Free Trial

Don’t Miss These Stock Picks for the Lumber Price Surge

Lumber yard stacks of lumber

Key Points

  • Lumber prices are starting to show a bottoming pattern, and fundamental factors could push it to new cycle highs.
  • Cheaper mortgages and normalized lumber prices could help Lennar see better treatment from analysts.
  • Wall Street analysts now expect over 60% upside in West Fraser Timber Company, driven by the Fed's potential interest rate cuts.
  • 5 stocks we like better than West Fraser Timber

Some stocks depend on commodity prices for their success – or failure – and the main ones that come to mind may be inside the energy sector. If Warren Buffett chooses to buy an oil company, as he did through a nine-day buying streak in shares of Occidental Petroleum Co. NYSE: OXY, it may be because he sees a fundamental reason for oil prices to move higher and bring the company’s valuation up with it.

Today, investors can step outside the most commonly watched commodities, such as oil and precious metals. While gold makes a breakout, taking silver along for a ride, some mining stocks can become an excellent space to watch today. But note that today’s soon-to-be hot commodity is the least expected: lumber.

That’s right, lumber prices crashed after their stratospheric rallies in 2020 through 2022, raising the cost of building homes. Today, there are reasons to believe that lumber could make a comeback soon, backed by housing and economic fundamentals. Because of this, investors can have their top pick between stocks like West Fraser Timber Co. NYSE: WFG, Weyerhaeuser NYSE: WY, and even Lennar Co. NYSE: LEN.

Why Analysts' Downgrade of Lennar Stock Might Be Wrong

Lennar Today

Lennar Co. stock logo
LENLEN 90-day performance
Lennar
$159.88
+4.05 (+2.60%)
(As of 07/12/2024 ET)
52-Week Range
$102.90
$172.59
Dividend Yield
1.25%
P/E Ratio
10.87
Price Target
$166.69

Recently, analysts at Citigroup decided to lower their targets on Lennar stock from $174 a share to $164 a share, roughly a 6% decline in forecasted valuations. These analysts lowered their targets due to bearish expectations for the housing sector moving forward.


Weaker readings in the national building permits, roughly 7% down on the year and 3.5% on the month, can be attributed to these bearish views. Lower building permits may indicate weaker housing demand and financial situations among homebuilders and would-be homebuyers.

Lennar MarketRank™ Stock Analysis
Overall MarketRank™
4.52 out of 5
Analyst Rating
Hold
Upside/Downside
4.3% Upside
Short Interest
Healthy
Dividend Strength
Moderate
Sustainability
-1.81
News Sentiment
1.27mentions of Lennar in the last 14 days
Insider Trading
Selling Shares
Projected Earnings Growth
12.57%
See Full Details

But that could be about to change. The Federal Reserve postponed interest rate cuts throughout 2024. Still, the CME’s FedWatch tool now sees over 60% probability for a rate cut as soon as September of this year. That could spark new housing demand as mortgage rates also come down.

Cheaper mortgages could spark new housing demand. Now that lumber prices are back to normal, margins for newly built homes could help Lennar see better treatment from Wall Street analysts. In fact, some in the construction sector may be already aware of these coming trends.

According to their second quarter 2024 earnings results, Lennar reports a 19% increase in new orders, bringing the total to 21,293 homes today.

The company’s backlog is now worth up to $8.2 billion, and according to the latest employment situation report (NFP), out of the total 206,000 jobs added to the economy, roughly 27,000 (or 13%) jobs went to the construction sector. New hands are needed to respond to the potential demand breakout if and when the Fed cuts rates in September.

The One Stock to Watch as Housing Demand Surges: West Fraser Timber

West Fraser Timber Today

West Fraser Timber Co. Ltd. stock logo
WFGWFG 90-day performance
West Fraser Timber
$77.17
-0.54 (-0.69%)
(As of 07/12/2024 ET)
52-Week Range
$64.11
$90.17
Dividend Yield
1.66%
Price Target
$106.25

Of course, analysts could be wrong about lowering Lennar’s price targets, but investors shouldn’t risk their capital on ‘what ifs’; rather, they can take a safer view on stocks that provide homebuilders with the main commodity they need, which is lumber.

Because lumber prices are so low compared to their 2020-2022 peaks, the profit margin cycle is also lower for companies in the sector. Despite the cycle’s lows, analysts at TD Securities still see a price target of $118 a share for West Fraser Timber stock, daring it to rally by roughly 60% from where it trades today.

West Fraser Timber MarketRank™ Stock Analysis
Overall MarketRank™
4.27 out of 5
Analyst Rating
Buy
Upside/Downside
37.7% Upside
Short Interest
Healthy
Dividend Strength
Weak
Sustainability
N/A
News Sentiment
1.14mentions of West Fraser Timber in the last 14 days
Insider Trading
N/A
Projected Earnings Growth
72.73%
See Full Details

But West Fraser Timber isn’t the only lumber provider in the block. Weyerhaeuser is also an honorable mention, but here’s how that stock compares to West Fraser.

Wall Street analysts only forecast 17.2% earnings per share (EPS) growth for Weyerhaeuser in the next 12 months, where those covering West Fraser Timber see up to 72.7% EPS growth this year as well, backing up the upside set by price targets.

On a valuation basis, this upside spread is just as evident. Trading at a 9.2x forward P/E multiple today, West Fraser Timber offers a discount of 61% to Weyerhaeuser’s 23.7x forward P/E valuation. If price action can be taken as another gauge of market sentiment, here’s what it looks like for both stocks.

Weyerhaeuser stock traded down to 75% of its 52-week high price, showing investors some bearish momentum. On the other hand, West Fraser Timber stock has traded up to 83% of its 52-week high, spreading the two companies into bearish and bullish momentum separately.

→ Does this make you sick? (From Allegiance Gold) (Ad)

Should you invest $1,000 in West Fraser Timber right now?

Before you consider West Fraser Timber, you'll want to hear this.

MarketBeat keeps track of Wall Street's top-rated and best performing research analysts and the stocks they recommend to their clients on a daily basis. MarketBeat has identified the five stocks that top analysts are quietly whispering to their clients to buy now before the broader market catches on... and West Fraser Timber wasn't on the list.

While West Fraser Timber currently has a "Buy" rating among analysts, top-rated analysts believe these five stocks are better buys.

View The Five Stocks Here

A Guide To High-Short-Interest Stocks Cover

MarketBeat's analysts have just released their top five short plays for July 2024. Learn which stocks have the most short interest and how to trade them. Click the link below to see which companies made the list.

Get This Free Report
Gabriel Osorio-Mazilli
About The Author

Gabriel Osorio-Mazilli

Contributing Author

Value Stocks, Asian Markets, Macro Economics

Like this article? Share it with a colleague.

Companies Mentioned in This Article

CompanyMarketRank™Current PricePrice ChangeDividend YieldP/E RatioConsensus RatingConsensus Price Target
Occidental Petroleum (OXY)
4.5388 of 5 stars
4.54 / 5 stars
$61.20-0.5%1.44%16.72Hold$71.67
Weyerhaeuser (WY)
4.7262 of 5 stars
4.73 / 5 stars
$29.28+1.1%2.73%26.62Hold$37.00
Lennar (LEN)
4.5185 of 5 stars
4.52 / 5 stars
$159.88+2.6%1.25%10.87Hold$166.69
West Fraser Timber (WFG)
4.2668 of 5 stars
4.27 / 5 stars
$77.17-0.7%1.66%-63.78Buy$106.25
Compare These Stocks  Add These Stocks to My Watchlist 


Featured Articles and Offers

Recent Videos

CPI News Breakdown: Key Market Moves to Follow
Understanding Oversold Stocks
Inside Pelosi’s Latest Stock Moves

Stock Lists

All Stock Lists

Investing Tools

Calendars and Tools

Search Headlines