Free Trial

Risk-Free Money Market vs. Bank Dividend Stock, Which is Better?

bank stocks

Key Points

  • Money markets are paying over 4% risk-free interest rates without the potential for a drop in principal like an investment in bank stocks.
  • If looking for a bounce in regional bank stocks, spreading the risk in a diversified regional bank ETF is prudent.
  • The iShares U.S. Regional Banks ETF is down (29%) for 2023 and pays a 4.25% annual dividend yield.
  • 5 stocks we like better than iShares U.S. Regional Banks ETF

Banks stocks have been making headlines due to the collapse of the nation’s 16th largest bank, Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank. Notably, the regional bank stocks have been mercilessly punished as the market adopts a "Throw the baby out with the bath water" mentality. Sentiment moves stock prices, and the sentiment with bank stocks hasn't been this bad since the 2008 financial meltdown.

Many banks last saw this kind of selling volume in 2008. While volatility can present opportunities, the risk may be too high for many investors.

Interestingly, the major market indexes have been ratcheting higher despite the uniform sell-off in the banks. This could be a "flight to safety" as money rotates into technology stocks, gold, and even bitcoin. But what about the bank stocks? What about bank stocks versus a risk-free 4% annual interest rate in a safe money market account?

Weighing the Risks

Money market accounts have seen a tidal wave of deposits as investors rush for the safety of an FDIC-insured asset with a risk-free rate of return. Since last year, the 4.5% spike in interest rates has swayed many investors to see shelter in an asset that won't lose money. It's also birthed new dividend investors seeking capital appreciation and income.

Indeed, not all bank stocks are in danger, so there must be an opportunity. Yes and no. Remember that sentiment drives stock prices in the near term. Negative sentiment can still lower prices and valuations even if the systemic risk is removed from bank stocks.

Dividend Versus Principal

Bank stocks are known for paying dividends. Since the market has been falling since 2022, there has been a growth of dividend investors seeking yield income. The problem is that focusing solely on the annual dividend rate and ignoring capital depreciation can be detrimental. Many regional banks have seen double-digit losses in the past three weeks.

The iShares U.S. Regional Banks ETF NYSEARCA: IAT has fallen (29%) for 2023 versus a 2.41% gain for the S&P 500. The IAT pays a 4.25% annual dividend yield. Even if we round up to a 5% dividend yield, investors have lost nearly six-years worth of dividend payments in principal. Of course, these stocks can bounce back. The question is from where and when.


Bank Term Funding Program

In the past few weeks, the U.S. Federal Reserve and the U.S. Treasury have been trying to shore up any liquidity issues to galvanize sentiment in the U.S. banking system. The Fed rolled out a mini-TARP program, allowing banks to swap out their underwater treasuries under its Bank Term Funding Program to get additional liquidity for depositors. Regulation is likely around the corner for regional banks that, up to now, have been able to bypass Dodd-Frank reforms.

Sentiment Still Weak

The coalition of banks that pledged to deposit $5 billion into First Republic Bank NYSE: FRC includes JPMorgan Chase & Co. NYSE: JPM, Wells Fargo & Co. NYSE: WFC, Citigroup Inc. NYSE: C, and Bank of America NYSE: BAC. While this helped FRC shares recover from a low of $19.80 to a high of $40.00 on March 16, 2023. Shares proceeded to collapse back down to $20.23 the following day. This indicates that investor sentiment is still fragile even if the liquidity problem gets resolved.  

Money Market or Bank Dividend Stock?

The fallout in the banking stocks has yet to be resolved, which means there could be more downside. Of course, this makes divided yields rise, but that's bad news for investors who are already underwater holding bank stocks. That was the problem with Silicon Valley Bank, as interest rates rose. It's $80 billion of treasuries kept losing value. The principal should be protected. A 5% dividend pales compared to a (30%) drop in the underlying stock price.

Dollar Cost Averaging and Diversification through Regional Bank ETFs

Keeping funds in a money market provide risk-free returns of a 4% interest rate without damaging principle. If you want to benefit from capital appreciation by stepping into bank stocks, waiting for the smoke to clear is prudent. Rather than pick individual bank stocks, some risks can be spread out using a regional bank ETF like IAT.

Dollar-cost averaging and diversification are two strategies that can be implemented for risk-tolerant investors looking for a rebound in regional bank stocks.

Inverse Cup and Handle Breakdown

The weekly candlestick chart on IAT illustrates an inverse weekly cup and handle breakdown. The inverse cup lip line formed after shares bounced off $43.74 in January 2021. Shares climbed to a high of $67.73 by January 2022. The rounding bottom formed as shares gradually sold off close to the lip line at $45.38 in December 2022.

The bounce at the handle high peaked at $53.92 in January 2023 as IAT collapsed through the inverse cup lip line triggering the weekly inverse cup and handle breakdown in March 2023 on its heaviest weekly volume since 2008. Pullback support levels are at a $27.93 weekly market structure low (MSL) trigger, $25.61, $22.59, and $20.79.

Should you invest $1,000 in iShares U.S. Regional Banks ETF right now?

Before you consider iShares U.S. Regional Banks ETF, you'll want to hear this.

MarketBeat keeps track of Wall Street's top-rated and best performing research analysts and the stocks they recommend to their clients on a daily basis. MarketBeat has identified the five stocks that top analysts are quietly whispering to their clients to buy now before the broader market catches on... and iShares U.S. Regional Banks ETF wasn't on the list.

While iShares U.S. Regional Banks ETF currently has a "hold" rating among analysts, top-rated analysts believe these five stocks are better buys.

View The Five Stocks Here

Elon Musk's Next Move Cover

Wondering when you'll finally be able to invest in SpaceX, StarLink, or The Boring Company? Click the link below to learn when Elon Musk will let these companies finally IPO.

Get This Free Report
Jea Yu
About The Author

Jea Yu

Contributing Author

Trading Strategies

Like this article? Share it with a colleague.

Companies Mentioned in This Article

CompanyMarketRank™Current PricePrice ChangeDividend YieldP/E RatioConsensus RatingConsensus Price Target
iShares U.S. Regional Banks ETF (IAT)N/A$39.19-1.1%3.80%9.90N/AN/A
Bank of America (BAC)
4.3215 of 5 stars
$39.24-0.1%2.45%13.58Moderate Buy$39.79
Chase (CCF)
0 of 5 stars
$127.49flat0.78%36.64N/A
Citigroup (C)
4.7956 of 5 stars
$59.33-1.5%3.57%17.55Moderate Buy$63.66
First Republic Bank (FRC)
1.3859 of 5 stars
$0.00-100.0%0.31N/A
iShares U.S. Regional Banks ETF (IAT)N/A$0.00flatN/AN/AN/AN/A
JPMorgan Chase & Co. (JPM)
3.9196 of 5 stars
$193.78+0.1%2.37%11.70Moderate Buy$194.10
Signature Bank (SBNYP)
0 of 5 stars
$6.10+0.8%N/AN/AN/A
Signature Bank (SBNY)
0 of 5 stars
$2.09+5.0%N/AN/AN/A
Wells Fargo & Company (WFC)
3.9724 of 5 stars
$57.40+0.2%2.44%11.98Hold$58.99
Compare These Stocks  Add These Stocks to My Watchlist 


Featured Articles and Offers

Recent Videos

Will FOMC Push Stocks Higher? Here’s What to Expect
Unlock Growth: Understanding Dividend Yield
Palantir Stock Excluded from S&P 500: Still a Buy?

Stock Lists

All Stock Lists

Investing Tools

Calendars and Tools

Search Headlines