According to a recent New York Times article, Americans have been absorbing years of rising beef prices but have not yet cut back on it. However, our research reveals that the average American household does indeed have a breaking point, and when it comes to a large pack of ribeye, that breaking point is 16% away from current prices.
Using Walmart’s price of $17.46 for a large ribeye steak (0.9-1.6 lb) as a reference point, we surveyed 3,043 consumers and asked how high that price would need to go before they stopped buying ribeye altogether. The average response was $20.34. That leaves just $2.88 between the average price and the point at which Americans would leave the ribeye in the supermarket fridge.
Respondents were also asked which cheaper alternatives they would consider, and the steakhouses worth a two-hour round trip.

| Rank | State | Restaurant | City |
|---|
| 1 | Illinois | Chicago Cut Steakhouse | Chicago |
| 2 | Kentucky | Steak & Bourbon | Louisville |
| 3 | New York | Peter Luger Steak House | Brooklyn (Williamsburg) |
| 4 | Tennessee | Cork & Cow | Franklin |
| 5 | New York | Delmonico's | New York (Financial District) |
| 6 | New Mexico | Market Steer Steakhouse | Santa Fe |
| 7 | California | House of Prime Rib | San Francisco |
| 8 | Montana | J.W. Heist Steakhouse | Bozeman (Downtown) |
| 9 | California | Shaw's Steakhouse & Tavern | Santa Maria |
| 10 | Ohio | Butcher and Barrel | Cincinnati |
| 11 | South Dakota | Morrie's Steakhouse | Sioux Falls |
| 12 | Idaho | Lock Stock & Barrel | Boise |
| 13 | Massachusetts | Post 1917 | Reading / Lexington |
| 14 | Idaho | Indian Creek Steakhouse | Caldwell (Boise area) |
| 15 | Tennessee | Char Restaurant | Memphis |
| 16 | Kansas | 6S Steakhouse | Wichita |
| 17 | Tennessee | Folk's Folly Prime Steak House | Memphis |
| 18 | Montana | Casagranda's Steakhouse | Butte |
| 19 | Montana | Land of Magic Steakhouse | Logan |
| 20 | California | Fia Steak | Santa Monica |
| 21 | Alabama | Conestoga Steak House | Dothan |
| 22 | South Dakota | Tarquin Argentinian Restaurant | Sioux Falls |
| 23 | New Mexico | Vernon's Speakeasy | Los Ranchos de Albuquerque |
| 24 | Massachusetts | Pellana Steakhouse | Peabody |
| 25 | Ohio | Tony's of Cincinnati | Cincinnati |
| 26 | Massachusetts | Oliveira's Steakhouse | Somerville |
| 27 | Alabama | The Cellar Fine Steaks & Wines | Dothan |
| 28 | Colorado | A5 Steakhouse | Denver |
| 29 | Kentucky | Brendon's Catch 23 | Louisville (Downtown) |
| 30 | Ohio | Central Station Steak and Ale | Cambridge |
| 31 | Florida | Bern's Steak House | Tampa |
| 32 | Kansas | North Star Steakhouse | Topeka |
| 33 | Indiana | St. Elmo Steak House | Indianapolis |
| 34 | New York | St. Anselm | Brooklyn (Williamsburg) |
| 35 | Vermont | Southside Steakhouse | Rutland |
| 36 | South Dakota | Ironwood Steakhouse | Sioux Falls |
| 37 | Alabama | Calhoun Steak House | Jacksonville |
| 38 | Michigan | Butcher's Union | Grand Rapids |
| 39 | Illinois | Butcher and the Bear | Chicago (Lincoln Park) |
| 40 | Idaho | Anderson Reserve | Sweet (Boise area) |
| 41 | Colorado | Buckhorn Exchange | Denver |
| 42 | Vermont | Guild Tavern | South Burlington |
| 43 | New Mexico | High Noon Restaurant & Saloon | Albuquerque (Old Town) |
| 44 | Vermont | Black Rock Steakhouse | Springfield |
| 45 | Louisiana | Charlie's Steakhouse | New Orleans |
| 46 | Virginia | Zoe's Steak & Seafood | Virginia Beach |
| 47 | Michigan | Five Steakhouse | Plymouth |
| 48 | Kentucky | Monk's Road Boiler House | Louisville (Downtown) |
| 49 | Kansas | Cattleman's II Cafe | Liberal |
| 50 | Texas | Perini Ranch Steakhouse | Buffalo Gap |
| 51 | Nebraska | Brother Sebastian's | Omaha |
| 52 | Nevada | Golden Steer Steakhouse | Las Vegas |
| 53 | South Carolina | Thoroughbreds Chophouse | Myrtle Beach |
| 54 | Louisiana | Chophouse New Orleans | New Orleans |
| 55 | Texas | Cattlemen's Steak House | Fort Worth (Stockyards) |
| 56 | Wyoming | Steadfire Chophouse | Teton Village |
| 57 | Oklahoma | Cattlemen's Steakhouse | Oklahoma City (Stockyards City) |
| 58 | North Carolina | The Porter's House | Charlotte (South) |
| 59 | Colorado | Bastien's Restaurant | Denver |
| 60 | North Carolina | Angus Barn | Raleigh |
| 61 | Wyoming | The Gun Barrel Steak & Game House | Jackson |
| 62 | Arizona | TEXAZ Grill | Phoenix |
| 63 | Missouri | Sam's Steakhouse | St. Louis (South) |
| 64 | Nebraska | Omaha Prime | Omaha (Old Market) |
| 65 | Iowa | The Prime Rib | Spencer |
| 66 | Virginia | Buckhead's Chop House | Richmond |
| 67 | Virginia | Local Chop and Grill House | Harrisonburg |
| 68 | Nebraska | Gorat's | Omaha |
| 69 | Texas | Taste of Texas | Houston |
| 70 | Florida | Christner's Prime Steak & Lobster | Orlando |
| 71 | Georgia | Little Alley Steak | Roswell / Atlanta |
| 72 | Maryland | The Prime Rib (The Original) | Baltimore (Downtown) |
| 73 | Nevada | Bavette's Steakhouse & Bar | Las Vegas (Park MGM) |
| 74 | South Carolina | Grill 225 | Charleston |
| 75 | Louisiana | Crescent City Steaks | New Orleans |
| 76 | Mississippi | Old Hickory Steak House | Columbus |
| 77 | Oklahoma | Ranch Steakhouse | Oklahoma City |
| 78 | North Carolina | Bin 54 Steak & Cellar | Chapel Hill |
| 79 | New Jersey | Sinner's Seafood & Steakhouse | Point Pleasant Beach |
| 80 | South Carolina | Marbled & Fin | Charleston |
| 81 | Arkansas | The Porterhouse | Hot Springs |
| 82 | Washington | The Butcher's Table | Seattle (South Lake Union) |
| 83 | Arkansas | Riverfront Steakhouse | North Little Rock |
| 84 | Nevada | Barry's Downtown Prime | Las Vegas (Downtown) |
| 85 | Pennsylvania | Rittenhouse Grill | Philadelphia |
| 86 | Utah | Harbor Seafood & Steak Company | Salt Lake City |
| 87 | Missouri | Carmine's Steak House | St. Louis (Downtown) |
| 88 | North Dakota | Outlaws Bar & Grill | Watford City |
| 89 | Michigan | Fiamma Grille and Bar | Plymouth |
| 90 | Washington | Metropolitan Grill | Seattle (Downtown) |
| 91 | Georgia | Aspens Signature Steaks | Marietta |
| 92 | Minnesota | Manny's Steakhouse | Minneapolis |
| 93 | Missouri | Cleaver & Cocktail | Town and Country |
| 94 | Mississippi | Dempsey's Steak and Seafood | Kiln |
| 95 | New Jersey | Strickland's Steakhouse | Woodbridge |
| 96 | Connecticut | Cast Iron Chef Chop House & Oyster Bar | New Haven |
| 97 | New Hampshire | Tomahawk Butchery and Tavern | Merrimack |
| 98 | Arizona | The Stockyards | Phoenix |
| 99 | Oregon | Grill 68 Steakhouse | Beaverton |
| 100 | Alaska | Stalk Steakhouse | Eagle River |
| 101 | Georgia | Chops Lobster Bar | Atlanta (Buckhead) |
| 102 | Wyoming | Local Restaurant and Bar | Jackson |
| 103 | Delaware | 1776 Steakhouse | Rehoboth Beach |
| 104 | New Jersey | Rails Steakhouse | Towaco |
| 105 | Wisconsin | Five O'Clock Steakhouse | Milwaukee |
| 106 | Delaware | Royal Prime Steakhouse | Dover |
| 107 | Mississippi | Two Rivers Restaurant | Canton |
| 108 | Washington | Flintcreek Cattle Co. | Seattle (Greenwood) |
| 109 | Oklahoma | Prhyme Downtown Steakhouse | Tulsa |
| 110 | Oregon | RingSide Steakhouse | Portland |
| 111 | West Virginia | Bricks & Barrels | Charleston |
| 112 | Arkansas | 501 Prime | Hot Springs |
| 113 | Maine | The Grill Room & Bar | Portland |
| 114 | Wisconsin | Johnny Delmonico's | Madison |
| 115 | Connecticut | Prime on the Green | Guilford |
| 116 | Florida | Sunny's Steakhouse | Miami (Little River) |
| 117 | Minnesota | The Butcher's Tale | Minneapolis (Loring Park) |
| 118 | Alaska | Club Paris | Anchorage |
| 119 | Connecticut | Saltbrick Prime | Branford |
| 120 | New Hampshire | Hanover Street Chophouse | Manchester |
| 121 | New Hampshire | Buckley's Great Steaks | Merrimack |
| 122 | Minnesota | Murray's Restaurant & Cocktail Lounge | Minneapolis |
| 123 | North Dakota | 40 Steak & Seafood | Bismarck |
| 124 | Maine | The Steakhouse | Wells |
| 125 | North Dakota | Speedway 805 Grill & Bar | Grand Forks |
| 126 | Iowa | Iowa Beef Steakhouse | Des Moines |
| 127 | Rhode Island | Mill's Tavern | Providence |
| 128 | Utah | Libertango | Sandy |
| 129 | Pennsylvania | Alpen Rose | Philadelphia (Midtown Village) |
| 130 | Rhode Island | Cut 123 | Providence |
| 131 | Utah | Christopher's Prime | Salt Lake City |
| 132 | Wisconsin | Field's at the Wilderness | Wisconsin Dells |
| 133 | Arizona | Feeney's Restaurant and Bar | Phoenix |
| 134 | West Virginia | The Wonder Bar Steakhouse | Clarksburg |
| 135 | Maine | Nick's Steakhouse | York |
| 136 | Iowa | Northwestern Steakhouse | Mason City |
| 137 | West Virginia | Laury's Restaurant | Charleston |
| 138 | Delaware | Tonic Seafood and Steak | Wilmington |
| 139 | Indiana | Bynum's Steakhouse | Indianapolis |
| 140 | Oregon | Laurelhurst Market | Portland (NE) |
| 141 | Indiana | Peterson's | Fishers |
| 142 | Maryland | Rec Pier Chop House | Baltimore (Fells Point) |
| 143 | Maryland | J. Hollinger's | Silver Spring |
| 144 | Rhode Island | Double Barrel Steak | Richmond |

Key Findings
- Utah has the smallest cushion for another price increase. Utahns set their average ceiling at $18.77, only $1.31 above the reference price. Rhode Island followed at $19.50, then South Dakota and Hawaii at $19.64, and Montana at $19.68. Oregonians have left the most room in the steak budget. Their threshold is $21.56, or $4.10 above the reference price.
- Despite price increases, many shoppers would still fall back on beef if they could no longer afford ribeye. When asked which alternative protein they would eat if steak was removed from their budget, chicken or turkey was the most popular replacement at 31%. However, ground beef came a close second at 30%. That means that consumers are not willing to give up on beef altogether – fewer ribeyes, perhaps, but burgers or meatballs will still appear on dinner tables across the country.
- Many consumers are prepared to make sacrifices to protect steak night. When asked what they would be prepared to forgo, takeout or restaurant meals emerged as the first “luxuries”, followed by everyday staples like coffee, snacks and desserts. It’s a reminder that resilience in one spending category can come at another’s expense.
- To some, steak is more important than streaming services. One in ten would be most willing to reduce streaming subscriptions to continue eating steak.
- Enthusiasm for premium steak remains strong nationally. We also wanted to explore how much effort consumers would be willing to make for a really good steak, asking a hypothetical question: which steakhouse would they make a two-hour round trip to visit? The results featured restaurants across all 50 states, from big-city institutions to smaller-town favorites. It reveals that enthusiasm for a premium steak experience remains nationwide, even as shoppers report limits on how much they would pay at the supermarket.
Final Thoughts
Our research has found that steak will continue to have considerable pull with US consumers. Consumers are prepared to make sacrifices in takeout spending and to reduce subscriptions to keep eating steak. Even for those who are prepared to cut steak entirely from their diet, a good proportion will just switch to cheaper beef before giving it up altogether.
The more complete view that emerges from our study is of how consumers defend the purchases they value. Spending levels continue at the current rate because people are willing to make compromises elsewhere. Steak is a good example: still in demand by consumers, who are willing to sacrifice other purchases.

Continue following MarketBeat
Add MarketBeat as your preferred source on Google to see our latest stories in your feed.
Like this article? Share it with a colleague.
Link copied to clipboard.