Simmons First National Q4 2024 Earnings Report

Simmons First National EPS Results

• Actual EPS: $0.39
• Consensus EPS: $0.36
• Beat/Miss: Beat by +$0.03
• One Year Ago EPS: $0.40

Simmons First National Revenue Results

• Actual Revenue: $208.50 million
• Expected Revenue: $208.67 million
• Beat/Miss: Missed by -$173.17 thousand
• YoY Revenue Growth: +17.40%

Simmons First National Announcement Details

• Quarter: Q4 2024
• Date: 1/21/2025
• Time: After Market Closes
• Conference Call Date: Wednesday, January 22, 2025
• Conference Call Time: 8:30AM ET

Simmons First National (NASDAQ:SFNC) operates as the holding company for Simmons Bank that provides banking and other financial products and services to individuals and businesses. The company offers checking, savings, and time deposits; consumer, real estate, and commercial loans; agricultural finance, equipment, and small business administration lending; trust and fiduciary services; credit cards; investment management products; treasury management; insurance products; and securities and investment services. It also provides ATM services; Internet and mobile banking platforms; overdraft facilities; and safe deposit boxes. The company was founded in 1903 and is headquartered in Pine Bluff, Arkansas.

Simmons First National Q4 2024 Earnings Call Transcript

Presentation

[Operator]

Good morning, and welcome to the Simmons First National Corporation 4th Quarter Earnings Conference Call. All participants will be in listen only mode. After today's presentation, there will be an opportunity to ask questions. Please note this event is being recorded. I would now like to turn the conference over to Ed Bilic, Director of Investor Relations.

[Operator]

Please go ahead.

[Ed Bilek, EVP and Director Investor of Relations at Simmons First National]

Good morning, and welcome to Simmons First National Corporation's 4th quarter 2024 earnings call. Joining me today are several members of our executive management team, including our Chairman and CEO, George Makris President, Jay Brogden and CFO, Daniel Hobbs. Today's call will be in a Q and A format. Before we begin, I would like to remind you that our Q4 earnings materials, including the earnings release and presentation deck are available on our website at simmonsbank.com under the Investor Relations tab. During today's call, we will make forward looking statements about our future plans, goals, expectations, estimates, projections and outlook, including, among others, our outlook regarding future economic conditions, interest rates, lending and deposit activity, credit quality, liquidity and net interest margin.

[Ed Bilek, EVP and Director Investor of Relations at Simmons First National]

These statements involve risks and uncertainties, and you should therefore not place undue reliance on any forward looking statements as actual results could differ materially from those expressed in or implied by the forward looking statements due to a variety of factors. Additional information concerning some of these factors is contained in our earnings release and investor presentation furnished with our Form 8 ks yesterday and our Form 10 ks for the year ended December 31, 2023, including the risk factors contained in that Form 10 ks. These forward looking statements speak only as of the date they are made and Simmons assumes no obligation to update or revise any forward looking statements or other information. Finally, in this presentation, we will discuss certain non GAAP financial metrics we believe provide useful information to investors. Additional disclosures regarding non GAAP metrics, including the reconciliations of these non GAAP metrics to GAAP are contained in our earnings release and investor presentation, which we included as exhibits to the Form 8 ks we filed yesterday with the SEC and are also available on our Investor Relations page of our website, simmonsbank.com.

[Ed Bilek, EVP and Director Investor of Relations at Simmons First National]

Operator, we are ready to begin the Q and A session.

[Operator]

We will now begin the question and answer session. The first question comes from Woody Lay with KBW. Please go ahead.

[Woody Lay, Vice President at Keefe, Bruyette & Woods (KBW)]

Hey, good morning guys. Good morning. Wanted to start on the NII guide and was hoping you could just walk through any major assumptions that are baked into that. I know you have the loan growth guide. But I was just curious what about the puts and the takes behind the low end of the range versus the high end of the range?

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Yes, I'll jump in on that. Woody, good morning. And Daniel may have some comments as well here. But I think when I think about the NII guide, the first thing I'd start with is our outlook even going back to I think prior quarters and in activities throughout the Q4 even, we've really been pointing toward our ability, our belief that we could cross over a 3% net interest margin in the back half of the year this year. Obviously, we were more optimistic about that.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

If you go back to maybe even like October when the forwards looked very different at that time than they do today, but we still believe that that is within the range of expectations. We had a really good quarter this quarter. Honestly, our launching off point at the beginning of the year is a little better than we thought it was going to be in terms of our original forecasting for the Q4. And we can talk about that some on the call today to the extent there are questions there. But I think as we look to 2025, I still really feel confident in our ability to continue to see NIM expansion.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Obviously, you asked about the puts and takes to the low and high end of the range. We remain a bit liability sensitive here, a fair amount liability sensitive. So any changes in the Fed's actions or the forwards would impact outcomes within that range. And then I think just the growth outlook on both sides of the balance sheet. We've been more optimistic certainly today as we think about loan growth.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

At the same time that's still sort of conversations and voiceover and optimism in conversations among our bankers and our clients. But we've got to see that convert into the pipeline and pull through the pipeline, and it's a bit early to see that optimism reading through. But we do see some green shoots there. And then on the deposit side, our focus will continue to very much be to grow the core customer base and simultaneously shrink the wholesale funding that's on the balance sheet. And so I think that the growth side of that equation will obviously have an impact on where we would be in the range on the guide there.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Daniel, anything you'd add to that?

[Daniel Hobbs, EVP & CFO at Simmons First National Corporation]

Yes. I would add, an important thing to note is that our guide is based on the forwards, which was the 1.13 January 13 forwards. And that had our first full rate cut by October of 2025. So if you think about the low end of the range versus the high end of the range, if that rate cut happened sooner, then we'd probably be at the high end of that range and maybe some opportunity. And if we didn't get a rate cut at all, we still feel pretty good that we could be at that low end of that range.

[Daniel Hobbs, EVP & CFO at Simmons First National Corporation]

So that's how I would tell you to think about that.

[Woody Lay, Vice President at Keefe, Bruyette & Woods (KBW)]

Got it. Yes, that's good to hear. And then a follow-up on the loan growth, up low single digits. It is below what I would consider as sort of a normalized growth rate for you all. Is it all related to customer demand?

[Woody Lay, Vice President at Keefe, Bruyette & Woods (KBW)]

Or is part of it related to you all being a little more disciplined in order to run off higher costing deposits? In order to run off higher costing deposits?

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

I think it's absolutely, I want to tie it back to something you've been hearing us say, Woody, all of you have been hearing us say, which is soundness, profitability and growth in that order. This comment applies both to the loans and the deposits. We're going to maintain discipline, always have on soundness and increasingly too on the profitability side. And that's going to mute absolute levels of growth, but candidly that's going to increase levels of profitability and returns. And so sort of leaner, meaner balance sheet with much more improved levels of profitability in terms of returns on invested capital.

[Woody Lay, Vice President at Keefe, Bruyette & Woods (KBW)]

Yes, makes sense. And last for me, I mean, just given the balance sheet should remain relatively stable, I would expect capital to grow pretty nicely throughout 2025. How do you view your excess capital position? And are there opportunities to deploy some capital in the year ahead?

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Yes. So let me make an attempt at just kind of thinking about the answer to that in terms of how we evaluate our priorities around capital, Woody. So I don't think you'll hear anything new here, but our number one priority around capital continues to be organic growth initiatives. To your point, that growth is really kind of within the mix of the balance sheet, etcetera. And so we should be able to continue to grow capital from here on that asset base.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

I would include within kind of organic balance sheet initiatives, we continue to also evaluate balance sheet restructure opportunities. You've seen us do that in the past. We did one in the most recently in Q3 of last year. So we'll continue to evaluate those and the market I think will continue to give us some opportunities to evaluate that. So that would be top priorities around our use of capital.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Obviously, our dividend is a priority. And then from there, we'll continue to maintain an authorized share buyback. We have that in place. We'll continue to evaluate that. But share buybacks or other external priorities around capital would fall behind those first couple of priorities that we outlined there.

[Woody Lay, Vice President at Keefe, Bruyette & Woods (KBW)]

All right. That's all for me. Thanks for taking my questions.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Thank you.

[Operator]

The next question comes from Matt Olney with Stephens. Please go ahead.

[Matt Olney, Managing Director at Stephens Inc]

Hey, thanks. Good morning. I want to go back to the margin discussion and it sounds like that 4th quarter margin at 2.87 was a little bit above your expectations. Just any color on that comment?

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

I'll give a couple of remarks. I know Daniel have some things to say here too. But really, I think even just thinking about our forecasting for the Q4, and I don't want to apologize for this at all, but we outperformed our expectations both on the loan pricing and the deposit pricing side in the Q4. We expected maybe a little more pressure on loan yields than what we saw. And so we were pleased with our discipline and ability to kind of fend off and at least for now lag some of the downward movement by the Fed on the asset side.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

And then conversely on the deposit side, sort of the double benefit was and Matt you've heard us talk about this previously, but we did a lot of work going back to last spring and especially over the summer around evaluating the elasticity of our customer base. We were sort of doing control testing across markets to see where we felt like the elasticity points were across different types of customers, different types of products. And really felt like we were able in the Q4 to pull forward, again, maybe mitigating some of the lag that we otherwise would have assumed, maybe outperforming our beta assumptions on the deposit side. And so I think the good news, as I said earlier, is that that allowed us to maybe have a better launch point in 2025 than where our original expectations were. Doesn't really change the shape of what we're expecting in terms of NIM expansion throughout 2025.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

We talked earlier about some of the dependencies there. But we did see some relative But we did see some relative

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

outperformance in the Q4 for some

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

of those reasons. Daniel, anything you

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

want to add?

[Daniel Hobbs, EVP & CFO at Simmons First National Corporation]

Yes. Maybe just a couple of finer points around your commentary there. If you look at our NIM walk forward in the IP, you'll see that the majority of our benefit and outperformance to our model came from our funding cost benefit. Our funding cost was about 24 basis points lower than the Q2 and that drove about 22 basis points of the NIM impact.

[Daniel Hobbs, EVP & CFO at Simmons First National Corporation]

And within that funding costs, you've got kind of deposits and the wholesale or the FHLB side of that funding. The majority of the benefit came from the deposit cost side, probably 80% of that benefit did for the reasons that Jay mentioned. If you go back, so if you look at our deposit costs, we're down 19 basis points in the Q3. Yes, I think it's even a little bit more impressive if you go back to the Q3 where we were flat at $279,000,000 from Q2 to Q3, while I think we were the only peer in our peer group that didn't increase our deposit cost over that time period. So our starting point was strong to Jay's comments around pulling forward the lag.

[Daniel Hobbs, EVP & CFO at Simmons First National Corporation]

We effectively eliminated a lag, which typically is about 3 to 6 months when at the change of a cycle. So that really is what drove a lot of our benefit in the 4th quarter outperformed our model. And then on the loan yield side, we were down 12 basis points. And you think about that between variable and fixed, our variable rate loan yields, portfolio yields were down about 40 basis points, but the fixed rate loans repricing was up 7 basis points. So that tailwind that we've been talking about for several quarters now around our rate loans re pricing higher, they re priced higher in the Q4 by about 200 basis points within the portfolio yield.

[Daniel Hobbs, EVP & CFO at Simmons First National Corporation]

So they're going off the pay downs versus the new production that was a spread about 200 basis points of positivity, which drove 7 basis points of total portfolio yield improvement on the fixed asset side fixed loan side. So, those two things kind of outperformed where we thought. And so we're in a really good spot going into the Q1.

[Matt Olney, Managing Director at Stephens Inc]

Okay. Appreciate that commentary. And Daniel, you kind of led me into that. My next question around the loan pricing of that fixed rate book, you've got some great disclosures on that Slide 15 around the $2,400,000,000 of cash flows during 2025. Not a small number, so it sounds like you still have some more tailwinds there.

[Matt Olney, Managing Director at Stephens Inc]

Any is that relatively spread throughout the year evenly or is that weighted towards any specific quarter? And is that 200 basis point increase that you just mentioned a few minutes ago, is that a reasonable number to assume at least in the near term as far as some of these renewals?

[Daniel Hobbs, EVP & CFO at Simmons First National Corporation]

Yes. In terms of the spreading across the timeframe, I think it's probably fair. I don't have it in front of me, but I think that's probably a fair assumption. I know it's going to continue the tailwind of that fixed rate book repricing is going to continue for some time into 2026. So that's going to continue to be a benefit for us.

[Daniel Hobbs, EVP & CFO at Simmons First National Corporation]

And that 200 basis point spread, I'd have to look at the our modeling on that, but I think that's probably a fair way to think about it.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

I think I'd add I don't disagree. I'd maybe just add a little bit of market color, Matt, to maybe influence the thought process there. And I'd also point you to the loan pipeline on slot 19 in the materials where you can see both the pipeline as well as our rate ready to close trends. And so I think the 200 basis point spread is certainly fair in the immediate term. What I'm already seeing, what we're already seeing in the marketplace is a fair amount of price competition, particularly on A credit out there.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

When we see really good opportunities in our pipeline, those are still that really high quality credit is still really, really coveted in the marketplace. The activity, as I mentioned earlier, has some green shoots to it, some optimism to it. But we're not just seeing tremendous volume in the market come to bear yet. And therefore, when you see good opportunities, right now we're seeing a lot of price competition on those. And so, can we maintain 200 basis point spread for 12 months this year?

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

I think part of that question is going to depend on that competitive environment that we're talking about there. And again, we're just going to we're going to maintain that's where relationships matter. That's where your ability to flex in relationships matters and get paid. And we're going to maintain those priorities around soundness, profitability and growth. And that will play out through the year this year.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

And there's probably some color there to lead through into the deposit side as well. You've got pricing competition both on the loan side and the deposit side that's still pretty intense out there in this market despite some that you think about the Fed.

[Daniel Hobbs, EVP & CFO at Simmons First National Corporation]

Hey, Matt. Sure.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Yes.

[Daniel Hobbs, EVP & CFO at Simmons First National Corporation]

This is Daniel. Let me make I'll make one more comment about NIM and kind of looking forward. The 13 basis points improvement that we got in the Q4, we talked about the lag and bringing that forward. We've got a really good jumping off point for the Q1, but I wouldn't expect the same pace of increase that we got in the Q4 to occur in the Q1 because of bringing forward a lot of that benefit from eliminating that lag. So just we do expect some expansion in the Q1, but not at the level that we saw in the Q4.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Yes, I

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

mean to accentuate that point, if we had if we stack 2, 13 basis point quarters together, we'd be at 3% NIM at the start of the year and the Q1 of the year. And our expectation is that as we've been saying all along, that's a run rate we believe we can get to in the back half of the year. So I think that's a good way to summarize that point.

[Matt Olney, Managing Director at Stephens Inc]

Okay, guys. Thanks for the commentary.

[Operator]

Thank you, Matt. The next question comes from David Feaster with Raymond James. Please go ahead.

[David Feaster, Director at Raymond James Financial]

Hey, good morning, everybody.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Hey, David. Good morning.

[David Feaster, Director at Raymond James Financial]

I just wanted to follow-up a

[David Feaster, Director at Raymond James Financial]

bit on kind of what

[David Feaster, Director at Raymond James Financial]

we were just talking about to an extent. But on the deposit side, you guys have done a great job optimizing the funding base, reducing deposit costs. How has client reception of lower rates been thus far? And just the competitive landscape as you see it in your ability to continue to reduce deposit costs, especially if the industry loan growth starts to accelerate like we've talked about?

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Yes. I think, David on the deposit side, it's still to state the obvious, it's still very, very competitive out there. The flip side of that is, the good news of that is we've been positively, I think, influenced around the elasticity in the deposit base as we've talked about it. When we did some of the testing over the summer last year, we really became increasingly confident in our ability to, as we talked about earlier, to kind of reduce some of the lags, became a little more confident in some of our beta assumptions around the core customer base. And so I don't I'm not aware of anything within our administered rate portfolio where we've made moves and sort of regretted those moves thus far.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

So that piece is encouraging. The competition piece is I wouldn't say it's more intense than it has been. It just continues to be a very competitive environment around the deposit side and we don't really expect that to abate. That's been a consistent thought of ours throughout the past couple of years and really doesn't influence how we think about sort of our outlook for 2025. That's just the environment we're operating in today.

[Daniel Hobbs, EVP & CFO at Simmons First National Corporation]

Yes. And David, I might add, always rate and balance growth, there's a trade off there and you're trying to maximize the right point there. And we probably have more optimization than our peers in terms of our rate part of our book. So as you think about growth for us relative to peers, we're trying to find that right balance. I think we've done a really good job of that.

[Daniel Hobbs, EVP & CFO at Simmons First National Corporation]

Maybe just a point around that. In the Q4, on our I forget what slide it is, but where we do our walk forward on our deposits, you'll notice that customer time deposits declined and IB deposits increased. And so if you dig into that and you look at the customer closure CDs in the 4th quarter, where relationship really pulls through is of those CDs that closed in the 4th quarter, we were able to retain on the relationship side, those in other words, those that had more than just a CD with us, we were able to retain over 75% of those balances either in lower cost CDs. In other words, they closed the CD they were in and went into a lower cost CD at the current lower rate or they moved into interest bearing lower cost deposits. And so we are really stressing relationship, profitability with our team and that's really showing through there.

[Daniel Hobbs, EVP & CFO at Simmons First National Corporation]

And then even on the ones that aren't relationship, we were able to retain 25 percent of those balances. And so that's the rate side of the house. But then if you just look at the core funding, the NIB, we're really encouraged in the Q4 with consumer. Consumer, we saw growth both on an ending and average basis for the first time in a long time. And even in all balanced tiers, so we do an analysis that looks at 5 or 6 different balanced tiers and we saw growth in every single one of those tiers in the 4th quarter, which is really encouraging to us as you generally see seasonal growth in consumer in that 4th quarter.

[Daniel Hobbs, EVP & CFO at Simmons First National Corporation]

So we're encouraged by that. And then one final point on that is that for the year, we grew consumer checking accounts by 1.5%. And that is the lifeblood and the core engine of a consumer bank. And so we're leaning into that, continue to expect that going forward.

[David Feaster, Director at Raymond James Financial]

That's great color. And maybe on the other side, just switching to loans, we talked a bit about that. Could you just touch a bit on the complexion of the pipeline and what you'd expect to be key drivers of growth? And just with the pipeline staying relatively stable, I mean, would you expect kind of growth to be maybe more focused on like the seasonally stronger quarters with ag increasing and maybe some slower growth in the first half of the year as demand starts to improve? And at what point do you just do you start getting more competitive on the pricing front in order to drive growth?

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Well, we'll be again, we'll be competitive. We're not trying to be out of market from a pricing point of view even today. I would just say that we're maintaining discipline from a pricing point of view and that includes relationship views around profitability, not just single transaction views, it's comprehensive of all of those things, David. So we I'm going to be real clear there. We're seeking to grow the loan portfolio and we're just seeking to get really good risk adjusted returns on those investments.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

The way I think about the pipeline today, we're seeing good opportunities really as we go into 2025. It's pretty well diversified. It's diversified within the commercial real estate areas of the bank and it's diversified in other commercial areas where we're seeing some good opportunities. So that part feels pretty healthy and broad based to me. It's also somewhat broad based geographically.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

I can't certainly markets like DFW and Nashville continue to be pretty positive markets for us on a relative basis within our entire footprint. But really I'm pleased with the level of productivity we're seeing throughout the footprint in terms of loan growth opportunities. I do as I sit here today, this is about as confident as predicting what the Fed is going to do. But I believe that we will potentially see an uptick in volume as we move through the year this year. I mentioned earlier in my some of the opening comments just around the puts and takes for the NII outlook when we talked about volume.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

We see some green shoots today. We see more positive conversations. Commercial balance sheets are very, very healthy. That's both good and bad. That's good from an overall credit point of view when we look at our customer base.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

But that can also mute demand a little bit. When you got a really, really healthy balance sheet that may not lead to an onslaught of borrowing need. I think as we move through the year, if some of the optimism continues that we see today, I'm optimistic we're going to see more need for investment, more willingness to invest and more opportunity out there. The last thing I'd mention in terms of that shape of that loan growth is we already talked about in one of the earlier questions around kind of fixed rate pay downs. We'll have pay downs, good healthy pay downs this year.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

We'll have for example, some CRE that goes to the permanent market, just exactly the way that it's supposed to. And so a lot of our what we see in the pipeline will fill up that good healthy activity and then we'll be seeking to grow on top of that and think we'll be able to do that.

[David Feaster, Director at Raymond James Financial]

That's great. That's great. And last one for me, just touching on credit. It seems like things are kind of just normalizing, right? Obviously, some weakness in areas like the consumer, but looking broadly, it just kind of feels like a normalization, and that's kind of what your guidance implies.

[David Feaster, Director at Raymond James Financial]

I'm just kind of curious, what are you seeing on the credit front? What are you watching closely? Is there anything notable or just kind of curious what you're seeing on the credit front broadly?

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Yes, thanks. Nothing that I would call notable that's new. I think normalization is still exactly the right term in terms of how we think about what's happening in the portfolio. David, specific to us, we've talked about, we've identified a runoff portfolio. It continues to runoff significantly.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Those balances are getting somewhat irrelevant to talk about. But as we've said before, your best loans in those portfolios are the ones that are paying off and the ones that we'll continue to have to deal with and could see some charge offs in are the ones that remain there. So the runoff portfolio, small balance, but that's one we keep a close eye on. And then outside of that, I mean, in our portfolio, it's really just kind of a handful of credits. It's nothing new.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

It's nothing new that's migrated in. So we feel like we've got a really tight box around the credits and the portfolios that we have to talk about and keep a close eye on. When I think about commercial real estate broadly, our performance and we have some detailed breakdowns in terms of the makeup of those portfolios, the levels of past dues, non accruals, etcetera, We're just we're not seeing anything that is causing us any kind of new concerns in those portfolios. So I think we'll continue to be prudent in dealing with the known credits and the small runoff portfolio that we have. We'll work through those as aggressively as we can.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Outside of that, the good news is we're just not seeing a lot of changes on the credit front. Even had some good trends within like classifieds and criticized in the quarter. So I feel like the credit picture is really kind of business as usual at this point.

[David Feaster, Director at Raymond James Financial]

Perfect. Thanks everybody.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Thank you, David. Thank you.

[Operator]

The

[Operator]

next question comes from Gary Tenner with D. A. Davidson. Please go ahead.

[Gary Tenner, Managing Director & Senior Research Analyst at D.A. Davidson]

Thanks. Good morning, guys.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Good morning.

[Gary Tenner, Managing Director & Senior Research Analyst at D.A. Davidson]

Hey, I

[Gary Tenner, Managing Director & Senior Research Analyst at D.A. Davidson]

just wanted to ask about longer term profitability. I mean, you talk about the kind of the focus on profitability at the kind of expensive growth, if you will, and the positive NIM direction you see for 2025. What's the rate environment do you think you need to get the ROA back over 1%? What's the kind of the optimal setup for you there and kind of visibility around that?

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

I think 1st and foremost, the steepening of the yield curve is a really good thing for the whole industry, right? And so that is an environment that I think all of us need in the industry. We've talked before, Gary. I feel pretty good about just kind of let's think down a couple of KPIs starting at the top. I feel pretty good about something in the area of a 3.50 NIM kind of being an operating NIM for us, plus or minus a range around that 3.50 area.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

That fits well within our risk appetite that would fit well within what we would think of as a more optimized balance sheet. I think when we're still going to be we're proud to have a retail community bank out there. So that you take a 3.50 NIM and our business model and the granularity of that model, that still probably spells out something in the low 50s top efficiency ratio. Hard to get a whole lot lower than that on a retail base like we have. And I think that would result in something in the area of the 125 ROA.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

And we have a real continuous improvement around all of those things to continue to press those metrics better and forward. To get there, we got to chew through some of the duration overhang on some of the assets on the balance sheet. So there's a rate and time element of that. Every time we talk about timeline, you have to talk about what's the rate environment in that timeline. And then what opportunities will we have from a balance sheet restructure or otherwise to help accelerate those timelines.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

So that's how we think about our long range targets and the scenarios or the path to getting there.

[Gary Tenner, Managing Director & Senior Research Analyst at D.A. Davidson]

Okay. I appreciate that. My other questions were answered. Thank you.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Thank you.

[Operator]

The next question comes from Stephen Scouten with Piper Sandler. Please go ahead.

[Stephen Scouten, MD & Senior Research Analyst at Piper Sandler Companies]

Yes. Thanks everyone. Jay, I know you kind of touched on this at a high level saying you guys would still evaluate potential securities restructuring. But can you talk about maybe what dynamics would compel you potentially to do that? Obviously, with rates a little higher, we think the math maybe slightly more compelling now.

[Stephen Scouten, MD & Senior Research Analyst at Piper Sandler Companies]

And maybe just in particular around the health maturity book and how you guys think about that?

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

Yes, Stephen, I appreciate the question. I think that the reality is we're looking at all versions of those scenarios. And it's not a there's not a single dimension that we look at it through. I mean, as an example, you mentioned the held to maturity portfolio. In a scenario where we did a larger top transaction like that, the sensitivity of the balance sheet changes dramatically.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

And so we evaluate the ALM aspects of the balance sheet kind of pre and pro form a. Obviously, we evaluate capital and earnings. That's probably you've heard me say this before, Stephen, that's probably our leading evaluation when we're looking at balance sheet restructures is just trade offs between capital and earnings. One of the things that I like to look at is in one of those in any kind of scenario, big or small kind of trade within the balance sheet restructure, I like to look out over the next 3, 4, 5 years. So I'll just finish my comment there to the extent, I'm not sure where we are in terms of the operator in the line here.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

But let me just finish my comment for those that are on the call. One of the things that we focused on that I think is particularly important is looking out 3 or 4 years in the context of any kind of trade, look out over a period of time and look at different rate scenarios, shock, for example, down rates 100, 200, 300 basis points. And what is our earnings outlook on the current balance sheet over that period of time versus the pro form a for a trade. Are we making more money or less money in different rate environments? And so we really, as you've heard me say before, we're very scenario rich.

[Jay Brogdon, President at Simmons First National Corporation]

We run a lot of scenarios around a lot of these things. And obviously, if we think that there's an economically viable path for a pull forward of those timelines, we're going to want to take advantage of that.

[Operator]

Excuse me, Steven, are you still there? Okay. At this time, this concludes our question and answer session. I would like to turn the conference back over to George Makris for any closing remarks.

[George Makris, Chairman & CEO at Simmons First National Corporation]

Thank you very much. And not surprisingly, we've outlined a pretty conservative outlook for 2025. But I will say that we're cautiously optimistic that a favorable business environment will help us exceed our expectations. So stay tuned. Before we drop off today, I've got some special recognition I'd like to make.

[George Makris, Chairman & CEO at Simmons First National Corporation]

We had 5 key executives retire at the end of 2024. Bob Feldman, who is our CEO Steve Massanelli, who was our Chief Administrative Officer Steve Wade, who had served as our Chief Credit Officer Johnny McCaleb, who had served as our Chief Audit Executive and Pat Neely, who ran bank operations, all retired at the end of 2024. That's a lot of talent to lose at one time, but I'll tell you their replacements are just as good with long runways and we're excited about that. These five folks played a pivotal role over the last 10 years as we grew. And if you can think about how they were able to manage our day to day operation, but also improve our operations, our risk management, oversee our credit operation as we integrated 13 banks.

[George Makris, Chairman & CEO at Simmons First National Corporation]

It was a monumental task. And I can't thank these guys enough for what they've meant for Simmons Bank. So guys, we'll miss you, but thank you very much. You've left the company in a good way. That's really all we have for today.

[George Makris, Chairman & CEO at Simmons First National Corporation]

Thank you for joining us and have a great day.

[Operator]

The conference has now concluded. Thank you for attending today's presentation. You may now disconnect.

Participants

Executives

• Ed Bilek, EVP and Director Investor of Relations
• Jay Brogdon, President
• Daniel Hobbs, EVP & CFO
• George Makris, Chairman & CEO

Analysts

• Woody Lay, Vice President at Keefe, Bruyette & Woods (KBW)
• Matt Olney, Managing Director at Stephens Inc
• David Feaster, Director at Raymond James Financial
• Gary Tenner, Managing Director & Senior Research Analyst at D.A. Davidson
• Stephen Scouten, MD & Senior Research Analyst at Piper Sandler Companies