Peoples Bancorp Q1 2026 Earnings Report

Peoples Bancorp EPS Results

• Actual EPS: $0.82
• Consensus EPS: $0.80
• Beat/Miss: Beat by +$0.02
• One Year Ago EPS: N/A

Peoples Bancorp Revenue Results

• Actual Revenue: $119.33 million
• Expected Revenue: $118.72 million
• Beat/Miss: Beat by +$612.00 thousand
• YoY Revenue Growth: N/A

Peoples Bancorp Announcement Details

• Quarter: Q1 2026
• Date: 4/21/2026
• Time: Before Market Opens
• Conference Call Date: Tuesday, April 21, 2026
• Conference Call Time: 11:00AM ET

Peoples Bancorp (NASDAQ:PEBO), Inc is a bank holding company headquartered in Marietta, Ohio. Through its subsidiary Peoples Bank, the company provides a comprehensive range of commercial and consumer banking services designed to serve individuals, businesses and institutional clients. Its deposit products include checking and savings accounts, money market accounts, certificates of deposit and digital banking platforms that enable secure online and mobile access.

On the lending side, Peoples Bancorp offers commercial and industrial loans, commercial real estate financing, construction and agricultural lending, as well as residential mortgage products. The company also delivers cash management and treasury services, merchant card processing, equipment leasing and other ancillary services to support the operational needs of its business customers. Wealth management and trust services are available, encompassing investment advisory, fiduciary and retirement planning solutions.

Founded in 1875 as the Bank of Marietta, Peoples Bank has expanded through organic growth and strategic acquisitions to build a regional presence across eastern Ohio, western Pennsylvania and northern West Virginia. Its branch network, ATM facilities and digital channels provide clients with convenient access to banking services. Governance is overseen by a board of directors and senior management team with deep ties to the communities the bank serves.

Peoples Bancorp Q1 2026 Earnings Call Transcript

Key Takeaways

• Positive Sentiment: We announced a planned merger with Citizens National Corporation (~$700M assets), expected to close in H2 2026, with consideration of 2.1 shares plus $8 cash and management forecasting 40% cost saves, tangible book earn-back <1 year, and ~+$0.20 EPS accretion in 2027.
• Positive Sentiment: First‑quarter results beat expectations with Diluted EPS $0.81 (consensus $0.80), NIM expansion of 4 bps, modest loan growth, improved credit metrics and capital (tangible equity to assets 8.91%), and an 11th consecutive dividend increase to $0.42/share (4.84% yield).
• Negative Sentiment: Credit-related headwinds included a $9.7M provision driven by weaker macroeconomic assumptions and $3.8M of small‑ticket lease charge‑offs (23 bps of annualized net charge‑off rate); management expects Q2 net charge‑offs to remain elevated before improving in H2 2026.
• Neutral Sentiment: 2026 outlook (ex‑merger) targets NIM 4.0%–4.2% (sensitive ~3–4 bps per 25 bp Fed move), quarterly fee income $28M–$30M, quarterly non‑interest expense $73M–$75M, and loan growth toward the low end of a 3%–5% range.

Presentation

[Operator]

Good morning, and welcome to Peoples Bancorp Inc.'s conference call. My name is Chuck, and I'll be your conference facilitator. Today's call will cover a discussion of the results of operations for the quarter ended March 31st, 2026. Please be advised that all lines have been placed on mute to prevent any background noise. After the speaker's remarks, there will be a question and answer period. If you would like to ask a question during this time, simply press star then one on your telephone keypad, and questions will be taken in the order they are received.

[Operator]

If you would like to withdraw your question, please press star, then two. This call is also being recorded. If you object to the recording, please disconnect at this time. Please be advised that the commentary in this call will contain projections and other forward-looking statements regarding Peoples Bancorp's future financial performance and future events.

[Operator]

These statements are based on management's current expectations. The statements in this call, which are not historical fact, are forward-looking statements and involve a number of risks and uncertainties detailed in the Peoples' Securities and Exchange Commission filings. Management believes that the forward-looking statements made during this call are based on reasonable assumption within the bounds of their knowledge of Peoples' business and operations. However, it is possible actual results may differ materially from these forward-looking statements. Peoples disclaims any responsibility to update these forward-looking statements after this call, except as may be required by applicable legal requirements. Peoples' first quarter 2026 earnings release and earnings conference call presentation were issued this morning and are available at peoplesbancorp.com under Investor Relations.

[Operator]

A reconciliation of the non-generally accepted accounting principles or GAAP financial measures discussed during this call to the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures is included at the end of the earnings release. This call will include about 15-20 minutes of prepared commentary, followed by a question and answer period, which I will facilitate. An archive webcast of this call will be available at peoplesbancorp.com in the investor relations section for one year. Participants in this call today are Mr. Tyler Wilcox, President and Chief Executive Officer, along with Ms. Katie Bailey, Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer, and each will be available for questions following opening statements. Mr. Wilcox, you may begin the conference.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Thank you, Chuck. Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining our call today. Earlier this morning, we announced that we entered into an agreement to merge with Citizens National Corporation. Citizens has approximately $700 million in assets and operates 12 branches in 8 counties in Kentucky. We expect to close the merger in the second half of 2026. We're excited about this partnership, which expands our presence in Kentucky markets that both overlap and complement our existing footprint. Citizens is a deposit-rich franchise that shares a similar philosophy in serving the needs of clients and communities. We look forward to welcoming their shareholders, employees, and clients to become part of the Peoples team. We believe this merger will improve shareholder value and benefit associates of both Citizens and Peoples while offering clients of Citizens more diversified products.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

I will go into more details on the planned merger later in the call, and you can refer to our accompanying slides for additional details. Now, I would like to highlight our results issued this morning. We reported Diluted Earnings Per Share of $0.81 for the first quarter. Our results included several improvements compared to the linked quarter. For the first quarter, our net interest margin expanded 4 basis points, driven by lower deposit costs. We had a $400,000 increase in fee-based income. We had loan growth of $13 million when we had originally anticipated loan growth to be flat due to expected pay-downs during the first quarter. Our non-performing loans and delinquency levels improved, while we also experienced reductions in our criticized and classified loan balances. Our non-interest-bearing deposits grew over $41 million or 3%. Our loan-to-deposit ratio improved to 88.5%.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Our Tangible Equity to Tangible Assets Ratio increased 12 basis points to 8.91%. Our book value per share grew 1% on an annualized basis compared to year-end, while our Tangible Book Value Per Share improved 3% on an annualized basis. All of our regulatory capital ratios improved and our Diluted EPS of $0.81 exceeded consensus analyst estimates of $0.80. As we've noted previously, we typically have annual first quarter one-time expenses that occur, which include stock-based compensation expense related to the annual forfeiture rate true-up on stock vested during the first quarter, along with upfront expense on stock grants to retirement eligible employees, which combined for a total of $764,000 and negatively impacted Diluted EPS by $0.02 per share and employer health savings account contributions of $689,000, which reduced Diluted EPS by $0.02 per share.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

For the first quarter, our provision for credit losses totaled $9.7 million, increasing our allowance for credit losses as a percent of total loans to 1.16% from 1.12% at year-end. Our provision for credit losses for the quarter was driven by a deterioration in macroeconomic conditions used within our models and is not indicative of issues we are seeing within our portfolio. However, we are cautious and disciplined within our underwriting and portfolio management as we assess the impact of the Iran conflict on oil prices and inflationary pressure on prospects and existing clients. Our annualized quarterly net charge-off rate improved to 40 basis points compared to 44 basis points for the linked quarter. Our small-ticket lease charge-offs totaled $3.8 million for the first quarter and contributed 23 basis points of our annualized quarterly net charge-off rate.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

While we experienced a reduction in our net charge-offs for the first quarter from a dollar perspective, we do anticipate our second quarter net charge-offs to be consistent with recent quarters. We continue to project that the net charge-offs will come down in the second half of 2026 compared to recent quarterly levels. We continue to reduce the size of our high balance accounts in our small ticket leasing business, which totaled around $9 million at March 31st, down from nearly $13 million at year-end. For more information on our small ticket leasing business and related net charge-offs, please refer to our accompanying slides. Our non-performing loans declined over $3 million compared to the linked quarter, mostly due to reductions in several categories of loans, 90+ days past due and accruing.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

We also had improvements in our criticized loans, which were down $12 million compared to the linked quarter end, and our classified loans were down $5 million. On March 31st, our criticized loan balances as a percent of total loans improved to 3.31%, while our classified loans as a percent of total loans declined to 2.1%. Our delinquency levels improved, and on March 31st, 98.9% of our loan portfolio was considered current, compared to 98.6% at year-end. Moving on to loan balances, we generated loan growth of $13 million. We had significant commercial and industrial loan growth of over $111 million, which was partially offset by reductions in construction and commercial real estate loans of about $55 million combined. We also had declines in premium finance and leases of $24 million and $15 million, respectively. We experienced some of the payoffs we had anticipated for the first quarter.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

However, some of those migrated to the second quarter. I will now turn the call over to Katie for a discussion of our financial performance.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Thanks, Tyler. Our net interest income declined $629,000 compared to the linked quarter, while our net interest margin expanded 4 basis points. Most of the reduction in net interest income was driven by declines in accretion income, which totaled $1.3 million compared to $1.8 million for the fourth quarter, contributing 6 basis points and 8 basis points, respectively. We had 2 fewer days in the first quarter than in the fourth quarter, which also contributed to the decline in net interest income. The improvement in our net interest margin was partially driven by a 12-basis point reduction in our core deposit costs, which exclude brokered CDs. We also had a decrease in our brokered CD position, which helped to increase our net interest margin. From a total balance sheet perspective, we have worked to minimize our interest rate risk exposure and are in a relatively neutral interest rate risk position.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

As it relates to our fee-based income, we had growth of $400,000 compared to the linked quarter. We recognized $1.2 million related to our annual performance-based insurance commission, which we typically receive in the first quarter of each year. This income was partially offset by lower electronic banking income and deposit account service charges, which are seasonally higher in the fourth quarter of each year. Our non-interest expenses were up $341,000 compared to the linked quarter. As Tyler mentioned, we typically recognize additional employee-related expense during the first quarter of each year, which drove the increase compared to the fourth quarter. If you exclude our additional one-time expenses from the first quarter, our non-interest expense is actually down compared to the fourth quarter. Our reported efficiency ratio was 58.6% for the first quarter and 57.8% for the linked quarter.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Increase in our ratio was driven by the one-time expenses from the first quarter, coupled with lower accretion income. Looking at our balance sheet at quarter end, our loan-to-deposit ratio improved to 88.5% compared to 88.8% at year-end as our influx of deposits outpaced our loan growth for the first quarter. Our investment portfolio as a percent of total assets declined slightly to 20.3% at March 31st compared to 20.5% at year-end. Our core deposit balances, which exclude brokered CDs, increased $192 million compared to the linked quarter end. This improvement was due to $102 million of governmental deposit growth, coupled with an increase of $41 million in non-interest-bearing deposits. This growth was partially offset by $154 million of declines in our brokered CDs as we reduced our position, opting for lower short-term borrowing rates as a funding source.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

As a note, our governmental deposits are seasonally higher in the first quarter of each year, so we anticipate seeing some of that money flow out in the second quarter. Our demand deposits as a percent of total deposits were flat at 35% for both quarter-end and year-end. Our non-interest bearing deposits to total deposits grew to 21% at March 31st compared to 20% at year-end. Moving on to our capital position. All of our regulatory capital ratios improved compared to the linked quarter-end. Our tangible equity to tangible assets ratio improved 12 basis points to 8.9% at quarter-end compared to 8.8% at year-end. Our book value per share grew to $33.85, while our tangible book value per share improved to $22.95 or 3% annualized. We increased our quarterly dividend rate for the 11th consecutive year to $0.42 per share.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

This results in an annualized dividend yield of 4.84%. Finally, I will turn the call over to Tyler for his closing comments.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Thank you, Katie. Looking to our results for the full year of 2026, we expect the following, which excludes the impact of non-core expenses and the proposed merger. We expect to achieve positive operating leverage for 2026 compared to 2025. We anticipate our net interest margin will be between 4% and 4.2% for the full year of 2026, which includes one 25 basis point rate cut. Each incremental 25 basis point reduction in rates from the Federal Reserve is expected to result in a 3-4 basis point decline in our net interest margin for the full year, while similar increases would have a 3-4 basis point improvement in our net interest margin. We believe our quarterly fee-based income will range between $28 million and $30 million. We expect quarterly total non-interest expense to be between $73 million and $75 million for the remaining quarterly periods of 2026.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

We believe our loan growth will come in towards the low end of our guided range of 3%-5% due to the movement of paydowns from late 2025 to 2026, coupled with the macro environment changes that occurred in the first quarter. We anticipate a slight reduction in our net charge-offs for 2026 compared to 2025, which we expect to positively impact provision for credit losses, excluding any changes in the economic forecasts. As far as our proposed merger, we find the Citizens merger attractive for many reasons. While we have talked more frequently about large deals to cross $10 billion, we have consistently sought opportunities for depth and efficiency in our existing markets. This opportunity with Citizens meets all of those other criteria while retaining the strategic flexibility to organically stay under $10 billion as well as pursue additional merger and acquisition opportunities.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Citizens has high quality, low cost deposits and an attractively low loan-to-deposit ratio. This merger will give us increased efficiency in markets where we already have a meaningful presence. Our diversified products and services will allow us to expand offerings to the Citizens clients to engage them in a more robust overall financial experience while giving our existing clients more access to convenient locations. We look forward to welcoming the Citizens associates into our organization and allowing them to continue to deliver high quality service to their clients while giving their clients the opportunity to work with our other lines of business in fulfilling their needs. This transaction is valued at approximately $77 million, with shareholders of Citizens receiving 2.1 shares of Peoples stock and $8 in cash for each share of Citizens stock.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

The merger is priced attractively for our shareholders with an expected tangible book value earn back period of less than one year. As far as assumptions, we anticipate realizing 40% cost savings associated with this transaction, which should improve our combined efficiency ratio. We expect the transaction to be accretive to our 2027 EPS by $0.20. We also anticipate that our regulatory capital ratios will improve at the close of the merger based on pro forma results. We have included additional details regarding the proposed merger within our accompanying slides. The Citizens merger transaction is subject to the satisfaction of customary closing conditions, including regulatory and shareholder approvals. Last quarter, we provided clarity as to our anticipated crossing of $10 billion in assets. We said that absent actions taken, we would cross that mark in 2027.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

This remains the case, and we also continue to retain some flexibility to remain under $10 billion for a period of time using the levers we described last quarter, including flexibility in our investment portfolio beyond proposed actions taken related to the merger. Going forward, we will continue to consider all viable paths. These include a larger bank acquisition in the $2 billion-$5 billion asset range as our primary priority. We additionally see a path where we do more small deals given the larger number of available partners at that level and the potential for efficiencies as seen in our recently announced deal. Additionally, we believe the current regulatory environment is generally favorable to bank mergers and acquisitions giving opportunities for multiple deals which our team is capable of pursuing and executing.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Finally, we will weigh the trade-offs of crossing $10 billion organically in the future and the negative impact of the Durbin Amendment. Ultimately, we acknowledge some uncertainty is inherent in our share price and has been noted by us, our analysts, and our shareholders. Crossing $10 billion in any of these described manners could serve to provide strategic clarity. We continue to strive to increase shareholder value by producing stable and reliable financial results, being mindful with our strategic and organic growth, while giving our clients a robust financial offering. We will always work to make decisions that are in the best interest of our shareholders, associates, and clients. This concludes our commentary, and we will open the call for questions. Once again, this is Tyler Wilcox, and joining me for the Q&A session is Katie Bailey, our Chief Financial Officer.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

I will now turn the call back into the hands of our call facilitator. Thank you.

[Operator]

Thank you. We will now begin the question and answer session. To ask a question, you may press star then one on your touch-tone phone. If you are using a speakerphone, please pick up your handset before pressing the keys. If at any time your question has been addressed and you would like to withdraw your question, please press star then two. Our first question for today will come from Jeff Rulis with D.A. Davidson. Please go ahead.

[Ryan Payne, Equity Research Associate at D.A. Davidson]

Good morning. This is Ryan Payne on for Jeff Rulis. If we could start with how the deal came to be and overall your relationship with the bank?

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Yeah, thanks. Appreciate the question. In 2018, we did the First Commonwealth acquisition, which was headquartered very close in proximity geographically. That represented our first of multiple expansions into Kentucky. Even at that time, we looked around those markets, saw the attractive cost of deposits, saw the like-minded associates and communities where we can make a difference, and frankly, have had an interest in this franchise ever since then. We've been watching and waiting for some number of years. They've been a good performing bank and have been committed to independence. Given their recent decision to proceed with exploring a sale, we found that I think we were great partners for each other, and it came together nicely because of that fit, because of that overlap, and because of that long-term interest that we had.

[Ryan Payne, Equity Research Associate at D.A. Davidson]

Okay, great. Appreciate the NIM guide for the full year. Looking ahead with the transaction, where could we see the margin shaking out post the planned security sales and borrowing paydowns?

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Yeah, I think there's obviously upward trajectory to that number. I think, 2026 is going to be impacted, but not until the later part of the year. I think when we look at 2027 on a more full year basis, I think there's a 15-20 basis points opportunity to our standalone guide on the margin side.

[Ryan Payne, Equity Research Associate at D.A. Davidson]

Got it. Last one for me. With the 40% cost savings, what's built into that number? Is that all more so back office and systems? Do you have estimates on timing of those cost saves?

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Yeah, I'll address the timing first. We expect about 50% of that cost savings to be effectuated within 2026 and the remainder within the beginning of 2027. As to kind of the mix of that, it's a combination of everything. There's contracts, there's duplicate locations, there's staffing and so forth. It's the usual mix of efficiencies gained from the two organizations combining.

[Ryan Payne, Equity Research Associate at D.A. Davidson]

Got it. Thanks, guys.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Thank you.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Thank you.

[Operator]

The next question will come from Tim Switzer with KBW. Please go ahead.

[Tim Switzer, VP of Equity Research at KBW]

Hey, good morning. Thanks for taking my question.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Hey, Tim.

[Tim Switzer, VP of Equity Research at KBW]

Hey. Congrats on the deal. One quick one, and I'm sorry if you guys already said this, but any more color you can provide on the timing of the deal close? Are we thinking end of Q4, beginning Q4, Q3? Just trying to get a better idea for the model.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Probably right near the ending of Q3/beginning of Q4 for a closing.

[Tim Switzer, VP of Equity Research at KBW]

Okay.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

We expect conversion in kind of the second quarter sometime of next year.

[Tim Switzer, VP of Equity Research at KBW]

Got it. Okay. Does the Citizens acquisition preclude you at all from announcing another merger before closing? Or do you think you still have the capability to do that if the right opportunity arrives?

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Yeah. Given the right opportunity, we are ready, willing, and able and obviously continue long-term in many conversations. Should any of those come to fruition, we would be ready to announce that and execute on it. This does not put us on the sidelines in any way, shape, or form.

[Tim Switzer, VP of Equity Research at KBW]

Okay. That's great to hear. My guess would be no, just given the size, but does this acquisition alter your criteria on the type of bank you'd like to acquire, the size of bank, your strategy or approach to that as you cross $10 billion?

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

It doesn't. I think, like I said in the prepared remarks, although we've talked probably more frequently about our number one choice being a single large acquisition, and we've left open that possibility, especially in the last year, given the regulatory favorability, time to close and those types of things that we've seen in other transactions out there in the world. We see that and noticed it, and then if we find something that's very attractive in the $1 billion range, maybe a little bit more, maybe a little bit less, that has a lot of the metrics that are attractive for our shareholders like this one is, we would absolutely pursue that and then be on the train to continue that over time and continue to be open in that scenario to larger or smaller deals going forward.

[Tim Switzer, VP of Equity Research at KBW]

Got you. Very helpful. Thank you, Tyler.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Thank you.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Thanks, Tim.

[Operator]

The next question will come from Brendan Nosal with Hovde. Please go ahead.

[Brendan Nosal, Director of Equity Research at Hovde]

Hey, good morning, folks. Hope you're doing well.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Good.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Good morning.

[Brendan Nosal, Director of Equity Research at Hovde]

If I look at slide 22, just the actions that you plan on taking around the $10 billion threshold, are those contemplated in the deal accretion of 5.6% or would that be further accretive? Just kind of given where securities roll off versus where the borrowing costs are.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Sorry, I'm getting to your slide. The selling of the securities is contemplated in the metrics that we noted related to the deal. Any further action outside of selling part of their securities portfolio and part of ours is not contemplated in the deal.

[Brendan Nosal, Director of Equity Research at Hovde]

Sorry, say that again, Katie. What is included in the deal accretion you provide and what isn't?

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Yeah. Included is the selling of about $300 million of our securities and their securities portfolio. Yeah, the $560 million noted on slide 22 is contemplated or is included in the deal math that we articulated.

[Brendan Nosal, Director of Equity Research at Hovde]

Okay. All right. Thank you. That's helpful. Maybe turning to expenses, even with the seasonally higher items that tend to hit in the first quarter, I thought expenses were really well contained. It looks like you did increase the expected run rate for the final three quarters of the year. Is this just a timing difference for when you realize certain things or is there maybe something else worth pointing out?

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

The one thing I would point out is it's mostly impacted by operating lease expense, which has corresponding revenue associated with it from our Vantage Leasing operations. It's positive to pre-tax earnings, but it does increase the expense base, and that's what's driving that increase in the guide. There's revenue on the other side, like I said, but that revenue side stayed within our previous guide.

[Brendan Nosal, Director of Equity Research at Hovde]

Got it. Okay. I'm going to sneak one more in here. Just on the loan mark for Citizens, 4% loan mark feels, I guess, somewhat heavy for the current credit environment. Was there anything particular that drove the mark to that level, whether it's a specific portfolio or something you saw in the diligence process that might not be super obvious to those of us on the outside?

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Yeah, I would agree with you that especially their reported metrics, which we found to be validated. They had very few charge-offs. I would say one, it's a very small denominator, so one or two loans can significantly move that a little bit. As we did our analysis, they had one or two very small emerging loan situations that we wanted to take a cautious approach to and ensure that we were fully reserved for. So there is no systemic issue. We're very satisfied with the credit. But one or two relationships is what drove a reasonable size for them, is what drove that mark.

[Brendan Nosal, Director of Equity Research at Hovde]

Okay. All right. That's helpful color, Tyler. Thanks for taking the questions.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Yeah, thank you.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Thank you.

[Operator]

The next question will come from Adam Crowell with Piper Sandler. Please go ahead.

[Adam Crowell, Research Analyst at Piper Sandler]

Hi, I'm on for Nate Race. Good morning, and thanks for taking our questions.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Good morning.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Good morning, Adam.

[Adam Crowell, Research Analyst at Piper Sandler]

Yeah, maybe a question for Katie. You had some really nice reductions in funding costs during the quarter. I guess, are you still seeing opportunities to reduce deposit costs even with the Fed on hold?

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Yeah, we continually evaluate. I think we meet at least twice a month and more regularly offline, to evaluate pricing and compare our pricing competitively as well as the balances that we're seeing in our portfolio. We have continued to remain strategic and opportunistic as it relates to the deposit costs and most notably the retail CD product.

[Adam Crowell, Research Analyst at Piper Sandler]

Got it. Maybe switching to the loan growth guide for the year. Just given some of the commentary in the deck on the macro environment changes, I was just wondering if you could provide some color if you're seeing that come through in the pipeline or hearing some of your borrowers pausing on projects, or is it more just being conservative?

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Yeah. I'll start by saying it's generally more being conservative. When we look at kind of the pressures on our net loan growth, it's really about the payoff activity. For context, we expect a little over $400 million in payoffs for the full year, and the vast majority, about $380 million of that, we expect in the first half. Just to give you an idea of kind of where we're coming from there. Our commentary about the macro environment, we still continue to see really robust, as shown in our results, C&I loan demand. Maybe a tinge down in the CRE project funding and sourcing, but still experience growth there.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Finally, I would say maybe in the consumer side, we're seeing a little bit more slowdown, particularly in kind of our indirect and residential as interest rates remain high and affordability, for example, in the auto industry, I think we've all seen the headlines around the average auto price hitting $50,000. I think rising fuel costs and some of those things are impacting the consumer demand a little bit more than the commercial demand.

[Adam Crowell, Research Analyst at Piper Sandler]

Got it. Really appreciate the color, Tyler. Maybe just last one on credit. On the North Star portfolio specifically, I was wondering if you had the charge-off contribution specifically from the high balance accounts during the quarter?

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Let's see, the high balance accounts as a % of the charge-offs, in this quarter, they were about $1.15 million of the $3.8 million of the charge-offs within that business, so about 30%.

[Adam Crowell, Research Analyst at Piper Sandler]

Okay, got it. Thanks for taking my questions.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Thank you.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Thanks, Adam.

[Operator]

The next question will come from Daniel Tamayo with Raymond James. Please go ahead.

[Daniel Tamayo, Director of Banking at Raymond James]

Thank you. Good morning, Tyler. Good morning, Katie.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Morning, Danny.

[Daniel Tamayo, Director of Banking at Raymond James]

I'm going to dig a little bit more into the size of the deal. I know you've made comments in the prepared remarks and then answered a question on it, but you've obviously been looking for a deal for a while, and then this one comes along and it's significantly smaller, I think, than what we were potentially looking for, which I don't think is a bad thing. I think you said it, but is it fair to say that the $2 billion-$5 billion deal that checks all the boxes is much harder to find maybe than you were anticipating and the more likely path or at least the easier to see path over the next few years as you do a number of these smaller deals to find your way over $10 billion?

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Yeah, just playing the odds, Danny. Well, one, I would say the old saying, "The neighbor's farm only goes on sale once a generation," right? I hope everybody realizes this is a deal that because it became available now, we felt like we had to be opportunistic and seize on it. If you're just going back, if you're just playing the numbers, there are literally hundreds of banks that fit within the kind of billion-dollar range, and there's a much smaller number. Strategically and execution-wise, for all the reasons we've said all along, it is much more preferable to grab that 3 or 4 billion-dollar bank. There's just fewer. I would say I'm still as optimistic as I have been because we continue to have conversations with banks that are in that space.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Whether those materialize in two quarters or two years, I can't say right now, but I am optimistic enough to continue to talk publicly here about that being something that we see as a viable path. Just given the numbers and given the favorable regulatory environment and given our ability to execute on that, I wouldn't say it's more likely that we'll do a smaller deal, but it may be as likely, and we're ready, willing, and able because, again, those who have followed us for a while, like you have, remember the four deals in four quarters. I'm not announcing that, to be very clear, but our team is capable of that, and so we see it as a viable path.

[Daniel Tamayo, Director of Banking at Raymond James]

Okay, that's great. Thanks, Tyler. Anything else in the loan book or business-wise that you think you are interested in getting out of or selling from their balance sheet?

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

No. Their balance sheet and their loan portfolio is very much in line with what you look at First Commonwealth Bank, you look at Premier. Although I would say it's maybe higher quality than some that we've looked at in the past. There's nothing that we're going to wholesale, walk away from, and we'll work with those clients, and we're looking forward to that. It's, again, communities we know. There are many loans that we had at some point that they picked up and vice versa. That's the good of being in markets that we are highly familiar with.

[Daniel Tamayo, Director of Banking at Raymond James]

Okay. The way to think about the net add from a balance sheet perspective is kind of their balance sheet that they're bringing on minus the 560 securities. That's kind of the way to think about it before any growth, obviously, and maybe some runoff. That's a kind of fair way to start, fair place to start.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Yeah, that's fair. I think their loan portfolio is about $350 million, CRE and 1-4 family, and it's just very community bank. No surprises. Some C-stores, some hotels, all things we're familiar with.

[Daniel Tamayo, Director of Banking at Raymond James]

Okay. Sorry, some cleanup items here. Katie, the 15-20 basis points of NIM expansion that you talked about, how much of that is accretion, do you think?

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

A couple basis points. It's not a significant contributor to the margin impact. I think the more significant margin benefit is coming from the reduction of low-yielding securities and the pay-down of higher cost overnight wholesale funding.

[Daniel Tamayo, Director of Banking at Raymond James]

Got it. Okay. I don't want to take everybody's questions. I'm not sure if I'm the last one or not. If I'm not, let me know and I'll jump off. Otherwise.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

There's still a few more behind you, but that's okay. You can go ahead.

[Daniel Tamayo, Director of Banking at Raymond James]

No, go ahead. I'll drop off and if it doesn't get asked, I'll get back on. Thank you.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Okay. All right. Thanks.

[Operator]

The next question will come from Matthew Breese with Stephens Inc. Please go ahead.

[Matthew Breese, Managing Director at Stephens Inc]

Hey, good morning. Maybe just to start.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Morning

[Matthew Breese, Managing Director at Stephens Inc]

What is the current Durbin-related revenue risks upon crossing 10 billion?

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

It's about $10 million pre-tax before this deal.

[Matthew Breese, Managing Director at Stephens Inc]

Okay. Is there any incremental expenses or you've kind of already checked off that box?

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

No. We have our expenses baked in. We are ready to cross and there won't be a negative dividend to that on expenses for us.

[Matthew Breese, Managing Director at Stephens Inc]

Okay. Katie, I think you'd mentioned just kind of the remixing or the repricing of securities. Could you give us some sense for expected cash flows the rest of the year in the securities book and kind of the roll on, roll off dynamics within that?

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

On a standalone basis for our portfolio, it still remains in that $15 million-$20 million a month of cash flow that we receive.

[Matthew Breese, Managing Director at Stephens Inc]

Do you know what the yield is on cash flows?

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

I would guess somewhere in the range of 350.

[Matthew Breese, Managing Director at Stephens Inc]

Okay. You're putting it back on 100-150 basis points better?

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Sometimes. It just depends where we are with loan growth, where we are on the funding side. Yes, if we're reinvesting it, I think your number is correct. Maybe up to five, depending where we are in the cycle of the market.

[Matthew Breese, Managing Director at Stephens Inc]

Okay. I think you had said it's just a couple of bps from accretion from the deal, is that right? Right out of the gate.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Correct.

[Matthew Breese, Managing Director at Stephens Inc]

All right. That's all I had. Thanks for taking my questions.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Thank you.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Yeah, thank you.

[Operator]

The next question is a follow-up from Adam Crowell with Piper Sandler. Please go ahead.

[Adam Crowell, Research Analyst at Piper Sandler]

Hi. Yeah, just a follow-up from me. Maybe for Katie. I'd be curious, just what are new loans coming on the portfolio at and more broadly, what you're seeing from a competition perspective, and maybe just remind us what you have in terms of fixed rate loans repricing over the next year or so.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Sure. The rate that's coming on, as you might imagine, it varies meaningfully across all the portfolios that we have on the lending side. I would say it's somewhere between 7% and 7.25%. Then as far as fixed versus variable, it's about 50/50. I think we're slightly, it might be 55% variable on 45% fixed as we sit here today. I can't remember if there was another component to your question, and if so, please feel free to re-ask.

[Adam Crowell, Research Analyst at Piper Sandler]

Just in terms of fixed rate loans, maybe repricing higher over the next 12 months or so, that could be kind of a tailwind to yields.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Yes, I think that's correct. The other thing I've highlighted the last few quarters is the production in our Northstar leasing portfolio has been depressed or lower than we had historically seen given the activities on the credit side that we've articulated the last few quarters. I think to the extent we start to see that production ramp back up and in the credit box that we've articulated very clearly, there's, I think, meaningful opportunity to the margin given those are coming in somewhere between 18%-20% from a rate perspective on new originations.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

We expect that ramp up too, kind of as we've talked about new management there, kind of towards the end of this year, beginning of next year, is when you'll see that begin to make an impact.

[Adam Crowell, Research Analyst at Piper Sandler]

Got it. Really appreciate the color there.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Thank you.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Thank you.

[Operator]

The next question is a follow-up from Brendan Nosal with Hovde. Please go ahead.

[Brendan Nosal, Director of Equity Research at Hovde]

Hey, guys. Just not to beat a dead horse on kind of the merger assumptions, but Katie, you said the security sales were contemplated in the 5.6% EPS accretion. Does that also include the impact of the borrowing reduction?

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Yes.

[Brendan Nosal, Director of Equity Research at Hovde]

Okay.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

That whole balance sheet trade right there is included.

[Brendan Nosal, Director of Equity Research at Hovde]

Okay, perfect. One other from me just on Northstar. I get the work you've done on kind of the high balance stuff, but given that two-thirds of the charge-offs from Northstar are coming from outside of that particular sleeve, is there any other actions you need to contemplate to get the lost content in that book where you need to, or is the high balance activities sufficient in your view?

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

No, there is action taking. We talk about the high balance quite a bit because it's a quantifiable portfolio that we haven't originated for well over a year now, and we want to make clear that that's not going to be a recurring issue. As to the rest of it, one, the denominator has continued to shrink, and that's as Katie just acknowledged, and that's by design. The charge-off rate is a bit higher than we would like. Historically, we'd like to get back to that 4%-6% charge-off rate. We turn that portfolio around to growth and originate what we will be seeing, that's non-high balance and that is of the quality that will deliver that 4%-6% charge-off ratio. We feel good about where the credit target is.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

I think we're right over the target that we want to be at, and it's just going to take a while for that rate to normalize as the portfolio begins to grow again. Some of that is non-high balance but is related to the 2022, 2023 vintages. With what we've been putting on the books and in this new credit regime over the last year, we have a high degree of confidence that we have it under control. It's a viable business that we're pretty excited about for the reasons that Katie articulated in the future.

[Brendan Nosal, Director of Equity Research at Hovde]

Okay, fantastic. Thank you for taking the follow-ups.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Thank you.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Thanks.

[Operator]

The next question will come from Daniel Cardenas with Brean Capital. Please go ahead.

[Daniel Cardenas, Director at Brean Capital]

Good morning, guys.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Hey, Dan.

[Daniel Cardenas, Director at Brean Capital]

Congrats on the deal. Just absent the transaction itself, maybe if you could, and I apologize if I missed this, I've been jumping around here, but could you maybe give us some color on competitive factors on the deposit side? Are those beginning to pick up in your footprint or are they still rather manageable at the moment?

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Yeah, I would say it's manageable. Katie talked a little bit about our regular pricing committee where we do kind of evaluations of our extensive geography, and there's always some outlier players, often smaller banks or credit unions. We're able to maintain where we want to be from a macro. As we shared, I think last quarter, we don't chase stupid. It's a technical banking term, but we really value our margins, so we don't price to the lowest common denominator. We're competing largely against rational actors in the community bank and larger regional space.

[Daniel Cardenas, Director at Brean Capital]

Perfect. Yeah, all my other questions have been asked and answered. Thank you.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Thank you.

[Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Thanks, Dan.

[Operator]

The next question is a follow-up from Daniel Tamayo with Raymond James. Please go ahead.

[Daniel Tamayo, Director of Banking at Raymond James]

Thanks, guys. Super quick one. The Durbin hit of $10 million, I think you said, was before the deal. I imagine it's really small, but do you have a sense for what Citizens would add to that?

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

It's about $1 million, Danny.

[Daniel Tamayo, Director of Banking at Raymond James]

Great. Okay, thanks. That's all I had.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Yep, thank you.

[Operator]

This will conclude our question and answer session. I would like to turn the conference back over to Mr. Wilcox for any closing remarks.

[Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO at Peoples Bancorp Inc.]

Yes. I want to thank everybody for joining our call this morning. Please remember that our earnings release and a webcast of this call, including our earnings conference call presentation, will be archived at peoplesbancorp.com under the investor relations section. Thank you for your time and have a great day.

[Operator]

The conference is now concluded. Thank you for attending today's presentation. You may now disconnect.

Participants

Executives

• Katie Bailey, EVP, CFO, and Treasurer
• Tyler Wilcox, President and CEO

Analysts

• Adam Crowell, Research Analyst at Piper Sandler
• Brendan Nosal, Director of Equity Research at Hovde
• Daniel Cardenas, Director at Brean Capital
• Daniel Tamayo, Director of Banking at Raymond James
• Matthew Breese, Managing Director at Stephens Inc
• Ryan Payne, Equity Research Associate at D.A. Davidson
• Tim Switzer, VP of Equity Research at KBW