offs by business segment, and it's still under $500,000 a quarter, it's under $250,000 for the last two quarters. So the write offs, the dollar amount are still pretty small. So seeing that those facts continue as we expected is what gives us the confidence to say we think that the net charge off rate will remain relatively low.

Speaker 12

Does that help? That helps very much. Thank you. Next question is with respect to financial markets, see that the average loan balances there up 11% year over year. That's some pretty good growth.

Speaker 12

I've heard from others that use of existing lines are relatively low or trending lower. So just wondering how you're generating that 11% growth? Is that coming from existing clients? Are you actually gaining new customers? And if you are gaining new corporate lending relationships, kind of give us a sense maybe where those are coming from geographically or by sector?

Speaker 8

Yes. Thanks for the question. It is 11% year over year, although it has trended lower sequentially. It is so it is a very well diversified book and so very well diversified across sectors. It is and you're right that the utilization rate has been trending a bit lower, although it is still elevated historically.

Speaker 8

But because of the opening of capital markets, we're seeing that utilization rate now trending a bit lower because in the low 40s and historically it's in the high 30s. And we have been so a lot of new clients on the project finance side definitely, so a lot of new clients in the renewable sectors. But that's really the one major trend I would point out related to that book. Otherwise, it is pretty stable across sectors and geographies.

Speaker 12

Got it. Okay. And last one, similar question, I guess, around Credigy. You're also seeing quite good growth year over year and sequentially. Are there any kind of common themes there in terms of the types of portfolios Credigy is acquiring, who the sellers of those portfolios are?

Speaker 12

And then maybe if you can give us some clues in terms of the outlook and if that strong growth can continue at Credigy? Thank you.

Speaker 8

Yes. Thanks, Paul. So you're right that Credigy has delivered strong growth, notably in the Q1. It's been a more normal pace in the Q2. But for the first half of the year, we've deployed about $1,800,000,000 and that's really in high quality long term secured assets.

Speaker 8

And that's mostly mortgage, solar loans and some life settlements also. When we continue to see, looking forward, opportunities primarily in secured consumer assets. So I mentioned mortgage, there's also home improvement loans and I mentioned solar. And we like the insurance space also because it is very uncorrelated with the overall economy. And so we see continued growth there across a balance of both indirect lending and direct portfolio acquisition.

Speaker 8

And when you look at Credigy, it's really a set of real solid client relationship and that creates, I think, a solid foundation for growth. And this allows strategy to really build a repeat customer business, and that means that we can remain competitive without being always highest on price. So does that answer your question, Paul?

Speaker 12

It does. Yes, that's great. That's all the questions for me. So thanks for the time.

Operator

Thank you. We have no further questions registered at this time. I would now like to turn the meeting back over to Laurent Ferrier.

Speaker 2

Well, thank you, operator, and thank you to all employees and shareholders on the call today for your support. Have a great summer.

Operator

Thank you. The conference has now ended. Please disconnect your lines at this time, and we thank you for your participation.

Earnings Conference Call
National Bank of Canada Q2 2024
00:00 / 00:00