AutoZone Reports Earnings Beat, Shares Fall, Outlook Positive

Indianapolis - Circa March 2016: AutoZone Retail Store. AutoZone is a Retailer and Distributor of Automotive Parts III

Key Points

  • AutoZone reports its third-quarter 2023 earnings results, sending the stock price lower.
  • Key performance metrics are lower, initially causing adverse reactions, other more essential developments will show that investors are still in for a higher ride. 
  • Management believes the stock to be undervalued and the company to have another push in it. These fundamental indicators will reiterate these viewpoints. 
  • Currently, where car owners and buyers stand, AutoZone's fundamentals are set to go nowhere but up from here. 
  • 5 stocks we like better than Advance Auto Parts

Shares of AutoZone NYSE: AZO has delivered investors a jaw-dropping rally, which has not hit any speed bumps since its start in 2021. As other operators in the industry, such as Advance Advance Auto Parts NYSE: AAP, underperform AutoZone stock by as much as eighty percent during the past twelve months, it becomes evident that AutoZone must be doing something right to command the attention of so many participants in the stock market.

Despite the hot momentum shown in the past two years, showcased by the stock chart, shares of AutoZone are trading lower in the pre-market session of Tuesday morning. The sell-off, implying a decline of 3.7%, stems from investors digesting the results shown in the company's third-quarter 2023 earnings. 

Within the press release, management leads the headline with some disappointing results. However, the market has some faith in the company still keeping up with its previous momentum, as investors are willing to pay a price-to-earnings ratio of up to 21.4x, compared to competitors like Advance Auto Parts, commanding only a 14.4x. The higher perceived value and investor willingness to pay more for AutoZone's underlying current - and future - earnings could give way for new investors to lean on further upside potential.

Earnings Results

Every industry has key performance indicators (KPIs) to measure periodic performance. However, the retail sector depends on the infamous comparable store sales growth rate. This measure gives analysts their viewpoints most of the time. For example, AutoZone operates like a retailer via brick-and-mortar shops; However, its digital presence is widely increasing. Still, the comparable store sales rate applies to measure its value.

Posting third-quarter 2023 comparable store sales growth of 1.9% may have set the foundation for the sell-off on Tuesday morning, as it severely underperformed the national inflation rate during the period, essentially taking away from the company's buying power. It is important to note that underperforming inflation on a sales growth basis, set as a minimum benchmark, would eat into the company's profitability as the cost of capital would outweigh any such sales growth, directly affecting investor returns. 


Despite the company's sales underperforming inflation and potentially eating into investor returns, earnings per share increased to $34.12 compared to $29.03 a year prior, representing a 17.6% increase.

The massive difference between the earnings growth rate from the sales growth rate speaks to management efficiency within its operations, as operating margins increased from 20.3% in 2022 to 20.9% in 2023, any boost in margins during the challenging economic times the industry faced should be taken as a majorly positive sign. Similarly, net income margins were boosted from 15.3% in 2022 to 15.8% in 2023, accruing to investor earnings per share. 

The company's share repurchase program is most important to investors within these results. Under this program, management bought back 365 thousand shares for $908.2 million during the quarter, effected at an average per share price of $2,551. The company still has a capital pool equaling $843.6 million to be deployed as further share repurchases authorized by the board.

When put into perspective, these buybacks are most impressive, as a total $902.8 million buyback would amount to nearly 2% of the company's market capitalization. 

Moving Forward

Achieving a three-year average return on invested capital (ROIC) above 25% is no small feat for a retail company, especially one operating in such a competitive environment as vehicle parts and maintenance. Management not only believes there is additional value to be realized in the stock price, as portrayed by their share repurchase implementation and further capital pool but by inventory dynamics seen during the quarter.

According to management's presentation, inventory per store rose by 10.7% during the twelve months period. This increase is considered an expectation of further demand to come, as stores need to be stockpiled and ready to serve the needs of more customers. 

Even though AutoZone analyst ratings expect little to no upside in the stock, many tailwinds at play may still need to be reflected within these price targets. Considering that today's rates for the average car loan are rising, hovering as high as 8.95% in 2023 compared to 5.66% just a year prior, these financing costs are rising along with unaffordable vehicle prices stemming from overall national inflation as well as a tight supply of both new and used vehicles.

These two forces at play, working against the average car buyer, incentivize people to keep their current vehicles until better conditions arrive and enable them to purchase a newer vehicle. Since this has become a dire realization for many, the demand to upkeep vehicles today and make sure they can make it out until these conditions improve can significantly drive AutoZone's fundamentals to reach a new high. 

>

Should you invest $1,000 in Advance Auto Parts right now?

Before you consider Advance Auto Parts, you'll want to hear this.

MarketBeat keeps track of Wall Street's top-rated and best performing research analysts and the stocks they recommend to their clients on a daily basis. MarketBeat has identified the five stocks that top analysts are quietly whispering to their clients to buy now before the broader market catches on... and Advance Auto Parts wasn't on the list.

While Advance Auto Parts currently has a "Reduce" rating among analysts, top-rated analysts believe these five stocks are better buys.

View The Five Stocks Here

20 Stocks to Sell Now Cover

MarketBeat has just released its list of 20 stocks that Wall Street analysts hate. These companies may appear to have good fundamentals, but top analysts smell something seriously rotten. Are any of these companies lurking around your portfolio? Find out by clicking the link below.

Get This Free Report

Companies Mentioned in This Article

CompanyMarketRank™Current PricePrice ChangeDividend YieldP/E RatioConsensus RatingConsensus Price Target
AutoZone (AZO)
3.774 of 5 stars
$2,988.51+0.9%N/A21.04Moderate Buy$3,086.61
Advance Auto Parts (AAP)
4.2297 of 5 stars
$76.53-1.9%1.31%103.42Reduce$64.56
Compare These Stocks  Add These Stocks to My Watchlist 

Gabriel Osorio-Mazilli

About Gabriel Osorio-Mazilli

  • gosoriomazzilli@gmail.com

Contributing Author

Value Stocks, Asian Markets, Macro Economics

Experience

Gabriel Osorio-Mazilli has been a contributing writer for MarketBeat since 2023.

Areas of Expertise

Value investing, long/short trading, options, emerging markets

Education

CFA Level I candidate; Goldman Sachs corporate training; independent courses

Past Experience

Analyst at Goldman Sachs, associate at Citigroup, senior financial analyst in real estate


Featured Articles and Offers

Search Headlines: