Encore Capital Group Has Doubled—But Its Best Tailwind Won’t Last Forever

Key Points

• Elevated consumer charge-offs have created favorable purchasing conditions for Encore Capital Group as banks sell more distressed debt.
• Record collections and improving operating efficiency are helping Encore turn that supply into stronger earnings.
• After the stock more than doubled over the past year, investors must weigh those gains against a credit cycle that will eventually change.

Encore Capital Group NASDAQ: ECPG has built a business around a part of the economy most investors would rather not think about. It buys charged-off consumer debt from banks, including credit-card balances that have been written off as hopeless, and then collects what it can.

It is an uncomfortable business, but elevated consumer credit stress has created unusually favorable conditions for Encore. The stock has more than doubled over the past year as the credit cycle has shifted increasingly in Encore’s favor.

But is it too late to get in? That’s the question investors should ask.

Record Collections Drive Encore’s Earnings Recovery

The business model is not a sure thing. Encore lost money in both 2023 and 2024 as rising interest rates pushed up borrowing costs while pressuring the value of older debt portfolios. Profitability returned last year.

The second quarter of this year, reported Aug. 5, showed why the market has been re-rating the shares so aggressively.

Net income came in at $64 million for the quarter, equal to earnings per share of $2.81, 14 cents above what analysts had modeled, continuing a streak of earnings beats. The increase in earnings came even as Encore absorbed refinancing costs during the quarter, roughly a dollar per share, in exchange for generating about $15 million in expected annualized savings going forward.

Revenue rose to $491.9 million, roughly 8.1% above what analysts expected. Global collections, or the amount the company collects from its portfolios of distressed debt, hit a quarterly record of $737 million, up 13%. Encore also put a record amount to work buying new debt portfolios in the United States.

But the most important number in the release was not revenue or collections. It was the relationship between them. Operating expenses rose only 5%, against 13% growth in collections. In other words, Encore is collecting substantially more money without adding expenses at anywhere near the same pace.

Consumer Credit Stress Expands Encore’s Opportunity

Those personally familiar with Encore know that behind its financials sits an uncomfortable engine. Encore's raw material is American financial distress, and there is a great deal of it right now.

Annualized U.S. net charge-off volume has run at a high level, and credit-card delinquencies remain near multiyear highs, giving Encore an unusually deep and cheap pool of debt to buy.

Management has leaned into that opportunity, sending the majority of the quarter's purchasing dollars to the U.S. market.

The company also responded by raising full-year guidance, now calling for collections of $2.8 billion to $2.85 billion and earnings of $13 to $14 per share for the full year.

Accounting Estimates Add Uncertainty

The company's revenue also depends on management's estimates of how much cash it expects to eventually collect from portfolios purchased years earlier. When those estimates get revised upward, revenue rises without any cash changing hands.

The second quarter included a favorable revision of that kind, and collections have been running well ahead of the company's own forecast from the end of 2025. That track record has been reassuring, but it still means investors are trusting a model rather than a bank statement.

On the balance sheet, a May refinancing and a July redemption of convertible notes leave the company with no material debt maturities until 2028.

Analysts Remain Positive Despite the Run-Up

While coverage of Encore is relatively thin, recent analyst sentiment has been broadly positive. The stock carries a consensus Buy rating, with recent ratings including Buy, Strong Buy, and Market Outperform.

With the stock trading at about $99.54 per share, the highest 12-month price target is $115, while the lowest sits at $62 per share, though that price target is notably old.

Even at the highest target price, the recent runup places it in reach. Shares in Encore have soared 83% since the start of the year and $120.5% over the past 12 months, beating even its five-year performance.

A Healthier Consumer Could Cool the Growth Story

The central risk with Encore is that its prosperity depends on the American consumer continuing to struggle.

The low prices and abundant supply of debt driving record purchasing volume exist precisely because delinquencies are up. If household credit heals, Encore's cost of inventory rises and its growth engine cools, which is the opposite of how most growth stories play out.

Europe already offers a preview of that pattern. The company's Cabot unit saw collections flat as the U.K. market deals with lower delinquencies, subdued lending, and stiff competition.

Debt collection also remains one of the most heavily regulated corners of finance, and Encore has settled multiple federal enforcement actions over the past decade, a reminder that regulatory risk never fully goes away in this business.

Encore’s Gains Depend on How Long This Cycle Lasts

That combination of a doubled stock price and a still-modest price-to-earnings multiple of roughly 7.5 is unusual and reflects a business that is cheap, improving, but eventually temporary.

The operating gains and the funding adjustment look durable. The heightened purchasing environment that is fueling growth does not, at least not forever. The share price has already absorbed a good deal of that good news.

For investors who are comfortable with where things sit now and know the credit cycle will eventually turn, Encore is well-positioned for the world as it is. But “eventually” is the word investors should always keep in mind.