Permian Resources Rally Faces a Test

Key Points

• Permian Resources reported strong second-quarter results on Aug. 5, with revenue, net income, and earnings per share all beating Wall Street estimates.
• Analysts rate the stock a consensus Buy, but the average 12-month price target of $23.47 suggests little upside after the shares climbed 66% this year.
• The company's profits depend heavily on oil prices and dozens of recent acquisitions, so a crude price drop or integration missteps could hurt future performance.

The oil patch is riding high these days, and Permian Resources NYSE: PR is right in the middle of it.

The Midland, Texas-based company recently turned in a blowout earnings report and has continued its rapid-fire acquisition campaign. The stock is up 62% this year, and analysts rate the company a Buy. The fundamentals of its business look strong.

But given the runup, analysts are targeting only minimal 12-month appreciation. And with Permian’s current valuation and its oil-price sensitivity, investors should consider what the future might hold.

Results Beat Expectations

There’s no doubt the second quarter in the sector has been a good one. Permian reported on Aug. 5 that both its revenue and earnings beat analysts’ expectations.

For the three months, its second quarter revenue hit $1.86 billion against a Wall Street estimate of $1.66 billion. Net income soared to $792.5 million compared with $245 million the year before, and adjusted earnings per share were 69 cents versus a consensus of 59 cents.

Much of that increase stemmed from oil prices rising. The average sale price of its oil during the quarter reached $97.81 per barrel compared with $62.71 a year earlier.

The company’s higher output also contributed. Oil production for the quarter averaged 198,100 barrels per day, up 3% sequentially and about 12% year-over-year. In the latest report, the company said it was raising the mid-point of its full year guidance for oil production to 199,000 barrels per day, with the mid-point of its capital expenditures hitting $1.95 billion.

Cash Flow Cuts Debt

That additional production helped push up the amount of cash coming in. Adjusted free cash flow hit a company record of $751 million during the quarter, roughly 50% higher than the prior quarter, and the company announced cash capital expenditures of $521 million.

Management also used that cash flow to attack the balance sheet, redeeming $550 million of legacy 8% notes and, on July 15, another $325 million of 9.875% notes assumed in its 2023 Earthstone Energy merger.

The company said the two moves were expected to cut annual cash interest expense by about $75 million. In all, the company has reduced its debt by about 35% since the end of 2024 to $2.7 billion from $4.2 billion.

At the same time, the board also declared a third-quarter dividend of 16 cents per share, for an annualized yield of about 2.8%.

Analysts Rate Shares a Buy

Not surprisingly, analysts like the stock enough for consensus rating of Buy. With 21 analysts following the company, 18 give Permian a Buy rating, including five who place it as a Strong Buy. Three suggest a Hold, and no one is recommending a Sell.

The current 12-month price target is $23.47 per share, roughly flat with recent levels. The highest price target is $27, while the lowest is $16. At least four upgrades or target increases have come in the past month, with Wells Fargo and Truist boosting their targets, and Weiss Ratings moving from Hold to Buy.

Oil Prices Add Appeal and Risk

Given how well Permian is doing these days, that’s where the risk comes in.

Much of this year’s rally is inseparable from crude oil itself. West Texas Intermediate (WTI) has climbed from below $60 per barrel at the start of the year to above $110 in the spring. Although fluctuating widely in recent days, it has ranged from roughly $84 to $86 per barrel, driven largely by geopolitical tensions in the Middle East and tight inventories.

Of course, oil price rallies tied to geopolitical risk can reverse quickly, and a retreat toward $70 would compress Permian Resources’ cash flow and likely its stock price.

The second consideration is that Permian Resources has pieced together dozens of acquisitions, which is good for production but can be challenging to integrate. Permian said that year-to-date, the company has completed roughly 190 separate transactions, adding about 54,000 net leasehold acres and 20,000 net royalty acres for a combined cost near $1.05 billion.

At the same time, competitors including Diamondback Energy NASDAQ: FANG, Devon Energy NYSE: DVN, and Matador Resources NYSE: MTDR have chased similar Delaware Basin inventory.

Strong Results, Limited Upside

For investors, it’s important to keep in mind that Permian Resources isn't riding oil prices alone. Record free cash flow, double-digit production growth, and a debt load cut by more than a third in the past few years show strong execution.

With shares near a 52-week high, however, and analysts pointing to almost no further 12-month upside, much of the good news might already be priced in.

A steep drop in crude or a stumble digesting acquisitions could quickly change the picture. Today’s shareholders have reason to stay put, but new investors might want to wait for a pullback.

Continue following MarketBeat

Add MarketBeat as your preferred source on Google to see our latest stories in your feed.

Add As Preferred Source