50% OFF
MarketBeat All Access
Get 30 days free. Save 50% your first year.
  •  days
  •  Hours
  •  Minutes
  •  Seconds
×
S&P 500   3,693.23
DOW   29,590.41
QQQ   275.51
Become an Ethical Hacking and Cybercrime Expert
Market Wizard Who Accurately Predicted 2022 Market Collapse Has Shocking New Forecast (Ad)
Judge rejects Justice Dept.'s bid to stop sugar merger
Will Wall Street's Enthusiasm About Datadog Lead To Big Gains?
'A Gold Storm Is Coming' (Ad)
MarketBeat: Week in Review 9/19 – 9/23
China using civilian ships to enhance navy capability, reach
'A Gold Storm Is Coming' (Ad)
German leader seeks energy deals, alliances on Gulf trip
World Bank head says he's not a climate denier, won't quit
S&P 500   3,693.23
DOW   29,590.41
QQQ   275.51
Become an Ethical Hacking and Cybercrime Expert
Market Wizard Who Accurately Predicted 2022 Market Collapse Has Shocking New Forecast (Ad)
Judge rejects Justice Dept.'s bid to stop sugar merger
Will Wall Street's Enthusiasm About Datadog Lead To Big Gains?
'A Gold Storm Is Coming' (Ad)
MarketBeat: Week in Review 9/19 – 9/23
China using civilian ships to enhance navy capability, reach
'A Gold Storm Is Coming' (Ad)
German leader seeks energy deals, alliances on Gulf trip
World Bank head says he's not a climate denier, won't quit
S&P 500   3,693.23
DOW   29,590.41
QQQ   275.51
Become an Ethical Hacking and Cybercrime Expert
Market Wizard Who Accurately Predicted 2022 Market Collapse Has Shocking New Forecast (Ad)
Judge rejects Justice Dept.'s bid to stop sugar merger
Will Wall Street's Enthusiasm About Datadog Lead To Big Gains?
'A Gold Storm Is Coming' (Ad)
MarketBeat: Week in Review 9/19 – 9/23
China using civilian ships to enhance navy capability, reach
'A Gold Storm Is Coming' (Ad)
German leader seeks energy deals, alliances on Gulf trip
World Bank head says he's not a climate denier, won't quit
S&P 500   3,693.23
DOW   29,590.41
QQQ   275.51
Become an Ethical Hacking and Cybercrime Expert
Market Wizard Who Accurately Predicted 2022 Market Collapse Has Shocking New Forecast (Ad)
Judge rejects Justice Dept.'s bid to stop sugar merger
Will Wall Street's Enthusiasm About Datadog Lead To Big Gains?
'A Gold Storm Is Coming' (Ad)
MarketBeat: Week in Review 9/19 – 9/23
China using civilian ships to enhance navy capability, reach
'A Gold Storm Is Coming' (Ad)
German leader seeks energy deals, alliances on Gulf trip
World Bank head says he's not a climate denier, won't quit

Is Goldman Sachs or Morgan Stanley the Better Investment?

Is Goldman Sachs or Morgan Stanley the Better Investment?

On July 15, Goldman Sachs (NYSE: GS) posted earnings that blew away expectations. Goldman stock charged up nearly $10 at the opening bell, but has cooled off some. About two hours into trading the stock is up just over 1%.

This is leaving investors wondering what Morgan Stanley (NYSE: MS) will do for an encore. The investment bank reports earnings on July 16. And with Goldman’s results already in, all eyes will be on the House of Morgan.

But as the pullback in Goldman stock is showing, I think investors are already realizing that the future of both stocks goes beyond this quarter’s earnings reports.

Why This Quarter Matters and Why it Doesn’t?

The answer to both is the same, the Federal Reserve. The Fed has been pumping trillions of dollars into the market. There is no shortage of liquidity and all that capital has to flow somewhere. In the case of Goldman at least, it’s paying off to be the middleman.

The firm’s equity business posted revenue of $2.94 billion, and its investment banking business posted $7.18 billion. Goldman generates approximately 40% of its business from sales and trading (as opposed to 33% for Morgan Stanley) and 17% from its asset and wealth management division (Morgan Stanley generates nearly 50% of its revenue from this division).

But it’s unrealistic to believe the Fed will continue to flood the market with liquidity. And no, I’m not saying that with my tongue in my cheek. There is evidence that the Fed has been slowing the amount of liquidity it is providing to the market.


And that means that you have to look at Goldman’s great results, and what analysts assume will be a solid report from Morgan Stanley tomorrow, as one-off events. These are results that are not likely to be repeated.  

Plus trading revenue historically slows down in the back half of a year, and analysts are projecting the same is likely to be true this year.

One Size Does Not Fit All

Looking into a post-coronavirus world, we see the two banks are on different paths. Morgan Stanley is looking to get leaner, whereas Goldman Sachs is looking to get bigger. Let’s examine why that is.

In the case of Morgan Stanley, it comes down to real estate. The pandemic has forced the vast majority of their 16,000 financial advisers to work from home. This has been especially true in New York City where it is unlikely that employees will return to anything resembling “normal” capacity until 2021.

With that in mind, it has been encouraging that the financial advisers are not having trouble interacting with and servicing their clients remotely. But this is also adding fuel to a larger narrative. Morgan’s chief executive officer (CEO) has gone on the record to say that Morgan Stanley could operate with a smaller real estate footprint. And they are considering a plan to accomplish this.

What if each of the company’s 16,000 financial advisers independent contractors? This model, which is similar to that of Charles Schwab (NYSE: SCHW) is being actively considered and discussed among the bank’s veteran advisers, branch managers, and regional managers.

The plan does, however, raise questions about non-employees having access to proprietary research. In remarks to Fox Business, a Morgan Stanley spokeswoman said, “We have absolutely no plans to change the employment classification of our Financial Advisers.”

For its part, Goldman Sachs is rumored to be considering making a deal with a major commercial bank. Necessity is often said to be the mother of invention and that’s certainly the case here. The venerable firm that has always prided itself on being independent is having a hard time keeping up with the big banks.

This is becoming a larger reality with the coronavirus taking away the appetite and demand for big deals. However, even when companies were making deals, Goldman was having its struggles.

With a market value of just $59 billion, the company is less than a quarter of the size of a bank, such as J.P. Morgan Chase (NYSE: JPM). This size disparity continues to cost Goldman the ability to effectively compete on deals.

Regulations imposed in the aftermath of the financial crisis continue to squeeze profits in Goldman’s trading business. At the same time, the company is seeing a reduction in fees from its investment banking business.

And the Winner Is …?

As I noted above, I don’t expect either firm to continue posting great earnings reports for the rest of this year. But things can change. The Fed has made the decision that it is not going to allow the economy to fail. And, it can keep its printing presses on longer than investors can be stubborn.

That’s why to decide which bank is the better investment you have to look through a wider lens. Based simply on the business models that the companies are pursuing, I give the nod to Morgan Stanley. Over the long term, Morgan’s model fits where the industry is going. Goldman looks to be moving into an area where the industry has already been.

Plus from 2009-2019, Morgan Stanley stock has grown at 1.8x the rate of Goldman Sachs. It has also outperformed Goldman on both the top and bottom lines.

Companies Mentioned in This Article

CompanyMarketRank™Current PricePrice ChangeDividend YieldP/E RatioConsensus RatingConsensus Price Target
The Goldman Sachs Group (GS)
3.4513 of 5 stars
$301.97-3.5%3.31%6.83Moderate Buy$410.79
Morgan Stanley (MS)
2.8448 of 5 stars
$81.51-3.8%3.80%11.01Hold$99.38
Charles Schwab (SCHW)
3.3354 of 5 stars
$70.89-1.6%1.24%23.32Moderate Buy$91.46
JPMorgan Chase & Co. (JPM)
3.3771 of 5 stars
$109.14-1.9%3.67%8.76Moderate Buy$145.95
Compare These Stocks  Add These Stocks to My Watchlist 

7 Water Stocks to Buy as the World Dries Up

Many of us will read this and be oblivious to the worldwide crisis. But if the current trends continue, it will become real to all of us soon enough. Most of us learned in elementary school that 97% of the world's water is salt water. And only about 1% of the total water supply is drinkable.

That is becoming difficult math for several areas of the world. A severe, multi-year drought is causing water levels to sink to historically low levels. And the federal government is threatening to cut water use by 25% in the most-affected states of Arizona, California, and Nevada.

And even if we're not put under water restrictions, we are all likely to see higher costs for food. One reason for that is that about 25% of the nation's food supply comes from California. An American Farm Bureau Federation survey conducted in 2021 found that 40% of farmers sold off part of their cattle herds.

 But opportunities present themselves in the midst of crisis, and this is no difference. In this special presentation, we're looking at seven water stocks that look like smart buys as the world grapples for solutions.

View the "7 Water Stocks to Buy as the World Dries Up".

Chris Markoch

About Chris Markoch

Contributing Author: Retirement, Individual Investing

Chris Markoch is a freelance financial copywriter with over five years of experience covering various aspects of the financial markets. You may find his writing a little different than other stock articles you’ve read. And that’s OK with him. Chris doesn’t have a traditional finance background. What he does bring to the table is a strong business and marketing background having worked for agencies that serviced Fortune 500 companies. With that in mind, he isn’t overly impressed with what companies say, and more focused on what they do. And because buyer behavior dictates so much of what happens with a stock, Chris always keeps the end consumer close in mind. Chris has been writing for MarketBeat since 2018.

Contact Chris Markoch via email at CTMarkoch@msn.com.
Free Email Newsletter

Complete the form below to receive the latest headlines and analysts' recommendations for your stocks with our free daily email newsletter:

Most Read This Week

Recent Articles

Search Headlines:

Latest PodcastDo These Dividend Achievers Deserve A Place In Your Portfolio?

ETF portfolio manager, Dave Gilreath offers a perspective on “dividend achievers” and why these deserve a role in your portfolio

MarketBeat Resources

Premium Research Tools

MarketBeat All Access subscribers can access stock screeners, the Idea Engine, data export tools, research reports, and other premium tools.

Discover All Access

Market Data and Calendars

Looking for new stock ideas? Want to see which stocks are moving? View our full suite of financial calendars and market data tables, all for free.

View Market Data

Investing Education and Resources

Receive a free world-class investing education from MarketBeat. Learn about financial terms, types of investments, trading strategies and more.

Financial Terms
Details Here
MarketBeat - Stock Market News and Research Tools logo

MarketBeat empowers individual investors to make better trading decisions by providing real-time financial data and objective market analysis. Whether you’re looking for analyst ratings, corporate buybacks, dividends, earnings, economic reports, financials, insider trades, IPOs, SEC filings or stock splits, MarketBeat has the objective information you need to analyze any stock. Learn more about MarketBeat.

MarketBeat is accredited by the Better Business Bureau MarketBeat is rated as Great on TrustPilot

© American Consumer News, LLC dba MarketBeat® 2010-2022. All rights reserved.
326 E 8th St #105, Sioux Falls, SD 57103 | contact@marketbeat.com | (844) 978-6257
MarketBeat does not provide personalized financial advice and does not issue recommendations or offers to buy stock or sell any security.

Our Accessibility Statement | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Do Not Sell My Information | RSS Feeds

© 2022 Market data provided is at least 10-minutes delayed and hosted by Barchart Solutions. Information is provided 'as-is' and solely for informational purposes, not for trading purposes or advice, and is delayed. To see all exchange delays and terms of use please see Barchart's disclaimer.