Colony Bankcorp Q2 2024 Earnings Report

Colony Bankcorp EPS Results

• Actual EPS: $0.33
• Consensus EPS: N/A
• Beat/Miss: N/A
• One Year Ago EPS: N/A

Colony Bankcorp Revenue Results

• Actual Revenue: $28.13 million
• Expected Revenue: N/A
• Beat/Miss: N/A
• YoY Revenue Growth: N/A

Colony Bankcorp Announcement Details

• Quarter: Q2 2024
• Date: 7/24/2024
• Time: Before Market Opens
• Conference Call Date: Thursday, July 25, 2024
• Conference Call Time: 9:00AM ET

Colony Bankcorp (NYSE:CBAN) is a bank holding company headquartered in Baxley, Georgia, that operates through its primary subsidiary, The Colony Bank. The company’s core focus is on delivering community banking services tailored to individuals, small businesses and agricultural customers throughout Georgia and Florida. Colony Bankcorp’s structure supports a full suite of deposit and lending solutions designed to meet the needs of local markets.

The company offers a range of deposit products, including personal and business checking accounts, savings and money market accounts, and certificates of deposit. On the lending side, its services encompass commercial and industrial loans, real estate and construction financing, agricultural lending, consumer installment loans, and residential mortgages. Colony Bankcorp also provides specialized treasury management solutions, merchant services, and digital banking platforms to help clients manage cash flow and payments efficiently.

Colony Bank’s origins date back to the mid-1970s, and the bank holding company was established through a reorganization in 2010 to support future growth and acquisitions. Over the years, it has expanded its footprint through strategic branch openings and targeted acquisitions, building a network of community banking offices across southeastern Georgia and northeastern Florida. This regional focus enables Colony Bankcorp to maintain close client relationships and respond swiftly to local market dynamics.

The company is governed by an experienced board of directors and an executive management team with deep roots in regional banking. With a commitment to community development, Colony Bankcorp emphasizes local decision-making, personalized customer service and investments in digital capabilities to balance the advantages of a community bank with the efficiencies of modern financial technology.

Colony Bankcorp Q2 2024 Earnings Call Transcript

Key Takeaways

• Positive Sentiment: Operating net income rose by roughly $170–200k quarter-over-quarter, driven by higher non-interest income and a lower provision expense from improved credit.
• Positive Sentiment: Margin declined only 1 basis point (better than expected) and management expects margin stabilization and eventual expansion in the second half of the year as assets reprice and deposit cost pressure eases.
• Positive Sentiment: Loan pipelines are increasing: loans held for investment rose $6.6M and management expects modest loan growth in H2 with potential for higher single‑digit growth into next year.
• Negative Sentiment: Total deposits fell about $62.5M (including $22M brokered CD paydowns), and the bank increased FHLB advances by $50M to fund operations, highlighting funding seasonality and near‑term funding pressure.
• Positive Sentiment: Credit quality improved — classified and criticized loans decreased, nonperforming loans declined since year‑end, and the bank reported zero past‑due CRE loans at quarter end.

Presentation

[Operator]

Good day, everyone, and welcome to the Colony Bank Second Quarter 2024 Conference Call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. Later, you will have the opportunity to ask questions during the question and answer session. You may register to ask questions by pressing the star and one on your telephone keypad. You may withdraw your question by pressing star two. Please note this call is being recorded, and I will be standing by should you need any assistance. It is now my pleasure to turn the conference over to Chief Financial Officer, Derek Shelnutt. Please go ahead.

[Derek Shelnutt, CFO at Colony Bankcorp]

Thanks, Nikki. Before we get started, I would like to go through our standard disclosures. Certain statements we make on this call could be constituted as forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Current and prospective investors are cautioned that any such forward-looking statements are not guarantees of future performance, but involve known and unknown risks and uncertainties. Factors that could cause these differences include, but are not limited to, pandemics, variations of the company's assets, businesses, cash flows, financial condition, prospects, and other results of operations. I would also like to add that during our call today, we will reference both our earnings release and our quarterly investor presentation, both of which were filed yesterday. So please have those available to reference.

[Derek Shelnutt, CFO at Colony Bankcorp]

With that, I will turn the call over to our Chief Executive Officer, Heath Fountain.

[Heath Fountain, CEO at Colony Bankcorp]

Thanks, Derek, and thanks to everyone joining our second quarter earnings call today. We're pleased with our improved operating results in the second quarter, and we appreciate the hard work from our team members, which has allowed us to continue to achieve progress towards our strategic goals. Operating net income increased close to $200,000 during the quarter as we continued to see improved performance from our complementary lines of business. All were profitable in the quarter, with the exception of Marine and RV Lending, which improved quarter-over-quarter, but was held back by sluggish sales in that industry. Net interest income decreased slightly during the quarter and was driven by a continued increase in our funding costs, albeit at a slower pace than in recent quarters. Loan growth was relatively low this quarter. As we've mentioned previously, our loan growth expectations were modest for the year.

[Heath Fountain, CEO at Colony Bankcorp]

We do see our loan pipelines increasing, and we do expect a little more growth in the second half of the year. Margin declined 1 basis point during the quarter, which was a little better than our expectations of a three-five basis point decline. We still expect margin to improve in the second half of the year, and Derek's going to speak in more detail to that later in the call. There was some seasonality in our deposit base in the second quarter. Historically, it's not unusual pre-COVID for us to see declines in the second quarter. A large portion of the decline this quarter was related to tax payments from a small number of large depositors, and of course, we generally would expect to see those balances come back later in the year.

[Heath Fountain, CEO at Colony Bankcorp]

We also were able to reduce our brokered CD levels this quarter. Our focus remains on deposits first, and our bankers continue to develop relationships that include deposits and other opportunities. We are believers that the value created in banking is based on the deposit relationships we can build, and so that's our primary focus. Credit quality remains strong. Classified and criticized loans decreased during the quarter, and those figures are available on Page 18 of the earnings release. At the end of the quarter, past dues were at very low levels. We had zero past due CRE loans at the end of the quarter. We have confidence in the credit quality of our portfolio, and we're not really seeing any areas at this time that gives us concerns about potential weakening.

[Heath Fountain, CEO at Colony Bankcorp]

Our mortgage banking group was profitable in the second quarter and had its most profitable quarter during... You know, since we started this rate cycle. We started seeing more activity during the home buying season this spring, but we're seeing still low inventory levels have an impact on volume. But the outlook on rate stability and, and the market adjusting to the current level of rates are starting to help drive activity, and we continue to adjust our product offering and staffing to remain competitive in the market and to remain profitable in this line. Our Small Business and Specialty Lending Division had another great quarter. We've seen a lot of success from our small dollar loan program, and these will continue to be a good source of revenue for our SBSL group.

[Heath Fountain, CEO at Colony Bankcorp]

There is some slowdown expected in that going forward, as we've seen many new entrants into that marketplace. And so while we expect to see revenue continue and this be a good product for us, it, it will not likely be at the same levels that we've seen in the first half of this year. And we keep continuing to focus on our core SBA loan customers and maintain a consistent pipeline in those products as well. Expenses were in line with our expectation, and I think our team's done an outstanding job of maintaining efficiency and expense discipline over the last year. Our operating net non-interest expense to average assets was 1.36% for the quarter, and it's shown at the bottom of Page 8 in the earnings release.

[Heath Fountain, CEO at Colony Bankcorp]

Since we have multiple sources of non-interest income, we use this metric as a way to compare our non-interest expense to peers... and we've moved in the peer group we measure from the bottom quartile in that group to the top quartile over the past year, and we expect to stay there. Our commitment to our markets is important to us, and although we maintain, we focus on remaining disciplined with our expenses, we manage that with the long-term benefits of continuing to invest in innovation, technology, and in our markets. Over the past few months, we've added experienced bankers to several of our markets based on needs, and in some markets, for transitions for upcoming retirements.

[Heath Fountain, CEO at Colony Bankcorp]

We're excited to have these new team members on board and look forward to the positive impacts that they're gonna have on our customers and our communities. And lastly, I'd just like to recognize two of our board members who retired this past quarter, Jonathan Ross, who served as a director since 2007, and Harold Wyatt, who served as a director with us since 2021 and previously served as a director of Southcrest Financial Group for many years before its merger with Colony. We wish them well and would like to thank them for their leadership and their service to our shareholders, our team members, our customers, and our communities. And with that, I'm going to turn it over to Derek, who'll go over the financials in more detail.

[Derek Shelnutt, CFO at Colony Bankcorp]

Thank you, Heath. Both GAAP and operating net income increased during the quarter, with operating net income increasing by a little over $170,000 as a result of increased non-interest income and lower provision expense, driven by improvement in credit quality. Interest income increased slightly quarter-over-quarter, with interest income on loans increasing by about $500,000. Interest income from investment securities decreased in the quarter, partially by the redeployment of principal payments to fund loans or pay down borrowings, but largely due to a one-time accelerated premium recognition on an early payoff of a security, which decreased overall investment income. That impact was about $250,000, and without that, net interest income would have been flat quarter-over-quarter.

[Derek Shelnutt, CFO at Colony Bankcorp]

Interest expense on deposits increased from the first quarter, but we are still seeing the rate of that increase slow down. As Heath mentioned, margin declined one basis point, and that was better than our expectations for the quarter. We still believe margin will start to expand in the second half of the year, but the exact timing will depend on several factors, including deposit competition and costs, loan fundings, as well as any interest rate changes. With margin declining only one basis point per quarter since the fourth quarter of 2023, we feel comfortable that we are at or very close to the bottom. Any further decline is likely to only be a basis point or so, but we feel better about margin being in the midst of turning the corner and seeing the next quarter margin being flat or up a few basis points.

[Derek Shelnutt, CFO at Colony Bankcorp]

Operating non-interest income increased from the prior quarter by $77,000. Both our SBSL and mortgage income increased quarter-over-quarter, while other non-interest income declined, but that was due to one-time items in the first quarter related to BOLI and OREO. Non-interest expense remained stable quarter-over-quarter, decreasing $67,000. As Heath mentioned, we are still focused on appropriately managing expenses relative to our growth expectations, and our operating net NIE to assets improved two basis points in the quarter and was four basis points better than our target of 1.40%. While we still look for efficiency with expenses, continued progress in our complementary lines of business should keep us close to or better than our net NIE target. Provision expense totaled $650,000 for the quarter.

[Derek Shelnutt, CFO at Colony Bankcorp]

Slower loan growth in the quarter was a contributor, but we also saw some credit improvement this quarter with a decrease in classified and criticized loans. As Heath mentioned, past dues were at low levels, which includes zero past dues CRE loans on the bank side, and we've seen a decrease in nonperforming loans since the end of last year. Net charge-offs were relatively flat and similar to last quarter. The majority of the charge-offs were related to the unguaranteed portion of SBA loans. The SBA small dollar loans represent most of the charge-offs, and these loans do have a higher premium when they're sold, which offsets the higher losses. Total loans held for investment increased $6.6 million from the prior quarter.

[Derek Shelnutt, CFO at Colony Bankcorp]

As we mentioned on our last call, our pipeline suggests more growth in the second half of the year, but still at modest levels. Demand, credit appetite, rates, and funding are all going to influence the exact level of growth we end up seeing. We still have opportunities this year for repricing on loans. There are about $50 million-$60 million with maturities through the end of the year that are currently priced at 5% or lower. So we should see some benefit from that going forward. Total deposits were lower by about $62.5 million, of which $22 million were broker deposit pay downs. And when you look at our deposit data pre-COVID, you typically see some seasonality and lower second quarter average deposits. Then you see those deposits return in the later half of the year.

[Derek Shelnutt, CFO at Colony Bankcorp]

We did see some large outflows for tax payments from some of our larger depositors. We've also seen seasonal supply and raw material purchases from our manufacturing and agricultural depositors. We are still focused heavily on deposits. FHLB advances increased in the quarter by $50 million. We took advantage of the inverted curve where we saw some opportunity to get some cheaper funding. Additionally, a portion of that was short-term, and the more attractive short-term pricing allowed us to shift out of the higher rate brokered CDs. This quarter, we continued our strategy of selling underperforming investments in the portfolio and redeploying those proceeds into higher-yielding assets... And those results are summarized on Slide 29. We sold approximately $9.3 million worth of securities, which included a loss of $425,000.

[Derek Shelnutt, CFO at Colony Bankcorp]

The book yield was 3.26%, and our earn back estimates are around two years or less. We expect to continue similar restructures in the future, and, as appropriate, and as market conditions allow. During the quarter, as part of our stock repurchase program, we repurchased 20,000 shares for an average price of $11.90, and a total value of about $238,000. Yesterday, the board declared a quarterly cash dividend of $0.1125 per share. We understand our dividend is important to many of our investors, and continuing our dividend represents the faith we have in the strength of our earnings. Mortgage net income was $138,000 for the second quarter, an increase of $152,000 from the prior quarter.

[Derek Shelnutt, CFO at Colony Bankcorp]

We've seen some increase in the volume during the home buying season, but being held back slightly by home affordability and inventory, we believe mortgage will continue to improve and be profitable on a go-forward basis. There's a lot of potential due to pent-up demand, and if we see rates come down a little, we would expect to see more profit growth along with an increase in volume. Our small business specialty lending division had a net income of $1.3 million during the quarter. That's a $459,000 increase from the prior quarter. The small dollar program has been successful and will continue to be a great product for that line of business. But as Heath mentioned, there have been new entrants to that market, and although premiums are still attractive, they've come down a little bit from their highs.

[Derek Shelnutt, CFO at Colony Bankcorp]

Going forward, we think this is still going to be a great product, but the related revenue will likely be a touch softer. The pipeline for core loans is still in good shape and has remained an important part of that business. On Slide 8, we provide a breakdown of pre-tax income for our complementary lines of business. Our Marine and RV Division continues to see loan growth, although it is slower than what we originally expected due to sluggish sales in the industry this season. The division is still trending towards profitability, but that may not occur for another quarter or two. Merchant Services had their first profitable quarter, and referrals have been strong. We are excited about the progress and expect to see that continue.

[Derek Shelnutt, CFO at Colony Bankcorp]

The second quarter was lighter for our Insurance Division, and the first quarter and early in the second quarter, the insurance industry overall saw tighter underwriting requirements and a lower risk appetite. We did see that relax near the end of the quarter, and we remain optimistic about the rest of the year. Bank referrals have been increasing, and we feel like we're gonna start seeing the benefits of those. The division also invested in growing the business during the second quarter, which had some upfront expenses associated with it. That concludes my overview, and now I'll turn it back over to Heath for any final comments before we take questions.

[Heath Fountain, CEO at Colony Bankcorp]

Thanks, Derek. That wraps our remarks up, and with that, I'll call on Nikki to open up the lines for questions.

[Operator]

At this time, if you would like to ask a question, please press star and one on your telephone keypad. You may withdraw your question by pressing star two. Once again, to ask a question, please press star and one on your telephone keypad. We'll pause a moment to allow questions to queue. I will take our first question from Justin Marca with Hovde Group. Please go ahead.

[Justin Marca, Equity Research Associate at Hovde Group]

Hey, guys. Good morning. I'm for Dave Bishop today. So you mentioned in your prepared remarks that pipelines are increasing. Any particular segments where you're seeing good opportunities, and, and how are your overall growth prospects looking for, say, the next 18 months?

[Heath Fountain, CEO at Colony Bankcorp]

Yeah, it's really, I think, across the board, we are seeing a pretty diversified amount. We do have, obviously, you know, we're if you look at our portfolio, it's largely real estate, and so we do have some nice opportunities on the commercial real estate front, and we have the appetite and capacity there. You know, our ultimate goals, we like to try to grow 8%-12% a year. Certainly, we don't expect to see that this year. I think, you know, loans were down in Q1 and then up slightly this quarter, maybe in the like 1% annualized range.

[Heath Fountain, CEO at Colony Bankcorp]

If we could potentially, next couple of quarters, maybe see closer, you know, 2%-5% type annualized growth, it's likely, and then, you know, given the economic outlook right now and, and what things look like, potentially leading into, you know, some higher single digit growth as we go into next year.

[Justin Marca, Equity Research Associate at Hovde Group]

Okay. And it sounds like a NIM drop might be in sight. How are you feeling about overall deposit costs and loan yields for the second half and into 25? And do you have any rate cuts baked into those projections?

[Heath Fountain, CEO at Colony Bankcorp]

So we feel good about where we are. We don't try to predict the rate cut. So we feel like, you know, our NIM return is gonna come back, regardless of, you know, rate drops. So we're thinking rate stability in our outlook. And as Derek mentioned in his remarks, you know, a lot's just gonna depend on funding pressure and on loan growth. We've got a lot of repricings coming up, so we have a lot of, you know, the pressure's lightening up on the deposit side, and on the loan side we've got a lot that'll reprice anyway, and with a little bit of growth that'll improve. Derek, you have any other thing to add to that?

[Derek Shelnutt, CFO at Colony Bankcorp]

I agree. Just to add some additional color, you know, we're continuing to see asset repricing through both the loan portfolio and the securities portfolio, and that's been pretty steady. And we have a lot of opportunity there. Again, our cost of funds, our deposit costs, has been steadily slowing down in terms of rate of increase and any Fed rate cuts that we may or may not see will have an impact on that. Probably not drop it, but definitely slow it down even further, and so that's just gonna help our overall funding cost and allow the assets to reprice faster, and then at that point, we'll start seeing margin expansion.

[Derek Shelnutt, CFO at Colony Bankcorp]

Again, I think we expect that to happen probably in the second half of this year, at some point, you know, even without any rate cuts, and then continue on into 2025.

[Justin Marca, Equity Research Associate at Hovde Group]

Great. Thanks for taking my questions today.

[Heath Fountain, CEO at Colony Bankcorp]

Thank you.

[Operator]

And once again, that is star and one on your telephone keypad, if you would like to join the queue. We'll pause a moment to allow any further questions to queue. And we show no further questions at this time. I will turn the program back to our presenters for any closing or additional remarks.

[Heath Fountain, CEO at Colony Bankcorp]

Well, thanks again, everyone, for being on the call today. We appreciate your support of Colony Bankcorp, and we appreciate you being on the call.

[Operator]

This does conclude...

Participants

Executives

• Derek Shelnutt, CFO
• Heath Fountain, CEO

Analysts

• Justin Marca, Equity Research Associate at Hovde Group