Free Trial

Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) Competitors

Selective Insurance Group logo
$85.12 -0.70 (-0.82%)
Closing price 06/13/2025 04:00 PM Eastern
Extended Trading
$85.12 +0.00 (+0.01%)
As of 06/13/2025 04:04 PM Eastern
Extended trading is trading that happens on electronic markets outside of regular trading hours. This is a fair market value extended hours price provided by Polygon.io. Learn more.

SIGI vs. ERIE, FNF, CNA, ORI, AXS, RLI, THG, FAF, WTM, and AGO

Should you be buying Selective Insurance Group stock or one of its competitors? The main competitors of Selective Insurance Group include Erie Indemnity (ERIE), Fidelity National Financial (FNF), CNA Financial (CNA), Old Republic International (ORI), AXIS Capital (AXS), RLI (RLI), The Hanover Insurance Group (THG), First American Financial (FAF), White Mountains Insurance Group (WTM), and Assured Guaranty (AGO). These companies are all part of the "property & casualty insurance" industry.

Selective Insurance Group vs. Its Competitors

Erie Indemnity (NASDAQ:ERIE) and Selective Insurance Group (NASDAQ:SIGI) are both finance companies, but which is the better investment? We will contrast the two companies based on the strength of their earnings, institutional ownership, profitability, community ranking, media sentiment, analyst recommendations, risk, dividends and valuation.

Erie Indemnity pays an annual dividend of $5.46 per share and has a dividend yield of 1.5%. Selective Insurance Group pays an annual dividend of $1.52 per share and has a dividend yield of 1.8%. Erie Indemnity pays out 46.5% of its earnings in the form of a dividend. Selective Insurance Group pays out 41.4% of its earnings in the form of a dividend. Both companies have healthy payout ratios and should be able to cover their dividend payments with earnings for the next several years. Erie Indemnity has increased its dividend for 36 consecutive years and Selective Insurance Group has increased its dividend for 11 consecutive years. Selective Insurance Group is clearly the better dividend stock, given its higher yield and lower payout ratio.

In the previous week, Erie Indemnity and Erie Indemnity both had 5 articles in the media. Selective Insurance Group's average media sentiment score of 1.62 beat Erie Indemnity's score of 0.37 indicating that Selective Insurance Group is being referred to more favorably in the news media.

Company Very Positive Positive Neutral Negative Very Negative Overall Sentiment
Erie Indemnity
0 Very Positive mention(s)
2 Positive mention(s)
1 Neutral mention(s)
1 Negative mention(s)
0 Very Negative mention(s)
Neutral
Selective Insurance Group
4 Very Positive mention(s)
0 Positive mention(s)
0 Neutral mention(s)
0 Negative mention(s)
0 Very Negative mention(s)
Very Positive

Selective Insurance Group received 70 more outperform votes than Erie Indemnity when rated by MarketBeat users. However, 63.42% of users gave Erie Indemnity an outperform vote while only 59.58% of users gave Selective Insurance Group an outperform vote.

CompanyUnderperformOutperform
Erie IndemnityOutperform Votes
241
63.42%
Underperform Votes
139
36.58%
Selective Insurance GroupOutperform Votes
311
59.58%
Underperform Votes
211
40.42%

Erie Indemnity has a beta of 0.37, indicating that its stock price is 63% less volatile than the S&P 500. Comparatively, Selective Insurance Group has a beta of 0.49, indicating that its stock price is 51% less volatile than the S&P 500.

Selective Insurance Group has a consensus target price of $94.00, suggesting a potential upside of 10.43%. Given Selective Insurance Group's stronger consensus rating and higher probable upside, analysts clearly believe Selective Insurance Group is more favorable than Erie Indemnity.

Company Sell Ratings Hold Ratings Buy Ratings Strong Buy Ratings Rating Score
Erie Indemnity
0 Sell rating(s)
0 Hold rating(s)
0 Buy rating(s)
0 Strong Buy rating(s)
0.00
Selective Insurance Group
1 Sell rating(s)
5 Hold rating(s)
1 Buy rating(s)
0 Strong Buy rating(s)
2.00

33.7% of Erie Indemnity shares are held by institutional investors. Comparatively, 82.9% of Selective Insurance Group shares are held by institutional investors. 45.8% of Erie Indemnity shares are held by insiders. Comparatively, 1.5% of Selective Insurance Group shares are held by insiders. Strong institutional ownership is an indication that endowments, large money managers and hedge funds believe a company is poised for long-term growth.

Erie Indemnity has higher earnings, but lower revenue than Selective Insurance Group. Selective Insurance Group is trading at a lower price-to-earnings ratio than Erie Indemnity, indicating that it is currently the more affordable of the two stocks.

CompanyGross RevenuePrice/Sales RatioNet IncomeEarnings Per SharePrice/Earnings Ratio
Erie Indemnity$3.99B4.13$446.06M$11.7530.36
Selective Insurance Group$4.98B1.04$207.01M$3.6723.19

Erie Indemnity has a net margin of 15.16% compared to Selective Insurance Group's net margin of 4.26%. Erie Indemnity's return on equity of 31.22% beat Selective Insurance Group's return on equity.

Company Net Margins Return on Equity Return on Assets
Erie Indemnity15.16% 31.22% 21.14%
Selective Insurance Group 4.26%7.33%1.62%

Summary

Erie Indemnity and Selective Insurance Group tied by winning 10 of the 20 factors compared between the two stocks.

Get Selective Insurance Group News Delivered to You Automatically

Sign up to receive the latest news and ratings for SIGI and its competitors with MarketBeat's FREE daily newsletter.

New MarketBeat Followers Over Time

This chart shows the number of new MarketBeat users adding SIGI and its top 5 competitors to their watchlist. Each company is represented with a line over a 90 day period.
Skip Chart

Media Sentiment Over Time

This chart shows the average media sentiment of NASDAQ and its competitors over the past 90 days as caculated by MarketBeat. The averaged score is equivalent to the following: Very Negative Sentiment <= -1.5, Negative Sentiment > -1.5 and <= -0.5, Neutral Sentiment > -0.5 and < 0.5, Positive Sentiment >= 0.5 and < 1.5, and Very Positive Sentiment >= 1.5.
Skip Chart

SIGI vs. The Competition

MetricSelective Insurance GroupFire, marine, & casualty insurance IndustryFinance SectorNASDAQ Exchange
Market Cap$5.17B$46.12B$11.61B$8.51B
Dividend Yield1.78%2.19%5.64%4.16%
P/E Ratio26.4312.0622.8219.65
Price / Sales1.047.0026.81152.19
Price / Cash19.7616.8117.6034.64
Price / Book1.772.452.834.59
Net Income$207.01M$4.16B$1.04B$248.23M
7 Day Performance-2.63%-2.07%0.10%-1.07%
1 Month Performance-3.96%0.27%0.02%2.59%
1 Year Performance-5.87%31.18%540.97%13.50%

Selective Insurance Group Competitors List

CompanyMarketRankShare PriceAnalysts' Price Target1Y Price PerformanceMarket CapRevenueP/E RatioEmployee CountIndicator(s)
SIGI
Selective Insurance Group
3.9601 of 5 stars
$85.12
-0.8%
$94.00
+10.4%
-5.9%$5.17B$4.98B26.432,520Positive News
ERIE
Erie Indemnity
1.5501 of 5 stars
$361.69
-2.7%
N/A+2.0%$16.71B$3.99B33.836,040News Coverage
FNF
Fidelity National Financial
4.7856 of 5 stars
$54.81
+0.2%
$71.60
+30.6%
+14.5%$15.05B$12.78B11.7928,300Positive News
CNA
CNA Financial
4.4254 of 5 stars
$46.46
-1.4%
$50.50
+8.7%
+5.3%$12.57B$14.18B13.206,100Positive News
ORI
Old Republic International
4.4819 of 5 stars
$36.70
-2.1%
$42.00
+14.5%
+25.9%$9.07B$8.33B13.959,500Positive News
Analyst Downgrade
AXS
AXIS Capital
4.4042 of 5 stars
$104.09
-2.7%
$107.75
+3.5%
+50.5%$8.19B$6.04B8.432,080
RLI
RLI
3.3831 of 5 stars
$73.86
-2.7%
$78.60
+6.4%
+4.6%$6.78B$1.73B19.721,000Positive News
THG
The Hanover Insurance Group
2.9443 of 5 stars
$173.46
-0.9%
$179.50
+3.5%
+40.1%$6.23B$6.27B14.844,400Short Interest ↑
FAF
First American Financial
4.816 of 5 stars
$56.36
-0.1%
$75.00
+33.1%
+11.1%$5.80B$6.28B45.0921,200Positive News
WTM
White Mountains Insurance Group
2.7555 of 5 stars
$1,789.41
-1.6%
N/A+1.0%$4.61B$2.28B19.881,650Positive News
High Trading Volume
AGO
Assured Guaranty
4.6236 of 5 stars
$84.03
-1.6%
$103.33
+23.0%
+12.2%$4.13B$913M6.53410Positive News

Related Companies and Tools


This page (NASDAQ:SIGI) was last updated on 6/15/2025 by MarketBeat.com Staff
From Our Partners