Simeon Gutman - Morgan Stanley Analyst Performance This page shows the methodology used to calculate Simeon Gutman's recommendation performance. Listed below are links to the research notes issued, the price targets issued by the analyst, and the stock's actual price 12 months from the date the research note was issued. These rankings are based on research reports from . Rankings are updated daily. MarketBeat Analyst Ranking: Subscribe to MarketBeat All Access for the recommendation accuracy ratingAverage 12-Month ROI of Buy and Strong Buy Recommendations: ???% Export to Excel CompanyReport DateReport Date Price12-MonthPrice TargetRating12-MonthActual Price12-MonthROIDetailsHDHome Depot8/20/2025$403.81$430.00Overweight???%???%AAPAdvance Auto Parts8/15/2025$56.90$55.00Equal Weight???%???%ARHSArhaus8/8/2025$11.34$12.50Equal Weight???%???%GOGrocery Outlet8/6/2025$13.02$16.00Equal Weight???%???%FNDFloor & Decor8/1/2025$76.28$97.00Equal Weight???%???%MCWMister Car Wash7/31/2025$5.35$7.50Equal Weight???%???%WWayfair7/2/2025$55.95$70.00Overweight???%???%KRKroger6/23/2025$73.82$76.00Equal Weight???%???%ASOAcademy Sports and Outdoors6/11/2025$46.35$52.00Equal Weight???%???%WOOFPetco Health and Wellness6/6/2025$2.79$4.50Equal Weight???%???%FIVEFive Below6/5/2025$125.80$135.00Equal Weight???%???%DLTRDollar Tree6/5/2025$96.43$96.00Equal Weight???%???%DGDollar General6/4/2025$110.66$115.00Equal Weight???%???%COSTCostco Wholesale5/30/2025$1,050.31$1,225.00Overweight???%???%ULTAUlta Beauty5/30/2025$471.10$550.00Overweight???%???%AZOAutoZone5/28/2025$3,777.62$4,000.00Overweight???%???%BJBJ's Wholesale Club5/23/2025$114.38$125.00Equal Weight???%???%AAPAdvance Auto Parts5/23/2025$47.40$48.00Equal Weight???%???%TGTTarget5/22/2025$93.01$112.00Overweight???%???%KRKroger5/19/2025$68.89$71.00Equal Weight???%???%DGDollar General5/19/2025$97.51$85.00Equal Weight???%???%ARHSArhaus5/9/2025$8.06$10.00Equal Weight???%???%VVVValvoline5/9/2025$33.38$39.00Equal Weight???%???%HDHome Depot5/5/2025$361.99$410.00Overweight???%???%LOWLowe's Companies5/5/2025$226.53$255.00Overweight???%???%OKTAOkta4/16/2025$101.17$123.00Overweight???%???%RHRH4/3/2025$249.28$300.00Overweight???%???%ASOAcademy Sports and Outdoors3/21/2025$47.42$55.00Equal Weight???%???%OLLIOllie's Bargain Outlet3/20/2025$107.94$118.00Equal Weight???%???%WSMWilliams-Sonoma3/20/2025$166.20$185.00Equal Weight???%???%FIVEFive Below3/20/2025$75.59$110.00Equal Weight???%???%OKTAOkta3/18/2025$113.25$125.00Overweight???%???%ULTAUlta Beauty3/14/2025$314.47$460.00Overweight???%???%EWCZEuropean Wax Center3/12/2025$4.45$4.00Underweight???%???%BJBJ's Wholesale Club3/7/2025$113.61$115.00Equal Weight???%???%AZOAutoZone3/5/2025$3,485.50$3,750.00Overweight???%???%BBYBest Buy3/5/2025$75.40$85.00Equal Weight???%???%LESLLeslie's3/3/2025$0.96$1.50Equal Weight???%???%GOGrocery Outlet2/26/2025$11.10$10.00Underperform???%???%MCWMister Car Wash2/20/2025$7.67$9.00Equal Weight???%???%WMTWalmart2/13/2025$103.88$115.00Overweight???%???%ORLYO'Reilly Automotive1/21/2025$81.12$96.67Overweight???%???%VVVValvoline1/21/2025$36.23$38.00Equal Weight???%???%ULTAUlta Beauty1/21/2025$405.01$500.00Overweight???%???%WOOFPetco Health and Wellness1/21/2025$3.88$5.00Equal Weight???%???%WMTWalmart1/21/2025$94.03$106.00Overweight???%???%SBHSally Beauty1/21/2025$11.15$10.00Underweight???%???%MCWMister Car Wash1/21/2025$7.33$8.00Equal Weight???%???%KRKroger1/21/2025$58.98$65.00Equal Weight???%???%EYENational Vision1/21/2025$11.34$13.00Equal Weight???%???%DKSDICK'S Sporting Goods1/21/2025$231.90$255.00Overweight???%???%DGDollar General1/21/2025$72.27$80.00Equal Weight???%???%BBYBest Buy1/21/2025$84.16$100.00Equal Weight???%???%WSMWilliams-Sonoma1/21/2025$209.03$195.00Equal Weight???%???%RHRH1/13/2025$414.75$530.00Overweight???%???%GOGrocery Outlet1/17/2023$29.78$26.00Underweight???%???%DGDollar General12/5/2022$243.30$260.00Overweight???%???%SBHSally Beauty11/16/2022$11.76$10.00???%???%AIRSAirSculpt Technologies11/15/2022$2.70$7.00Equal Weight???%???%GOGrocery Outlet11/10/2022$31.00$30.00Underweight???%???%RHRH9/9/2022$261.71$325.00Equal Weight???%???%WSMWilliams-Sonoma8/29/2022$77.98$75.00Equal Weight???%???%DGDollar General8/26/2022$246.08$270.00Overweight???%???%WOOFPetco Health and Wellness8/25/2022$14.34$19.00Equal Weight???%???%AIRSAirSculpt Technologies8/24/2022$9.95$11.00Equal Weight???%???%SBHSally Beauty8/8/2022$14.60$11.00Underweight???%???%HDHome Depot7/20/2022$298.67$350.00Overweight???%???%WSMWilliams-Sonoma7/20/2022$66.86$70.00Equal Weight???%???%RHRH6/30/2022$237.32$350.00Equal Weight???%???%DGDollar General6/16/2022$232.25$250.00Overweight???%???%WSMWilliams-Sonoma6/6/2022$64.15$76.00Equal Weight???%???%RHRH6/3/2022$305.87$385.00Equal Weight???%???%WSMWilliams-Sonoma5/26/2022$57.49$80.00Equal Weight???%???%WSMWilliams-Sonoma3/18/2022$82.09$85.00Hold???%???%AZOAutoZone3/2/2022$1,849.86$2,125.00Equal Weight???%???%EYENational Vision3/1/2022$36.52$65.00Overweight???%???%HDHome Depot2/23/2022$316.17$380.00Overweight???%???%WMTWalmart2/22/2022$46.00$55.00Overweight???%???%AAPAdvance Auto Parts2/16/2022$222.60$240.00Equal Weight???%???%HDHome Depot1/28/2022$366.54$420.00Buy???%???%MCWMister Car Wash1/18/2022$17.09$20.00Overweight???%???%MCWMister Car Wash12/10/2021$17.79$19.00Hold???%???%AZOAutoZone12/8/2021$2,023.57$2,050.00Equal Weight???%???%DKSDICK'S Sporting Goods11/26/2021$126.64$144.00Buy???%???%AAPAdvance Auto Parts11/17/2021$239.01$235.00Equal Weight???%???%WWayfair11/8/2021$244.82$200.00Underweight???%???%ORLYO'Reilly Automotive10/29/2021$41.65$45.00Equal Weight???%???%EYENational Vision10/14/2021$56.27$70.00Overweight???%???%FIVEFive Below10/7/2021$175.75$230.00Overweight???%???%AZOAutoZone9/22/2021$1,643.07$1,710.00Equal Weight???%???%EWCZEuropean Wax Center9/15/2021$24.24$26.00Equal Weight???%???%WMTWalmart8/30/2021$49.11$56.67Buy???%???%AZOAutoZone8/27/2021$1,588.90$1,650.00Equal Weight???%???%WMTWalmart8/18/2021$50.23$56.67Overweight???%???%MCWMister Car Wash8/17/2021$18.39$20.00Equal Weight???%???%MCWMister Car Wash8/13/2021$19.83$21.00Equal Weight???%???%AZOAutoZone5/26/2021$1,391.87$1,640.00Buy???%???%OLLIOllie's Bargain Outlet5/24/2021$76.35$85.00Equal Weight???%???%WMTWalmart5/19/2021$47.30$53.33Overweight???%???%WMTWalmart2/25/2021$44.45$51.33Overweight???%???%WMTWalmart2/11/2021$48.13$52.00Buy???%???%KRKroger12/7/2020$30.50$32.00Equal Weight???%???%ORLYO'Reilly Automotive7/20/2020$28.80$31.33Overweight???%???%TSCOTractor Supply7/8/2020$26.85$29.00Overweight???%???%KRKroger6/25/2020$32.82$35.00Equal Weight???%???%KRKroger6/11/2020$32.70$34.00Hold???%???%MIKMichaels Companies6/8/2020$7.26$5.00Underweight???%???%LLLL Flooring6/2/2020$10.00$8.00Underweight???%???%DGDollar General5/29/2020$184.11$218.00Overweight???%???%TSCOTractor Supply5/28/2020$24.20$25.00Overweight???%???%ORLYO'Reilly Automotive4/23/2020$25.35$26.33Overweight???%???%TSCOTractor Supply4/8/2020$17.30$19.00Overweight???%???%LLLL Flooring4/2/2020$4.32$3.00Underweight???%???%MIKMichaels Companies3/18/2020$1.84$3.00Underweight???%???%DGDollar General3/17/2020$143.45$170.00Overweight???%???%TSCOTractor Supply3/17/2020$13.51$20.00Overweight???%???%LLLL Flooring3/17/2020$4.05$4.00Underweight???%???%BBBYBed Bath & Beyond3/16/2020$7.29Underweight???%???%KRKroger3/6/2020$32.44$29.00Equal Weight???%???%BBYBest Buy2/28/2020$78.31$90.00Equal Weight???%???%AAPAdvance Auto Parts2/13/2020$134.32$180.00Overweight???%???%BBYBest Buy1/22/2020$90.24$85.00Equal Weight???%???%KRKroger1/22/2020$28.57$27.00Equal Weight???%???%TSCOTractor Supply1/21/2020$18.73$23.00Overweight???%???%PRTYParty City Holdco1/3/2020$2.37$3.00Equal Weight???%???%WMTWalmart12/31/2019$39.80$43.33Overweight???%???%MIKMichaels Companies12/20/2019$6.70$5.00Underweight???%???%DGDollar General12/6/2019$155.10$174.00Overweight???%???%BBYBest Buy11/27/2019$80.34$77.00Equal Weight???%???%DKSDICK'S Sporting Goods11/27/2019$46.02$46.00Equal Weight???%???%UALUnited Airlines10/10/2019$86.56$103.00Overweight???%???%BBBYBed Bath & Beyond10/8/2019$12.98$12.00Hold???%???%UALUnited Airlines10/2/2019$84.99$108.00Overweight???%???%KRKroger9/13/2019$26.23$26.00Hold???%???%AAPAdvance Auto Parts9/10/2019$158.86$185.00Buy???%???%MIKMichaels Companies9/9/2019$9.74$7.00Hold???%???%HOMEAt Home Group9/6/2019$7.22$6.00Equal Weight???%???%WMTWalmart9/5/2019$38.64$41.67Overweight???%???%ULTAUlta Beauty8/30/2019$337.45$275.00Equal Weight???%???%OLLIOllie's Bargain Outlet8/30/2019$56.36$70.00Equal Weight???%???%BJBJ's Wholesale Club8/23/2019$26.36$29.00Equal Weight???%???%DKSDICK'S Sporting Goods8/22/2019$34.03$36.00Hold???%???%LOWLowe's Companies8/22/2019$108.00$130.00Overweight???%???%TGTTarget8/22/2019$103.00$107.00Equal Weight???%???%TSCOTractor Supply8/22/2019$20.26$23.00Equal Weight???%???%FNDFloor & Decor8/22/2019$48.60$41.00Equal Weight???%???%WMTWalmart8/16/2019$37.94$38.33Buy???%???%TSCOTractor Supply7/26/2019$21.99$22.40Hold???%???%ULTAUlta Beauty7/18/2019$366.39$395.00Overweight???%???%BBBYBed Bath & Beyond7/12/2019$11.37$13.00Equal Weight???%???%WMTWalmart6/17/2019$36.36$38.33Overweight???%???%MIKMichaels Companies6/17/2019$8.85$9.00Hold???%???%OLLIOllie's Bargain Outlet6/11/2019$96.00$89.00Hold???%???%HOMEAt Home Group6/10/2019$7.61$8.00Equal Weight???%???%COSTCostco Wholesale6/3/2019$240.29$230.00Equal Weight???%???%BJBJ's Wholesale Club5/24/2019$26.66$28.00Hold???%???%LOWLowe's Companies5/23/2019$95.31$123.00Buy???%???%VVVValvoline5/2/2019$17.27$19.00Hold???%???%ULTAUlta Beauty4/15/2019$351.01$375.00Overweight???%???%LOWLowe's Companies4/15/2019$117.18$123.00Overweight???%???%HOMEAt Home Group3/28/2019$17.83$30.00Buy???%???%LLLL Flooring3/19/2019$9.99$10.00Hold???%???%LOWLowe's Companies3/19/2019$104.03$115.00Buy???%???%ULTAUlta Beauty3/18/2019$338.96$355.00Overweight???%???%COSTCostco Wholesale3/8/2019$227.82$220.00Hold???%???%FNDFloor & Decor2/22/2019$37.94$36.00Hold???%???%WMTWalmart1/23/2019$32.50$36.67Overweight???%???%ULTAUlta Beauty12/9/2018$254.47$330.00Buy???%???%WMTWalmart11/16/2018$32.53$35.67Neutral???%???%LLLL Flooring10/31/2018$11.60$10.00Hold???%???%LOWLowe's Companies10/23/2018$98.39$110.00Overweight???%???%LOWLowe's Companies10/11/2018$104.23$125.00Overweight???%???%WWayfair10/11/2018$116.00$125.00Equal Weight???%???%WMTWalmart10/11/2018$31.31$34.00Equal Weight???%???%WMTWalmart10/4/2018$31.19$32.67Neutral???%???%BBBYBed Bath & Beyond9/28/2018$14.86$13.00Underweight???%???%ULTAUlta Beauty9/4/2018$260.00$280.00Overweight???%???%WMTWalmart8/28/2018$31.51$32.67Neutral???%???%WMTWalmart8/22/2018$32.03$32.67Neutral???%???%WMTWalmart8/17/2018$98.64Hold???%???%WMTWalmart8/16/2018$32.88$32.67Neutral???%???%WWayfair8/7/2018$114.50$105.00Hold???%???%SBHSally Beauty8/6/2018$14.13$13.00Underweight???%???%WMTWalmart6/13/2018$27.99$31.00Neutral???%???%LOWLowe's Companies5/24/2018$93.75$115.00Buy???%???%WMTWalmart5/14/2018$28.01$33.00Hold???%???%SBHSally Beauty5/5/2018$14.81$14.00Sell???%???%BBBYBed Bath & Beyond4/12/2018$21.50$16.00Sell???%???%WMTWalmart4/2/2018$28.64$33.00Hold???%???%HDHome Depot3/21/2018$178.02$210.00Buy???%???%ULTAUlta Beauty3/16/2018$220.33$260.00Buy???%???%TGTTarget3/7/2018$71.79$64.00Sell???%???%ULTAUlta Beauty3/7/2018$200.22Buy???%???%VSIVitamin Shoppe2/28/2018$3.75$3.75Equal Weight???%???%LOWLowe's Companies1/22/2018$104.95$115.00Buy???%???%ULTAUlta Beauty1/17/2018$237.12$245.00Overweight???%???%BBBYBed Bath & Beyond12/27/2017$22.93$22.00Sell???%???%BBBYBed Bath & Beyond12/21/2017$24.57$22.00Sell???%???%COSTCostco Wholesale12/15/2017$186.53$175.00Hold???%???%EYENational Vision12/8/2017$33.18$36.00Buy???%???%HDHome Depot12/8/2017$183.41$185.00Buy???%???%WSMWilliams-Sonoma11/17/2017$26.44$24.00Hold???%???%VSIVitamin Shoppe11/9/2017$3.50$4.00Equal Weight???%???%VSIVitamin Shoppe10/2/2017$5.35$7.50Equal Weight???%???%VSIVitamin Shoppe8/10/2017$6.10$8.00Hold???%???%BBBYBed Bath & Beyond6/24/2017$29.65$30.00Sell???%???%WMTWalmart5/29/2017$26.04$25.67Neutral???%???%HDHome Depot5/17/2017$158.26$173.00Overweight???%???%WMTWalmart5/15/2017$25.24$25.67Neutral???%???%VSIVitamin Shoppe5/11/2017$12.70$14.00Equal Weight???%???%TGTTarget3/1/2017$58.77$52.00Underweight???%???%HDHome Depot2/23/2017$145.25$165.00Overweight???%???%LOWLowe's Companies2/23/2017$76.80$88.00Buy???%???%WMTWalmart1/23/2017$22.39$23.33Equal Weight???%???%TGTTarget1/18/2017$70.94$65.00Underweight???%???%TGTTarget12/28/2016$72.83$67.00Underweight???%???%BBYBest Buy12/7/2016$46.93$43.00Buy???%???%BBYBest Buy11/19/2016$44.79$43.00Hold???%???%WMTWalmart10/7/2016$23.12$24.67Hold???%???%HDHome Depot9/28/2016$126.82$145.00Hold???%???%AZOAutoZone9/27/2016$758.88$840.00Overweight???%???%TGTTarget8/19/2016$70.30$64.00Sell???%???%WMTWalmart8/19/2016$24.77$25.33Neutral???%???%SPLSStaples8/18/2016$8.48$10.00Hold???%???%AAPAdvance Auto Parts8/18/2016$158.05$180.00Overweight???%???%DKSDICK'S Sporting Goods8/17/2016$58.76$54.00Equal Weight???%???%AZOAutoZone8/11/2016$803.45$820.00Hold???%???%WMTWalmart8/3/2016$24.38$24.33Neutral???%???%BBBYBed Bath & Beyond6/23/2016$43.18$40.00Sell???%???%COSTCostco Wholesale5/27/2016$149.71$165.00Overweight???%???%TGTTarget5/25/2016$69.28Underweight???%???%AAPAdvance Auto Parts5/22/2016$146.39Buy???%???%DKSDICK'S Sporting Goods5/20/2016$41.36$43.00Equal Weight???%???%SPLSStaples5/18/2016$8.23Hold???%???%PRTYParty City Holdco5/13/2016$13.45$14.00Hold???%???%COSTCostco Wholesale5/9/2016$146.44$165.00Overweight???%???%DKSDICK'S Sporting Goods5/5/2016$46.59$39.00Underweight???%???%BBBYBed Bath & Beyond4/7/2016$48.81$40.00Underweight???%???%DKSDICK'S Sporting Goods3/28/2016$46.71$51.00Equal Weight???%???%COSTCostco Wholesale3/28/2016$151.43$170.00Overweight???%???%PRTYParty City Holdco3/10/2016$12.50$12.00Equal Weight???%???%COSTCostco Wholesale3/5/2016$150.90$170.00Buy???%???%COSTCostco Wholesale2/23/2016$150.06Overweight???%???%BBYBest Buy1/19/2016$27.11$28.00Equal Weight???%???%PRTYParty City Holdco1/19/2016$10.78$12.00Equal Weight???%???%BBYBest Buy11/24/2015$30.78$37.00Buy???%???%WSMWilliams-Sonoma11/20/2015$33.11$36.50Equal Weight???%???%WMTWalmart11/18/2015$19.97$20.00Neutral???%???%DKSDICK'S Sporting Goods11/18/2015$36.96$44.00Equal Weight???%???%COSTCostco Wholesale11/17/2015$156.45$179.00Buy???%???%PRTYParty City Holdco11/2/2015$15.33$20.00Buy???%???%WMTWalmart10/15/2015$20.01$20.00Neutral???%???%WMTWalmart10/9/2015$22.23$22.67Equal Weight???%???%BBBYBed Bath & Beyond9/25/2015$59.33$61.00Underweight???%???%TGTTarget9/20/2015$76.62$76.00???%???%ULTAUlta Beauty8/28/2015$160.24$180.00Equal Weight???%???%WSMWilliams-Sonoma8/27/2015$41.56$43.00Equal Weight???%???%BBYBest Buy8/26/2015$32.95$40.00Buy???%???%TGTTarget8/21/2015$78.40$74.00Underweight???%???%LLLL Flooring8/6/2015$13.27$12.00Equal Weight???%???%LOWLowe's Companies6/29/2015$68.61$84.00Buy???%???%TGTTarget6/15/2015$79.47Underweight???%???%WMTWalmart6/8/2015$24.35$26.67Equal Weight???%???%DKSDICK'S Sporting Goods5/20/2015$53.56Hold???%???%LLLL Flooring4/6/2015$33.20Equal Weight???%???%WMTWalmart4/2/2015$26.91$29.33Equal Weight???%???%WSMWilliams-Sonoma3/20/2015$39.34$42.00Hold???%???%TSCOTractor Supply2/25/2015$17.81$18.40Hold???%???%COSTCostco Wholesale2/9/2015$148.70$163.00Buy???%???%AAPAdvance Auto Parts2/9/2015$160.74$170.00Buy???%???%TSCOTractor Supply1/26/2015$15.94$16.80Equal Weight???%???%WMTWalmart1/21/2015$86.69Equal Weight???%???%AAPAdvance Auto Parts11/17/2014$144.81$170.00Overweight???%???%TSCOTractor Supply10/23/2014$12.26$14.40Equal Weight???%???%WMTWalmart10/16/2014$25.07$28.00Overweight???%???%WMTWalmart10/6/2014$25.77$28.00In-Line???%???% Return to Analyst Rankings Get 30 Days of MarketBeat All Access for Free Sign up for MarketBeat All Access to gain access to MarketBeat's full suite of research tools. Start Your 30-Day Trial MarketBeat All Access Features Best-in-Class Portfolio Monitoring Get personalized stock ideas. Compare portfolio to indices. Check stock news, ratings, SEC filings, and more. Stock Ideas and Recommendations See daily stock ideas from top analysts. Receive short-term trading ideas from MarketBeat. Identify trending stocks on social media. Advanced Stock Screeners and Research Tools Use our seven stock screeners to find suitable stocks. Stay informed with MarketBeat's real-time news. Export data to Excel for personal analysis. Sign in to your free account to enjoy these benefits In-depth profiles and analysis for 20,000 public companies. Real-time analyst ratings, insider transactions, earnings data, and more. Our daily ratings and market update email newsletter. Sign in to your free account to enjoy all that MarketBeat has to offer. Sign In Create Account Your Email Address: Email Address Required Your Password: Password Required Log In or Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google Forgot your password? Your Email Address: Please enter your email address. Please enter a valid email address Choose a Password: Please enter your password. Your password must be at least 8 characters long and contain at least 1 number, 1 letter, and 1 special character. Create My Account (Free) or Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google By creating a free account, you agree to our terms of service. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
MarketBeat All Access