Survey Reveals: How Much Would People Pay for Ribeye Before Giving It Up? [2026]

According to a recent New York Times article, Americans have been absorbing years of rising beef prices but have not yet cut back on it. However, our research reveals that the average American household does indeed have a breaking point, and when it comes to a large pack of ribeye, that breaking point is 16% away from current prices. 

Using Walmart’s price of $17.46 for a large ribeye steak (0.9-1.6 lb) as a reference point, we surveyed 3,043 consumers and asked how high that price would need to go before they stopped buying ribeye altogether. The average response was $20.34. That leaves just $2.88 between the average price and the point at which Americans would leave the ribeye in the supermarket fridge. 

Respondents were also asked which cheaper alternatives they would consider, and the steakhouses worth a two-hour round trip.

The below reveals America's top steakhouses, as voted for by diners willing to make a two-hour round trip for a great steak.

RankStateRestaurantCity
1IllinoisChicago Cut SteakhouseChicago
2KentuckySteak & BourbonLouisville
3New YorkPeter Luger Steak HouseBrooklyn (Williamsburg)
4TennesseeCork & CowFranklin
5New YorkDelmonico'sNew York (Financial District)
6New MexicoMarket Steer SteakhouseSanta Fe
7CaliforniaHouse of Prime RibSan Francisco
8MontanaJ.W. Heist SteakhouseBozeman (Downtown)
9CaliforniaShaw's Steakhouse & TavernSanta Maria
10OhioButcher and BarrelCincinnati
11South DakotaMorrie's SteakhouseSioux Falls
12IdahoLock Stock & BarrelBoise
13MassachusettsPost 1917Reading / Lexington
14IdahoIndian Creek SteakhouseCaldwell (Boise area)
15TennesseeChar RestaurantMemphis
16Kansas6S SteakhouseWichita
17TennesseeFolk's Folly Prime Steak HouseMemphis
18MontanaCasagranda's SteakhouseButte
19MontanaLand of Magic SteakhouseLogan
20CaliforniaFia SteakSanta Monica
21AlabamaConestoga Steak HouseDothan
22South DakotaTarquin Argentinian RestaurantSioux Falls
23New MexicoVernon's SpeakeasyLos Ranchos de Albuquerque
24MassachusettsPellana SteakhousePeabody
25OhioTony's of CincinnatiCincinnati
26MassachusettsOliveira's SteakhouseSomerville
27AlabamaThe Cellar Fine Steaks & WinesDothan
28ColoradoA5 SteakhouseDenver
29KentuckyBrendon's Catch 23Louisville (Downtown)
30OhioCentral Station Steak and AleCambridge
31FloridaBern's Steak HouseTampa
32KansasNorth Star SteakhouseTopeka
33IndianaSt. Elmo Steak HouseIndianapolis
34New YorkSt. AnselmBrooklyn (Williamsburg)
35VermontSouthside SteakhouseRutland
36South DakotaIronwood SteakhouseSioux Falls
37AlabamaCalhoun Steak HouseJacksonville
38MichiganButcher's UnionGrand Rapids
39IllinoisButcher and the BearChicago (Lincoln Park)
40IdahoAnderson ReserveSweet (Boise area)
41ColoradoBuckhorn ExchangeDenver
42VermontGuild TavernSouth Burlington
43New MexicoHigh Noon Restaurant & SaloonAlbuquerque (Old Town)
44VermontBlack Rock SteakhouseSpringfield
45LouisianaCharlie's SteakhouseNew Orleans
46VirginiaZoe's Steak & SeafoodVirginia Beach
47MichiganFive SteakhousePlymouth
48KentuckyMonk's Road Boiler HouseLouisville (Downtown)
49KansasCattleman's II CafeLiberal
50TexasPerini Ranch SteakhouseBuffalo Gap
51NebraskaBrother Sebastian'sOmaha
52NevadaGolden Steer SteakhouseLas Vegas
53South CarolinaThoroughbreds ChophouseMyrtle Beach
54LouisianaChophouse New OrleansNew Orleans
55TexasCattlemen's Steak HouseFort Worth (Stockyards)
56WyomingSteadfire ChophouseTeton Village
57OklahomaCattlemen's SteakhouseOklahoma City (Stockyards City)
58North CarolinaThe Porter's HouseCharlotte (South)
59ColoradoBastien's RestaurantDenver
60North CarolinaAngus BarnRaleigh
61WyomingThe Gun Barrel Steak & Game HouseJackson
62ArizonaTEXAZ GrillPhoenix
63MissouriSam's SteakhouseSt. Louis (South)
64NebraskaOmaha PrimeOmaha (Old Market)
65IowaThe Prime RibSpencer
66VirginiaBuckhead's Chop HouseRichmond
67VirginiaLocal Chop and Grill HouseHarrisonburg
68NebraskaGorat'sOmaha
69TexasTaste of TexasHouston
70FloridaChristner's Prime Steak & LobsterOrlando
71GeorgiaLittle Alley SteakRoswell / Atlanta
72MarylandThe Prime Rib (The Original)Baltimore (Downtown)
73NevadaBavette's Steakhouse & BarLas Vegas (Park MGM)
74South CarolinaGrill 225Charleston
75LouisianaCrescent City SteaksNew Orleans
76MississippiOld Hickory Steak HouseColumbus
77OklahomaRanch SteakhouseOklahoma City
78North CarolinaBin 54 Steak & CellarChapel Hill
79New JerseySinner's Seafood & SteakhousePoint Pleasant Beach
80South CarolinaMarbled & FinCharleston
81ArkansasThe PorterhouseHot Springs
82WashingtonThe Butcher's TableSeattle (South Lake Union)
83ArkansasRiverfront SteakhouseNorth Little Rock
84NevadaBarry's Downtown PrimeLas Vegas (Downtown)
85PennsylvaniaRittenhouse GrillPhiladelphia
86UtahHarbor Seafood & Steak CompanySalt Lake City
87MissouriCarmine's Steak HouseSt. Louis (Downtown)
88North DakotaOutlaws Bar & GrillWatford City
89MichiganFiamma Grille and BarPlymouth
90WashingtonMetropolitan GrillSeattle (Downtown)
91GeorgiaAspens Signature SteaksMarietta
92MinnesotaManny's SteakhouseMinneapolis
93MissouriCleaver & CocktailTown and Country
94MississippiDempsey's Steak and SeafoodKiln
95New JerseyStrickland's SteakhouseWoodbridge
96ConnecticutCast Iron Chef Chop House & Oyster BarNew Haven
97New HampshireTomahawk Butchery and TavernMerrimack
98ArizonaThe StockyardsPhoenix
99OregonGrill 68 SteakhouseBeaverton
100AlaskaStalk SteakhouseEagle River
101GeorgiaChops Lobster BarAtlanta (Buckhead)
102WyomingLocal Restaurant and BarJackson
103Delaware1776 SteakhouseRehoboth Beach
104New JerseyRails SteakhouseTowaco
105WisconsinFive O'Clock SteakhouseMilwaukee
106DelawareRoyal Prime SteakhouseDover
107MississippiTwo Rivers RestaurantCanton
108WashingtonFlintcreek Cattle Co.Seattle (Greenwood)
109OklahomaPrhyme Downtown SteakhouseTulsa
110OregonRingSide SteakhousePortland
111West VirginiaBricks & BarrelsCharleston
112Arkansas501 PrimeHot Springs
113MaineThe Grill Room & BarPortland
114WisconsinJohnny Delmonico'sMadison
115ConnecticutPrime on the GreenGuilford
116FloridaSunny's SteakhouseMiami (Little River)
117MinnesotaThe Butcher's TaleMinneapolis (Loring Park)
118AlaskaClub ParisAnchorage
119ConnecticutSaltbrick PrimeBranford
120New HampshireHanover Street ChophouseManchester
121New HampshireBuckley's Great SteaksMerrimack
122MinnesotaMurray's Restaurant & Cocktail LoungeMinneapolis
123North Dakota40 Steak & SeafoodBismarck
124MaineThe SteakhouseWells
125North DakotaSpeedway 805 Grill & BarGrand Forks
126IowaIowa Beef SteakhouseDes Moines
127Rhode IslandMill's TavernProvidence
128UtahLibertangoSandy
129PennsylvaniaAlpen RosePhiladelphia (Midtown Village)
130Rhode IslandCut 123Providence
131UtahChristopher's PrimeSalt Lake City
132WisconsinField's at the WildernessWisconsin Dells
133ArizonaFeeney's Restaurant and BarPhoenix
134West VirginiaThe Wonder Bar SteakhouseClarksburg
135MaineNick's SteakhouseYork
136IowaNorthwestern SteakhouseMason City
137West VirginiaLaury's RestaurantCharleston
138DelawareTonic Seafood and SteakWilmington
139IndianaBynum's SteakhouseIndianapolis
140OregonLaurelhurst MarketPortland (NE)
141IndianaPeterson'sFishers
142MarylandRec Pier Chop HouseBaltimore (Fells Point)
143MarylandJ. Hollinger'sSilver Spring
144Rhode IslandDouble Barrel SteakRichmond
MarketBeat

Key Findings

  • Utah has the smallest cushion for another price increase. Utahns set their average ceiling at $18.77, only $1.31 above the reference price. Rhode Island followed at $19.50, then South Dakota and Hawaii at $19.64, and Montana at $19.68. Oregonians have left the most room in the steak budget. Their threshold is $21.56, or $4.10 above the reference price.
  • Despite price increases, many shoppers would still fall back on beef if they could no longer afford ribeye. When asked which alternative protein they would eat if steak was removed from their budget, chicken or turkey was the most popular replacement at 31%. However, ground beef came a close second at 30%. That means that consumers are not willing to give up on beef altogether – fewer ribeyes, perhaps, but burgers or meatballs will still appear on dinner tables across the country.
  • Many consumers are prepared to make sacrifices to protect steak night. When asked what they would be prepared to forgo, takeout or restaurant meals emerged as the first “luxuries”, followed by everyday staples like coffee, snacks and desserts. It’s a reminder that resilience in one spending category can come at another’s expense.
  • To some, steak is more important than streaming services. One in ten would be most willing to reduce streaming subscriptions to continue eating steak.
  • Enthusiasm for premium steak remains strong nationally. We also wanted to explore how much effort consumers would be willing to make for a really good steak, asking a hypothetical question: which steakhouse would they make a two-hour round trip to visit? The results featured restaurants across all 50 states, from big-city institutions to smaller-town favorites. It reveals that enthusiasm for a premium steak experience remains nationwide, even as shoppers report limits on how much they would pay at the supermarket.

Final Thoughts

Our research has found that steak will continue to have considerable pull with US consumers. Consumers are prepared to make sacrifices in takeout spending and to reduce subscriptions to keep eating steak. Even for those who are prepared to cut steak entirely from their diet, a good proportion will just switch to cheaper beef before giving it up altogether. 

The more complete view that emerges from our study is of how consumers defend the purchases they value. Spending levels continue at the current rate because people are willing to make compromises elsewhere. Steak is a good example: still in demand by consumers, who are willing to sacrifice other purchases.

Continue following MarketBeat
Add MarketBeat as your preferred source on Google to see our latest stories in your feed.
Like this article? Share it with a colleague.

Featured Articles

Recent Videos

Stock Lists

All Stock Lists

Investing Tools

Calendars and Tools

Search Headlines